Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

CalMac Ferries (Wi-fi) (PE1473)

Friday 15 March 2013 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 23 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

23 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The second new petition is PE1473 by Frances Anne Gillies, on behalf of Barra youth council, on wi-fi on CalMac ferries. Members have a note by the clerk—paper 3—which refers to the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing on the petition.Members will be aware that the BBC reported last week that CalMac had announced that it would make wi-fi available on all its sailings between the Western Isles and the mainland. It expects to introduce that by the end of the year. Therefore, I thank our petitioners for what is the most successful petition that we have ever had—they managed to achieve a change in three weeks.I welcome the petitioners and I invite Mairi Maclean to make a short presentation of about five minutes, which will be followed by questions.

Mairi Maclean Barra Youth Council
link

Hi. I am Mairi Maclean, and I am here with Annie Teresa MacNeil and Frances Anne Gillies to represent the Barra youth council.We are here today because we are asking the Scottish Parliament—

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I am sorry, but I cannot hear. Could you pull the microphone a little bit nearer?

Mairi Maclean Barra Youth Council
link

We are asking the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that a universal system of wi-fi operates on all Caledonian MacBrayne ferry services from the Western Isles to the mainland, and to provide a specific timescale for implementation.The introduction of wi-fi on CalMac ferries would be hugely beneficial to local businesses, commuters, young people from the islands and tourists. The benefits are that it would allow greater access to information, would increase work productivity, would boost the local economy, would improve communication links and would make travelling more attractive to CalMac passengers and crew.We started our campaign in September 2011, when first we wrote to CalMac to suggest the installation of wi-fi. We received a response that indicated that CalMac needed to investigate the idea further. In December 2011, Barra youth council met Comhairle nan Eilean Siar’s transport committee. Those who were present at the meeting included regional and local managers, as well as Councillor Donald Manford. The discussion that took place concentrated on the types of technology that could be used. It was agreed that a wi-fi trial would be implemented on the ferry MV Lord of the Isles, which serves the company’s longest route between Oban, Barra and Lochboisdale.It was also agreed that a CalMac representative would liaise directly with Barra youth council. That did not happen, so in February 2012 a further letter was sent, in which we asked for an update. We were informed that there had been no further developments. Further discussion took place between Barra youth council and CalMac in June 2012. We received a letter that stated that a trial would commence in June 2012. That was seen as real progress and a step in the right direction, and we were delighted.However, problems were quickly identified with the trial. The signal was intermittent, it was accessible only at one location on the ship and it was not widely advertised. No further progress was made on the issue at that point. In October 2012, Barra youth council attended a Highlands and Islands transport partnership meeting with Keith Brown, who is the Minister for Transport and Veterans, Alasdair Allan MSP and Councillor Donald Manford, at which we brought up the issues with the trial. We wanted timescales to be specified and an assurance that wi-fi would be installed on all ferries.At that meeting, it was agreed that the wi-fi trial would continue and that, if it was deemed to be successful, it would be a good idea to cascade the service to all ferries. We felt that we had been acknowledged and listened to, but there was no real outcome as regards further progress on the issue or a timescale for implementation.In February this year, Barra youth council attended a meeting with a representative from the Scottish Parliament’s Public Petitions Committee, at which we learned about the petitions process and the benefits of engaging in it. That was a major step forward for us, as it was agreed that we would formally lodge a petition on provision of wi-fi on all CalMac ferries.In the same month, we contacted CalMac to ask for an update. We were informed that CalMac hoped to install wi-fi on its ferries by the end of 2013. We recognised that that was further progress and were again delighted, but we felt that we needed assurance from the Scottish Parliament that implementation would take place and that we were being taken seriously.15:30

Our campaign gathered momentum when we received letters of support from local businesses, the council’s education department, the chair of the Outer Hebrides community planning partnership, Alasdair Allan MSP, Councillor Donald Manford and Angus MacNeil MP. We also collected 380 signatures online and we issued a press release that gave our campaign much wider media coverage.We were delighted that CalMac issued its own press release stating that it is not just hoping to, but is going to implement wi-fi provision by the end of 2013. However, that did not change our determination to bring the issue to the Public Petitions Committee’s table. We are here today because we want an assurance from the Scottish Parliament that it will be possible for any system that is installed to be accessed by all CalMac customers across the Western Isles, including at all the ports—Barra, Lochboisdale, Lochmaddy, Leverburgh, Tarbert and Stornoway.Secondly, we would like an assurance from the Scottish Parliament that implementation will take place within a specified timescale. We consider our action to be necessary because we want the issue to be taken seriously by the Scottish Parliament and we would like an assurance that it will assist with the issue. We will measure the success of the Parliament when all CalMac ferries throughout the Western Isles have wi-fi that is robust, available, dependable, affordable and widely accessible.By lodging a formal petition, we are asking the Scottish Parliament to listen to young people, to take our views seriously, to take on board what we are saying and to let our voices be heard. Thank you.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you, Mairi. I know that it must be a bit nerve-wracking to come before the committee, but you made your points extremely well.I have a couple of questions to begin with. If we look at comparisons with other transport systems, ScotRail has a contractual obligation to put in wi-fi and my understanding is that it has wi-fi on many of its trains. I appreciate that CalMac is looking at the technical issues and burdens, but would you agree that one way forward would be for the Scottish Government to make it a condition of any future tenders for ferry routes that the successful company provides wi-fi on the ferries? In that way, whoever wins the contract, there will be a guarantee that wi-fi will be provided.

Frances Anne Gillies Barra Youth Council
link

That would be a massive step forward for the guarantee of wi-fi. It would benefit all the ports in the Western Isles.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am sure that the issues that Barra youth council has raised are similar to issues that people of your age in other parts of Scotland have, particularly in relation to long-distance ferry services. It is an excellent idea. The paper from CalMac states that it is looking at some technical issues and that it has to look at“satellite, point-to-point wireless and 3G”as technical solutions. If people are on a seven-hour ferry journey, it is essential that they have wi-fi. I am sure that you know that from your experience of using the internet, but I am also thinking of people in the business community, tourists and so on. The provision of wi-fi would also give CalMac a competitive advantage, would it not? People would be more likely to take the ferry if wi-fi were available.I think that it is a great petition. It seems to me that it is pretty well coming to fruition, but my preference would be for us to have a concrete guarantee. Thank you again for your comments. I throw the meeting open to my colleagues for questions and points.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I take your point, convener. I think that that is right. As far as I am concerned, the letter from Caledonian MacBrayne about the challenges is still a bit open-ended. It states:“We hope to tender and transition to a new service model during 2013 and the formal procurement process for this has started.”I commend the petitioners for lodging the petition. It would not be unfair to ask Caledonian MacBrayne for a timeline for the various activities so that we can see whether it is achieving what it says it will achieve, and to ask whether it can accelerate that. It would be reasonable for the ministers who are responsible to ask that question of Caledonian MacBrayne.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

To clarify another point, you mentioned that you want wi-fi in the ferry terminal buildings. What is the current position in Western Isles ferry terminals? Can you get wi-fi in any of them when you are waiting for the ferry?

Annie Teresa MacNeil Barra Youth Council
link

No, we cannot.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thanks for that. I like an absolute response.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I congratulate you on the petition that you have lodged and its seeming success to date. A pertinent point stuck out for me when I was reading it. You say—I can just imagine it—that you have to go to a particular place on the boat to get a signal. That reminded me of what happened a generation ago, before we had integral television aerials, when I had to stand in a certain part of the room on top of a chair holding my aerial in order to get a picture. I am sure that others in the room remember those days.If Caledonian MacBrayne’s intention is to provide the broadest possible service, we should commend it for its response. However, if that is more about making a statement to give the impression that it intends to provide a service, when the reality is that in every vessel there is only one bizarre spot where you get the signal, I am slightly concerned. Is a key worry for you that what might be provided is a service in name but not in fact?

Annie Teresa MacNeil Barra Youth Council
link

Yes, that is a major concern. Because we have lodged the petition, perhaps CalMac is feeling slightly threatened. I have decided that we would not be happy until we are sitting on the ferry and our mobile phones are receiving wi-fi, and we will continue the petition until then.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I thank Frances Anne Gillies, Mairi Maclean and Annie Teresa MacNeil for their contributions. I had a lot of sympathy for the issue before the petition was lodged because, on the many occasions when I have been crossing the Minch, I have wished that wi-fi was available so that I could get on with my work. It begs the question, as Mairi mentioned, how much productivity has been lost collectively over the past few years when wi-fi was not available, particularly on the long journeys such as the seven and a half hour crossing from Oban to Castlebay and Lochboisdale.I travel quite a bit to Norway, where even small interisland foot-passenger ferry services have had wi-fi services for a number of years. In many ways, we are behind the times. Closer to home, NorthLink installed its first wi-fi system in August 2011 and replaced it with a second system in February 2012. I believe that NorthLink has around 40 wi-fi access points across its three vessels serving the northern isles. I am pleased to note that there is a commitment by CalMac to move forward. However, it must be said that CalMac is behind and that other operators are ahead of the game. Given the success of the petition, what will your next petition be on? Perhaps you can think about that.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Broadband extension might be another topic to consider, but I will leave that for another day.This is an important petition. We certainly need to write to CalMac about the issue. An interesting point was made about NorthLink; Angus MacDonald summed up well what happens in the northern isles. It would be useful to compare and contrast the two operators. Are members content to ask the Scottish Government about whether wi-fi could be a condition for future tenders?

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We are writing to CalMac to ascertain the tender timeline. We also want to clarify whether wi-fi will be implemented across all routes or whether it will apply only to one route. We need to find out the technical answers.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Can we also clarify the quantitative level of service that it expects will be available on each route, so we can address the issue of just how easily accessible and available it will in practice prove to be?

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is a good point. Are members happy with that course of action?Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

As the petitioners have heard, we are proceeding with your petition. Obviously, we will keep you up to date with developments. It may be that, in the future, we look at the issue again when we meet in Edinburgh. It would be tremendous if we could get the three of you along to sit in at that committee, but that will depend on other commitments.Thank you for coming along. I really appreciate your comments. You are welcome to stay on and listen to our other petitions for the half an hour or so that we have left.

Annie Teresa MacNeil Barra Youth Council
link

If it would be possible, convener, I just want on behalf of Barra youth council to thank CalMac for listening to us, for allowing us to put our point across and for working with us.I also thank Councillor Donald Manford, Angus MacNeil MP and Alasdair Allan MSP for their continuing support throughout our campaign; the Outer Hebrides community planning partnership, which has also supported us; young people throughout the Western Isles; local businesses; the education department; Guth Bharraigh, the Stornoway Gazette, and the West Highland Free Press, all of which have written greatly appreciated letters of support. We also thank the Scottish Parliament for bringing Parliament day to the Western Isles and for travelling to Barra to discuss it with us, and the Public Petitions Committee for listening to the Barra youth council, taking our point of view on board and allowing us to have our say.Last but not least we thank our youth leader Katie Denehy, who has given us 100 per cent support throughout the process. She is an inspirational woman and we are very thankful for everything that she has done for us.Thank you all very much. Applause.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Technically, I am not supposed to allow applause, but today I make an exception. I have to say that it does not happen very often in my speeches, but not to worry.I suspend the meeting for one minute to allow our witnesses to leave their seats.15:41 Meeting suspended.

15:43 On resuming—

  1. 14:00 Current Petition Petitions · 87
  2. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 37
  3. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 23
  4. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  5. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  6. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.