1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01134)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 12
- Alex Salmond SNP 8
- Elaine Smith Lab 8
The record
28 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01134)
Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Last week, the First Minister told the BBC’s “Today” programme:
“we’re going into talks with President Barroso and the European Commission.”
When will those talks take place?
“we’re going into talks with President Barroso and the European Commission.”
When will those talks take place?
Johann Lamont will have seen the European Commission’s viewpoint, which states that it has not expressed an opinion on a specific situation regarding Scotland. So, according to the European Commission, all the stuff that we heard before Christmas was not about Scotland at all.
However, the European Commission offered a route forward. It said that, if the member state wanted to ask for an opinion, that opinion could be provided. We have made it clear to the United Kingdom Government that we could go jointly to the European Commission and find out, with interest, what its viewpoint is. That seems to me to be an entirely reasonable suggestion. Perhaps Johann Lamont will depart from her colleagues in the coalition Government and support the Scottish Government’s positive suggestion.
However, the European Commission offered a route forward. It said that, if the member state wanted to ask for an opinion, that opinion could be provided. We have made it clear to the United Kingdom Government that we could go jointly to the European Commission and find out, with interest, what its viewpoint is. That seems to me to be an entirely reasonable suggestion. Perhaps Johann Lamont will depart from her colleagues in the coalition Government and support the Scottish Government’s positive suggestion.
I think that we can work out that the First Minister did not answer the question. Putting aside what he is asked and talking about something else might be an interesting thing to do, but it is not what he is supposed to do in this chamber.
The First Minister said that he was going into talks with President Barroso. Since he made that assertion before the Deputy First Minister had even received a reply to her letter asking for talks, what was the basis on which the First Minister said that he was going into talks with the European Commission? Was it the same basis on which he said that he had legal advice when he did not—that is, he just made it up?
The First Minister said that he was going into talks with President Barroso. Since he made that assertion before the Deputy First Minister had even received a reply to her letter asking for talks, what was the basis on which the First Minister said that he was going into talks with the European Commission? Was it the same basis on which he said that he had legal advice when he did not—that is, he just made it up?
The basis was that we asked for talks with the European Commission on what seemed to be the viewpoint that it stated in December and which was widely reported, which applied to the case of Scotland. The European Commission has now replied saying that it said no such thing and was not talking about a specific case. However, I think that it would be useful for the European Commission’s viewpoint to be heard. I want to hear its opinion. That is why the Deputy First Minister has indicated that we will go jointly, with the UK Government, if it agrees, to find out what the European Commission thinks.
Of course, since December, we have had some other important opinions on this matter from people such as Sir David Edward, a former judge in the European Court of Justice and, only this week, from Professor David Scheffer. Professor Scheffer seemed to profoundly support the Scottish Government’s viewpoint, which we have stated many times, that we will negotiate our position from within the European Union, and stated his opinion that there should be two successor states with equal status with regard to each other.
Those profound and important legal opinions tend to give weight to the Scottish Government’s point of view. I am sure that Johann Lamont has read and understood them and will want to take account of them as we pursue this debate.
Johann Lamont rose—
Of course, since December, we have had some other important opinions on this matter from people such as Sir David Edward, a former judge in the European Court of Justice and, only this week, from Professor David Scheffer. Professor Scheffer seemed to profoundly support the Scottish Government’s viewpoint, which we have stated many times, that we will negotiate our position from within the European Union, and stated his opinion that there should be two successor states with equal status with regard to each other.
Those profound and important legal opinions tend to give weight to the Scottish Government’s point of view. I am sure that Johann Lamont has read and understood them and will want to take account of them as we pursue this debate.
Johann Lamont rose—
It would be interesting—if Johann Lamont would give me a second—to have an indication from the Labour Party—[Interruption.]
Order.
It would be interesting to have an indication from the Labour Party of whether it, along with its colleagues in the Tories, is heading towards the exit door of the European Union.
Forgive me for not allowing the First Minister his sound bite before moving on.
Although President Barroso has not spoken about the specific issue of Scotland, he has said that current treaties do not apply to a new state. I can only assume that, although the First Minister has trimmed on the monarchy, the currency and the regulation of the banks, he still thinks that an independent Scotland would be a new state. He can correct me if I am wrong in that regard.
Of course, President Barroso has said that he cannot comment on Scotland’s application to join the European Union, but the Czech foreign minister has done so. The Czech Republic will have a veto on an independent Scotland’s EU application, and Karel Schwarzenberg, the Czech foreign minister, has said that Scotland
“would have to apply for ... membership”
and went on to say that it would get “a worse deal” because
“a much smaller country with much lesser economical importance has less weight”.
Why is the Czech foreign minister scaremongering like that?
Although President Barroso has not spoken about the specific issue of Scotland, he has said that current treaties do not apply to a new state. I can only assume that, although the First Minister has trimmed on the monarchy, the currency and the regulation of the banks, he still thinks that an independent Scotland would be a new state. He can correct me if I am wrong in that regard.
Of course, President Barroso has said that he cannot comment on Scotland’s application to join the European Union, but the Czech foreign minister has done so. The Czech Republic will have a veto on an independent Scotland’s EU application, and Karel Schwarzenberg, the Czech foreign minister, has said that Scotland
“would have to apply for ... membership”
and went on to say that it would get “a worse deal” because
“a much smaller country with much lesser economical importance has less weight”.
Why is the Czech foreign minister scaremongering like that?
Actually, Scotland is approximately the same geographical size as the Czech Republic.
I have the comments from the Czech foreign minister in front of me. When he was specifically asked whether he would want to block Scotland’s entry into the EU, he said no. Even the Czech foreign minister, speaking before he realised that the UK is heading for the exit door under Cameron’s leadership, thought that he would not want to stop Scotland’s membership of the EU. He does not want to stop Scotland’s being a member of the EU, so why is the Labour Party seeming to cast some doubt on it?
The events of the past 24 hours are very interesting in this debate, are they not? They indicate that the threat to Scotland’s continued membership of the European Union comes not from this Parliament, this Government or the people of Scotland but from the banks of the Thames with a Tory coalition Government that is heading towards the exit door and a Labour Opposition that has still to clarify what on earth it thinks about it.
I have the comments from the Czech foreign minister in front of me. When he was specifically asked whether he would want to block Scotland’s entry into the EU, he said no. Even the Czech foreign minister, speaking before he realised that the UK is heading for the exit door under Cameron’s leadership, thought that he would not want to stop Scotland’s membership of the EU. He does not want to stop Scotland’s being a member of the EU, so why is the Labour Party seeming to cast some doubt on it?
The events of the past 24 hours are very interesting in this debate, are they not? They indicate that the threat to Scotland’s continued membership of the European Union comes not from this Parliament, this Government or the people of Scotland but from the banks of the Thames with a Tory coalition Government that is heading towards the exit door and a Labour Opposition that has still to clarify what on earth it thinks about it.
I know that it is the First Minister’s stock-in-trade to miss the point, but the Czech foreign minister’s point is not about whether the Czechs would block Scotland but the price that they would extract for Scotland’s membership of the European Union.
The fact of the matter is that Alex Salmond and David Cameron are like peas in a pod. They will always put—[Interruption.]
The fact of the matter is that Alex Salmond and David Cameron are like peas in a pod. They will always put—[Interruption.]
Order.
They will always put—[Interruption.]
Order!
They will always put—[Interruption.]
Order!
They will always put their parties’ interest before the interests of the people of this country.
There is nothing quite so negative as trying to mislead the country, which is perhaps why support for independence is at its lowest since devolution. Perhaps the people who hear the First Minister say that he has legal advice when he does not do not believe him any more; maybe the pensioner lying on a trolley in a freezing corridor does not believe him when the First Minister says that he is doing a great job with the national health service; and maybe when the First Minister says that he is doing everything he can to create jobs and then goes on a half-million pound trip to the golf, people do not believe him.
The reality is that Alex Salmond cheered the Tories into Downing Street. [Interruption.]
There is nothing quite so negative as trying to mislead the country, which is perhaps why support for independence is at its lowest since devolution. Perhaps the people who hear the First Minister say that he has legal advice when he does not do not believe him any more; maybe the pensioner lying on a trolley in a freezing corridor does not believe him when the First Minister says that he is doing a great job with the national health service; and maybe when the First Minister says that he is doing everything he can to create jobs and then goes on a half-million pound trip to the golf, people do not believe him.
The reality is that Alex Salmond cheered the Tories into Downing Street. [Interruption.]
Order!
He sees Tory welfare cuts as an opportunity for his party and celebrates Tory mistakes on Europe. In fact, is it not the case that he loves the Tories so much that he has taken—[Interruption.]
Order!
Let me try it again so he definitely hears it.
In fact, is it not the case that he loves the Tories so much that he has taken support for independence down to Tory levels of popularity?
In fact, is it not the case that he loves the Tories so much that he has taken support for independence down to Tory levels of popularity?
I think that Johann Lamont should try it many times in order to get it right. I am not the one who is hand in glove with the Conservative Party in the better together campaign.
Amid all that fluff and nonsense, there was a serious point about the national health service. I want to make it clear that it is not acceptable in the NHS for any patient, let alone an 84-year-old man from Glasgow, to wait eight hours. However, I point out that the NHS conducts 1.5 million accident and emergency admissions in a year; indeed, the figure has gone up about 6 per cent over the past few years. I have been looking back at the figures, because not all of those admissions are conducted in the manner that we would like them to be. That is inevitable in any human-led organisation.
That said, one can measure whether the health service is improving or not. The facts are that when we took office, 90.3 per cent of patients in September 2006 waited less than four hours in accident and emergency across the national health service, while in September 2012, 95 per cent of patients waited less than four hours. Those are facts about improvement in the health service, which must be driven forward to ensure that we do not have individual cases of 84-year-olds waiting eight hours.
I have dealt with Johann Lamont’s alliance with the Conservative Party. [Interruption.] If those on the Labour benches do not like it, they should not be hand in glove with the better together campaign.
The point about the European Commission is not that it says that it is not going to comment on the Scottish situation; it says that it has not commented, but it allows the opportunity for the member state to find out its opinion. I would like to hear the European Commission’s opinion, which is why the Deputy First Minister has indicated that we are willing to do that in a joint submission. Unfortunately, Johann Lamont’s allies in the Conservative Party, and for that matter in the Liberal party, do not seem to have any enthusiasm for that. I wonder why. Is it because the proposition from the unionist parties that somehow energy-rich, fish-rich and renewables-rich Scotland would not be welcomed with open arms into the European Union is absolutely incredible? In contrast to the anti-European attitudes that prevail in the House of Commons, many people across the continent would welcome a pro-European Scotland into the community of nations.
Amid all that fluff and nonsense, there was a serious point about the national health service. I want to make it clear that it is not acceptable in the NHS for any patient, let alone an 84-year-old man from Glasgow, to wait eight hours. However, I point out that the NHS conducts 1.5 million accident and emergency admissions in a year; indeed, the figure has gone up about 6 per cent over the past few years. I have been looking back at the figures, because not all of those admissions are conducted in the manner that we would like them to be. That is inevitable in any human-led organisation.
That said, one can measure whether the health service is improving or not. The facts are that when we took office, 90.3 per cent of patients in September 2006 waited less than four hours in accident and emergency across the national health service, while in September 2012, 95 per cent of patients waited less than four hours. Those are facts about improvement in the health service, which must be driven forward to ensure that we do not have individual cases of 84-year-olds waiting eight hours.
I have dealt with Johann Lamont’s alliance with the Conservative Party. [Interruption.] If those on the Labour benches do not like it, they should not be hand in glove with the better together campaign.
The point about the European Commission is not that it says that it is not going to comment on the Scottish situation; it says that it has not commented, but it allows the opportunity for the member state to find out its opinion. I would like to hear the European Commission’s opinion, which is why the Deputy First Minister has indicated that we are willing to do that in a joint submission. Unfortunately, Johann Lamont’s allies in the Conservative Party, and for that matter in the Liberal party, do not seem to have any enthusiasm for that. I wonder why. Is it because the proposition from the unionist parties that somehow energy-rich, fish-rich and renewables-rich Scotland would not be welcomed with open arms into the European Union is absolutely incredible? In contrast to the anti-European attitudes that prevail in the House of Commons, many people across the continent would welcome a pro-European Scotland into the community of nations.
I call Johann Lamont again, because I expect any member in the chamber to be allowed to be heard when they ask their question.
Thank you, Presiding Officer. I have two brief points. The SNP’s position on Europe seems to have changed from, “Of course we would be a member,” to, “Why wouldn’t we be a member?” We need certainty.
On the health service, it is not good enough for a First Minister to come here and say that everything is fantastic or for policy to shift and be driven by a newspaper and a journalist raising questions. [Interruption.]
On the health service, it is not good enough for a First Minister to come here and say that everything is fantastic or for policy to shift and be driven by a newspaper and a journalist raising questions. [Interruption.]
Order.
It is about time that the First Minister got his health minister to ensure that the NHS is safe, rather than simply responding to scandal stories that have to get into the papers for action to be taken.
The record will show that I never said anything of the sort; on the contrary, I pointed out that there were 1.5 million admissions to accident and emergency and that, as with any human-led organisation, some people will not be treated as we would like. That is not acceptable. I specifically made the point that it is not acceptable for an old person to wait that length of time on a trolley in a Glasgow hospital or anywhere across the national health service.
The point that Johann Lamont did not like is that, through the statistics, we can see the improvement in accident and emergency in the national health service. If it is unacceptable now for anybody to be in that position—as I say it is—was it not more unacceptable in 2006, when the Labour Party was in power and many thousands more people were in that position in the national health service? A national health service that deals with 7 million treatments in a year, 1.5 million of which are in accident and emergency, should be seen as a health service and its workers performing in the interest of the nation.
I have one last point about accident and emergency: thank goodness that the Ayr and Monklands accident and emergency units are still open and have not been closed, as the Labour Party would have done.
The point that Johann Lamont did not like is that, through the statistics, we can see the improvement in accident and emergency in the national health service. If it is unacceptable now for anybody to be in that position—as I say it is—was it not more unacceptable in 2006, when the Labour Party was in power and many thousands more people were in that position in the national health service? A national health service that deals with 7 million treatments in a year, 1.5 million of which are in accident and emergency, should be seen as a health service and its workers performing in the interest of the nation.
I have one last point about accident and emergency: thank goodness that the Ayr and Monklands accident and emergency units are still open and have not been closed, as the Labour Party would have done.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 24 Jan 2013 →- Concessionary Fare Scheme (Edinburgh Trams) Questions · 7
- First World War (Centenary) Questions · 5
- NHS Borders Questions · 6
- Hospital Transport (Care Home Patients) Questions · 4
- Scottish Court Service (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Scottish Household Survey (Volunteering) Questions · 6
- Welfare Reform (Housing Benefit) Questions · 5
- Access to Culture (North Glasgow) Questions · 5
- Child Trafficking Questions · 8
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 28
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Defence Spending First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Life Expectancy (Deprived Areas) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cervical Cancer First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Cardiac Rehabilitation (Clinical Standards) Members’ business · 9
- Mental Health Strategy Debate · 69
- Point of Order Procedure · 5
- Decision Time Decision time · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.