4. To ask the First Minister what the Scottish Government’s position is on the recent report in The Scotsman that Scotland is receiving less than its population share of defence spending. (S4F-01144)
Official Report · Chamber
Defence Spending
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Bill Kidd SNP 2
- Elaine Smith Lab 2
- Rhoda Grant Lab 1
The record
10 contributions4. To ask the First Minister what the Scottish Government’s position is on the recent report in The Scotsman that Scotland is receiving less than its population share of defence spending. (S4F-01144)
The freedom of information request on which the article in The Scotsman is based reports that between 2007-08 and 2011-12, Scotland received £1.9 billion less than its population share of Government spending on major European Union-exempt projects.
The Scottish Government’s position is that Scotland’s interests would be best served under independence and if this Parliament could take decisions on such matters, allowing our defence and shipbuilding industries to flourish. I notice that that was backed by Ian Godden, former chairman of defence industry leader ADS, who recently said in evidence to the Scottish Affairs Committee:
“Scotland can maintain its position in defence interests because there is an industrial and engineering capability that Scotland has got which makes it attractive.”
The Scottish Government’s position is that Scotland’s interests would be best served under independence and if this Parliament could take decisions on such matters, allowing our defence and shipbuilding industries to flourish. I notice that that was backed by Ian Godden, former chairman of defence industry leader ADS, who recently said in evidence to the Scottish Affairs Committee:
“Scotland can maintain its position in defence interests because there is an industrial and engineering capability that Scotland has got which makes it attractive.”
The First Minister will be aware that the Ministry of Defence announced earlier this week that up to 5,000 job losses are expected as a result of further Army redundancies. Will the Scottish Government raise that issue with the United Kingdom Government and seek clarity on how Scotland might be affected by those redundancies? Does the First Minister think that instead of wasting billions of pounds on the obscenity of nuclear weapons, the money would be better spent on maintaining the front line?
I do think that, and I think that the Conservative-led Government, which has regarded defence as a major issue in the constitutional debate, should explain why people who have been on the front line, fighting in Afghanistan, will potentially come home to P45s. Most human beings would find that prospect, under the Conservative Party, disgraceful.
On Trident, I also note a correction in The Herald newspaper. It seems that the previous jobs estimates that were quoted were based on double and triple counting.
Given the real redundancies in defence that are happening under the Conservative-led Government—[Interruption.]
On Trident, I also note a correction in The Herald newspaper. It seems that the previous jobs estimates that were quoted were based on double and triple counting.
Given the real redundancies in defence that are happening under the Conservative-led Government—[Interruption.]
Order.
—and the waste of billions of pounds of expenditure on a system of mass destruction, it would be far better if those areas were under Scottish control.
The First Minister will be aware that The Scotsman report did not cover all Ministry of Defence spending in Scotland, including the cost of extensive world-class protection for our oil and gas rigs in the North Sea. Can he tell me how that protection would be provided if Scotland was to leave the UK?
It would be provided by the Scottish conventional defence forces and the advantage would be that we would have conventional forces—[Interruption.]
Order.
We would have conventional forces protecting Scotland’s interests in partnership with our allies, as opposed to wasting billions of pounds on an unwanted, unusable system of weapons of mass destruction that the vast majority of Scottish MPs, and the overwhelming majority of MSPs in this chamber, have voted against.
If Rhoda Grant believes in this Parliament and in the views that have been expressed by many people in the Labour Party, how on earth can she accept a situation in which billions of pounds of expenditure are wasted on Trident, while conventional defence forces are being run down? With the system of public spending cuts that we see across the UK, how can she possibly defend those billions going into weapons of mass destruction? She should look to her conscience and come up with a different answer.
If Rhoda Grant believes in this Parliament and in the views that have been expressed by many people in the Labour Party, how on earth can she accept a situation in which billions of pounds of expenditure are wasted on Trident, while conventional defence forces are being run down? With the system of public spending cuts that we see across the UK, how can she possibly defend those billions going into weapons of mass destruction? She should look to her conscience and come up with a different answer.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 24 Jan 2013 →- Concessionary Fare Scheme (Edinburgh Trams) Questions · 7
- First World War (Centenary) Questions · 5
- NHS Borders Questions · 6
- Hospital Transport (Care Home Patients) Questions · 4
- Scottish Court Service (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Scottish Household Survey (Volunteering) Questions · 6
- Welfare Reform (Housing Benefit) Questions · 5
- Access to Culture (North Glasgow) Questions · 5
- Child Trafficking Questions · 8
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 28
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Defence Spending First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Life Expectancy (Deprived Areas) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cervical Cancer First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Cardiac Rehabilitation (Clinical Standards) Members’ business · 9
- Mental Health Strategy Debate · 69
- Point of Order Procedure · 5
- Decision Time Decision time · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.