Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Non-Domestic Rating (Unoccupied Property) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations (SSI 2013/37)

Wednesday 13 March 2013 Local Government and Regeneration Committee About 10:00 Subordinate legislation 31 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

31 contributions
Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Agenda item 3 is an oral evidence-taking session on a negative instrument. Members will have received the clerk’s cover paper setting out the background to the regulations, which the Subordinate Legislation Committee has drawn to the Parliament’s attention in relation to the clarity of regulation 6 and proper drafting practices for SSIs. Those comments are set out in annex A in the clerk’s paper. Margaret Mitchell has lodged a motion to annul the instrument, and we will consider that after this oral evidence session.I welcome to the meeting Derek Mackay, the Minister for Local Government and Planning, who is accompanied by Graham Owenson, head of the local government finance unit, and Colin Brown, senior principal legal officer, both with the Scottish Government. Do you wish to make any remarks on the SSI, minister?

The Minister for Local Government and Planning Derek Mackay
link

I have no remarks on either SSI we will be discussing. I think that they are both straightforward.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Do you have any comments, Mrs Mitchell?

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Then I think that we should just move straight to that, convener.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Does anyone have any questions for the minister? Interruption. Minister, the clerk has just informed me that you should address SSI 2013/37.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

It would be particularly useful to hear what, if anything, the officials have to say about the regulations. After all, they cannot make any comments during the debate on the motion to annul.

Colin Brown Scottish Government
link

Are we still on item 2, convener?

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

No, we are on item 3.Minister, if you want to make a statement and if any of the officials have any comments to make, now is the time to do so.

Derek Mackay
link

I seek clarification, convener. Is item 3 not the motion to annul, in which case I would be responding to Margaret Mitchell’s motion?

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Item 4 is on the annulment. Item 3 is an evidence-taking session on the regulations.

Derek Mackay
link

In that case, I will be speaking to rebut a motion to annul. If that is what I am doing, that is what I will proceed with.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

No. Minister, I will suspend the meeting for a couple of minutes to allow the clerk to speak with you.10:04 Meeting suspended.

10:06 On resuming—

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I apologise to the masses watching at home. Laughter. As the deputy convener has pointed out, today is the 13th, which is probably why we are having these glitches.I call Margaret Mitchell to speak to her motion to annul the Non-Domestic Rating (Unoccupied Property) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2013 (SSI 2013/37).

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Thank you, convener.As the committee will be aware, the Scottish Conservatives have consistently opposed the Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc) (Scotland) Act 2012 and the policies behind it, which these regulations implement. It is the wrong policy at the wrong time, premised as it is on the fundamentally flawed notion that commercial properties are empty through choice rather than as a result of a fundamental lack of demand and the current economic climate. Furthermore, the Government has presented neither a shred of evidence to suggest that owners of empty properties are intentionally keeping them unoccupied nor any empirical evidence to indicate the number of properties that will be brought back into use because of the cut in relief.According to the minister, there was no formal consultation on these proposals in the legislation because of“the scale of the issue.”—Official Report, Local Government and Regeneration Committee, 30 May 2012; c 1058.However, all the other parts of the legislation were subject to formal consultation, including an aspect that will affect only one council and will cost only £750,000 a year. It beggars belief that a measure that, according to the Government’s figures, would impose an £18 million burden on businesses was not formally consulted on and that, despite the Government’s own guidelines categorically stating that a business and regulatory impact assessment is required if a proposal imposes “additional cost ... on businesses”, such an assessment was not carried out in this case. The minister claimed that carrying out a BRIA would not be proportionate, given the small amount that the relief cut will raise, but he failed to mention that, according to his own guidelines, proportionality is relevant only to the BRIA’s content and not to the decision on whether to carry out such an assessment.The minister has been successful only in uniting business representatives across the board in their justified opposition to this unwarranted additional tax on retail and other business property, from which unoccupied industrial property is exempt. Bizarrely, as a consequence—and as the Scottish business ratepayers group has highlighted—internet retailers who are in direct competition with the retail sector on the high street and who are often located in industrial or warehouse space will be exempt from the reduced rate of tax relief regarding their unoccupied property. That is clearly an inconsistency in this poorly thought out policy, which disadvantages the non-industrial business sector.By introducing an exemption for newly built properties in the regulations, the Government has admitted that the bill, as it was passed, would have harmed the very kind of speculative development that our economy needs to get growing. If the minister had listened to the Scottish Conservatives and accepted the amendment that I lodged at stages 2 and 3, which would have secured such an exemption in the bill, a great deal of uncertainty and negative messages over speculative development could have been avoided.On that basis and for the reasons that I have given, I urge the committee to support the motion to annul the regulations and I move the motion in my name.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

You should move the motion when we get to agenda item 4, Mrs Mitchell.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

The Conservative position is well understood and has been rehearsed on a number of occasions. However, it misses some rather important points that run counter to what the Conservatives would traditionally suggest that they stand for.We have just heard reference made to the lack of demand for premises. The regulations and the primary legislation promote demand by creating an environment in which there is an incentive to businesses to price to let, so as to get money from lets at a level that is sustainable in the current market rather than have property sitting empty. Far from being anti-business, that is a pro-business proposition.Margaret Mitchell said that the issue had united business, but that is far from the case. Many businesses are finding the rental price for properties sufficiently high that they are unable to progress. Businesses that will benefit from an increase in the supply of property to the market at an affordable price are unlikely to feel that we should not proceed with the measure. Margaret Mitchell also said that the economy needs speculative activity. It is time to promote a bit more activity among the landlords and owners of unlet premises to price accordingly in order to get the economy moving. That is precisely what can be achieved through the measure.The Conservatives, as a party that suggests that it is fiscally responsible—although I would not necessarily concur—must identify where the £18 million that might come to the Government from the measure, which is voluntary in the sense that it can be avoided if a landlord lets their premises, might otherwise be found in the Government’s books.Having listened to the arguments and in anticipation of what the minister has to say, I think that it is entirely appropriate that we continue to support this much-needed change.

Derek Mackay
link

I have been waiting keenly for this moment. I rebut Margaret Mitchell’s motion to annul the SSI. The purpose of the instrument is to vary rates relief on empty properties by regulation, an intention that was set out during the spending review in 2011. I acknowledge that Ms Mitchell has been critical of the policy from the outset. There has indeed been consistency, but it has been consistently inconsistent with what the Conservatives have done in office.In these challenging economic times, it is important that we ensure that business rates relief maximises opportunity and allows Scotland to retain its position as the most supportive business environment anywhere in the United Kingdom. We also need to maximise the effectiveness of the £560 million-worth of annual rates relief that we provide to businesses and ensure that we continue to provide the right incentives to support the economic recovery that we need.10:15

The regulations will create two new rates relief schemes, which I announced after listening to stakeholders. The first is the fresh start initiative, which applies where a property has been empty for more than 12 months and then becomes occupied. As an incentive to support the diversification of our town centres, properties with a rateable value of under £45,000 that were previously occupied as a shop or office, or where there has been no previous use, will be eligible for rates relief on their new use as a shop or office. For the first year of occupancy, the new occupier can apply for a 50 per cent reduction in the rates that are payable, capped by state aid de minimis rules. The Welsh Government announced on 5 March that it will introduce a similar scheme.The second relief scheme is the new start initiative, which will apply when a new property is first entered in the valuation roll on or after 1 April 2013. The ratepayer can apply for 100 per cent rates relief for up to 18 months while the property is unoccupied, capped by state aid de minimis rules. The relief scheme will run for three years and is being introduced six months ahead of the UK Government’s planned equivalent. Its aim—which has been welcomed by the Scottish Property Federation—is to continue to encourage speculative development.We remain focused on maintaining Scotland’s position as the most competitive environment for business by offering a significantly more generous relief package than is offered elsewhere in the UK. We are still protecting industrial and listed properties from the reforms to empty property relief. Despite the UK Government funding cuts, the relief package is worth more than £0.5 billion a year.To support our businesses and high streets further through our empty property relief reforms, we launched a review of our town centres. We all acknowledge that the role of town centres is changing and evolving, which is having a visible impact on businesses and communities throughout the country. A key challenge for us all is to ensure that we support the process of change that is required to help to turn around the fortunes of our town centres.We all share the objective of seeing town centres return to being viable centres for employment and services for local communities, and a focus for entrepreneurial and civic activity. We have already signalled our support for the work of the review by announcing a £2 million fund that is aimed at promoting our town centres as attractive places not only to work or visit but to live. A report from the town centre review, on a trial of the conversion of offices and shops to residential properties, is due in April.Margaret Mitchell is attempting to annul not only the reform of empty property relief, but the fresh start and new start relief schemes, which are a direct outcome of stakeholder engagement. With regard to the points that have been made about demolition and speculative development, and the Tory view of industrial properties, we have learned from the evidence on what happened to such properties in England, which is why the exemption continues in Scotland.The point about demolition refers specifically to the experience with industrial properties, and I question why Margaret Mitchell would not want such properties to continue to be exempt. We believe that we have addressed the points about speculative development through our new start relief.We must be able to adapt to changing circumstances, which is why the new act is helpful, and we are able to return to the regulations. We are committed to a review and on-going monitoring of the policy. In recognising that the high street is under pressure, I question the Conservatives’ point of view. Why is it fair to make it cheaper to close a property on the high street than to keep it open and trading? How exactly would that help the high street?For all those reasons, I urge the committee to reject Margaret Mitchell’s motion to annul the regulations.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Thank you. Are there any questions for the minister?

John Pentland Lab Motherwell and Wishaw
link

I have not so much a question, but more of a statement.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

We will have the opportunity to debate under the next agenda item, so perhaps we can just stick to questions at the moment. I know that we have been a little bit here and there this morning, but it is probably best that we proceed in that way.If there are no questions for the minister, we move to item 4, which is the debate on the motion to annul the Non-Domestic Rating (Unoccupied Property) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2013 (SSI 2013/37), on which we have just taken evidence. I know that members want to speak in the debate. Mr Pentland can go first.

John Pentland Lab Motherwell and Wishaw
link

The minister will be aware that, in the past, we in the Labour Party have agreed in principle that something must be done about unoccupied properties. The instrument will probably go through but, for the record, we believe that, rather than act as an incentive, it could result in the problem of further unoccupied properties. We do not have confidence that the instrument will achieve its objective, because we do not believe that the work has been done to back it up. No BRIA or any other impact assessment has been carried out. We believe that the measure could be counterproductive.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I ask Margaret Mitchell to speak to motion S4M-05785.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Stewart Stevenson asserts that the rates relief cut would create an environment in which there is an incentive to price to let, which shows just how out of touch he and the Scottish National Party Government are. Does he not realise that that is already in place and that people are cutting rates and rental incomes to the bone in an effort to rent out property?The minister heralded two measures: the fresh start initiative and the speculative development exemption on newly built properties, which should have been included during the passage of the Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc) (Scotland) Bill, but which the Government rejected for no good reason. It seems to me that the Government has had time to reflect and has come back with those measures. They amount to no more than sticking plasters on what is a fundamentally flawed act and policy, the only consequence of which will be to deeply damage business growth and economic development.Throughout the debate, there has been the assertion that the policy will bring business properties back into use. We have heard that claim time and again without any evidence to support it. Perhaps when the minister replies, he could give us an indication of how many properties will be brought back into use and how much of the projected £18 million of possible income will actually be collected.The minister, either deliberately or through a fundamental misunderstanding of the rates that are currently due on unoccupied property, has continued to present the policy as one that will ensure that landlords pay rates for vacant properties, rather than let those properties go empty at no cost. However, landlords already pay 50 per cent on vacant properties, which is once again proof positive that this rates relief reduction tax is not an incentive, as the minister has repeatedly claimed, but an extended penalty on already hard-pressed businesses.By contrast, the evidence in the sector is that landlords are doing all that they can to cut rents, and I hope that Stewart Stevenson is listening keenly at this point. The Scottish Property Federation listed examples of property owners cutting rents by up to half, just to get the properties let out. That is hardly the behaviour of absentee or disinterested landlords.The policy will add a further burden to businesses and property owners at a time when many are already struggling, without the most basic evidence to support the minister’s claim that it will bring empty properties back into use or provide an incentive to do so. For that reason, I cannot support the regulations.I move,That the Local Government and Regeneration Committee recommends that the Non-Domestic Rating (Unoccupied Property) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2013 (SSI/2013/37) be annulled.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Minister, do you wish to respond?

Derek Mackay
link

Nobody likes paying more taxes—nobody likes paying taxes and, certainly, nobody likes paying more, and I am not surprised that some groups have expressed that opinion.It is important to get the policy right, which is why there has been a continuing process of engagement beyond a business and regulatory impact assessment. If members are familiar with BRIAs, they will know what they involve. The Government can evidence how we have gone beyond the expectations of a BRIA in assessing the impact of the policy and in addressing the formulation of policy through the regulations that are before us and through our proposals to maximise their effect.We have looked at all the available evidence. We should bear it in mind that the policy on empty property rates relief began under the Labour Party and was emulated by the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats in England. We have closely studied the UK Government’s command paper, to which I assume Margaret Mitchell objects. We closely studied the view of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors on the matter and we listened carefully to the evidence from the Scottish Property Federation, the Confederation of British Industry and other organisations before coming to the conclusion that there were things that we could do to make the policy better. That amounted to the new start and fresh start initiatives, which address some of the concerns that have been raised.We must balance the books. The silence during the budget debate was deafening as regards what our counterparts in other parties would do to balance the books. To return to Mr Stevenson’s point, I did not hear about any substitute finance for the £18 million that we think we will realise through this budget saving. The cost of the relief will still be more than £700 million over a spending review period, and the total rates relief per year is now more than £500 million. People appreciate the rates relief, although we are posing the question on that in our rates consultation to ensure that we get it right.We have responded appropriately, and I believe that the regulations provide a cost-saving measure and a genuine incentive to bring empty properties that blight our communities back into use. Although that might not be universally popular among the folk who pay the taxes, it has certainly been far more popular among the local communities throughout Scotland that want something done about empty premises on their high streets.I again make the point that, in office, the Conservatives have continued with the policy. The regulations will add the necessary ingredient as part of the regeneration of our country.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

I am afraid that the minister has reeled out the same tired old assertion without any substance to back it. Let us be in no doubt that empty properties are already taxed and that the regulations impose an additional penalty on business. No ifs, no buts—it is a fact. I find it astounding that the minister has looked to what is happening in England—where, incidentally, the Government is reviewing the policy, with good reason—and says that we must follow the same line. I wonder why on earth he advocates independence for Scotland.The Scottish Government’s policy is fundamentally flawed and will damage business. The fact that no consultation has taken place and no BRIA has been carried out speaks volumes, and measures are having to be taken in the background to try to make the policy palatable or even workable. For all those reasons, I cannot support the regulations.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

The question is, that motion S4M-05785 be agreed to. Are we agreed?Members: No.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

There will be a division.ForMcTaggart, Anne (Glasgow) (Lab)Mitchell, Margaret (Central Scotland) (Con)Pentland, John (Motherwell and Wishaw) (Lab)AgainstMcMillan, Stuart (West Scotland) (SNP)Stevenson, Stewart (Banffshire and Buchan Coast) (SNP)Stewart, Kevin (Aberdeen Central) (SNP)Wilson, John (Central Scotland) (SNP)

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

The result of the division is: For 3, Against 4, Abstentions 0.Motion disagreed to.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  3. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 31
  4. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 56
  5. 10:00 Local Government Elections 2012 Committee business · 10
  6. 10:00 Petition Petitions · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.