Item 5 is oral evidence on a draft affirmative instrument. Members have a cover paper from the clerk, setting out the background to the instrument. The Subordinate Legislation Committee did not raise any points on the draft order.10:30
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Valuation (Postponement of Revaluation) (Scotland) Order 2013 [Draft]
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Derek Mackay 19
- Kevin Stewart SNP 13
- Margaret Mitchell Con 12
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 5
- Stuart McMillan SNP 3
- Graham Owenson Scottish Government 2
- John Pentland Lab 1
- Anne McTaggart Lab 1
The record
56 contributionsThank you, convener.The purpose of this affirmative instrument is to postpone the next business rates revaluation until 2017. As members will know, the UK Government announced last October that it would delay the next revaluation in England from 2015 to 2017. That decision created a set of circumstances that could have undermined our continued commitment to match the English poundage rate. The business community has—rightly—wanted the uncertainty to be removed. If the average rateable values of properties in Scotland fell as a result of our proceeding with our own revaluation in 2015, the poundage would have had to be increased above the English rate to maintain the same income necessary to deliver the services on which businesses rely. For seven consecutive years, the previous Administration set the poundage in Scotland higher than that in England, putting all ratepayers in Scotland at a significant competitive disadvantage.Although I also acknowledge the petition that has been submitted to Parliament by Colliers International to have the decision overturned, I feel that it misses the point. Holding the next revaluation in 2015 will, as I have said, put businesses in Scotland at a competitive disadvantage, as it would mean having to raise the poundage rate above that set in England. We are not prepared to do that. For many businesses, a revaluation would be a zero-sum game. Having discussed the issue with stakeholders, we think that there is an impression that everyone would be a winner, but that is not the case and ministers have fully considered the policy implications. To achieve the Scottish Government’s policy of ensuring that the poundage rate in Scotland does not rise above the English rate during the lifetime of the 2011 to 2016 session of Parliament, we will hold the next revaluation in 2017. In short, therefore, the result of the order will be that the next Scottish revaluation will come into effect on 1 April 2017, allowing us to set in Scotland the same poundage rate as that in England.We have chosen to use the time productively to conduct a thorough and comprehensive review of the rating system, beginning with our consultation paper on business rates, “Supporting Business—Promoting Growth”. That consultation sought views from all business ratepayers on two main areas: how the rating and valuation appeals system can support businesses and sustain sustainable economic growth; and how to improve transparency and streamline the operation of the rating system, including the appeals process, while still raising revenue to deliver the services on which businesses rely. The consultation closed on 22 February and, following the independent analysis of all responses, a report will be published in due course. Any change to the rating system that results from the consultation will be put in place in time for the next revaluation, but any affordable early actions that are identified can be implemented much sooner.I am happy to answer the committee’s questions.
Thank you, minister. I remind members that this is a question-and-answer session, after which we will have the debate on the motion.
I have a couple of questions about the review of the rating system that can be conducted in the space created by the order’s postponement of the revaluation. First, I do not have any evidence so I am uncertain what lies beneath these comments but, according to many smaller town centre retailers, supermarkets game the system by buying properties in town centres and then letting them out for a high rental in an attempt to influence prevailing rentals and, through that artificial inflation of town centre rentals, to shift out-of-town ratings in their favour. As I have said, I have no evidence that I can point to, but I would be interested to hear your views on that.Secondly, should we look again at businesses in which there is a significant link between rateable value and turnover? If turnover is going to be the paramount determinant of rateable value for some businesses, should such an approach not be taken to all businesses? After all, it might level the playing field for both town centre businesses and very large out-of-town businesses.I wonder whether creating the space by postponing the revaluation would allow us to consider those and other issues.
The short answer to that is yes: postponement would give us time to consider more fully all those matters and a number of questions that we have posed in the consultation paper.On tactics, I have no evidence that I could confidently present to the committee today on how supermarkets deploy either their planning strategy or their rental strategy, although I may have some views on that. However, it goes to the nub of the issue regarding rates revaluation. For people to assume that everyone would be a winner if revaluation went ahead is wrong; there will be winners and losers in any revaluation. There will be an interesting geographic spread, and even within geographical areas there will be winners and losers based on who is sited where. There is no question but that high streets across the country are suffering and that out-of-town sites have generally fared better. However, even to say that one sector—the supermarket or smaller retail sector—would be better off with a revaluation is not necessarily true. I would not want to comment further on tactics.On turnover, business rates are a property tax rather than a profit tax. Some people confuse the two. It is still our proposition that non-domestic rates continue to be based on the value and rental as a property tax, not a turnover or profit tax. Nevertheless, members have raised some interesting considerations in relation to that.
The minister will be aware that many rentals that are operated in the commercial sector are tied to the turnover of business, so there is no absolute disconnect between the turnover of the business and the rental that is established in a commercial environment. Is it not proper that we should at least consider—albeit that we do not necessarily yet have the evidence—whether there should be a similar component in the taxation system in determining what the rateable value should be?
I understand your point. You are absolutely right that rateable values are driven by rents, which are driven by turnover in many respects on the basis of the profitability of businesses. Therefore, there is a linkage. The valuers assess not the value of the turnover but the value of the property, although turnover is, as you say, an indicator and a factor within that.I will give you an example. At the moment there is some discretion so that, if there is a change of circumstances in a place, the local authority valuer can amend the assessment and give some relief to those who have been impacted through that change of circumstances. That change might be tied to turnover or profitability issues outwith the control of the tenant or the ratepayer.It is a complex area. Your fundamental question was whether there is scope to look at the issue. There is, but our proposition is to continue with a property-based tax.
The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth, John Swinney, announced the decision to postpone business rates revaluation from 2015 to 2017 on 27 November last year. Can the minister tell us what consultation took place prior to that announcement?
Because of the other issues around business rates, the cabinet secretary would, like me, have been discussing with a range of stakeholders what the options were. There was no formal consultation, but a BRIA has been conducted—as best we could conduct a BRIA in the circumstances—to arrive at this recommendation and action today, which is what members asked for.
I point out to the minister that, when I asked the cabinet secretary about the consultation that had taken place prior to his announcement, he could not name a single organisation that the Government had consulted. Can you do that today, minister?
I say to you again that there was no formal consultation on the matter. That is an issue for Government. The partial BRIA that we have conducted has informed this morning’s debate. I also guarantee that the matter would have come up in conversations relating to rates. People would have been asking ministers and the cabinet secretary what was likely to happen in Scotland as a consequence of the decision in England. The Welsh Administration has made the same decision as we have. I guarantee that the matter would have come up in the conversation that ministers have had with stakeholders over the past number of months.
So that is a no—no organisation or business was formally consulted prior to the decision being made.
link
Good morning, minister. Can you give any indication of what the financial burden on businesses would be if the revaluation was not postponed?
Given that we aspire to keep our manifesto commitment to maintain poundage at the same level as it is in England, which is well worth doing, we estimate that the cost of non-domestic rates would potentially have had to increase by around 20 per cent.
If Mr Owenson wants to come in at this point, that would be appropriate.
There is no exact answer, because there can be no certainty until the revaluation is carried out. However, when England announced its postponement of the revaluation, estimates suggested that values would have gone down by approximately 23 to 25 per cent. If that had been the case, there would have been a corresponding increase in poundage to maintain the same level of income, although there would have been differing impacts on individual businesses. Unless we undertake the revaluation, there is no definitive answer to that question.
link
But it is fair to assume that there would have been an additional cost burden on Scottish businesses.
Yes. If the revaluation had gone ahead and values had reduced as a result, there would have been a direct increase in rates for some businesses in order to maintain the poundage level. However, we cannot say for certain which sectors or which businesses would have been affected, because that is all based on the revaluation. The postponement gives us certainty in that regard.
link
Sure.
Putting aside speculation about what may have happened as a result of a revaluation that has not taken place and will now be postponed, is it not the case that, as a direct consequence of the postponement, businesses throughout Scotland will continue to pay good-time rates until 2017 despite having to trade throughout the current recession and some of the most challenging economic times and conditions imaginable? That is the reality resulting from the postponement.
Of course, the same applies in England and now in Wales. Margaret Mitchell may want to argue again for Scottish independence, and I am sympathetic to that. I am also sympathetic to the Scottish Government having a range of financial levers so that it can act independently in other ways rather than simply through non-domestic rates.We have the most generous relief package in the United Kingdom, which is helping many businesses to sustain their operations in difficult times. The small business bonus scheme, for example, has been a great relief for the high streets, as many businesses pay nothing and many more pay discounted rates.
I find the minister’s obsession with what is going on in England absolutely fascinating, considering that he is supposed to be standing for an independent Scotland, but that is up to him.The minister will be aware that transitional relief is in place south of the border to compensate for the potential impact on businesses from the revaluation by limiting increases and decreases and taking cognisance of individual circumstances. Will the minister put in place transitional relief in Scotland, now that he has just been whispered to by his official?
I want to clarify that there cannot be transitional relief if there is no transition, and there is no transition if there is no revaluation. It is very straightforward, as we are not undertaking the revaluation.
The transition came in 2010 at the previous revaluation, so the relief has been in place but we have not had it here. Will the minister put in place transitional rates relief now that he is extending the revaluation postponement to 2017? It seems completely fair that we recognise the new circumstances.
If Margaret Mitchell is familiar with transitional relief, she will know that it takes effect when there has been a change to the rateable value. There is no revaluation and therefore such relief is not required. It is debatable whether it would actually help certain businesses that may face a different set of circumstances.10:45
Margaret Mitchell makes the assumption that every business would be a winner and that every business will pay a smaller rates bill as a consequence of revaluation, but that is absolutely not the case. The picture will be different from sector to sector and, for the reasons that I gave earlier, it will even be different in different parts of the country. For many businesses, it will be a zero-sum game, as what they gain through revaluation will be lost through an increased poundage rate. I have not heard Margaret Mitchell object to trying to give Scotland that competitive advantage. My aim in keeping a very close eye on what happens in other parts of the United Kingdom is—just as with the planning system—to ensure that Scotland is at a competitive advantage. The poundage, the rates relief and the general environment that we create for business in Scotland put us in a very good place. In relation to this policy area, we are able to do better than other parts of the UK because of our comprehensive package of support.
Like Margaret Mitchell, I sometimes wonder whether the Scottish Government really wants independence. Whenever there is an opportunity for a decision to be made, it is put aside and the Government refers to our brothers in England. This issue is a very good example of that: the Government is frightened to make its own decision.I have two questions to ask the minister. First, do we have any guarantee that the revaluation will not be postponed further? Secondly, what projections have been assumed for future property values?
Unless the Government becomes a self-perpetuating oligarchy, I cannot predict any future Government minister—or indeed Government—ruling out a postponement in the future. I have set out our intention for the period that we are in office, which is to put Scotland at a competitive advantage, to make this a great place in which to do business, to postpone the revaluation and to do it within the timeframe that I have set out. There is no reason why it cannot be done in that timeframe.I disagree with your comment that, whenever there is a difficult decision to be made, we follow Westminster. The Labour Party in Wales is making exactly the same decision on revaluation. Why is that the case? We set out in our manifesto our aspirations to make Scotland a good place to do business and not to allow the Scottish poundage rate to be higher than that which is set in England, and we must see what is happening in England to make that policy take effect. That is why our actions have followed what has happened in England. Wales has done the same—Northern Ireland’s circumstances are completely different.We want access to all the levers of financial control and access to our resources, as Scotland generates more than is spent here. Many opportunities would come with independence, but I would argue that it is worth keeping an eye on what our counterparts in other Administrations are doing so that we can do a wee bit better than them. I am confident in both the timescale that we have set out and the justifications that we have given for making this decision. So far, I have not heard any member—either in the chamber or in the committee—come up with an alternative suggestion that would be good for business.
Minister, how would you react to the possibility that these measures would penalise family and small businesses that acquired property in better economic circumstances only to see the value reduce significantly post-2008 and which feel not only that they could be forced to sell their property as a result of the loss through the revaluation but, in many circumstances, that they could be forced into a position of negative equity?
That is an excellent question and I will respond in kind. Anne McTaggart gives the example of a small family business in a local town. That small family business is likely to be paying no rates whatsoever now, so revaluation would possibly mean no change for it. Depending on the value of the property, that business may well be receiving the small business bonus, which has supported a great number of businesses. Two in five premises have seen their rates removed or reduced.The number of businesses that have benefited from the small business bonus has been increasing across the country year on year. According to the current estimate, that particular relief costs £145 million for the year 2012-13. That is £145 million of support for the kind of small businesses that Anne McTaggart eloquently characterised in her scenario. Over the spending period, the relief amounts to £711 million—an invaluable relief that is supported by, for example, the Federation of Small Businesses. Even after amendment, it is still not quite as costly as the empty property rates relief that we were debating just moments ago.In addition to the invaluable relief for small businesses, a range of work is going on in partnership with local government on the regeneration of town centres and on the question in the on-going rates review of potentially giving local authorities discretion in that area. Anne McTaggart was formerly a member of Glasgow City Council, which has a particular package for supporting what are almost mini enterprise zones, whether that is a high street, a property or an area.To be generous, I should say that good work is going on in England, where there is some legal flexibility for local authorities to determine where to give extra support through rates relief. We are probing that in our current consultation. Over and above what we give right now to support businesses in town centres and small businesses, we are looking at the prospect of giving greater flexibility and further discretion to local authorities on rates relief—as long as they are willing to pay for it, of course—for the creation of mini enterprise zones, which might be a property, a street or a community. I am confident that the package of support that we provide is adequate—it is more generous than that in any other part of the United Kingdom—but we are looking at how we can do more. I hope that that answers the member’s question.
I want to make just a quick point in relation to transitional relief. I wonder whether the minister can confirm that, in relation to the previous revaluation and any future one, those having their increases in payments moderated by transitional relief would find that it was paid for by postponement for those who would benefit from a reduction in their rates and that it is a net-sum game; and that just as there may have been businesses in the previous revaluation that wanted the introduction of transitional rates relief because they might benefit from postponement of extra costs, there were large numbers of businesses that were desperate to ensure that they got a reduction in the taxation that they were paying at the earliest possible opportunity.
That is absolutely correct.
I have two brief points. First, surely the minister must accept that the rates review consultation is less than effective, to say the least, given that the bombshell decision to postpone the revaluation came as a fait accompli right in the middle of the consultation, with no prior consultation of any businesses or organisations. Secondly, will the minister confirm that by postponing the revaluation, the majority of businesses—I do not think that I referred anywhere to all businesses—are now paying rates determined by much more favourable market conditions that no longer exist and that therefore those rates are often no longer affordable for the businesses? That being the case, I wonder where that leaves the Scottish Government’s rhetoric on its governing principle of taxation, given that the cabinet secretary told the Parliament that the burden of taxation is to be proportionate to the ability to pay.
Will the member take an intervention?
I will let you in later. It is now for the minister to respond.
My first response is that for an earlier item on the agenda I was told that the BRIA was the be-all and end-all of consultation with the private sector on policy matters, but now I am being told that a partial BRIA that is the best that we can do is not good enough for engagement with the private sector—that is completely contrary to what I heard earlier. The reason why we cannot have a full BRIA, of course, is because we cannot assess the full impact, which would need a revaluation. However, the order’s purpose is, for the reasons that I have given, not to have the revaluation.Margaret Mitchell made a point about our policy choices. I think that other parts of the United Kingdom look very jealously at our economic recovery plan and economic policies, but we could do more if we had all the powers to maximise the opportunities to build economic recovery in this country, rather than do what the UK chancellor is doing, which is to stagnate economic recovery.The clear commitment that we have made on the poundage was never delivered by our predecessors, but it is being delivered by our action on the order today—and it has been delivered over the past number of years by matching Scotland’s poundage rate to the rate in England so that Scotland retains a competitive advantage.On the member’s reference to there being no business support for our policy, I refer her to the comments of the CBI. It is hardly the closest ally of the Scottish Government, but it said that we are doing the right thing, given the limitations that we face.
Will you just answer the question, minister? Will you confirm that businesses are stuck with good-times rates when the good times no longer exist?
I think that you asked me a number of questions, and I have been able to go over all of them.
Will you address the fundamental question that I asked?
Again, you make the fundamentally wrong assumption that every business and every property in every area would benefit—
I have already said that that is not the case.
Give the minister the opportunity to respond, please, Mrs Mitchell.
The assumption has been made that every business would benefit from a rates revaluation. The fundamental proposition that it was good times for everyone before and that it is bad times for everyone now is not accurate. I will be candid that, for some, we will never know what they might have paid, because we are not having the revaluation. Of course, revaluation would have meant a different rates bill for some, but you cannot make the universal charge that Margaret Mitchell has.
I think that you are making it up now, minister.
Can the minister confirm that the amount that an individual business pays as a proportion of the overall amount raised from business rates is determined by the proportion of the overall valuation of properties across Scotland that its property represents, and that the only way to reduce the tax take for all businesses is to reduce uniform business rates? The rateable value itself is utterly irrelevant; it is only relevant for businesses relative to other businesses, and for every winner there will always be a loser, unless the uniform business rate level is reduced altogether.
That is exactly why I focus on the poundage. That is the formula that determines how much people pay in a bill to the local authority. That money then comes to the Scottish Government, and we then give the resources back to the local authorities.
Minister, you mentioned at the outset that there may be quite large geographical differences. If the revaluation went ahead, could it stymie economic growth in certain areas of the country?
That really would be speculating, and I would not want to do that. I am indicating that economies and recoveries have different strengths across the country. For example, there is a completely different experience in your constituency in Aberdeen, sector by sector and area by area, compared with the experience in parts of the central belt. Different pressures are being experienced. For some areas that are enjoying a stronger economic recovery, that may well have meant higher rateable values, higher rates bills and bigger tax bills to the point that that could possibly discourage growth.
Just to clarify, there are always winners and losers with revaluation. Will you comment on what happened with the previous revaluation? Do officials have information about that?
I do not have the exact statistics, but my memory of what happened, particularly in relation to the decision not to have a transitional relief scheme, is that if we had had a transitional relief scheme the balance would have favoured the public sector at the expense of the private sector. For that reason, the Government decided that it was not prepared to do that.
That is very useful. I thank you both for your evidence.Agenda item 6 is the debate on motion S4M-05883, to approve the draft Valuation (Postponement of Revaluation) (Scotland) Order 2013, on which we have just taken oral evidence. Do any members wish to speak in the debate?
I think that we have debated the order quite fully.
In that case, I ask the minister to move the motion.Motion moved,That the Local Government and Regeneration Committee recommends that the Valuation (Postponement of Revaluation) (Scotland) Order 2013 draft be approved.—Derek Mackay.
The question is, that motion S4M-05883, in the name of Derek Mackay, be agreed to. Are we agreed?Members: No.
There will be a division.ForMcMillan, Stuart (West Scotland) (SNP)McTaggart, Anne (Glasgow) (Lab)Pentland, John (Motherwell and Wishaw) (Lab)Stevenson, Stewart (Banffshire and Buchan Coast) (SNP)Stewart, Kevin (Aberdeen Central) (SNP)Wilson, John (Central Scotland) (SNP)AgainstMitchell, Margaret (Central Scotland) (Con)
The result of the division is: For 6, Against 1, Abstentions 0.Motion agreed to.
I thank the minister and the officials for their evidence. I suspend the meeting for a few minutes to allow them to leave.11:00 Meeting suspended.
11:02 On resuming—
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportNo recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.
In this meeting
Everything on 13 Mar 2013 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 31
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 56
- 10:00 Local Government Elections 2012 Committee business · 10
- 10:00 Petition Petitions · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.