Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Prison Visiting Committees

Scottish Executive Question Time Justice and Law Officers

Thursday 22 December 2011 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 8 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Margaret McDougall Lab West Scotland
link


8. To ask the Scottish Executive what its plans are for prison visiting committees. (S4O-00536)

Kenny MacAskill SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Justice · Edinburgh Eastern
link
I wrote to all visiting committee members recently to thank them for their hard work and dedication. As I wrote in my letter of 5 December to the convener of the Justice Committee, we stand to deliver better outcomes by replacing the current structure of 16 prison visiting committees with a new dedicated independent advocacy service for prisoners.

Margaret McDougall Lab West Scotland
link
Many people in my region have asked me to raise the issue and share their concerns about the development. Prison visiting committees should be independent local bodies, and they were widely praised in the consultation process, so why disband them? Who would be in charge of appointing the new independent prisoner advocacy service and monitoring its progress? Who would it be accountable to, and how would it be funded?

Kenny MacAskill SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Justice · Edinburgh Eastern
link
The requirement to protect prisoners and review on-going matters in the prison estate is why we have Her Majesty’s chief inspector of prisons. Brigadier Monro does an outstanding job, as his predecessors did, and I pay tribute to him.

In a small country, we need to ask how many organisations we need to deal with a single matter. We do not currently provide an advocacy service to support the needs and welfare of prisoners, but I and the Scottish Prison Service believe that it is necessary to have one in order to tackle reoffending. We are discussing the matter with procurement, and it will go out to tender. Whether it goes to Sacro, Apex Scotland or some other organisation can be reviewed and discussed, but we will certainly seek to work with partners who already work in the sphere.

I put on the record that the proposal is not about making a cost saving. The cost of running the visiting committees is less than the cost of running an advocacy service. However, we have a responsibility to protect prisoners—Her Majesty’s inspectorate of prisons, the European convention on human rights and a host of other matters are relevant in that regard—and we must do what is necessary to break the cycle of reoffending for people who have learning difficulties, those who are inarticulate and so on. We believe that an advocacy service will be fundamentally better placed to do that, which is why we are putting one in place. It is not about the money; it is about doing the right thing.

Dennis Robertson SNP Aberdeenshire West
link
Can the cabinet secretary confirm that the new independent advocacy service will make progress in reducing duplication?

Kenny MacAskill SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Justice · Edinburgh Eastern
link
I believe that it will. As I said, I envisage that the dedicated independent advocacy service will support hard-to-reach prisoners and prisoner groups, mentor and support prisoners appropriately and professionally, and improve prisoner links with the community. It will replace a service that was established before many of our current checks and balances were in place and it will avoid duplicating the work of HMIP. It will also enable third-sector organisations to work together to provide services, rather than compete against each other.

As I said, this is not about financial savings; it is about doing what will best provide for the needs and wants of hard-to-reach prisoners, who all too often become caught in a cycle of reoffending. If it works, it will be a good thing.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link
Does the cabinet secretary recognise that the visiting committees undertake unannounced prison visits, that they often provide objective evidence to Scottish Parliament committees that is based on the wealth of knowledge that their members have gathered on their visits to prisons, and that that advice is sometimes at variance with the initial line from the SPS? In view of that, does he recognise that the two roles that he is talking about—the independent advocacy role and the prison visiting role—do not represent a duplication of work but are independent? In view of that, will he consider retaining both?

Kenny MacAskill SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Justice · Edinburgh Eastern
link
As I said to Nanette Milne last week, I will happily reflect on that. However, fundamentally, these matters are dealt with by Her Majesty’s chief inspector of prisons, who also carries out unannounced visits. Equally, as the Government knows to its cost, we pay for challenges by lawyers who seek to defend the rights of prisoners and raise requirements around the ECHR. We think that one body should cover that.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Welfare Reform Bill Bill debate · 87
  2. Hospital-acquired Infections Questions · 5
  3. Year of Creative Scotland 2012 Questions · 4
  4. Employment and Regeneration (Deprived Areas) Questions · 8
  5. Royal Alexandra Hospital (Children’s Ward) Questions · 4
  6. A75 (Dunragit Bypass) Questions · 6
  7. Oil Industry Questions · 5
  8. National Health Service Boards Questions · 6
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
  10. Prime Minister (Engagements) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  11. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  12. Rural Communities (Online Delivery Charges) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  13. Access to Justice (Local Court Closures) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. European Fisheries Negotiations First Minister’s Questions · 8
  15. Child Trafficking (Cocoa Industry) Members’ business · 8
  16. Rural Affairs and the Environment Questions · 1
  17. Recycling Questions · 8
  18. United Nations Climate Change Conference Questions · 6
  19. Radioactive Contamination (Dalgety Bay) Questions · 4
  20. Cities (Environmental Issues) Questions · 6
  21. Rural Priorities (Funding) Questions · 4
  22. Greylag Geese (Orkney) Questions · 6
  23. Climate Change Delivery Plan Questions · 4
  24. Waste Targets Questions · 6
  25. Sheep (Electronic Identification) Questions · 4
  26. Automatic Early Release Questions · 9
  27. Criminal Cases (Punishment and Review) (Scotland) Bill (United Kingdom Government Response) Questions · 7
  28. Police Entrance Exam Questions · 4
  29. Violent Crime (Additional Police Officers) Questions · 4
  30. Prison Visiting Committees Questions · 8
  31. Murder (Influence of Alcohol) Questions · 5
  32. Spending Review 2011 and Draft Budget 2012-13 Debate · 81
  33. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.