Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 22 December 2011 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 12 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. May I say how delighted and privileged I am to be here? Before I start, I wish the First Minister and everyone across the chamber and in the Parliament a happy Christmas and a peaceful new year. [Applause.] And now to business. [Laughter.]

To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00368)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
In this pre-Christmas edition of First Minister’s questions, I congratulate Johann Lamont on her success in the Labour leadership election, welcome her to her place in the chamber today and say to her, as I said when we met yesterday, that she can be assured that, where the Opposition brings forward points of substance, the Government, notwithstanding our majority, will be prepared to take common cause. That is symbolised today in the fact that the Parliament will substantially unite in expressing concern about the direction of travel of the United Kingdom Government’s welfare reforms which, instead of increasing employability, seem to be in danger of impoverishing further some of the most impoverished people in the country. Perhaps that is the shape of things to come.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Where it is possible for us to work together, I assure the First Minister that we will do that, but it is also our responsibility to oppose and challenge him.

It is Christmas, and a time when we are all looking forward to spending time with our children. Certainly, I have seen less of my own recently than I might want to. It is a time that belongs to children but, for some children, there is not much to look forward to—children abandoned and abused by their parents; children like Declan Hainey. What has the First Minister done in response to that tragic case?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
All cases involving children are examined by the Government and the Government keeps things under action, but perhaps Johann Lamont will want to specify the action that she is looking for, and then I will be able to tell her what the individual minister has done.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I am rather concerned that the First Minister has not already indicated what he is intending to do in response to something that is very serious. We have to ensure that the rhetoric in the chamber reflects the reality of Scottish life. When the First Minister was asked about a similar tragic case—the death of Brandon Muir—he said:

“we have the most systematic and strenuous inspection system certainly anywhere in these islands and perhaps anywhere in Europe.”—[Official Report, 25 June 2009; c 18904.]

Does the First Minister still believe that that is the case? Does he agree that the reality is that it was not good enough for Brandon Muir or Declan Hainey and that it is not good enough for scores of children whose names may never appear in the papers but who are suffering now?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I remember the Brandon Muir and Declan Hainey cases very well. The point that I made in the Brandon Muir case was that we have in place a systematic way of trying to identify children at risk. I also made the point that no system can be foolproof and that there will be individual tragedies almost regardless of what system is in place but that we have reinforced the support to local authorities and social work departments to enable that systematic way to be followed.

I reiterate another point that I made on the Brandon Muir case. I stressed that there was often a tendency to blame social work departments and see their failings. Of course, where there are failings, they must be examined and, in that case, they were systematically examined in the correct fashion. However, members must understand another point, which is that we have a substantial system and excellent social workers in Scotland who subscribe to the highest standards and are a professional group of people. However substantial we make our system and whatever the sincere efforts of our social workers, there will always be tragic cases—that is a certainty in society. Our job as parliamentarians is to give the maximum support to our social work departments and to their professionalism to ensure that our systems of inspection are such as to minimise the number of tragic cases and therefore minimise the effect on society.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I want to believe that that system is in place and that our children are safe, but we know that that is not the case. We cannot simply say that there is an inevitability about this. The responsibility of Government in this kind of case is to identify where the challenges are, where the problems are and what we can do to address them. It is not about blaming the workforce; it is about recognising that, for all of us, whatever systems are in place, they are not sufficient. Throughout Scotland, we have social workers who are overburdened, health visitors who are under pressure and the inevitability of children who have been abandoned by their parents being abandoned by a system that is supposed to care. We all know that budget cuts will only get worse, so what is the First Minister going to do in his budget choices to ensure that the most vulnerable children in our country are protected?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The system of inspection has been substantially enhanced and improved. That has been validated by the reinspections that take place. In the substantial majority of cases in which there have been faults and difficulties in individual local authorities, there has been huge improvement on reinspection. The Government put those things in place to try to correct the failings of a system that was already in place, but parliamentarians and political parties have to understand that, however we attempt to improve such systems to protect every single child in Scotland, there will still be tragic cases. In terms of budget choices for disadvantaged children, perhaps Johann Lamont would like to welcome our initiative to give looked-after two-year-olds access to nursery education. It is the first time that that has been done in these islands. That is a budget choice that we have made and I am sure that Johann Lamont would like to reflect her support for it.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Of course, I support that kind of thing, but this child was not in care; that is part of the difficulty. The child was in the family home. The danger is that we have a counsel of despair that there is nothing that Government can do. We all know that, if we work together and are honest, we can get this right, but we cannot afford a gap between what we say we care about—our rhetoric in the chamber—and the reality in Scotland’s homes. There has to be a connection between what we say and how people live, so I am asking the First Minister to have an independent inquiry into how our most vulnerable children are being affected by the budget choices that his Government has made. Surely it is possible, recognising the scale of the challenge, to test our budget choices by their capacity to protect the most vulnerable in our communities.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I am not certain that the direction in which Johann Lamont has taken her question reflects her aspirations at the start of the question session. In terms of budget choices, the settlement for local government has protected it against the average cut—the local government settlement is much better than the settlements for areas under direct Government control, for example—which indicates our view of the value and worth of social work and other departments. As for the inspection regimes and the improved system that we have established compared with the one that we inherited, most people across social work would say that, regardless of the fact that we will always have individual tragic cases, nonetheless the system is far better than it was some years ago and the system of inspection and reinspection is proving its worth.

I mentioned looked-after children and two-year-olds not because it was relevant to the individual case that Johann Lamont raised but because it was relevant to her question about how this Government looks on children within its budget priorities. The huge emphasis that we have given to early intervention, with a substantial transfer of funds even in this extraordinarily difficult time of great economic stringency, is an indication that this Government is concerned for every child in Scotland and wants to make the earliest intervention possible in order to establish an equality of opportunity that will do this country and this Parliament proud.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I am asking the First Minister this question as a mother. There are mothers throughout the country asking the same question. These children are hidden to the system and I am asking the First Minister what he can do. Can we have an independent inquiry into how the child protection system is working? Bits of it will be fantastic, as he says, but there is clearly a huge problem. If we can have an independent inquiry, we can work together to challenge this most awful of circumstances in our communities and make Scotland a better place for our most vulnerable children.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I point out that the improvements in the inspection regime came about as a result of such an inquiry looking at tragic individual cases and seeing how they reflected on the system throughout the country. Those improvements have been made and there is substantial evidence that, as a result of inspections and reinspections, social work departments are performing much better than they were before.

If Johann Lamont is asking for a guarantee that there will never be another tragic circumstance and that no child will ever be in that position, I cannot give that guarantee—no politician can. If she is asking what the Government has done, the systematic improvement in inspection regimes validates what the Government has done. If she is asking about budget choices, the huge input of resources into early intervention indicates that the Government cares—as the whole Parliament cares—about all of Scotland’s children.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Welfare Reform Bill Bill debate · 87
  2. Hospital-acquired Infections Questions · 5
  3. Year of Creative Scotland 2012 Questions · 4
  4. Employment and Regeneration (Deprived Areas) Questions · 8
  5. Royal Alexandra Hospital (Children’s Ward) Questions · 4
  6. A75 (Dunragit Bypass) Questions · 6
  7. Oil Industry Questions · 5
  8. National Health Service Boards Questions · 6
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
  10. Prime Minister (Engagements) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  11. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  12. Rural Communities (Online Delivery Charges) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  13. Access to Justice (Local Court Closures) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. European Fisheries Negotiations First Minister’s Questions · 8
  15. Child Trafficking (Cocoa Industry) Members’ business · 8
  16. Rural Affairs and the Environment Questions · 1
  17. Recycling Questions · 8
  18. United Nations Climate Change Conference Questions · 6
  19. Radioactive Contamination (Dalgety Bay) Questions · 4
  20. Cities (Environmental Issues) Questions · 6
  21. Rural Priorities (Funding) Questions · 4
  22. Greylag Geese (Orkney) Questions · 6
  23. Climate Change Delivery Plan Questions · 4
  24. Waste Targets Questions · 6
  25. Sheep (Electronic Identification) Questions · 4
  26. Automatic Early Release Questions · 9
  27. Criminal Cases (Punishment and Review) (Scotland) Bill (United Kingdom Government Response) Questions · 7
  28. Police Entrance Exam Questions · 4
  29. Violent Crime (Additional Police Officers) Questions · 4
  30. Prison Visiting Committees Questions · 8
  31. Murder (Influence of Alcohol) Questions · 5
  32. Spending Review 2011 and Draft Budget 2012-13 Debate · 81
  33. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.