2. To ask the First Minister when he will next meet the Prime Minister. (S4F-00432)
Official Report · Chamber
Prime Minister (Meetings)
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ruth Davidson Con 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 2
- Christine Grahame SNP 1
- David Torrance SNP 1
- John Pentland Lab 1
The record
16 contributions2. To ask the First Minister when he will next meet the Prime Minister. (S4F-00432)
I am seeking early meetings with the Prime Minister, as I have been for the past six months or so. I hope that there will be an early meeting with him so that we can take forward a few matters on a mutual agenda.
I presume that the mutual agenda is the referendum. Since the referendum consultation was launched in the chamber, members on the Government benches, from the First Minister right through his Cabinet and down to the lowliest of lowly back benchers, have been using the removal of nuclear-armed and powered submarines from Faslane as a reason for Scotland to become a state separate from the rest of the United Kingdom. The Faslane naval base is the largest single-site employer in Scotland, with 6,500 people working on the Clyde.
The latest Ministry of Defence figures show that there are 18,000 uniformed and civilian defence personnel based across 30 of Scotland’s 32 local authority areas. That does not include the 4,500 workers in yards in Rosyth and on the Clyde who are building navy destroyers and aircraft carriers, or the thousands of other defence contractors throughout Scotland who are engaged in work for the UK military.
We know that the First Minister wants to decimate the 6,500-strong workforce at Faslane, but how many defence workers—uniformed or otherwise—does he plan to keep?
The latest Ministry of Defence figures show that there are 18,000 uniformed and civilian defence personnel based across 30 of Scotland’s 32 local authority areas. That does not include the 4,500 workers in yards in Rosyth and on the Clyde who are building navy destroyers and aircraft carriers, or the thousands of other defence contractors throughout Scotland who are engaged in work for the UK military.
We know that the First Minister wants to decimate the 6,500-strong workforce at Faslane, but how many defence workers—uniformed or otherwise—does he plan to keep?
The estimated cost of a replacement for the Trident submarine fleet over the next generation is £100,000 million. I do not believe that even Ruth Davidson would argue that there could not be more sensible investment that would create far more jobs than investment in a new generation of Trident submarines.
The guarantee that we have given, as opposed to what has happened under the UK Government, is that we would maintain the military establishment in terms of bases after independence. That includes a naval base at Faslane, which, incidentally, is not just the home of the Trident fleet; it is also the home of minesweepers and other submarines.
I am interested in the proposition that there could be no orders for Scottish yards post-independence. On 4 October 2011, “Jane’s Defence Industry”—the bible of military procurement—said:
“The UK Ministry of Defence (MoD) is entering the final round of bidding for its MARS (Military Afloat Reach and Sustainability) Tanker requirement, with just three of the original six contenders left in the frame … Daewoo Shipbuilding and Marine Engineering (South Korea), Fincantieri (Italy) and Hyundai Heavy Industries (South Korea) remain in contention.”
Is Ruth Davidson’s proposition really that the Ministry of Defence will purchase from Italy and South Korea, but not from the Clyde yards or Rosyth? Under current European Union regulation, that is perfectly permissible and possible. The Clyde yards exist because of the excellence of their workforce and the efficiency of the products that they produce. It would be quite interesting if, given its lowly position in Scottish politics, the Conservative Party realised that talking down Scotland in such a manner is not the way to obtain votes from the Scottish people.
The guarantee that we have given, as opposed to what has happened under the UK Government, is that we would maintain the military establishment in terms of bases after independence. That includes a naval base at Faslane, which, incidentally, is not just the home of the Trident fleet; it is also the home of minesweepers and other submarines.
I am interested in the proposition that there could be no orders for Scottish yards post-independence. On 4 October 2011, “Jane’s Defence Industry”—the bible of military procurement—said:
“The UK Ministry of Defence (MoD) is entering the final round of bidding for its MARS (Military Afloat Reach and Sustainability) Tanker requirement, with just three of the original six contenders left in the frame … Daewoo Shipbuilding and Marine Engineering (South Korea), Fincantieri (Italy) and Hyundai Heavy Industries (South Korea) remain in contention.”
Is Ruth Davidson’s proposition really that the Ministry of Defence will purchase from Italy and South Korea, but not from the Clyde yards or Rosyth? Under current European Union regulation, that is perfectly permissible and possible. The Clyde yards exist because of the excellence of their workforce and the efficiency of the products that they produce. It would be quite interesting if, given its lowly position in Scottish politics, the Conservative Party realised that talking down Scotland in such a manner is not the way to obtain votes from the Scottish people.
So, no answer then on the number of jobs that the First Minister plans to keep, just as there is no answer on what the one naval base in an independent Scotland would have in terms of minesweepers, destroyers or frigates, or on what would be done with the Marines and what would be done about a fleet auxiliary.
Let us look at the experts’ response to the First Minister’s defence plans. A former commander of the Black Watch, Lt Col Sir Andrew Ogilvy-Wedderburn, said that the First Minister had
“absolutely no grasp of how the British Armed Forces work”.
Lord Robertson—[Laughter.]
Let us look at the experts’ response to the First Minister’s defence plans. A former commander of the Black Watch, Lt Col Sir Andrew Ogilvy-Wedderburn, said that the First Minister had
“absolutely no grasp of how the British Armed Forces work”.
Lord Robertson—[Laughter.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Lord Robertson, the former secretary-general of NATO said that the First Minister’s plans have “no coherence or relevance”. He continued:
“And what about logistical troops? Or combat support and combat service support? Engineers, medics, communicators, reconnaissance, surveillance and intelligence forces ... Nothing is said about how this gap is to be filled”.
Colonel Clive Fairweather, a former commanding officer of the King’s Own Scottish Borderers and former deputy commander of the SAS, said:
“I have respect for some of the stuff the SNP come up with and are proposing, but when it comes to defence I don't think they have a scooby.
I do find Mr Salmond very, very, very weak in this area. I have watched him, I have been with him, he doesn’t really understand it. He really doesn’t get it.”
There are many unanswered questions on the Scottish Government’s plans for defence, but I will ask just one, which comes from a young Scottish soldier who is based down south and wrote to me this week.
“And what about logistical troops? Or combat support and combat service support? Engineers, medics, communicators, reconnaissance, surveillance and intelligence forces ... Nothing is said about how this gap is to be filled”.
Colonel Clive Fairweather, a former commanding officer of the King’s Own Scottish Borderers and former deputy commander of the SAS, said:
“I have respect for some of the stuff the SNP come up with and are proposing, but when it comes to defence I don't think they have a scooby.
I do find Mr Salmond very, very, very weak in this area. I have watched him, I have been with him, he doesn’t really understand it. He really doesn’t get it.”
There are many unanswered questions on the Scottish Government’s plans for defence, but I will ask just one, which comes from a young Scottish soldier who is based down south and wrote to me this week.
He has not been sacked yet, then.
I would have thought that the member would have more respect. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order. The member is speaking.
He wrote:
“Dear Ms Davidson,
I am currently serving in the British Army and have done so for the past 2 years.
I am due to deploy on operations in Afghanistan in early April, I love my job and am proud to serve this country.
I am sure you are aware of the phrase ‘back of a fag packet’ and this it seems, is how Mr Salmond has developed his ‘plan’ for the Armed Forces.
I would be greatly appreciative if you could raise the following question for me ... Does he envisage a point where those serving will be forced to make a choice between the uniform in which they have faithfully served the crown and in many cases tragically lost friends, and the country of their birth?”
Well, does he?
“Dear Ms Davidson,
I am currently serving in the British Army and have done so for the past 2 years.
I am due to deploy on operations in Afghanistan in early April, I love my job and am proud to serve this country.
I am sure you are aware of the phrase ‘back of a fag packet’ and this it seems, is how Mr Salmond has developed his ‘plan’ for the Armed Forces.
I would be greatly appreciative if you could raise the following question for me ... Does he envisage a point where those serving will be forced to make a choice between the uniform in which they have faithfully served the crown and in many cases tragically lost friends, and the country of their birth?”
Well, does he?
People would certainly have a choice in terms of the armed forces in which they served. At the last count, I think that there are members of 23 nationalities serving in the British armed forces.
The issue of choice is a valuable one. The soldiers who are being made compulsorily redundant at the moment do not have a choice. They are being made compulsorily redundant by the Government that Ruth Davidson supports while many of them have been in theatres of conflict. That is no choice at all.
I met Clive Fairweather when I was marching to defend the Scottish regiments that were being shut down by the Labour Government. In that regard, I do not think that George Robertson is the strongest suit for the Conservatives. After all, not only did George Robertson say that devolution would kill the Scottish National Party stone dead, which I do not think has quite happened—[Laughter.]
Ruth Davidson should have a glance at today’s Ipsos MORI opinion poll, which shows 49 per cent support for the Scottish National Party and 12 per cent support for the Conservative Party, which is a reduction even on that party’s previous record low levels.
As I was saying, George Robertson described the strategic defence review as being neither strategic nor a defence review. Ruth Davidson should be careful whom she quotes.
On advisers, I liked the quotation that I read from the former financial adviser to the Conservative Party and former member of this Parliament, Brian Monteith. Only two days ago, he wrote:
“By taking a position of no more powers because he says so, the Prime Minister has laid his party open to the charge of arrogance and left isolated those Tories who seek to defend him. With these injudicious comments in his name, the Prime Minister has consigned Ruth Davidson’s nascent leadership in Scotland to ignominy and failure.”
I never thought that I would find myself in agreement with Brian Monteith, but perhaps he is on to something at last.
The issue of choice is a valuable one. The soldiers who are being made compulsorily redundant at the moment do not have a choice. They are being made compulsorily redundant by the Government that Ruth Davidson supports while many of them have been in theatres of conflict. That is no choice at all.
I met Clive Fairweather when I was marching to defend the Scottish regiments that were being shut down by the Labour Government. In that regard, I do not think that George Robertson is the strongest suit for the Conservatives. After all, not only did George Robertson say that devolution would kill the Scottish National Party stone dead, which I do not think has quite happened—[Laughter.]
Ruth Davidson should have a glance at today’s Ipsos MORI opinion poll, which shows 49 per cent support for the Scottish National Party and 12 per cent support for the Conservative Party, which is a reduction even on that party’s previous record low levels.
As I was saying, George Robertson described the strategic defence review as being neither strategic nor a defence review. Ruth Davidson should be careful whom she quotes.
On advisers, I liked the quotation that I read from the former financial adviser to the Conservative Party and former member of this Parliament, Brian Monteith. Only two days ago, he wrote:
“By taking a position of no more powers because he says so, the Prime Minister has laid his party open to the charge of arrogance and left isolated those Tories who seek to defend him. With these injudicious comments in his name, the Prime Minister has consigned Ruth Davidson’s nascent leadership in Scotland to ignominy and failure.”
I never thought that I would find myself in agreement with Brian Monteith, but perhaps he is on to something at last.
link
The First Minister will be aware that, over the past three weeks, the chairman and three members of the board of Adam Smith College have resigned following allegations of bullying, intimidation, victimisation and financial mismanagement. What actions can be taken to hold an external investigation into the governance and management of Adam Smith College?
The Scottish Government takes very seriously allegations of this kind. It is important that all the facts are scrutinised before any specific course of action can be taken. To that end, the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning has asked the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council to take appropriate steps and report on the issue, taking account of all the evidence available and seeking assurances that the college’s governance and management practices are properly and effectively serving the needs of learners.
I have been informed that one bid in relation to the Forth crossing included the supply of steel by Tata from the Dalzell plant in Motherwell. That would have been a major boost for employment in my constituency and in Lanarkshire, and for Scotland’s steel industry. Will the First Minister therefore explain why Transport Scotland has said that no Scottish firms were involved? Will he meet Tata’s chief executive to discuss the Scottish steel industry’s role?
I would certainly be glad to arrange a ministerial meeting. I point out that 118 subcontracts have been awarded to Scottish firms from the total of 155 subcontracts that have been awarded to date. That represents 76 per cent of total subcontracts. We can also consider that 870 of the 1,041 supply orders that have been awarded for the principal contract have gone to Scottish companies.
I cite those figures as strong evidence because I know that the member would not wish to give a misleading impression about the willingness to award contracts to Scottish companies when possible. The figures illustrate that determination. I am happy to arrange ministerial meetings, because the evidence indicates a strong willingness among the consortium’s members—including Morrison Construction—to make awards to Scottish contractors when possible.
I cite those figures as strong evidence because I know that the member would not wish to give a misleading impression about the willingness to award contracts to Scottish companies when possible. The figures illustrate that determination. I am happy to arrange ministerial meetings, because the evidence indicates a strong willingness among the consortium’s members—including Morrison Construction—to make awards to Scottish contractors when possible.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 2 Feb 2012 →- Colleges (Funding) Debate · 71
- Prison Visiting Committees Debate · 64
- Common Repairs Questions · 6
- Scottish Road Works Commissioner Questions · 4
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Whistleblowers (National Health Service) Questions · 6
- Edinburgh Tram Project Questions · 4
- Agri-environment Budget Questions · 8
- Single Fire and Rescue Service Questions · 7
- Prison Visiting Committees Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Higher Education (Scotland-based Students) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Youth Unemployment First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Prison Visiting Committees First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Green Investment Bank First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Central Unallocated Provision 2006-07 Questions · 8
- Supported Employment Questions · 7
- Scottish Retail Consortium (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Employment Initiatives Questions · 4
- Public Health Levy Questions · 4
- Construction Job Losses Questions · 4
- Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Enterprise Areas Questions · 6
- Small Business Bonus Scheme (Glasgow Shettleston) Questions · 6
- Remploy Employees Questions · 6
- Scottish Retail Consortium (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Employment (Clydebank and Milngavie) Questions · 5
- Post Office Branches (Council Counters) Questions · 4
- Budget Priorities (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Broadband Debate · 74
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 20
- Assistance Dogs Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.