9. To ask the Scottish Executive what services will be lost when prison visiting committees are replaced with an independent advocacy service. (S4O-00637)
Official Report · Chamber
Prison Visiting Committees
Scottish Executive Question Time General Questions
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Margaret McDougall Lab 2
- Kenny MacAskill SNP 2
The record
4 contributions9. To ask the Scottish Executive what services will be lost when prison visiting committees are replaced with an independent advocacy service. (S4O-00637)
The new service is being designed to enhance prisoners’ access to services in custody and the community that will contribute to reducing their reoffending. We want those who will deliver the service to have a good knowledge and understanding of the community justice system and be able to support prisoners as they move through the system. As well as looking to improve offender outcomes, we will ensure that there is no detriment to the overall service provision if the Parliament agrees to disband the visiting committees.
My question has been superseded by this morning’s debate. The cabinet secretary said that a lot of prisoners do not know about the service. Surely, that is a failing in the system and we should do more to promote the visiting committees rather than replace that first-class service, which is praised overall in the consultation. Although I support the advocacy service, I think that it should be run in conjunction with the prison visiting committees and should not replace them. Does the minister not agree that we need a body that monitors prisons and checks on prisoner welfare independently of the Scottish Prison Service?
I appreciate the member’s points. As she says, 50 per cent of prisoners do not know of the existence of visiting committees. As was pointed out in the debate, only two people sought their services in Aberdeen; there were only seven requests in Inverness; and, out of 6,400 admissions to Barlinnie last year, only 14 people requested their services.
There are two issues. First, how do we provide an advocacy service? We think that that is better dealt with through the provision of more specialist resources in that more complex area. Secondly, both Margaret McDougall and others raise a valid point about independent monitoring. We are happy to enter into discussion and debate about that. However, let us be clear: we must operate under the European convention on human rights until such time as David Cameron changes that fact, and we are subject to challenges. We have an independent inspectorate of prisons, we have a Scottish Human Rights Commission and, as we all know, the Government is frequently litigated against by people pursuing prisoners’ rights who are not members of visiting committees but lawyers. Nevertheless, we will ensure that the doubt that people have about monitoring is addressed, and we will enter into debate and discussion.
There are two issues. First, how do we provide an advocacy service? We think that that is better dealt with through the provision of more specialist resources in that more complex area. Secondly, both Margaret McDougall and others raise a valid point about independent monitoring. We are happy to enter into discussion and debate about that. However, let us be clear: we must operate under the European convention on human rights until such time as David Cameron changes that fact, and we are subject to challenges. We have an independent inspectorate of prisons, we have a Scottish Human Rights Commission and, as we all know, the Government is frequently litigated against by people pursuing prisoners’ rights who are not members of visiting committees but lawyers. Nevertheless, we will ensure that the doubt that people have about monitoring is addressed, and we will enter into debate and discussion.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 2 Feb 2012 →- Colleges (Funding) Debate · 71
- Prison Visiting Committees Debate · 64
- Common Repairs Questions · 6
- Scottish Road Works Commissioner Questions · 4
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Whistleblowers (National Health Service) Questions · 6
- Edinburgh Tram Project Questions · 4
- Agri-environment Budget Questions · 8
- Single Fire and Rescue Service Questions · 7
- Prison Visiting Committees Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Higher Education (Scotland-based Students) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Youth Unemployment First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Prison Visiting Committees First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Green Investment Bank First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Central Unallocated Provision 2006-07 Questions · 8
- Supported Employment Questions · 7
- Scottish Retail Consortium (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Employment Initiatives Questions · 4
- Public Health Levy Questions · 4
- Construction Job Losses Questions · 4
- Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Enterprise Areas Questions · 6
- Small Business Bonus Scheme (Glasgow Shettleston) Questions · 6
- Remploy Employees Questions · 6
- Scottish Retail Consortium (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Employment (Clydebank and Milngavie) Questions · 5
- Post Office Branches (Council Counters) Questions · 4
- Budget Priorities (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Broadband Debate · 74
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 20
- Assistance Dogs Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.