1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00438)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 3
The record
14 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00438)
Later today, I will take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Excellent.
Today I would like to discuss a Royal Bank of Scotland banker who enjoyed huge success but whose arrogance drove him to overreach himself and lead Scotland to disaster. [Laughter.] The First Minister need not worry—I am not talking about him. I am, of course, talking about Fred Goodwin, the Fred Goodwin to whom the First Minister wrote to back the deal that broke the bank. The First Minister wrote:
“Dear Fred,
I wanted you to know that I am watching events closely on the ABN front. It is in Scottish interests for RBS to be successful, and I would like to offer any assistance my office can provide. Good luck with the bid.
Yours for Scotland,
Alex”.
Yesterday, the First Minister admitted that with “the benefit of hindsight” he would “do things differently”. Does that mean that he is prepared to apologise to the people of Scotland for his serious error of judgment?
Today I would like to discuss a Royal Bank of Scotland banker who enjoyed huge success but whose arrogance drove him to overreach himself and lead Scotland to disaster. [Laughter.] The First Minister need not worry—I am not talking about him. I am, of course, talking about Fred Goodwin, the Fred Goodwin to whom the First Minister wrote to back the deal that broke the bank. The First Minister wrote:
“Dear Fred,
I wanted you to know that I am watching events closely on the ABN front. It is in Scottish interests for RBS to be successful, and I would like to offer any assistance my office can provide. Good luck with the bid.
Yours for Scotland,
Alex”.
Yesterday, the First Minister admitted that with “the benefit of hindsight” he would “do things differently”. Does that mean that he is prepared to apologise to the people of Scotland for his serious error of judgment?
As I said yesterday, I regret writing that letter. That much is obvious. However, as I said to Johann Lamont last week, I really do not think that Fred Goodwin is the Labour Party’s strongest suit. After all, as we now understand, my predecessor Jack McConnell recommended him for a knighthood and Gordon Brown as Prime Minister appointed him as one of his economic advisers. I certainly regret writing Fred Goodwin a letter, but I did not have him as a financial adviser; I did not have six meetings with him as chancellor as Gordon Brown and Alistair Darling did in the space of just over a year; and he was not at the heart of this Government, advising on economic policy. I really suggest to Johann Lamont that Fred Goodwin and the Fred Goodwin story are not the Labour Party’s strongest suit.
In my previous life as a schoolteacher, if I asked a child to accept that they had done something wrong, I did not accept the defence of, “It wisnae just me.” It is not a defence to say that other people made mistakes as well. What I asked the First Minister to do—and what he has singularly refused to do—was to apologise for his error of judgment. His judgment was wrong and he should apologise.
More important, however, the First Minister needs to learn a lesson from this. Mr Goodwin clearly got carried away with himself, did not ask the hard questions and became blind to the consequence. As the First Minister is in danger of doing likewise, let us look at the hard questions about separation; after all, I am not the only one who questions the First Minister’s judgment. His former economic adviser, Professor John Kay, says that if Scotland were to remain in a currency union,
“It might ... cause people to start wondering what the point of independence was in the first place”.
Will the First Minister tell Professor Kay and the rest of us what, exactly, the point is?
More important, however, the First Minister needs to learn a lesson from this. Mr Goodwin clearly got carried away with himself, did not ask the hard questions and became blind to the consequence. As the First Minister is in danger of doing likewise, let us look at the hard questions about separation; after all, I am not the only one who questions the First Minister’s judgment. His former economic adviser, Professor John Kay, says that if Scotland were to remain in a currency union,
“It might ... cause people to start wondering what the point of independence was in the first place”.
Will the First Minister tell Professor Kay and the rest of us what, exactly, the point is?
Before Johann Lamont wanders off the subject of Fred Goodwin, I remind her that the report on the Financial Services Authority’s inquiry into the collapse of the Royal Bank of Scotland was published on 12 December last year. It names three politicians as being influential in the FSA’s extraordinary decision to have lax financial supervision. The first is Tony Blair; the second is Gordon Brown; and the third is Ed Balls—one gone, one going and one still there.
As for the benefits of fiscal independence, I suspect that they have something to do with the fact that, right now, this Parliament controls about 12.5 per cent of Scotland’s finances and resources. Under the Calman proposals, that figure will creep up towards 20 per cent. However, under independence, we will control 100 per cent. That sounds to me like a benefit of independence.
As for the benefits of fiscal independence, I suspect that they have something to do with the fact that, right now, this Parliament controls about 12.5 per cent of Scotland’s finances and resources. Under the Calman proposals, that figure will creep up towards 20 per cent. However, under independence, we will control 100 per cent. That sounds to me like a benefit of independence.
The First Minister needs to learn from history, not rewrite it. The fact is that it was the First Minister who said that the problem with banking regulation was that it was gold plated and that he would lighten it.
I am curious as to why the First Minister is sticking by his plan to remain in a currency union. Last week, to bolster his position, he told us that there were 67 countries with a similar arrangement; however, all week, in response to my office, to the Scottish Parliament information centre and to the media, he refused to name them. Indeed, he named them only 30 minutes ago. It took him seven days to get information that he could have got in seven seconds from Wikipedia. [Interruption.]
I am curious as to why the First Minister is sticking by his plan to remain in a currency union. Last week, to bolster his position, he told us that there were 67 countries with a similar arrangement; however, all week, in response to my office, to the Scottish Parliament information centre and to the media, he refused to name them. Indeed, he named them only 30 minutes ago. It took him seven days to get information that he could have got in seven seconds from Wikipedia. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order. Please settle down.
We do not want to have people making things up on the hoof. Will the First Minister clear this up and give us three good examples of countries that do not have a central bank and are in a currency union?
Again, Johann Lamont tried to ask two questions in one. I turn to the first part of her question. She complained about one comment from me in 25 years about light-touch regulation. I remind her of the comments of the former Prime Minister who was in charge of these things in November 2005, as Chancellor of the Exchequer. Gordon Brown argued in a speech to the Confederation of British Industry on 28 November 2005 that he was proposing not just a light touch in regulation, but a limited touch. He went on:
“more than that, we should not only apply the concept of risk to the enforcement of regulation, but also to the design and indeed to the decision as to whether to regulate at all.”
He was not just proposing light-touch regulation. He was proposing no regulation. [Interruption.]
The Labour Party should not have to rely on the Scottish Government to provide it with ammunition. If Johann Lamont wants to ask me the question, she should ask me the question. [Interruption.] Is it not better to come along and ask the question as opposed to wanting the answer in advance?
On the other question, of the 20 most prosperous countries in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, 11, including Switzerland, are in monetary unions. That sounds to me as if monetary unions are a pretty common feature across the planet and across prosperous countries.
Johann Lamont seems to complain that we have suggested that there should be a monetary union between Scotland and England after independence. We have merely pointed out last week and this week that such arrangements are not uncommon in the modern world and that the countries involved are still independent countries. It strikes me that, if it is good enough for all those other countries around the world, including 11 of the 20 most prosperous countries in the OECD, it might not be too bad a thing for Scotland.
Last week I helpfully explained why, given the huge protection that it would offer to the balance of payments, it might be rather a good thing for England as well. I am just trying to be helpful and co-operative. [Interruption.]
“more than that, we should not only apply the concept of risk to the enforcement of regulation, but also to the design and indeed to the decision as to whether to regulate at all.”
He was not just proposing light-touch regulation. He was proposing no regulation. [Interruption.]
The Labour Party should not have to rely on the Scottish Government to provide it with ammunition. If Johann Lamont wants to ask me the question, she should ask me the question. [Interruption.] Is it not better to come along and ask the question as opposed to wanting the answer in advance?
On the other question, of the 20 most prosperous countries in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, 11, including Switzerland, are in monetary unions. That sounds to me as if monetary unions are a pretty common feature across the planet and across prosperous countries.
Johann Lamont seems to complain that we have suggested that there should be a monetary union between Scotland and England after independence. We have merely pointed out last week and this week that such arrangements are not uncommon in the modern world and that the countries involved are still independent countries. It strikes me that, if it is good enough for all those other countries around the world, including 11 of the 20 most prosperous countries in the OECD, it might not be too bad a thing for Scotland.
Last week I helpfully explained why, given the huge protection that it would offer to the balance of payments, it might be rather a good thing for England as well. I am just trying to be helpful and co-operative. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Before Ms Lamont continues, I point out that there is far too much shouting across the chamber. Ms Lamont is asking the questions and the First Minister is answering them. Will the rest of you settle down?
Would that it were so. The fact of the matter is that, whatever that was, it was not an answer, and it certainly did not clarify anything.
The reality is that up to a third of the countries that are identified in the 67 have no influence whatsoever. It appears that the First Minister is saying that he is pursuing independence at any cost. His case for independence is beginning to look like the RBS deal that broke the bank. He cannot provide the detail, and when we look at the proposal closely, it falls apart. He is proposing a currency union just like those in, say, Togo, San Marino or the Federated States of Micronesia.
In 2003, we were getting the euro. In 2005, we were getting a Scottish central bank. Yesterday, it was sterling, but somehow free from the Bank of England. Is it not demonstrably the case that the First Minister is simply unable to make an economic case for independence? Is he not in danger of becoming the Fred Goodwin of Scottish politics? [Interruption.]
The reality is that up to a third of the countries that are identified in the 67 have no influence whatsoever. It appears that the First Minister is saying that he is pursuing independence at any cost. His case for independence is beginning to look like the RBS deal that broke the bank. He cannot provide the detail, and when we look at the proposal closely, it falls apart. He is proposing a currency union just like those in, say, Togo, San Marino or the Federated States of Micronesia.
In 2003, we were getting the euro. In 2005, we were getting a Scottish central bank. Yesterday, it was sterling, but somehow free from the Bank of England. Is it not demonstrably the case that the First Minister is simply unable to make an economic case for independence? Is he not in danger of becoming the Fred Goodwin of Scottish politics? [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Johann Lamont seems not to have appreciated my point that 11 of the most prosperous countries in the world are in a monetary union. It is not an unusual state of affairs. Nor has she taken on board the point that I made last week, that Gordon Brown gave away the right to set interest rates in 1997, when he declared the Bank of England independent. I think that the Labour Party has to catch up with the policies that it pursued in government.
Johann Lamont finds it amusing that the countries that she named are in monetary unions. Let us look at some of the countries in the world that are not in monetary unions. The Democratic Republic of Congo, Iran and North Korea are not in a monetary union. So what exactly is the point? It is a reasonable proposition to argue that a monetary union is not uncommon in the modern world. I referred to 11 of the top 20 most prosperous countries in the OECD. I believe that, of the other nine, all but Japan have been in a monetary arrangement at some point in fairly recent history. Therefore, monetary unions are not uncommon in the modern world.
The purpose and point of independence is to control the country’s taxation policy, resources and wealth. If we look at the past five years of Scotland’s balance of income and revenue, we will see that it is a fact that we would have been £7.5 billion better off if we had controlled our own revenue and resources. That seems to me to be a rather powerful economic argument for independence.
Johann Lamont finds it amusing that the countries that she named are in monetary unions. Let us look at some of the countries in the world that are not in monetary unions. The Democratic Republic of Congo, Iran and North Korea are not in a monetary union. So what exactly is the point? It is a reasonable proposition to argue that a monetary union is not uncommon in the modern world. I referred to 11 of the top 20 most prosperous countries in the OECD. I believe that, of the other nine, all but Japan have been in a monetary arrangement at some point in fairly recent history. Therefore, monetary unions are not uncommon in the modern world.
The purpose and point of independence is to control the country’s taxation policy, resources and wealth. If we look at the past five years of Scotland’s balance of income and revenue, we will see that it is a fact that we would have been £7.5 billion better off if we had controlled our own revenue and resources. That seems to me to be a rather powerful economic argument for independence.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 2 Feb 2012 →- Colleges (Funding) Debate · 71
- Prison Visiting Committees Debate · 64
- Common Repairs Questions · 6
- Scottish Road Works Commissioner Questions · 4
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Whistleblowers (National Health Service) Questions · 6
- Edinburgh Tram Project Questions · 4
- Agri-environment Budget Questions · 8
- Single Fire and Rescue Service Questions · 7
- Prison Visiting Committees Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Higher Education (Scotland-based Students) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Youth Unemployment First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Prison Visiting Committees First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Green Investment Bank First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Central Unallocated Provision 2006-07 Questions · 8
- Supported Employment Questions · 7
- Scottish Retail Consortium (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Employment Initiatives Questions · 4
- Public Health Levy Questions · 4
- Construction Job Losses Questions · 4
- Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Enterprise Areas Questions · 6
- Small Business Bonus Scheme (Glasgow Shettleston) Questions · 6
- Remploy Employees Questions · 6
- Scottish Retail Consortium (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Employment (Clydebank and Milngavie) Questions · 5
- Post Office Branches (Council Counters) Questions · 4
- Budget Priorities (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Broadband Debate · 74
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 20
- Assistance Dogs Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.