Agenda item 3 is consideration of guidance subject to approval. The committee will take evidence from the minister, Stewart Stevenson, on the Scottish Natural Heritage code of practice on deer management. Although not legislation, the code has been laid under the affirmative procedure, which means that the Parliament must approve it. Following the evidence session, members will be invited to consider the motion to approve the code.I welcome, again, Stewart Stevenson, who is accompanied by two Scottish Government officials—Andrew Taylor from the natural resources division and Andrew Crawley from the directorate for legal services—and Alastair MacGugan, a deer officer with SNH. I invite the minister to make some brief introductory remarks on the code.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Scottish Natural Heritage Code of Practice on Deer Management
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Stewart Stevenson SNP 10
- Rob Gibson SNP 8
- Jim Hume LD 3
- Annabelle Ewing SNP 2
- Elaine Murray Lab 1
- Alastair MacGugan Scottish Natural Heritage 1
The record
25 contributionsI am pleased to speak on the code of practice on deer management, which is provided for under section 5A of the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996, as inserted by the Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Act 2011, with an intended start date of 1 January 2012.Before I expound on the code, I acknowledge the work of SNH, which took the lead on developing the code, and all the interested stakeholders, some of whom went to very considerable effort to provide input in the course of the code’s development. The code and what it aims to achieve originate with the previous Rural Affairs and Environment Committee, so the personnel have changed substantially—indeed, at one point, I was sitting on the other side of the table, so clearly a different minister was in post at the time.In 2009, the consultation on the Wildlife and Natural Environment Bill proposed the introduction of a statutory duty on landowners to manage deer in a sustainable manner, supplemented by a code of practice. However, in the light of further policy and legal analysis in the run-up to the bill’s introduction, we chose not to pursue that measure. Furthermore, in the course of developing the bill, the Government resisted proposals to establish a statutory requirement for deer management planning, with every plan requiring SNH approval, because of the significant cost in time and resources both to SNH and to individuals and businesses.As a result, the legislation retained the voluntary principle in deer management with suitable enforcement powers, backed up with a code of practice on deer management. The important thing is that deer managers and deer management groups deliver what they have been entrusted with—the public interest in deer management, which might include protecting the natural environment, ensuring public safety by reducing deer-vehicle collisions, promoting deer welfare, securing employment in rural areas or promoting quality, sustainable local venison.Although we have retained the voluntary principle, SNH’s intervention powers with regard to deer control agreements and control schemes were refined to make them more usable and timely. The code of practice on deer management is intended to support deer managers and to provide practical guidance on what they need to do to deliver good practice. As I have mentioned, it was developed in collaboration with stakeholders, and SNH is developing further related guidance under the existing wild deer best practice guidance.The code is also intended to support deer managers by setting out how to comply with the relevant legislation. However, failure to comply will not in and of itself constitute an offence. Instead, SNH will have a duty to monitor compliance with the code and to take any failure to comply into account in considering enforcement action. A higher standard is required of our public bodies, which will be required to have regard to the SNH guidance.The code is based on the same approach taken in our strategy document “Scotland’s Wild Deer: A National Approach”, which sets out how deer management contributes to a high-quality and robust environment, a sustainable economic environment and social wellbeing. As I have said, the code provides a practical guide and sets out to whom it applies and what they have to do to manage deer. In summary, it provides guidance on what must be done, what should be done and what could be done. I believe that it is a valuable addition to the guidance that is already available and provides a link between wild deer strategy and the respected best practice guidance developed by the Deer Commission for Scotland, now SNH. I commend it to the committee.
Thank you, minister. I invite questions from members.10:45
Obviously, a lot of work has gone into the code and I commend everyone involved, including the organisations who made submissions during the consultation process.I note the new duty on SNH to monitor compliance with the code, but I wonder who monitors the monitors, because this is a new element of SNH’s brief. Will there be provision for periodic reporting on how successfully the monitoring is going? If so, whom will that be to?
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
I could not have said it better myself.
What is the Gaelic for that?
It is the Roman saying, “Who guards the guards?”The basic answer is that SNH is accountable to ministers and ministers are accountable to Parliament. Monitoring will be covered in SNH’s annual reports and, as those are laid before Parliament, it will be open to Parliament and individual members to pursue matters relating to the stewardship of SNH’s oversight of deer practice.
I recall a discussion about this matter when the WANE bill was going through Parliament. As you mentioned, minister, there was quite a bit of evidence from people who thought that the responsibilities should be statutory. If someone is not taking their responsibilities seriously—they are not getting involved in deer management groups and so on—they will not be contravening the legislation, and what can SNH do? That was the concern of the previous committee. When you were on the other side of the table, you brought up, I think, the issue of homeowners who might have deer straying on to their land. What can they do?You raised the issue of accidents being caused because of deer crossing roads. That happens frequently on one road in my constituency, where deer cross at a bend and people cannot see them until it is too late. What is the land manager expected to do to prevent that sort of thing from happening?
The question is a three-for-one offer, obviously.There are a range of legal sanctions that SNH could take. The ultimate one is a referral to the procurator fiscal, but the hope would be that earlier interventions—discussion of the management practices of an individual who has responsibilities for managing deer—would deliver an accord.It might be worth drawing the committee’s attention to this “Best Practice Guidance” document, which is a substantial piece of work and contains a wide range of quite detailed instructions about things that can be done. It is largely informed by practitioners, who use it to share best practice with others in the business. On the legal sanctions, various steps can be taken. First, SNH becomes involved with the owner and seeks to work with them. Then, SNH seeks to intervene in the situation, which could involve it facilitating negotiation to reach a decision, which could include instigating a deer panel or a voluntary control agreement. Finally, SNH implements a control scheme and, if necessary, emergency action can be taken. If those steps do not work, legal action can be taken. However, I stress that, if legal action is taken, it will be because a lot of steps have failed before that point. I would like to think that the success of the legislation will mean that we will never be in the situation of having to take legal action. Perhaps I am just an optimist. The saying is that a pessimist is an optimist who is better informed, so we shall see how that goes.The point about landowners is important. Clearly, deer can be found anywhere. Indeed, they are found on the outskirts of many of our cities. I visited urban deer on the outskirts of Easterhouse in Glasgow over the summer or more recently. It is important that we do not place a duty on everyone who may end up with deer. We are seeking to place the duty on deer managers who manage land that they expect large numbers of deer to be on.Transport Scotland and others record deer-vehicle accidents. I do not have it in front of me, but the most recent figure that I recall seeing for such accidents was 150. I suspect that that grossly understates the number of interactions between deer and vehicles.Through the code, we seek to raise awareness of the need to consider fencing in certain places. If high concentrations of deer are crossing busy roads, fencing can play a role in directing deer elsewhere. There have been recent incidents involving deer from the Easterhouse cohort on the M8 in Glasgow. I am told that they were not red deer but roe deer. Therefore, we seek to ensure that drivers are aware of deer, which includes ensuring that there is signage on roads where there is a high risk of deer. Such signage is in place in many parts of Scotland.
Is there any guidance to landowners in the code of practice on the erection of fences? I know that new fences have been erected at the side of some roads that have been improved. For example, I passed some on Monday near Achnashellach. Is that done at the expense of the public roads authorities or of landowners?
I suspect that it will vary. I am not familiar with the fences at Achnashellach, but deer fences are a difficult issue because they may have an effect on other wildlife as well. In particular, there is a well-understood tension between capercaillie and deer fences. There is Scottish Government fencing policy in the best practice guidance. I ask Alastair MacGugan whether he can find that for me.
It is still being developed.
Oh, it is one that is still being developed—that is the answer to that. There is so much in the best practice guidance. It is perhaps appropriate to say at this point that the work that has gone into the guidance, which very much reflects what practitioners do, is so highly regarded that it has been picked up by the Deer Initiative in England and, so far, expressions of interest in using the guidance have come from Australia, South Africa, the Netherlands and Japan. In addition, Mexico and Norway want it translated into their own languages. The guidance is therefore a substantial start, and there will be further work on fencing policy. I thought that the committee might be interested to know that the guidance is attracting such widespread interest.
Thank you. We will probably follow up the issue with a progress report at some point. Jim Hume has a question.
First, I am sure that Mr Stevenson is aware that high fences are also bad for black grouse.
Indeed.
Such fences are also very expensive, so they would be a cost to someone’s purse, whether public or private.I am interested in the differentiation of deer in the code of practice. We have native species and non-native species. The latter category includes sika deer in particular, but muntjac deer are getting closer—some have already crossed the border. Is there enough to differentiate between the non-native invasive types, as I would describe sika, and the native species—red and roe? We will not mention reindeer at this time of year.
Of course, we have reindeer on the Cairngorms, albeit that they are supervised.In our guidance, we have separate sections for red deer, roe deer, fallow deer and sika deer. We then have a further section that covers non-native species and makes some of the points about their variety. It talks about the social structures and gives advice on handling the animals, on drugs that are administered to them and on what to do in the case of escape.It is a concise document—two sides of A4—but it gives pointers to many other pieces of information. We are not neglecting to look at other species, such as muntjac, as well as the four with which we are relatively familiar.
That is fine. Thank you.
I want to return to one subject that the minister mentioned: the creation of local jobs through the code of practice. In particular, a question has been raised with me about the Forestry Commission, which manages deer and the processing of their cull. Is that processing done in local abattoirs, or is there a contract to take much of the potential venison out of the Highlands, part of which I represent? It has been suggested to me that local processing of venison would create jobs.
I am not sure that I have sufficient information on the Forestry Commission’s activities to give you the detailed answer that you will want so, if you permit me, I will revert to you and the committee. I do not think that any of the officials can help. There is a substantial part in the guidance on carcase preparation and the process of delivering a newly shot deer to somebody’s plate to ensure that, at every step in the process, we have appropriate behaviours that mean that it is delivered in a safe and nutritious form. Many of us love to have them on our plate, as well as admiring them when we see them on the hills.
There being no further questions, we move on to agenda item 4, which is consideration of motion S4M-01540, which calls on the committee to recommend approval of the Scottish Natural Heritage code of practice on deer management.The motion will be moved with an opportunity for a formal debate on the code, which can procedurally last up to 90 minutes. In practice, most of the issues will have been covered just now. The minister will introduce the debate and propose the motion. It should be noted that officials cannot now take part in the formal debate. I invite the minister to speak to and move the motion.
I will restrict myself to moving the motion formally.I move,That the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee recommends that the Scottish Natural Heritage Code of Practice on Deer Management be approved.Motion agreed to.
Thank you. We will report to the Parliament accordingly. I thank the minister and his officials for their attendance.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportNo recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Dec 2011 →- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 45
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 25
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.