Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Crofting Commission (Elections) (Scotland) Regulations 2011 [Draft]

Wednesday 14 December 2011 Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee About 10:00 Subordinate legislation 45 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

45 contributions
Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Good morning, everybody, and welcome to the 15th meeting in 2011 of the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee. Members and the public should turn off mobile phones and BlackBerrys because leaving them in flight mode—especially for ministers—or silent mode will affect the broadcasting system. We have received apologies from John Lamont and Jenny Marra.Agenda item 1 is subordinate legislation. We will take evidence from the Minister for Environment and Climate Change on the draft Crofting Commission (Elections) (Scotland) Regulations 2011. The regulations have been laid under affirmative procedure, which means that Parliament must approve them before their provisions may come into force. Following this evidence session, under agenda item 2, the committee will be invited to consider a motion to approve the regulations.I welcome the minister, Stewart Stevenson, and his officials, who are Michael Anderson, from the directorate of legal services, and Iain Dewar, from the land tenure branch. I invite the minister to make any brief remarks that he thinks are appropriate.

Stewart Stevenson SNP The Minister for Environment and Climate Change · Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Thank you very much indeed for inviting me to discuss the regulations, which mark another piece of crofting history in the making. For the first time, crofters will be given the opportunity to have their say on who they think should be on the new crofting commission and how crofting should be regulated.It is not often that you get much agreement in the world of crofting, but I think it is fair to say that the proposals to make the commission more transparent and accountable have generally been supported for some time. There has been plenty of discussion as to what form it should take.The Shucksmith inquiry proposed the abolition of the Crofters Commission and the election of local crofting boards with a national federation of boards. The Government consulted on elected area committees of the commission, which would have delegated authority.Following consideration of the consultation responses, the Government brought forward proposals for directly elected commissioners. The proposals, which were passed in the Crofting Reform (Scotland) Act 2010, were widely supported, as those of you who were on this committee’s predecessor committee will recall. I refer to Dr Murray, in particular.There was a bit of discussion around the detail of the election. Liam McArthur lodged an amendment to the Crofting Reform (Scotland) Bill, which everyone supported, requiring the Government to consult on the regulations. When the bill was passed, the consultation took place, and here we are with the draft regulations. I will give the committee a wee bit of feedback on the consultation response and an update on preparations for the election.The regulations are modelled on other election regulations and adopt many of the practices, procedures and offences that are used in other election regulations, such as those for national park, health board and local government elections. Nonetheless, local authorities made some helpful technical comments on the regulations, many of which we have taken on board. I thank them and the Association of Electoral Administrators for their comments.On the wider policy issues that were considered in the consultation, the analysis of responses showed broad support for the proposals from a range of stakeholders. On the electoral system that is to be used, as was agreed during the passage of the bill, the Government consulted on regulations that provide for the alternative vote system. Despite the result of the referendum on that issue for Westminster elections, there were few comments against, so we propose to use the AV system because it seems to offer the fairest method of electing a single candidate from each of the constituencies. On boundaries, the majority of respondents preferred the second of the two options that were debated when Parliament considered the issue, so we have gone with that option.I think that everyone recognised the challenge of devising a franchise that is fair and appropriate for the commission elections, but the vast majority of people who responded to the consultation thought that we had got it right with the proposal to have one vote per croft but to limit it to one vote per crofter. In the end, there were few substantive amendments to the draft regulations on which we consulted.By way of an update on the arrangements for the elections, the committee will appreciate that preparations take a while and that we often have to make a start before regulations come forward. If all goes well, we propose to hold the elections in March 2012, with the new crofting commission taking office on 1 April 2012. The six elected members will be joined by three appointed members, whom I will announce in due course.If I may be so bold, I ask for committee members’ help in promoting the elections to as many people as possible, because it is important that the elections are successful, that people register to vote, that some put themselves forward for election and that anyone who is entitled to vote does so. It is a unique opportunity for them to have their say on the future of crofting and those who will influence it.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Thank you, minister. My personal history in this area goes back to the second session of Parliament, when I supported amendments by John Farquhar Munro that went against the position of his party’s coalition partners. I believe that elections are a good thing and I am glad that we have reached the point of seeing the elections take shape. We will now have questions from members.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

On the conduct of the elections, I note from the papers in front of us that there are no references to limits on spend by candidates, on how to access the list of candidates or on limits on the contact that they can have with electors. Is there guidance to cover those points?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

There is a limit of £600 on candidates’ expenditure. In part VI—“Miscellaneous and Supplemental”—of the regulations, paragraph 63 sets that limit.It may be worth drawing the committee’s attention to the fact that when someone submits their papers for standing in the election, they have the opportunity, but are not required, to submit a candidate statement to the returning officer that will be distributed to every elector with the ballot paper. Clearly, given the distribution of the constituencies, we do not have to do too much arithmetic to realise that for £600 a candidate will not be able to post other material to every elector. Of course, it is perfectly permissible for candidates to go and knock on doors or telephone people, but that must be done within the expenses limit of £600.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

Are you entirely satisfied that there will be no need to check the expenses of unsuccessful candidates?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

As with similar elections, a record of expenses will have to be submitted, so the expenses will be open to public scrutiny. It depends what you have in mind when you use the word “check”, but people will certainly be able to look at what candidates have spent their expenses on.Of course, there is no requirement for people to spend anything. The electorates will probably be familiar with the candidates and a statement—from all the candidates, I presume—will come with the ballot papers. I suspect that much of the campaigning might be done on the basis of the local media taking an interest in the election.I am just playing for time, because Iain Dewar is writing something down for me and I do not know what it is. I do not know what I have not said.

Iain Dewar Scottish Government
link

I just wanted to point out the thinking behind the provision. Who would spend more than £600 knowing that, if they were successful, they would be disqualified? That would be a bit illogical. When someone wins the election, their expenses will be checked and if they are found to be within £600, they will be duly elected.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

It is fair to say that in other elections people have inadvertently gone a few pounds over the limit but, ultimately, it was decided that that was not a deliberate ploy. I suspect that that is not likely to happen in this context, but human nature being what it is, the important thing is that the information that candidates have will make it clear what the limit is. It is up to the candidates to obey the regulations; if they do not, they risk not being successful in their campaign.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfriesshire
link

In the previous session of Parliament, the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee saw draft regulations that were similar to the current ones that spelled out Government thinking on how the elections would be conducted. The equality impact assessment says that there will be no impacts. When we considered the Crofting Reform (Scotland) Bill, a concern was raised that, in many areas, the majority of registered crofters are male and that there could therefore be an equalities issue to do with gender representation. That is difficult to tackle: the alternative would be to give everybody who lives on a croft a vote, so if four people lived on one croft, they would have four times the say of one person on another croft. Will you say a little more about that?I note that candidates must either be registered crofters or be nominated by an elector. The executive note states:“The regulations ... set out the details for the constituency in which a candidate may stand.”Is there a requirement for the candidate to live in, or to be on the electoral roll in, the constituency in which they stand?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I will deal with the first point second, if I may, because it is more complex. I might get a nudge from my officials on that.To be a crofter, a person is required to live within 32km of the croft, and someone must be a crofter to stand.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfriesshire
link

I am sorry: I thought that a candidate could be nominated by an elector and will not need to be a crofter.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

That is correct—there are two categories. If a candidate is a crofter, they will be geographically associated with the area. Otherwise, it could be a person from New Zealand, although that seems unlikely. Under crofting tenure, there is an option for people to continue to be a crofter even though they live more than 32km away. For example, they might be in hospital for the long term or they might work abroad for a period. The provision covers a number of such difficult exceptions.One point in the regulations that might be relevant and which applies generally in elections is that people can stand in only one constituency. If someone is nominated in more than one constituency, which is possible under the rule that a person who is not a crofter can be nominated, they must choose one constituency before the period for nominations closes, otherwise they will be disqualified in total. I do not know whether that was part of the thinking behind your question. If you want to ask supplementary questions, I can come back to the gender issue later, if the convener permits.10:15

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

We really need to explore these things.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I have written the gender one down, so I will not forget it.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfriesshire
link

If someone were nominated who was not an elector—for example, our former colleague, Peter Peacock, who might decide that, now that he is not an MSP, he would like to be a crofting commissioner—would he have to stand in the Inverness area or could he be nominated in, say, Shetland? I should point out that I am not suggesting for one minute that Peter Peacock wishes to be a crofting commissioner; it was just an example.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Peter Peacock is now doing some valuable work in his area. I have met him in that connection on a number of occasions.If Peter Peacock were appropriately nominated, he could stand in any of the constituencies. With all the respect that I have for Peter, I would say that that is not as improbable as you suggest—not that I have heard any rumours on the matter.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

It is interesting that the crofting counties, as designated, now include part of Moray and Arran and Bute. Many parishes within the crofting counties do not contain crofts—only about a third of them do. It is interesting to see the way in which the constituencies have been drawn up, given that we are talking about crofting, not the more general representation of people in the Highlands.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

The issue is about crofters having the vote. When we talk about electoral boundaries, at the end of the day, decisions have to be made. One could put those decisions against alternatives and it would be difficult to find an objective reason to make one decision instead of another; at the end of the day, one simply has to decide. The consultation asked what shape the constituencies should be and we ended up with a pretty clear balance of opinion in favour of what we have proposed. Does that mean that the arrangement cannot be changed? Of course it does not. Like

parliamentary constituency boundaries, the boundaries can be changed. I accept that registered crofts are in defined areas, but there are crofts well outside the crofting counties. I speak of my immediate neighbours in what is called Aberdeenshire but which those of us who live there would prefer to call Banffshire. In that area, there are many crofts that are not registered crofts under crofting legislation. There are complexities to the language that we use.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

As a historian, I will not go into that at the moment. I think that we should move on to other questions.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Forgive me, but I was going to address the issue of equality. You allowed your member to ask two questions.The issue of equality that Dr Murray raised in respect of there being comparatively few female crofters is valid, but that is a separate equality issue from that of how the elections are run. The only opportunity that we could have had in that regard—which would have been open to challenge, if we had taken it—would have involved situations in which multiple crofters are associated with the croft, whether in one location or distributed across locations, and must make a choice about who should vote. Clearly, we could have thought of making a direction to the effect that, if there is a female available, she must be given preference. However, there is little doubt that we would have been unable to do that, under human rights legislation. Apart from that, I do not think that there are equalities issues within the limits of what we are trying to do in relation to an election.The equalities issues lie much more broadly in the croft-ownership pattern. In a sense, it might be considered slightly surprising that there should be such a preponderance of men among croft owners. Statistically, women tend to outlive their husbands; therefore, one would expect crofts to pass from husband to wife so that there would be more women owning crofts. However, that is a broader issue, which goes beyond the elections.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Does that satisfy Elaine Murray?

Richard Lyle SNP Central Scotland
link

After an election, people might come along and say, “I wasn’t on the electoral roll,” or “I was lost from the roll, so when I went to vote I couldn’t cast my vote.” It says on the second page—the pages are not numbered, which is unfortunate—of the Executive note:“However, not all crofters will be entitled to vote. Regulation 5 provides that if, on the day the election notice is published, the Commission has determined under section 22(1)(a) (as repealed by schedule 4 of the 2010 Act) that a crofter was not ordinarily resident on or within the then defined 16 kilometres of the croft ... they will be disqualified from voting.”Are you concerned about that? People might say, “I should have voted, but I was not entitled to vote.”

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

There are two parts to the question of who gets on the electoral register and is, therefore, entitled to vote. First, it is up to people to come forward to be put on the register. Not everyone chooses to do that, as is the case for the electoral register for local authority and parliamentary elections. What proportion of the population chooses not to register to vote is a little unclear—I asked about that—but it is perhaps in the range of 7 per cent to 10 per cent.Secondly, crofters have to meet a range of qualifications if they are to get on the register, one of which is residency. The issue was subject to considerable debate as the Crofting Reform (Scotland) Bill went through Parliament, and Parliament took the view that the approach that is before the committee is the fairest and most equitable one. The issue revolved around—as much as anything—whether a crofter who has an interest in multiple crofts should have a vote in relation to each croft. In other words, should someone with six crofts have six votes? The Parliament was clear that that would not be appropriate.There is the corresponding issue of a croft that is associated with more than one person, which itself has two aspects. Many crofts have no habitable property on them, but it was decided that where people reside together in a property on a croft it would be up to the residents—assuming that there was no non-resident owner—to make up their minds. If all the people who are crofters are at one address, the ballot paper will be sent to that address and it will be for them to decide who votes. If there is a distribution of addresses of crofters who have an interest in the croft, the crofters will be contacted and invited to nominate a person to vote.Although the system is complicated to describe, we are seeking to make it relatively straightforward for the people who are involved, so that they understand how the people who vote are selected. We are seeking to ensure that it is the people who are entitled to vote who choose, rather than the returning officer. However, the returning officer will have to take decisions about whether people meet the eligibility rules and can be registered to vote, so there are complexities.Mr Lyle talked about people turning up to vote. We are talking about an all-postal ballot, so the issue will be whether a person receives a ballot paper. There are provisions—as there are generally in electoral rules—for replacement ballot papers to be issued where it appears that they have gone missing and so on. There is nothing particularly different about that. It is as well to remember that it is a postal vote.

Richard Lyle SNP Central Scotland
link

I take it that when we agree to the regulations, each person will be contacted and invited to register and that a decision will then be made as to whether they are entitled to go on to the electoral roll.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Yes—although I draw to your attention the fact that we do not know where they all are. A huge proportion of crofts are tenancies and it is not always obvious who the tenant is, for a variety of reasons. Although there is value to someone’s registering their interest in a croft—and we encourage them to do so—people might choose not to or might simply forget or neglect to do so. A proportion of people who are entitled to vote will ultimately not end up on the register. It is fair to say that in the crofting counties there is a pretty widespread understanding of what is happening. We will make sure, by every means possible, that as many people as possible are aware of that and have the opportunity to consider whether they wish to register to vote, but there is no legal requirement for them to do so.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I want to ask about timing. I see in the Executive note that the regulations set out specific provisions. Given the potential complexity in that on the date of the publication of the notice of the election, there might be further tweaking of the roll, depending on the disqualification criteria, are you satisfied that there will be sufficient time to ensure that a properly administered postal ballot takes place? There would need to be time to ensure that all the i’s were dotted and all the t’s crossed, unless I am missing something.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Let me read the timetable into the record. Assuming that Parliament consents to passing the regulations, publication of the electoral notice, which is required to be not less than 10 weeks before the day of the count, would therefore be no later than 5 January. We expect it possibly to be on 4 January. The closure of the electoral roll has to be not later than eight weeks before the day of the count, which would be no later than 19 January. The deadline for returning nomination papers and applications for proxy and absent votes is not later than seven weeks before the day of the count, which is no later than 26 January. Return of notices or withdrawal of candidates is required to be done by the deadline for the return of nomination papers at the election, which is 26 January. The draft electoral roll will be available to check the validity of nominations on 26 January—not surprisingly, because that is the closure date.The registration officer has to supply the crofting electoral register to the returning officer not later than four weeks before the day of the count, which is no later than 16 February, and issue ballot papers no later than two weeks before the day of the count, which would be no later than 1 March—although we expect it to be about half a week earlier than that. The deadline for returning ballot papers is not later than 4 pm on the day before the day of the count, which is 4 o’clock on Thursday 15 March. The count itself, which is expected to take place in committee rooms 1 and 2 of the Highland Council headquarters in Inverness, is scheduled for Friday 16 March. The return of expenses has to be done within 35 days of the result being declared, which would mean by 4 May.There are quite a lot of dates there. The question that was asked was, essentially, when does the roll close? That date is 19 January, but it is set in the context of quite a lot of other dates that are prescribed by the legislation.10:30

Annabelle Ewing SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Thank you for that detailed response, minister. Assuming that the regulations are agreed to, I take it that an effort will be made to publicise the electoral process as soon as possible, because we are coming up to the Christmas and new year holidays. I understand that the timetable is as it is so that we can get the process in place as soon as possible but, as we are getting into the festive period, I hope that the regulations will be publicised sufficiently so that electors—particularly the ones that we do not know about—realise that something is afoot and ensure that they are on the roll.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

One part of that process is the election notice, which is two weeks in advance of closure of the electoral roll. There will be the usual public notices, but we also expect there to be substantial editorial comment. I repeat that those committee members who have the opportunity to do so—although looking round the room I think that that is only one of you: Mr Gibson—should, by whatever means, ensure that their constituents and as many others as possible are aware of what is going on.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I presume that members of other parties have colleagues from somewhere near the Highlands.

Jim Hume LD South Scotland
link

Part of my question concerns Annabelle Ewing’s last point. I am concerned about people coming out of the woodwork because they have not had notices. The minister says that it would be good for all of us to ensure that people are aware of what is going on, but it could be seen as being the Government’s responsibility to advertise the election as widely as possible. It would be good to explore that a little bit more.I have a question on the basics of the votes. The minister mentioned that the election ballots would be counted in the Highland Council building in Inverness. Does that mean that the returning officer will be a Highland Council official? Will responsibility for the election lie with the council, the commission or the Government?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

The returning officer will be provided by Highland Council and is an experienced returning officer, which is good. There are four councils within the crofting areas, so one could have made three other choices quite reasonably. There will be depute returning officers from the other local authorities, so all four authorities will be involved—I beg your pardon, that should be “all five authorities”; I somehow forgot Argyll and Bute Council for a moment.In a huge area, we inevitably need to have the count at one physical location. Inverness is simply the most convenient place to have it.It is important to say that, although the Government and local authorities will make every effort to ensure that people are aware of the election, it is electors’ individual responsibility to register. We are not legislating to make registration a legal requirement. We will make every effort, but it would be astonishing if, at the end of the day, there were not at least one case of an individual who has somehow slipped through the net. We will do our best to avoid that, so that people have the choice of voting, but ultimately the duty and choice are theirs; it is not for us to compel them. The Parliament did not debate whether we should compel people to vote and, even if it had, it would be rather difficult to deliver on that in practice.

Jim Hume LD South Scotland
link

I was not implying that you would compel people to vote. My concern was about someone missing the chance to vote because the election was not advertised widely enough.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

We will make every effort. Our success will be substantial, but I do not wish to claim to the committee that it will be 100 per cent, because that would be a specious claim.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

When the boundaries were drawn up, was any consideration given to the likely broad elector numbers in each constituency? If not, there is surely the potential for an imbalance—perhaps a pronounced imbalance—in the size of the electorate from constituency to constituency. If that proved to be the case, would it be addressed by a boundary review ahead of the following set of elections?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

We would certainly look at the outcome of the electoral process and the operation of the new body, which we expect to establish on 1 April. Although those who are elected are being elected by different areas, the intention is not that they should be representatives of those areas. The intention is that all who sit on the Crofting Commission should take the interests of all crofters to heart. We have laid down that principle and we will look at how the body works in practice.If we had adopted a strict rule about how close the size of the electorate in each constituency had to be, that would have had the potential to lead to a disproportionate geographical skewing that would probably have been unhelpful. The consultation process showed that people were substantially behind the two alternatives. There were some differences between them and people plumped pretty substantially for the one that we have brought forward, which was option 2 in the consultation.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

As there are no further questions, I thank the minister and his officials for the information that they have given the committee.Agenda item 2 is consideration of motion S4M-01522. The motion will be moved and there will be an opportunity for a formal debate on the Scottish statutory instrument, which can last for up to 90 minutes. In practice, I hope that most of the issues will have been covered in the evidence.We can have an opening speech from the minister and other speeches. We should bear it in mind that officials cannot take part in the debate. I invite the minister to speak to and move the motion.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I will limit myself to moving the motion formally.I move,That the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee recommends that the Crofting Commission (Elections) (Scotland) Regulations 2011 draft be approved.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

The regulations will make it possible for some of crofters’ responsibilities to match their rights under various pieces of legislation. I hope that many people will take up the opportunity that the regulations offer.The question is, that motion S4M-01522, in the name of Stewart Stevenson, be agreed to.Motion agreed to.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Thank you, minister. I will record the result and report it to Parliament.I suspend the meeting briefly to allow for a changeover of officials. 10:38 Meeting suspended.

10:39 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 45
  2. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 25
  3. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  4. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.