4. To ask the First Minister whether the Scottish Government considers that the High Court of Justiciary should be the final arbiter of criminal cases in Scotland. (S4F-00009)
Official Report · Chamber
High Court of Justiciary
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nigel Don SNP 3
- Alex Salmond SNP 3
- David McLetchie Con 2
The record
8 contributions4. To ask the First Minister whether the Scottish Government considers that the High Court of Justiciary should be the final arbiter of criminal cases in Scotland. (S4F-00009)
Yes. It is our firm view that the final appeal court for any Scottish criminal case should be in Scotland, as it was always meant to be. The Scottish Cabinet discussed the issue on Tuesday at its normal session—not in emergency session—and agreed to establish an expert review to examine how best to achieve that.
I put it on record—I am sure that the First Minister will wish to confirm this—that there is international law, European law, English law, which happens also to run in Wales, and Scots law; there is no British law.
Yes, there is. There is employment law—
Can the First Minister confirm what I suspect to be the case: that an appeal from the High Court of Justiciary, the highest Scottish criminal court, can run to the Supreme Court without leave from the Scottish court, whereas there would be no appeal to the Supreme Court in England without leave from the Court of Appeal there?
I was trying to listen to Mr Don despite Mr McLetchie heckling from the sidelines—
Telling the First Minister that there is such a thing as British law.
And doing so in a way that no court in the land would find acceptable, incidentally.
Nigel Don makes a highly important point, and it is worth reflecting on the matter, for those in the chamber who do not believe that there is a difficulty. The current situation is that the Court of Appeal in England, in a criminal case, would have to give leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, with the possibility of the Court of Appeal’s decisions being overturned, whereas the Supreme Court can take a criminal case that has been heard in the High Court of Justiciary in Scotland, even if the High Court does not give leave to appeal, with the Supreme Court acting as another court of appeal.
I make that point in response to people who have said in the past few days that we should all be equal under the United Kingdom. In the present situation, it seems that some courts are more equal than others. Either those who argue that the present position is perfect should suggest that the Court of Appeal in England reverse its procedures or, more likely, we should go back to what was always the case: that our appeal court is in Scotland. Those of us who have faith in the Scottish courts and in our ability properly to protect human rights, and those of us who are not frightened of the European convention on human rights—as we have faith in our system’s ability to accommodate that convention—might wish for Scottish justice to be brought home, where it was always meant to be: with the courts of Scotland.
Nigel Don makes a highly important point, and it is worth reflecting on the matter, for those in the chamber who do not believe that there is a difficulty. The current situation is that the Court of Appeal in England, in a criminal case, would have to give leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, with the possibility of the Court of Appeal’s decisions being overturned, whereas the Supreme Court can take a criminal case that has been heard in the High Court of Justiciary in Scotland, even if the High Court does not give leave to appeal, with the Supreme Court acting as another court of appeal.
I make that point in response to people who have said in the past few days that we should all be equal under the United Kingdom. In the present situation, it seems that some courts are more equal than others. Either those who argue that the present position is perfect should suggest that the Court of Appeal in England reverse its procedures or, more likely, we should go back to what was always the case: that our appeal court is in Scotland. Those of us who have faith in the Scottish courts and in our ability properly to protect human rights, and those of us who are not frightened of the European convention on human rights—as we have faith in our system’s ability to accommodate that convention—might wish for Scottish justice to be brought home, where it was always meant to be: with the courts of Scotland.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 2 Jun 2011 →- Green Energy Debate · 50
- Crown Estate Questions · 4
- Waste Incinerators (Planning Regulations) Questions · 8
- Affordable Housing Questions · 4
- Gourock to Dunoon Ferry Service (Tender) Questions · 9
- National Forestry Treasures Questions · 6
- Grade-separated Junction (Laurencekirk) Questions · 6
- Animal Health and Welfare (Scotland) Act 2006 (Regulation) Questions · 4
- Local Authorities (Duty of Care and Responsibility) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Spending Plans First Minister’s Questions · 6
- High Court of Justiciary First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Older People (Standards of Care) First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Berry Farmers First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Sport Debate · 47
- Decision Time Decision time · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.