1. In a conversation with me and Miss Goldie last night, the First Minister mentioned rediscovering the joys of watching television after the election. I rather suspect that some of us have more time for that than others. I am just relieved to be back on Thursday daytime television rather than watching it at home.
I saw on television this week the “Panorama” documentary that showed the appalling abuse of residents in a private hospital in England. Yesterday, four staff who were involved were arrested. The programme highlighted the failing of the care regulator—the Care Quality Commission. The Scottish equivalent of that commission is, of course, Social Care and Social Work Improvement Scotland—SCSWIS—which is a newly formed body from the Scottish Commission for the Regulation of Care and other bodies. What assurances can the First Minister give us about the new regulator’s capacity to ensure standards of care in Scotland?
With permission, Presiding Officer, I will answer the question about my engagements and then the question that Iain Gray asked. I know that that was inadvertent.
Later today, I will meet the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth to discuss the uptake in modern apprenticeship opportunities. The latest figures show that, of the 25,000 modern apprenticeship places that the Government promised for this year, which is an unprecedented number, Skills Development Scotland has now contracted for 24,300 with training providers. I am sure that all members will wish to welcome the significant progress that has been made on that vital jobs initiative only two months into the financial year. [Applause.] I shall keep members updated as those youngsters move into employment in their training opportunities.
I saw the commentary on the documentary that Iain Gray mentioned, which raised matters of great concern. SCSWIS will review the current position of the three registered services that are run in Scotland to ensure that it is satisfied that there are no areas of key concern. That is clearly an important work of investigation. It is a matter for the authorities in Scotland to ensure that the Scottish position is up to scratch in all respects.
My apologies for my lack of practice at doing this, Presiding Officer. [Laughter.]
We can practically see the Elsie Inglis care home from the Parliament; it is just down the road. Two residents of that home have died in recent weeks and six more have been hospitalised. The conditions are so bad that the rest of the residents have been evacuated.
I asked about the capacity of the new care regulator in Scotland. It is a fact that the care regulator has had its budget cut by 25 per cent, 55 staff have gone and another 50 might go in the year ahead. Those are the very staff who are meant to inspect homes such as the Elsie Inglis care home. Should not we consider what happened at Elsie Inglis and cancel that cut?
Perhaps I can reassure Iain Gray both on the generality and on the specifics at Elsie Inglis.
On 31 May this year—that is, in the past few days—there were, in total, 1,333 care homes for adults. During 2011-12, we will inspect a minimum of 961 of those care homes. At least 1,549 inspections will be carried out—some care homes will be inspected more than once because of the risk-based evidence that is held on the service.
Specifically on Elsie Inglis, a complaint about the standards of care there was received on 25 March and the regulator undertook a full inspection in April. During that period, the City of Edinburgh Council and Lothian NHS Board put their own staff into the home. That was done by 12 May. By 26 May, all 46 residents had been moved to suitable settings, where their needs are currently being met.
Members will agree that unsatisfactory conditions existed, but it is clear from that timetable that the relevant authorities acted quickly to rectify the situation and, as we must all agree, had the position and wellbeing of the residents as their primary concern.
I did not criticise the response of SCSWIS to the situation at the Elsie Inglis home; my question was about the inspectorate’s continuing capacity to carry out such work. We are moving from a statutory requirement for six-monthly inspections to a risk-assessment model that will mean fewer inspections. Further, the number of staff who carry out those inspections has been cut and will be cut in the two or three years ahead. However, concerns have been expressed not only about the regulator. Audit Scotland has today condemned the community health partnerships, which are supposed to plan and manage social care, and doctors say that those partnerships have “spectacularly failed”.
Southern Cross Healthcare, which runs 98 care homes in Scotland, is on the verge of collapse after financial speculation on the beds in which our older people are cared for.
So, the inspectorate is being cut, the social care system has been declared not fit for purpose and the biggest provider of residential care in Scotland is on the verge of collapse. This week, the First Minister held an emergency Cabinet summit on the United Kingdom Supreme Court. Does he not think that a summit on the crisis in care is more urgent than that?
There were a number of points in that. Just as a point of fact, I did not have an emergency Cabinet summit—the issue was discussed at the Cabinet, as was Southern Cross. I have given the figures on the inspection regime for social care homes in Scotland. Perhaps Iain Gray and the Labour Party did not want to hear those figures, but they indicate an impressive level of inspection. One crucial point that I did not make is that all care home inspections are now unannounced. That is a crucial part of ensuring that care homes in Scotland are at the best possible standard. I also mentioned the response to the situation at Elsie Inglis, and Iain Gray seemed to agree that it had been an effective response to a difficult situation.
He has now taken us on to Southern Cross. The Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy is dealing with that issue daily in conjunction with the UK Department of Health and in constant communication with all others who are involved in that serious issue. It is true that Southern Cross, which has more than 3,000 residents in Scotland of a total of about 98,000 across the UK, is on the brink of administration. The Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, Scottish Care and the relevant local authorities are ready to ensure continuity of care for the residents concerned if Southern Cross moves into administration.
There is one cautionary note that we should take from the Southern Cross situation. Southern Cross is an example of a private company that is involved in social care. Some people seem to think that that model should be applied across the health service in England. Indeed, in the past, the Labour Party wanted to introduce private companies into mainstream health services in Scotland. Given the difficulties that arise when a private company is on the brink of administration and given the position in which that leaves vulnerable people in social care or the health service, the current situation should be a cautionary note for those who seem to think that private intervention is a solution in the health service or in the social care service.
A cautionary note to the First Minister: I think that he will find that the Scottish National Party council in Fife is currently transferring its publicly owned care homes to the private sector. We should not try to score points on the issue; we should try to move forward. We have done that before in the Parliament. In the first session of Parliament, when the First Minister and I were both members, we introduced the Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act 2000, the learning disability strategy and then free personal care, although I think that Mr Salmond was not a member by that time.
Only last week, the First Minister said:
“This Parliament speaks for the people of Scotland, and the people’s voice should be heard.”—[Official Report, 26 May 2011; c 67.]
I agree with him. It is too late for Lynn Beveridge from Elsie Inglis to be heard, but we need to hear the voices of the elderly, the disabled and the vulnerable in the Parliament. They are not talking about the things about which we have heard so much—the constitutional issues, the Supreme Court, corporation tax or the Crown estate—important as those may be. No, those voices are asking what we are going to do to improve and secure the care that they need. Our job is to do that together. What are we going to do to improve the situation?
Iain Gray referred to community health partnerships. He also referred to the importance of the Parliament acting together and of not making party-political points. Community health partnerships were established in 2004. Today’s Audit Scotland report, like last year’s independent inspection report, has indicated that there are serious problems—not failing across Scotland—in some areas, with a lack of integration of health and social care. That is exactly why the Government has established such integration as a priority.
If I were to take a non-political look at the establishment of community health partnerships, I might say that we have learned from experience something that may not have been evident when the relevant legislation was introduced. The legislation left the co-ordination of health and community care as a voluntary aspect of the 36 partnerships in Scotland. Why is that important? Today’s Audit Scotland report did not indicate that the system was failing across Scotland. On the contrary, one of its key findings was that there was co-sharing of services in 20 of the partnerships. That begs the question, why has it not happened in the other 16 partnerships? I suggest that it was a flaw in the Parliament’s legislation that those of us who were in the Parliament in 2004—neither Iain Gray nor I were—did not realise that the co-ordination that was hoped for had to be made compulsory and that integration had to happen and should not be left to individual health boards and local authorities across Scotland. That is why the Government has made making such integration happen a priority.
In the spirit of not looking to score party-political points about whose legislation was best and of not saying that the system is failing across the country, we should recognise that, for example, delayed discharges have not been increasing in community health partnerships. In April 2004, there were more than 1,000 delayed discharges; two days ago, the recorded figure was 12. Twelve may be too many—there is no room for complacency, given the pressure on local authorities and the health service from budget cuts from Westminster—but it would be wrong not to regard the improvement that has been made as significant. To get a sense of perspective, we should take what is good and proper about the change and the aspects of it that have worked, and should ensure—as is the Government’s priority—that health and community care are integrated as a service across Scotland.