3. To ask the First Minister when the Scottish Government will set out its detailed spending plans for this session of the Parliament to allow its commitments to be met. (S4F-00022)
Alex SalmondSNPThe First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
The Scottish Government will publish detailed spending plans in September, which will draw on the conclusions of and be informed by the commission on the future delivery of public services.
I am interested in what those figures will show for the justice budget. Annabel Goldie is right. I am astonished that a Government minister—and now, apparently, the First Minister—has attacked senior judges in that way. I am surprised that the First Minister has not taken action to seek the withdrawal of those remarks. Was Kenny MacAskill speaking for the whole Government when he said that he would stop the budget for the Supreme Court on the principle that
“He who pays the piper ... calls the tune”?
Did he seek the First Minister’s approval for that proposal?
Alex SalmondSNPThe First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
The budgetary issue that is the subject of Willie Rennie’s question is a matter of serious concern. The funding of the Supreme Court is only one aspect of that. Of much more concern is the cost of having that further tier of justice.
Let us take as an example the Somerville ruling by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council—the forerunner of the Supreme Court. It was a civil case, in which the total cost of the representations—which I know, because we have had it compiled—was more than £3 million. Incidentally, the great wrong that was being righted in that case was not something that happened with Kenny MacAskill, but something that happened when Lord Wallace was justice minister because of his action—or, more likely, his inaction—in forgetting to get the prison estate into proper condition. It cost us £8 million because a series of lawyers, following on from that decision, wanted to pursue claims not just for the past year but all the way back to 1999. The potential bill for Lord Wallace’s inaction, way back in 2002, could have run to £100 million if it had not been for the actions of this Government in introducing emergency legislation to limit that exposure.
I say, in case Willie Rennie thinks that those matters are not important in budgetary terms, that it is enormously expensive to plead cases before the Supreme Court. The implications of the decisions can cost tens—indeed hundreds—of millions of pounds, which many of us believe could properly be spent on police services, courts and the law-abiding citizens of this country.
It would be helpful if the First Minister answered my question. Is it really the First Minister’s policy to cut funding for the courts that dare to disagree with him? As well as the budget implications, did the First Minister discuss with the Cabinet Secretary for Justice his attack on the judges? That was my question. Let me go over it again. The cabinet secretary called one of the most senior independent judges in Scotland an ambulance chaser. That is not the language of Government ministers; it is the language of the football terraces. Did the First Minister give approval for those tawdry remarks?
Alex SalmondSNPThe First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
That was not the nature of the remarks. As Willie Rennie may or may not know, the term “ambulance chaser” is generally used to describe some—and it is only a few—members of the legal profession who see, in loopholes in the law, opportunities to pursue cases right back. The example that I gave Mr Rennie is an interesting one. The one-year time bar on human rights cases is, I think, shared by every other jurisdiction in Europe, but the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council said that in the case of Scotland, and Scotland alone, it might have to go back to 1999 because of a deficiency in the Scotland Act 1998.
Willie Rennie may think that it is perfectly acceptable for people to pursue compensation cases over that period. He might think that it is perfectly acceptable for us to have imperfections in our legal system—unintended consequences of legislation, or major constitutional changes, as it was put to Lord Wallace’s review last year in the judicial submission. I do not think that that is acceptable, because I do not think that it is right and proper for the citizens of this country to feel that their justice system is being second-guessed because of imperfections in legislation.
What is right and proper is to proceed in the way that the Cabinet agreed on Tuesday, which is to have a review group. The group will present proposals to this Parliament, which can then reach conclusions on behalf of the people of Scotland.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.