Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 3 questions

What current or proposed rail projects have a higher benefit cost ratio than the Glasgow Airport Rail Link.

Started with S3W-31079 on 26 Jan 2010; latest 10 Mar 2010. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
2
longest chain 1 step
Span
43 days
26 Jan 2010 to 10 Mar 2010
Answered
3 of 3
by Stewart Stevenson
Asked by
1
Robert Brown

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S3W-31079 26 Jan 2010 Robert Brown LD Answered

    To ask the Scottish Executive what current or proposed rail projects have a higher benefit cost ratio than the Glasgow Airport Rail Link.

    Stewart Stevenson, 4 Feb 2010: The current and proposed rail projects with a higher benefit cost ratio than the Glasgow Rail Link are: the Edinburgh to Glasgow Improvements Programme: Airdrie to Bathgate; Borders, and Edinburgh Trams.
  2. S3W-32292 10 Mar 2010 Robert Brown LD Answered

    Whether the projects mentioned were compared on a like-for-like basis over the same time period; whether there was a common (a) discount and (b) inflation rate, and what account was taken of the complementary investment at Glasgow Airport of a new public transport interchange.

    Stewart Stevenson, 20 Mar 2010: All infrastructure projects assessed by Transport Scotland are conducted in line with Scottish Transport Appraisal Guidance (STAG). This ensures consistency across projects as the same methodology is used to identify measure and record all costs, benefits and wider impacts. STAG recommends all costs and benefits are e…
  3. S3W-32293 10 Mar 2010 Robert Brown LD Answered follows S3W-31079

    What the basis is of the assertion that the projects listed had a higher benefit cost ratio than the Glasgow Airport Rail Link (GARL), given that the published figures are GARL, 1.28, Borders, 1.36, Edinburgh to Glasgow Improvements Programme, 1.10, Airdrie to Bathgate, 1.81, Edinburgh Trams 1, 1.21, and Edinburgh Trams 2, 1.40.

    Stewart Stevenson, 24 Mar 2010: The business case for all major transport projects is reviewed and updated on a regular basis as more information becomes available on costs, benefits and the wider impacts considered within the Scottish Transport Appraisal Guidance. This helps improve the robustness of forecasts and ensure projects continue to offer …

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads