Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S3W-32293 · Session 3

Further to the answer to question S3W-31079 by Stewart Stevenson on 4 February 2010, what the basis is of the assertion that the projects l…

Answered Asked by Robert Brown LD Lodged 10 Mar 2010

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S3W-31079 by Stewart Stevenson on 4 February 2010, what the basis is of the assertion that the projects listed had a higher benefit cost ratio than the Glasgow Airport Rail Link (GARL), given that the published figures are GARL, 1.28, Borders, 1.36, Edinburgh to Glasgow Improvements Programme, 1.10, Airdrie to Bathgate, 1.81, Edinburgh Trams 1, 1.21, and Edinburgh Trams 2, 1.40.

The answer

Answered by Stewart Stevenson on 24 Mar 2010 · 14 days after it was lodged, on time

The business case for all major transport projects is reviewed and updated on a regular basis as more information becomes available on costs, benefits and the wider impacts considered within the Scottish Transport Appraisal Guidance. This helps improve the robustness of forecasts and ensure projects continue to offer value for money and meet their objectives.
The original Benefit Cost Ratio (BCR) of 1.28 was at the point of the GARL Bill submission in 2006 but in September 2009 at the point of cancellation the BCR had reduced to 1.1. This was due to the formulation of more fully informed costs for the project.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S3W-32293 by reference.