Question thread · 6 questions
What information it is able to provide on whether there have been any disagreements between experts from Aberdeen fingerprint bureau and experts from the Scottish Criminal Records Office in Glasgow on what constitutes f…
Started with S2W-20244 on 1 Nov 2005; latest 16 Jan 2006. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.
The thread, in order
Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text-
To ask the Scottish Executive what information it is able to provide on whether there have been any disagreements between experts from Aberdeen fingerprint bureau and experts from the Scottish Criminal Records Office in Glasgow on what constitutes fingerprint identification and, if there there have been any such disagreements, whether these disagreements have been resolved and, if so, how they were resolved and, if …
Cathy Jamieson, 9 Nov 2005: Experts in the Aberdeen officeof the Scottish Fingerprint Service (SFS) recently disagreed with colleagues inthe Glasgow office about the identification made in 1997 of a markin the case of Shirley McKie. There is no difference of opinionin the SFS about the basis for identification. All SFS experts subscribe to theun… -
And given that experts in the Aberdeen and Edinburgh offices of the Scottish Fingerprint Service (SFS) disagreed with colleagues in the Glasgow office about the identification of a mark in the case of Shirley McKie, what steps it is taking to ensure that (a) miscarriages of justice do not occur and (b) all fingerprint identifications by the SFS given in Scottish courts will be accompanied by information on any diffe…
Cathy Jamieson, 28 Nov 2005: Criminal trials in Scotland are conducted in open court where the evidence that is led by the prosecution is open to challenge by the defence. The Scottish Fingerprint Service has a consistent approach to fingerprint identification which is followed by all fingerprint officers. It is based on the scientific process of… -
Whether at any time in the last 10 years any experts from outwith the Scottish Criminal Records Office (SCRO) have disagreed with any of the SCRO's fingerprint identifications other than those referred to in the answers.
Cathy Jamieson, 28 Nov 2005: In October 2003, two fingerprint officers from the Police Service of Northern Ireland and Mr Allan Bayle (a former fingerprint officer with the Metropolitan Police Service) reached a different conclusion from fingerprint officers based in the Scottish Fingerprint Service Glasgow Bureau about a mark found at the scene … -
Whether it is able to comment on the proposition that the ongoing publicity in respect of the case referred to in these answers is causing damage to its own reputation and that of the Scottish Criminal Record Office and the Scottish Fingerprint Service, as well as the wider justice system.
Cathy Jamieson, 15 Dec 2005: The case in question arises from an identification made in 1997. Since then more than 2,000 identifications made by officers in Glasgow have been verified by experts from the Metropolitan Police Service and the Police Service of Northern Ireland. In addition, fingerprint officers now have annual competency tests and a… -
How the Minister for Justice reconciles her reply that the Scottish Fingerprint Service has a “consistent approach to fingerprint identification which is followed by all fingerprint officers” with her reply to question S2W-20244 on 9 November 2005 which confirms the existence of disagreements between the Aberdeen Fingerprint Bureau and the Scottish Criminal Record Office.
Cathy Jamieson, 25 Jan 2006: The fact that there is a disagreementover a single specific historical fingerprint identification does not imply an inconsistentapproach to fingerprint identification. There is no disagreement in the ScottishFingerprint Service (SFS) about the basis of fingerprint identification and allfingerprint identifications are … -
Whether the Assess, Compare, Evaluation and Verify (ACE-V) process is fallible and what evidence it has to justify its reply.
Cathy Jamieson, 25 Jan 2006: The process of Assess, Compare,Evaluation and Verify (ACE-V) is the description of the scientific approach to fingerprintanalysis adopted by fingerprint professionals and criminal justice agencies world-wide.It is a qualitative approach rather than an arbitrary quantitative approach wherebythe likelihood of error is m…
How this thread is put together
- Follow-up
- A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
- Several citations
- When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
- Thread
- Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.