Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S2W-20244 · Session 2

What information it is able to provide on whether there have been any disagreements between experts from Aberdeen fingerprint bureau and ex…

Answered Asked by Alex Neil SNP Lodged 1 Nov 2005

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive what information it is able to provide on whether there have been any disagreements between experts from Aberdeen fingerprint bureau and experts from the Scottish Criminal Records Office in Glasgow on what constitutes fingerprint identification and, if there there have been any such disagreements, whether these disagreements have been resolved and, if so, how they were resolved and, if they have not been resolved, what steps it is taking to ensure that (a) miscarriages of justice do not occur and (b) all fingerprint identifications from the Scottish Fingerprint Service given in Scottish courts will be accompanied by information on the different approaches to the scientific basis of fingerprint identification which currently exist within the Scottish Fingerprint Service.

The answer

Answered by Cathy Jamieson on 9 Nov 2005 · 8 days after it was lodged, on time

Experts in the Aberdeen officeof the Scottish Fingerprint Service (SFS) recently disagreed with colleagues inthe Glasgow office about the identification made in 1997 of a markin the case of Shirley McKie.
There is no difference of opinionin the SFS about the basis for identification. All SFS experts subscribe to theuniversally accepted definition that an identification is made when the fingerprintexpert is personally satisfied that the order, relationship and unique propertiesof the features within any two prints are in agreement with no features in disagreementwhich cannot be explained. When a match is made the comparison is subject to separateverification by two further fingerprint officers.
The processes used are subjectto internal quality assurance and to external independent audit under the ISO 9001:2000Certificate to which the SFS is accredited.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-20244 by reference.