Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 23 questions

What action it plans to take to deal with any difficulties or inequalities in the law on march fence type boundary walls as identified in page nine of the Consultation Paper on Mutual Boundary Walls issued by the Scotti…

Started with S1W-11646 on 29 Nov 2000; latest 14 Aug 2002. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
22
longest chain 4 steps
Span
623 days
29 Nov 2000 to 14 Aug 2002
Answered
23 of 23
by Jim Wallace, Iain Gray
Asked by
1
Irene Oldfather

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S1W-11646 29 Nov 2000 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered

    To ask the Scottish Executive what action it plans to take to deal with any difficulties or inequalities in the law on march fence type boundary walls as identified in page nine of the Consultation Paper on Mutual Boundary Walls issued by the Scottish Law Commission in 1992.

    Jim Wallace, 12 Jan 2001: The Commission published a report on this subject on 25 March 1998, which recommended that it was not necessary to introduce legislation either to reform or restate the existing law on boundary walls. The Executive supports this view and does not plan to take any action in this area.
  2. S1W-14105 12 Mar 2001 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered

    Whether, in the course of concluding that it supports the view that it is not necessary to introduce legislation either to reform or restate the existing law on boundary walls, it took note of the statement at paragraph 2.14 of the Scottish Law Commission's 1992 consultation paper on this issue that there was an element of confusion in this area of law and what other criteria it applied in arriving at this conclusio…

    Jim Wallace, 2 Apr 2001: The Commission considered the strengths and weaknesses of various approaches before reaching the conclusion in its report that legislation was not required. The Commission's consultation paper and its report were considered in detail by the Scottish Executive which supports the final conclusions of the report.
  3. S1W-14106 12 Mar 2001 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-11646

    Whether, in the course of concluding that it supports the view that it is not necessary to introduce legislation either to reform or restate the existing law on boundary walls, any consideration was given to the extent to which any differences between the views on this issue expressed in the Scottish Law Commission's 1998 report and the Commission's 1992 consultation paper may be attributable to changes in the membe…

    Jim Wallace, 26 Mar 2001: The Executive considers recommendations made to it by the Scottish Law Commission, as with recommendations that it receives from other bodies, on their merits.
  4. S1W-15753 23 May 2001 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-11646

    And with reference to a letter of 16 October 1990 from the Chairman of the Scottish Law Commission to Mr David Lambie MP, whether it is aware of any independent research on the law of boundary walls initiated by the Commission which indicated that the law on this subject consists of two lines of decision which cannot be satisfactorily reconciled and, if so, whether this research supports its position that no further…

    Jim Wallace, 11 Jun 2001: The research referred to in the letter of 16 October 1990 was conducted "in-house" by the Scottish Law Commission and covered the exposition of the existing law. This research was taken into account when the Commission issued its consultation paper and reached its recommendations in its report.
  5. S1W-15754 23 May 2001 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-11646

    Whether it will make any independent research on the law of boundary walls initiated by the Scottish Law Commission publicly available.

    Jim Wallace, 11 Jun 2001: No independent research on this subject was initiated by the Scottish Law Commission.
  6. S1W-16913 9 Jul 2001 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-15753

    Whether the research on boundary walls conducted by the Scottish Law Commission in 1990 was carried out by a student who was a temporary member of staff.

    Iain Gray, 6 Aug 2001: I can confirm that the research in question was conducted by a student employed on a temporary basis by the Scottish Law Commission.
  7. S1W-16914 9 Jul 2001 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-15753

    Whether it will make the research report on the law on boundary division walls, compiled for the Scottish Law Commission in 1990, available to any member of the public on request.

    Iain Gray, 6 Aug 2001: As the report was an internal working paper produced by the Scottish Law Commission, the Executive does not have a copy and it would not be for the Executive to decide whether to make it available to the public. I understand that such working papers do not contain proposals for public consultation, but provide interna…
  8. S1W-16915 9 Jul 2001 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-15753

    Whether it is aware that the Scottish Law Commission, in its consultation paper on boundary walls of June 1992, agreed with the research report of 1990 and concluded that case law on boundary division walls consisted of contradictory lines of decision and was in a state of confusion.

    Iain Gray, 6 Aug 2001: The consultation paper did not comment on the research report in such terms, but only noted inconsistencies between older and more recent court decisions. The relevant consideration is that the Commission recommended in its final report published on 25 March 1998 that it was not necessary to introduce legislation eith…
  9. S1W-21639 10 Jan 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-15753

    Whether it supports the use by the Scottish Law Commission in its report on Boundary Division Walls (Report No. 163, paragraph 1.4, footnote 6) of the case of Robertson v Scott 1886 (13R 1127) as being central to its opinion that that case changed the law on march fence type divisions when it concerned a common or mutual gable and when the only question which was put before the court in that case, and the only decis…

    Jim Wallace, 1 Feb 2002: The Executive considers reports of the commission as a whole. The commission concluded that the existing law as decided by the case of Thom v Hetherington 1988 SLT 724 was satisfactory and that there was no need for legislation to restate or reform it. The Executive continues to support that recommendation and does no…
  10. S1W-21640 10 Jan 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-15753

    What recognition it has given to those legal titles concerning boundary division subjects which are extant and which conform to, and are based on, the legal standing of the subject as set out in Principles of the Law of Scotland, (10th Edition 1899, section 1078).

    Jim Wallace, 1 Feb 2002: I refer the member to the answer given to question S1W-21639.
  11. S1W-21641 10 Jan 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-15753

    What action it plans to take in respect of holders of legal title concerning boundary division subjects which are based on the Principles of the Law of Scotland, (10th Edition 1899, section 1078) which confirmed the subjects as being held as common or mutual property "pro indiviso" if such holders' rights and value in their property are affected in adverse manner by an alleged change in the law to ownership only to …

    Jim Wallace, 1 Feb 2002: I refer the member to the answer given to question S1W-21639.
  12. S1W-23641 4 Mar 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-15753

    Whether it supports the use by the Scottish Law Commission in paragraph 1.5 of its Report on Boundary Division Walls (footnote 7) of the Stair Memorial Encyclopaedia (Volume 18, paragraph 223) to justify the commission's opinion that the law on March Fence Type Divisions had been changed from ownership "pro-indiviso" to ownership to mid-line only ("ad medium filum") when at the time of publication of this encyclopae…

    Jim Wallace, 15 Mar 2002: It would not be appropriate for the Executive to comment on the detailed considerations taken into account by the Scottish Law Commission in the preparation of its reports. I can confirm, however, that the Executive agrees the conclusions of the commission's report on boundary walls.
  13. S1W-23645 4 Mar 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-15753

    Whether it supports the change of mind by the Scottish Law Commission, as stated at paragraph 1.13 of their Report on Boundary Division Walls; on what basis this change of mind came about; what reconsideration was given to the Commission's consultation paper and the Stair Memorial Encyclopaedia on this issue; what importance can be attached to the change of Commissioners at the commission, and what plans it has to e…

    Jim Wallace, 18 Mar 2002: I refer the member to the answer given to question S1W-23641 on 15 March 2002.
  14. S1W-24572 27 Mar 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-21639

    What its response is to the statement by the presiding judge in the case of Thom v Hetherington (SLT 724) on the third day of proof that the subject in the case, described as a "mutual" wall, was legally held as "common property pro indiviso" as the words "mutual" and "common" were interchangeable both meaning the same thing and to the fact that the judge referred defence counsel to p639 of The Law of Land Ownership…

    Jim Wallace, 23 Apr 2002: It is not appropriate for ministers to seek to interpret case law or comment on statements made in court cases or on the authority of sheriff court opinions. The law in relation to boundary walls has been considered over the years by the courts, the Scottish Law Commission, the Westminster and Scottish Parliaments and…
  15. S1W-24573 27 Mar 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-21639

    Whether the presiding judge in the case of Thom v Hetherington (SLT 724) changed his opinion in deciding that "mutual" and "common" meant different things and that the subject march fence type boundary wall in the case was not held as common property but as "ad medium filum" that is, ownership to an imaginary mid-line only; if so, what response it has given to this; what consideration it has given to paragraph 218 i…

    Jim Wallace, 23 Apr 2002: I refer the member to the answer given to question S1W-24572.
  16. S1W-24574 27 Mar 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-21639

    What consideration and response it has given to the case of Gray v MacLeod (SLT 17) where the sheriff, when faced with the proposition that a march fence type boundary wall was owned to the mid-point only ("ad medium filum"), stated in his written opinion "There has been long-standing doubt as to whether this is correct as a proposition of law" (p.20 of Scots Law Times, 1979) and then went on to make it clear that t…

    Jim Wallace, 23 Apr 2002: I refer the member to the answer given to question S1W-24572.
  17. S1W-24575 27 Mar 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-21639

    What consideration and response it has given to the case of Gill v Mitchell regarding a march fence type boundary wall where the sheriff, when no titles were produced, stated he was faced with a difference of opinion, when falling back on common law, as to whether the wall was held "ad medium filum" or as "common property pro indiviso" and while he himself preferred the "ad medium filum" view, the 'common property' …

    Jim Wallace, 23 Apr 2002: I refer the member to the answer given to question S1W-24572.
  18. S1W-24576 27 Mar 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-21639

    Whether the statements by the sheriffs in the cases of Gray v MacLeod and Gill v Mitchell convey to it corroboration of the expression of confusion by the Scottish Law Commission which was extant in the period 1990-93 and of the commission's statement that there are two conflicting lines of case law decision which cannot be satisfactorily reconciled in the aspect of the law concerning march fence type boundary divis…

    Jim Wallace, 23 Apr 2002: I refer the member to the answer given to question S1W-24572.
  19. S1W-24577 27 Mar 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-21639

    Whether it will confirm that sheriff court opinions do not create case law.

    Jim Wallace, 23 Apr 2002: I refer the member to the answer given to question S1W-24572.
  20. S1W-24669 2 Apr 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-15753

    How the legal holding of march fence type boundary walls can, in terms of common sense and equity between adjacent parties, be ascribed to the rule of ownership in law to the mid-point only where the wall is constructed of linear single brick or bree'e-block with butted support along one side and capped by concrete cope.

    Jim Wallace, 24 Apr 2002: I refer the member to the answer given to question S1W-24572 on 23 April 2002.
  21. S1W-25846 13 May 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-24572

    Whether he has received any letter from the Royal Incorporation of Architects in Scotland making representations that the alleged rule of law stating that boundary divisions are held ad medium filum is unmanageable in practice, that on a day-to-day basis current practice in allocating rights and responsibilities uses the principle of common property pro indiviso and that the position resulting from this is such that…

    Jim Wallace, 27 May 2002: I am aware that the Royal Incorporation of Architects in Scotland wrote to the Public Petitions Committee on 28 February 2000 on this subject, but have had no correspondence from that body.
  22. S1W-27719 17 Jul 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-24669

    How the rule of ownership of boundary divisions on an ad medium filum basis, which rule derives from a theoretical concept of inaedificatum cedit solo, can be ascribed on any common sense grounds to floors and ceilings where these form the divisions in terraced and flatted houses.

    Jim Wallace, 26 Aug 2002: I refer the member to the answer given to question S1W-24572 on 23 April 2002, which confirmed the Executive's view that the law on boundary walls is satisfactory and repeated the offer made in my letter to the member of 11 March this year to meet to discuss her concerns.
  23. S1W-28418 14 Aug 2002 Irene Oldfather Lab Answered follows S1W-24669

    How the rule of ownership of boundary divisions on an ad medium filum basis can be ascribed to fences that stand on and mark the boundary where, after specifying the type of fence, the title deeds of the adjacent parties state that the dividing fence is the (a) common and (b) mutual property of the parties to be maintained at equally shared cost by them.

    Jim Wallace, 10 Sep 2002: It is not appropriate for ministers to seek to interpret the law, as this is a matter for the courts. I am meeting the member on 2 October to discuss issues relating to boundary walls.

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads