Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S1W-24572 · Session 1

Further to the answer to question S1W-21639 by Mr Jim Wallace on 1 February 2002, what its response is to the statement by the presiding ju…

Answered Asked by Irene Oldfather Lab Lodged 27 Mar 2002

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S1W-21639 by Mr Jim Wallace on 1 February 2002, what its response is to the statement by the presiding judge in the case of Thom v Hetherington (SLT 724) on the third day of proof that the subject in the case, described as a "mutual" wall, was legally held as "common property pro indiviso" as the words "mutual" and "common" were interchangeable both meaning the same thing and to the fact that the judge referred defence counsel to p639 of The Law of Land Ownership in Scotland (Rankine 4th Edition, 1909).

The answer

Answered by Jim Wallace on 23 Apr 2002 · 27 days after it was lodged, on time

It is not appropriate for ministers to seek to interpret case law or comment on statements made in court cases or on the authority of sheriff court opinions. The law in relation to boundary walls has been considered over the years by the courts, the Scottish Law Commission, the Westminster and Scottish Parliaments and both the former Scottish Office and the Scottish Executive. Details of that consideration were set out in my letter of 11 March 2002, a copy of which I have placed in the Parliament's Reference Centre (Bib. number 20516). The issues have received exhaustive examination and the Scottish Law Commission and the Executive are of the view that the existing law in this area is satisfactory and that there is no need for legislation to restate or reform it. The only representations received on this subject are those from the member and one of her constituents.I would, however, be happy to meet the member, together with a representative of the Scottish Law Commission.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S1W-24572 by reference.