Parliament Workbench

Questions · Insight

Questions MSPs keep chasing

Some questions start with “further to the answer to question …”: the MSP is coming back to an earlier answer to press a point, ask for an update or ask for more detail. Linked together, these follow-ups form threads.

Threads
10,962
since 1999
Follow-up questions
17,494
7.3% of 238,876 questions
Chased 5+ times
389
threads with five or more follow-ups

Longest threads

10,962 threads · showing 1,701–1,750
  1.  how many incidences of stop-skipping were recorded on ScotRail services in 2018.
    John Finnie Green 22 Jan 2019 to 6 Jan 2020 Answered by Michael Matheson Latest S5W-26846 Answered
    2
    follow-ups
  2. 2
    follow-ups
  3. 2
    follow-ups
  4. 2
    follow-ups
  5. 2
    follow-ups
  6. 2
    follow-ups
  7. 2
    follow-ups
  8. 2
    follow-ups
  9. 2
    follow-ups
  10. 2
    follow-ups
  11. How many children in each local authority area will receive support from the Scottish Child Payment.
    Mark Griffin Lab and 1 other 26 Jun 2019 to 4 Nov 2019 Answered by Shirley-Anne Somerville Latest S5W-26170 Answered
    2
    follow-ups
  12. 2
    follow-ups
  13. 2
    follow-ups
  14. 2
    follow-ups
  15. 2
    follow-ups
  16. How much it has spent on smoking cessation campaigns in each year since 1999.
    Miles Briggs Con 25 Jan 2018 to 22 Oct 2019 Answered by Aileen Campbell, Joe FitzPatrick Latest S5W-25914 Answered
    2
    follow-ups
  17. 2
    follow-ups
  18. How many hours overtime have been worked by (a) permanent, (b) temporary and (c) contract staff in the social security …
    Mark Griffin Lab and 1 other 15 May 2019 to 10 Oct 2019 Answered by Shirley-Anne Somerville Latest S5W-25770 Answered
    2
    follow-ups
  19. 2
    follow-ups
  20. 2
    follow-ups
  21. 2
    follow-ups
  22. 2
    follow-ups
  23. 2
    follow-ups
  24. 2
    follow-ups
  25. 2
    follow-ups
  26. 2
    follow-ups
  27. 2
    follow-ups
  28. Whether it will meet the MoD to discuss the Education Support Fund and, if so, when.
    Jackie Baillie Lab 10 Jan 2019 to 22 Jul 2019 Answered by John Swinney, Graeme Dey Latest S5W-24435 Answered
    2
    follow-ups
  29. 2
    follow-ups
  30. 2
    follow-ups
  31. 2
    follow-ups
  32. Question to be taken in Chamber.
    Richard Leonard Lab and 2 others 24 Jan 2019 to 12 Jul 2019 Answered by Fergus Ewing Latest S5W-24336 Answered
    2
    follow-ups
  33. 2
    follow-ups
  34. 2
    follow-ups
  35. 2
    follow-ups
  36. When it will provide a progress update regarding the Northern Isles Ferry Services tender.
    Gail Ross SNP and 2 others 7 May 2019 to 17 Jun 2019 Answered by Paul Wheelhouse Latest S5W-23839 Answered
    2
    follow-ups
  37. What provision the GP contract makes for (a) the work involved with and (b) fees in relation to providing benefits cert…
    Mark Griffin Lab 29 May 2019 to 13 Jun 2019 Answered by Jeane Freeman, Shirley-Anne Somerville Latest S5W-23774 Answered
    2
    follow-ups
  38. 2
    follow-ups
  39. 2
    follow-ups
  40. 2
    follow-ups
  41. 2
    follow-ups
  42. 2
    follow-ups
  43. 2
    follow-ups
  44. What its position is on it nearing its capital borrowing limit of £3 billion.
    Tom Mason Con 22 Jun 2018 to 22 May 2019 Answered by Derek Mackay Latest S5W-23407 Answered
    2
    follow-ups
  45. 2
    follow-ups
  46.  whether it will provide an update on the development of ferry vessels 801 and 802.
    Jamie Greene Con 8 May 2019 to 13 May 2019 Answered by Paul Wheelhouse Latest S5W-23127 Answered
    2
    follow-ups
  47. 2
    follow-ups
  48. 2
    follow-ups
  49. 2
    follow-ups
  50. 2
    follow-ups

How this is worked out

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …”, “further to the answers to questions … and …”, or uses “reply” or “response” instead of “answer”, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question. References are matched however they are written (S6W-07058 and S6W-7058 are the same question).
Parent
The earlier question named. When several are named, the most recent one we hold. A citation of a question we do not hold, or of one dated after the follow-up, is ignored.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question. A thread needs at least one follow-up. Its session filter matches any question in the thread, and the party filter matches the party of any asker at the time.
What it does not show
Follow-ups that do not use these words, and oral supplementary questions, are not linked. A follow-up does not by itself mean the earlier answer was inadequate: MSPs also use it to ask for updates.