Parliament Workbench

Questions · Insight

Questions MSPs keep chasing

Some questions start with “further to the answer to question …”: the MSP is coming back to an earlier answer to press a point, ask for an update or ask for more detail. Linked together, these follow-ups form threads.

Threads
10,959
since 1999
Follow-up questions
17,489
7.3% of 238,655 questions
Chased 5+ times
389
threads with five or more follow-ups

Longest threads

10,959 threads · showing 10,851–10,900
  1. 1
    follow-up
  2. 1
    follow-up
  3. 1
    follow-up
  4. 1
    follow-up
  5. 1
    follow-up
  6. 1
    follow-up
  7. 1
    follow-up
  8. 1
    follow-up
  9. 1
    follow-up
  10. 1
    follow-up
  11. 1
    follow-up
  12. How many NHS beds are currently 'blocked' in Scotland.
    Mary Scanlon Con and 1 other 29 Sep 1999 to 9 Dec 1999 Answered by Iain Gray Latest S1W-03173 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  13. 1
    follow-up
  14. 1
    follow-up
  15. 1
    follow-up
  16. 1
    follow-up
  17. 1
    follow-up
  18. 1
    follow-up
  19. What steps it is taking to increase the number of women appointments to public bodies.
    Johann Lamont Lab 11 Nov 1999 to 7 Dec 1999 Answered by Jack McConnell Latest S1W-03041 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  20. 1
    follow-up
  21. 1
    follow-up
  22. 1
    follow-up
  23. 1
    follow-up
  24. 1
    follow-up
  25. 1
    follow-up
  26. 1
    follow-up
  27. 1
    follow-up
  28. 1
    follow-up
  29. 1
    follow-up
  30. 1
    follow-up
  31. 1
    follow-up
  32. Whether it intends to introduce a ban on tobacco advertising and sponsorship.
    Fergus Ewing SNP and 1 other 30 Jun 1999 to 23 Nov 1999 Answered by Susan Deacon Latest S1W-02746 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  33. 1
    follow-up
  34. 1
    follow-up
  35. Whether it has any plans to provide additional financial support to Scottish Opera and whether it will make a statement.
    Malcolm Chisholm Lab and 1 other 5 Nov 1999 to 16 Nov 1999 Answered by Sam Galbraith, Rhona Brankin Latest S1W-02569 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  36. 1
    follow-up
  37. 1
    follow-up
  38. What is the membership of the reference laboratories working group.
    Brian Adam SNP 5 Oct 1999 to 11 Nov 1999 Answered by Susan Deacon Latest S1W-02496 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  39. 1
    follow-up
  40. 1
    follow-up
  41. 1
    follow-up
  42. 1
    follow-up
  43. 1
    follow-up
  44. 1
    follow-up
  45. 1
    follow-up
  46. Whether the operation of Hampden Football Stadium is now financially and managerially secure.
    Fiona McLeod SNP and 1 other 8 Oct 1999 to 1 Nov 1999 Answered by Sam Galbraith, Rhona Brankin Latest S1W-02282 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  47. 1
    follow-up
  48. 1
    follow-up
  49. 1
    follow-up
  50. 1
    follow-up

How this is worked out

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …”, “further to the answers to questions … and …”, or uses “reply” or “response” instead of “answer”, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question. References are matched however they are written (S6W-07058 and S6W-7058 are the same question).
Parent
The earlier question named. When several are named, the most recent one we hold. A citation of a question we do not hold, or of one dated after the follow-up, is ignored.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question. A thread needs at least one follow-up. Its session filter matches any question in the thread, and the party filter matches the party of any asker at the time.
What it does not show
Follow-ups that do not use these words, and oral supplementary questions, are not linked. A follow-up does not by itself mean the earlier answer was inadequate: MSPs also use it to ask for updates.