Parliament Workbench

Questions · Insight

Questions MSPs keep chasing

Some questions start with “further to the answer to question …”: the MSP is coming back to an earlier answer to press a point, ask for an update or ask for more detail. Linked together, these follow-ups form threads.

Threads
10,962
since 1999
Follow-up questions
17,494
7.3% of 238,876 questions
Chased 5+ times
389
threads with five or more follow-ups

Longest threads

10,962 threads · showing 8,601–8,650
  1. 1
    follow-up
  2. 1
    follow-up
  3. 1
    follow-up
  4. 1
    follow-up
  5. 1
    follow-up
  6. 1
    follow-up
  7. 1
    follow-up
  8. 1
    follow-up
  9. 1
    follow-up
  10. 1
    follow-up
  11. 1
    follow-up
  12. 1
    follow-up
  13. 1
    follow-up
  14. 1
    follow-up
  15. How many robberies involving (a) firearms and (b) handguns were committed in (i) 1995-96, (ii) 1996-97, (iii) 1997-98, …
    Phil Gallie Con and 1 other 4 Jun 2001 to 15 Jun 2005 Answered by Jim Wallace, Cathy Jamieson Latest S2W-17358 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  16. How many police officers from ethnic minority communities there currently are in each police force and what the latest …
    Gordon Jackson Lab and 1 other 8 May 2001 to 15 Jun 2005 Answered by Jim Wallace, Cathy Jamieson Latest S2W-17359 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  17. What the average number of patients per general practitioner is in (a) urban areas; (b) rural areas and (c) island comm…
    Trish Godman Lab and 1 other 22 Feb 2000 to 14 Jun 2005 Answered by Susan Deacon, Andy Kerr Latest S2W-17328 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  18. Whether, following the decision to allow Dumfries and Galloway to form a transport partnership in its own right, it wil…
    David Mundell Con and 1 other 18 May 2005 to 13 Jun 2005 Answered by Nicol Stephen, Tavish Scott Latest S2W-17289 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  19. How many nursing home and residential care home beds have been closed in each of the past three years.
    Mary Scanlon Con and 1 other 30 Nov 2000 to 13 Jun 2005 Answered by Malcolm Chisholm, Rhona Brankin Latest S2W-17296 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  20. What percentage of recorded crime was committed in each police force area in 1999 and what percentage of the population…
    Lewis Macdonald Lab and 1 other 23 Nov 2000 to 13 Jun 2005 Answered by Jim Wallace, Cathy Jamieson Latest S2W-17293 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  21. 1
    follow-up
  22. What per capita health spending was in each NHS board in 2004-05 and what it will be in 2005-06.
    Nanette Milne Con and 1 other 23 May 2005 to 10 Jun 2005 Answered by Andy Kerr Latest S2W-17262 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  23. How many claims for compensation for damage to vehicles and injuries to passengers and pedestrians caused by dangerous …
    Nick Johnston Con and 1 other 15 Sep 2000 to 10 Jun 2005 Answered by Sarah Boyack, Nicol Stephen Latest S2W-17272 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  24. 1
    follow-up
  25. 1
    follow-up
  26. 1
    follow-up
  27. How many people died as a result of (a) road traffic accidents; (b) using Class A drugs and (c) using volatile substanc…
    Scott Barrie Lab and 1 other 13 Jan 2000 to 7 Jun 2005 Answered by Susan Deacon, Tavish Scott Latest S2W-17175 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  28. 1
    follow-up
  29. 1
    follow-up
  30. What the total annual spend on mental health services in Scotland was in each of the last five years.
    Irene McGugan SNP and 1 other 22 Aug 2000 to 1 Jun 2005 Answered by Iain Gray, Rhona Brankin Latest S2W-17021 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  31. How many primary school classes of over 30 pupils in each local authority area have more than one full-time teacher.
    Brian Monteith Con and 1 other 1 Aug 2000 to 1 Jun 2005 Answered by Sam Galbraith, Peter Peacock Latest S2W-17020 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  32. How many (a) primary one to three and (b) primary four to seven classes in each local authority area contain more than …
    Brian Monteith Con and 1 other 1 Aug 2000 to 1 Jun 2005 Answered by Sam Galbraith, Peter Peacock Latest S2W-17019 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  33. 1
    follow-up
  34. How many Positron Emission Tomography (PET) scanners there are in Scotland and where they are located.
    Brian Adam SNP and 1 other 22 Mar 2005 to 31 May 2005 Answered by Andy Kerr Latest S2W-16675 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  35. 1
    follow-up
  36. 1
    follow-up
  37. 1
    follow-up
  38. What percentage of NHS funding allocated using the Arbuthnott formula was allocated to each NHS board area for the curr…
    Richard Lochhead SNP and 1 other 9 Oct 2003 to 30 May 2005 Answered by Malcolm Chisholm, Andy Kerr Latest S2W-16761 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  39. 1
    follow-up
  40. 1
    follow-up
  41. 1
    follow-up
  42. 1
    follow-up
  43. What Sewel motions it will lodge in the Parliament in connection with the legislative programme of the UK Government an…
    Scott Barrie Lab and 1 other 16 May 2005 to 20 May 2005 Answered by Margaret Curran, Malcolm Chisholm Latest S2W-16786 Answered
    1
    follow-up
  44. 1
    follow-up
  45. 1
    follow-up
  46. 1
    follow-up
  47. 1
    follow-up
  48. 1
    follow-up
  49. 1
    follow-up
  50. 1
    follow-up

How this is worked out

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …”, “further to the answers to questions … and …”, or uses “reply” or “response” instead of “answer”, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question. References are matched however they are written (S6W-07058 and S6W-7058 are the same question).
Parent
The earlier question named. When several are named, the most recent one we hold. A citation of a question we do not hold, or of one dated after the follow-up, is ignored.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question. A thread needs at least one follow-up. Its session filter matches any question in the thread, and the party filter matches the party of any asker at the time.
What it does not show
Follow-ups that do not use these words, and oral supplementary questions, are not linked. A follow-up does not by itself mean the earlier answer was inadequate: MSPs also use it to ask for updates.