Written Question · S2W-17416 · Session 2
Further to the answer to question S2W-17138 by Mr Andy Kerr on 15 June 2005, how much the NHS has paid in respect of legal fees in clinical…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S2W-17138 by Mr Andy Kerr on 15 June 2005, how much the NHS has paid in respect of legal fees in clinical negligence cases in each year since 1997, broken down by NHS board.
The answer
Question S2W-17415 shows that although the number of clinical negligence awards made each year has not changed significantly over the last five years, the level of awards has risen. Accordingly, the level of legal expenses has also risen.
The information held centrally on the payment of legal expenses made after April 2000 does not differentiate between clinical claims and non-clinical claims. Legal expenses cover legal and other associated costs including adverse fees and expenses paid in any one year do not always relate to the awards paid in that year, as in most cases the legal costs are not settled until after the award has been made and therefore may fall into a different financial year.
The cost of legal expenses made in relation to clinical and, where appropriate, non-clinical claims against NHSScotland in each financial year since 1997-98, broken down by NHS board, is detailed in the following tables:
NHS Board
| 1997-98 (£)
| 1998-99 (£)
| 1999-2000 (£)
| 2000-01 (£)
Argyll and Clyde
| 59,817
| 97,794
| 47,611
| 52,144
Ayrshire and Arran
| 105,642
| 8,328
| 5,721
| 74,944
Borders
| 0
| 4,502
| 7,751
| 2,651
Dumfries and Galloway
| 22,950
| 62,921
| 19,887
| 3,000
Fife
| 53,083
| 14,659
| 13,075
| 77,114
Forth Valley
| 21,837
| 18,716
| 5,964
| 52,259
Grampian
| 39,560
| 20,626
| 8,957
| 59,074
Greater Glasgow
| 104,001
| 206,466
| 166,494
| 173,941
Highland
| 8,564
| 9,541
| 25,198
| 45,328
Lanarkshire
| 19,725
| 32,178
| 20,610
| 75,765
Lothian
| 137,802
| 118,972
| 204,452
| 139,109
Orkney
| 0
| 0
| 0
| 0
Shetland
| 4,983
| 0
| 893
| 827
Tayside
| 45,972
|
The information held centrally on the payment of legal expenses made after April 2000 does not differentiate between clinical claims and non-clinical claims. Legal expenses cover legal and other associated costs including adverse fees and expenses paid in any one year do not always relate to the awards paid in that year, as in most cases the legal costs are not settled until after the award has been made and therefore may fall into a different financial year.
The cost of legal expenses made in relation to clinical and, where appropriate, non-clinical claims against NHSScotland in each financial year since 1997-98, broken down by NHS board, is detailed in the following tables:
NHS Board
| 1997-98 (£)
| 1998-99 (£)
| 1999-2000 (£)
| 2000-01 (£)
Argyll and Clyde
| 59,817
| 97,794
| 47,611
| 52,144
Ayrshire and Arran
| 105,642
| 8,328
| 5,721
| 74,944
Borders
| 0
| 4,502
| 7,751
| 2,651
Dumfries and Galloway
| 22,950
| 62,921
| 19,887
| 3,000
Fife
| 53,083
| 14,659
| 13,075
| 77,114
Forth Valley
| 21,837
| 18,716
| 5,964
| 52,259
Grampian
| 39,560
| 20,626
| 8,957
| 59,074
Greater Glasgow
| 104,001
| 206,466
| 166,494
| 173,941
Highland
| 8,564
| 9,541
| 25,198
| 45,328
Lanarkshire
| 19,725
| 32,178
| 20,610
| 75,765
Lothian
| 137,802
| 118,972
| 204,452
| 139,109
Orkney
| 0
| 0
| 0
| 0
Shetland
| 4,983
| 0
| 893
| 827
Tayside
| 45,972
|
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-17416 by reference.