Inspired Question · S5W-10393 · Session 5
Whether it will provide an update on the progress of the policy review on the future approach to the procurement of lifeline ferry services…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on the progress of the policy review on the future approach to the procurement of lifeline ferry services, as announced by the Minister for Transport and the Islands in his statement to Parliament on 2 February 2017.
The answer
Since my announcement on 2 February, officials have met with counterparts from the European Commission, undertaken a series of meetings with a range of stakeholders across the Clyde and Hebrides (including Gourock–Dunoon) and Northern Isles ferry networks and considered legal and policy implications related to the application of the Teckal exemption and State aid rules.
The combination of this engagement with the Commission and consideration of the legal and policy implications has led to the conclusion that a direct award of an operating contract to a Teckal compliant body would be compatible with the Maritime Cabotage Regulation. This still necessitates a review of David MacBrayne Ltd. and its operating companies to determine which changes would be required to the structure and governance of those companies to ensure that they were fully compliant with the strict control and functions tests of the Teckal exemption.
It will also be necessary to undertake more detailed consideration of State aid rules before determining whether it would be possible to make a direct award to an in-house operator. This will require a full analysis of the Altmark criteria, namely the fourth criterion
- which, in the absence of a public procurement procedure, requires that compensation for delivering the public service obligation does not exceed the cost of a typical, well-run and adequately equipped undertaking.
The fourth Altmark criterion is a particularly challenging requirement to satisfy. Any proposed in-house operation will require to be benchmarked against a number of typical comparator operators in the ferry sector and this will most likely require further legal and financial consideration and more detailed discussion with the Commission. The level of engagement and detailed information required will almost certainly lead to an extended timeline to that initially envisaged for the full consideration and completion of the review. This will extend the timeline for the review beyond the autumn period, when a report on the emerging findings of the review is due for publication.
This extension means that we will have to consider the implications for the next contracts for the Gourock-Dunoon and Northern Isles ferry services, and we will lay out the way forward for both contracts in due course.
In terms of stakeholder engagement, officials have held meetings with the STUC and the trades unions to discuss the purpose and progress of the review. Officials have also met with a range of key stakeholders in Glasgow, Oban, Benbecula, Stornoway, Orkney and Shetland. Initial soundings were that there was, in general, more local support for a direct award to an in-house operator for the Clyde and Hebrides networks, while Northern Isles stakeholders either expressed a more neutral stance, or a preference for the tendering of future contracts.
The review is also considering the case for continued tendering of the ferry services, including the cost of tendering, the wider economic and financial implications of tendering, the empirical evidence collated from the recent Clyde and Hebrides ferry services tender and the views of local communities and key stakeholders.
The Government's preference is to award the contract to an in house provider. It is, however, important that the outcome of the review is not prejudged, or to create expectations that further consideration of State aid rules, and the Altmark criteria in particular, will necessarily result in a direct award to an in-house operator on any, or all, of the ferry services supported by the Scottish Government.
The combination of this engagement with the Commission and consideration of the legal and policy implications has led to the conclusion that a direct award of an operating contract to a Teckal compliant body would be compatible with the Maritime Cabotage Regulation. This still necessitates a review of David MacBrayne Ltd. and its operating companies to determine which changes would be required to the structure and governance of those companies to ensure that they were fully compliant with the strict control and functions tests of the Teckal exemption.
It will also be necessary to undertake more detailed consideration of State aid rules before determining whether it would be possible to make a direct award to an in-house operator. This will require a full analysis of the Altmark criteria, namely the fourth criterion
- which, in the absence of a public procurement procedure, requires that compensation for delivering the public service obligation does not exceed the cost of a typical, well-run and adequately equipped undertaking.
The fourth Altmark criterion is a particularly challenging requirement to satisfy. Any proposed in-house operation will require to be benchmarked against a number of typical comparator operators in the ferry sector and this will most likely require further legal and financial consideration and more detailed discussion with the Commission. The level of engagement and detailed information required will almost certainly lead to an extended timeline to that initially envisaged for the full consideration and completion of the review. This will extend the timeline for the review beyond the autumn period, when a report on the emerging findings of the review is due for publication.
This extension means that we will have to consider the implications for the next contracts for the Gourock-Dunoon and Northern Isles ferry services, and we will lay out the way forward for both contracts in due course.
In terms of stakeholder engagement, officials have held meetings with the STUC and the trades unions to discuss the purpose and progress of the review. Officials have also met with a range of key stakeholders in Glasgow, Oban, Benbecula, Stornoway, Orkney and Shetland. Initial soundings were that there was, in general, more local support for a direct award to an in-house operator for the Clyde and Hebrides networks, while Northern Isles stakeholders either expressed a more neutral stance, or a preference for the tendering of future contracts.
The review is also considering the case for continued tendering of the ferry services, including the cost of tendering, the wider economic and financial implications of tendering, the empirical evidence collated from the recent Clyde and Hebrides ferry services tender and the views of local communities and key stakeholders.
The Government's preference is to award the contract to an in house provider. It is, however, important that the outcome of the review is not prejudged, or to create expectations that further consideration of State aid rules, and the Altmark criteria in particular, will necessarily result in a direct award to an in-house operator on any, or all, of the ferry services supported by the Scottish Government.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S5W-10393 by reference.