Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

SPCB Written Question · S4W-28997 · Session 4

Further to the answer to question S4W-28782 by John Pentland on 15 December 2015, whether the recent issue with the software had not happen…

Answered Asked by Neil Findlay Lab Lodged 16 Dec 2015

The question

To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, further to the answer to question S4W-28782 by John Pentland on 15 December 2015, whether the recent issue with the software had not happened previously.

The answer

Answered by John Pentland on 13 Jan 2016 · 28 days after it was lodged, on time

To inform investigations into whether the issue identified with the MAQA software at the end of November 2015 had occurred previously, the Scottish Parliament Information Centre has been commissioned to audit historical results of the draw for General and Portfolio Questions.
This statistical audit, which is being independently peer reviewed by the University of Edinburgh, covers the period from when MAQA was introduced at the start of the session until March 2015. Investigations are on-going and will be completed as soon as possible.
We will respond to the member in more detail at that point and the results will be made available to all members.
Supplementary answer by John Pentland (03/02/2016):
The recent issue with the software used to select Members for General and Portfolio Questions was identified as resulting from changes made to the software as part of a scheduled software update made in March 2015. The issue did not exist prior to this point.
To provide additional assurance that the draw had previously been carried out correctly, SPICe has investigated the probability of Members’ names being drawn for General and Portfolio Questions, from the period when MAQA was introduced at the start of the session until the software update in March 2015. In doing so, account was taken of the number of weeks in which Members put their names forward for draws and the number of draws to which they asked to be entered in each of those weeks. The University of Edinburgh reviewed the work carried out by SPICe and a copy of the report has been placed in the Scottish Parliament Information Centre (Bib number 57665).
Statistical analysis of the type undertaken indicates what the likelihood is of something occurring. It does not, of course, of itself prove or disprove whether something happened by chance or randomly.
Overall, the analysis suggests a relatively even incidence of selection across the surnames of Members. The selection rates were found to be largely ‘normally distributed’ and, for the vast majority of Members, were close to the average (within two standard deviations). The report concluded that it is likely that Members’ names were selected randomly during the period in question.
The statistical tests revealed a very small number of outliers who were outwith the boundaries of normal distribution. However, only one case was considered to be a notable outlier. IT staff have investigated the system in light of this information, and no additional software issues have been identified. The Member identified as a notable outlier has been made aware.
As indicated in the answer to question S4W-28997, Chamber Desk staff will continue to monitor results of future draws using the new audit functionality which was introduced when the software issue was addressed in December 2015. Chamber Desk staff will be able to provide members with information relating to their own draw histories on request.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-28997 by reference.