Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

SPCB Written Question · S4W-28782 · Session 4

Whether it has carried out an audit of the randomised system for selecting members for oral questions to ensure that the recent issue with …

Answered Asked by Neil Findlay Lab Lodged 1 Dec 2015

The question

To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body whether it has carried out an audit of the randomised system for selecting members for oral questions to ensure that the recent issue with the software has not happened previously.

The answer

Answered by John Pentland on 15 Dec 2015 · 14 days after it was lodged, on time

The recent issue with the software used to manage parliamentary motions, amendments, questions and answers (MAQA) resulted in not all of the members who submitted their names for the random draw for General and Portfolio Questions being included in the draw. The fault was inadvertently introduced when changes were made to the software in March 2015 as part of a scheduled software update.
Replacement software to address the fault was tested and then subsequently put in place on 7 December 2015. The latest software also introduces audit functionality which will provide assurance that the system is working as intended. Chamber Desk staff will be able to provide members with information relating to their own draw histories on request.
In order to give additional reassurance to members that the random draw for General and Portfolio Questions has been carried out correctly since the introduction of the MAQA system at the start of this parliamentary session, the Scottish Parliament Information Centre has been commissioned to audit the results of the draw during that period. The audit will be independently peer reviewed. The results will be made available to all members.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-28782 by reference.