Written Question · S4W-21657 · Session 4
What consultants it hired for advice about the new Caledonian sleeper rail franchise; how much each was paid; whether they were asked to de…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government what consultants it hired for advice about the new Caledonian sleeper rail franchise; how much each was paid; whether they were asked to declare any possible conflicts of interest and, if so, what declarations were made.
The answer
The requirement for a procurement competition for rail franchising in Scotland occurs once every 7-10 years, and it is not therefore economically advantageous to continually employ, train and retain the specialist staff required in order to provide advice on undertaking such procurement competitions. Scottish Ministers have always stressed the importance of having an expert and appropriately resourced team to undertake both franchise procurements in order to do so competently and maximise the benefits of the public sector franchise investment, and also to mitigate against potential procurement challenge. The Caledonian sleeper franchise contract award is the first one to be completed since the West Coast Main Line debacle (reported to have cost around £40 million).
A fair and open competition was undertaken to appoint advisors to work on both procurements and the external advisors appointed for advice as part of the Caledonian sleeper franchise procurement were: technical advisors – Atkins, financial advisors – Ernst & Young and the legal advisors – DWF. The advisors work on both procurements and in the case of the legal advisors were sourced through the Scottish Government framework for external legal services. The costs of the procurement have not yet been finalised as the franchise contract has only very recently been signed.
The members of the advisor teams and Transport Scotland officials working on the procurement are routinely asked to check and declare if there are any conflicts of interest. To date no conflicts have been identified.
A fair and open competition was undertaken to appoint advisors to work on both procurements and the external advisors appointed for advice as part of the Caledonian sleeper franchise procurement were: technical advisors – Atkins, financial advisors – Ernst & Young and the legal advisors – DWF. The advisors work on both procurements and in the case of the legal advisors were sourced through the Scottish Government framework for external legal services. The costs of the procurement have not yet been finalised as the franchise contract has only very recently been signed.
The members of the advisor teams and Transport Scotland officials working on the procurement are routinely asked to check and declare if there are any conflicts of interest. To date no conflicts have been identified.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-21657 by reference.