Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S2W-27685 · Session 2

Which IT projects it has initiated and started without an estimate of costs having been established in advance.

Answered Asked by Stewart Maxwell SNP Lodged 4 Aug 2006

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive which IT projects it has initiated and started without an estimate of costs having been established in advance.

The answer

Answered by Tom McCabe on 7 Sep 2006 · 34 days after it was lodged, 6 days after it was due

All internal IT projects thatrequire funding are subject to approval by the Executive’s Information Systems SteeringGroup (SEISSG), or by the ICT Senior Managers to whom authority to approve fundingfor smaller projects is delegated. All internal IT projects are managed in accordancewith Prince 2 Project Management methodology, except where the project is too smallin scale to merit this. Prince 2 requires estimated costs and funding sources tobe identified prior to formal Project Initiation. No ICT projects currently underwaywithin the Executive that are subject to SEISSG approval processes have progressedbeyond scoping stage without a cost estimate and a committed source of funding.
Business areas within the ScottishExecutive may be involved in the funding or oversight of IT projects or Programmesexternal to the Executive itself. Best practice guidance advises that projects shouldbe managed in accordance with approved Project Management approaches, and incorporateadvice that costs and funding sources should be identified prior to Project Initiation.Larger projects – generally those with budgets of over £5 million – and that arecategorised as high risk, are subject to the Gateway Review process. Projects requiringlevels of funding that cannot be met from business areas’ delegated staffing andadministration budgets would be required to make a case for funding from an appropriatesource, usually the relevant Programme Budget.
No Executive sponsoredICT projects that are currently underway– other than the criminal history system replacement project – have been initiatedand started without a separate budget having been defined.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-27685 by reference.