Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01782 · Session 1

Full consultation on stocking of salmon rivers

Closed Submitted 27 Jul 1999 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
938 online signatures with a country
Comments
158
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that a full stakeholder consultation is carried out before Marine Scotland formalises policy on the stocking of Scotland’s salmon rivers.

What the petitioner did first

Meetings with Marine Scotland officials, discussions with MSPs.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 5 Mar 2020
    1 mention
  2. 29 Oct 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 13 Jan 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

938 online signatures
  1. Scotland499 53.2%
  2. England199 21.2%
  3. United Kingdom191 20.4%
  4. Northern Ireland12 1.3%
  5. Wales10 1.1%
  6. Ireland4 0.4%
  7. Germany4 0.4%
  8. France4 0.4%
  9. Norway2 0.2%
  10. Australia2 0.2%
  11. 9 other countries11 1.2%

Comments

158 comments, oldest first
158 comments · showing 101–150
  1. David Burgess 12 Jan 2020
    We need to support a rural industry and stocking may help to do this. One comment is I would like to see some fish brought on to smolt stage.
  2. Kevin j Clark 12 Jan 2020
    Thanks
  3. Frank Myhre Hansen 12 Jan 2020
    I have for years seen hatcheries work. When used as eggboxes set in the gravel on sidestreams at places the fish dont hatch naturally.
  4. Alan Wilson 12 Jan 2020
    Things need to change now before it's to late.
  5. David McLaughlin 12 Jan 2020
    I definitely do not agree this is the way forward what's need to be done all government bodies and government needs to introduce rejuvenation of spawning beds and habitats throughout all rivers get back to the basics bring in thinning out of predators land base and sea including factory ships banned from our waters and i do think hatcheries can work if eggs are put out into artificial reds
  6. Bill Green 12 Jan 2020
    Salmon stocks too low, they need our help.
  7. David Bamford 12 Jan 2020
    With Marine Survival of Atlantic salmon at an all time low it is it my strong belief that many rivers will lose their stock of salmon without sensible supportive stocking schemes.
  8. Ron moore 12 Jan 2020
    When is Hollyrood going to wake up realise just how much salmon fishing brings to rural enconamies
  9. Charles Jeffrey 12 Jan 2020
    Nature needs a helping hand immediately.
  10. Roland Craven 12 Jan 2020
    Purely restrictive or negative measures are not going to resolve the issues. Positive steps, of which hatcheries are one, are essential.
  11. Cameron Chapman 12 Jan 2020
    It seems that the Scottish and British Government have agreed that the Scottish economy is more important than the Scottish ecology, especially that of its waters and the Future of the endeared species that are trying to survive in them.
  12. Iain Wilson 12 Jan 2020
    Listen to the professional, the ghiiies!!
  13. Douglas Green 12 Jan 2020
    Start listening to the people who know the rivers they work on. We must have hatcheries and reduce the number of predators. Act now before we lose everything.
  14. Paul Pritchard 12 Jan 2020
    Actions needs to be taken urgently.
  15. Gordon Duncan 12 Jan 2020
    About time just hope it's not to late
  16. Ted Edgar 12 Jan 2020
    Give the hatcheries an opportunity and examine the results, listen to those who work on the river, who know the river and want to improve it.
  17. Brian Key 12 Jan 2020
    Hatcheries are an obvious step in the right direction
  18. George Holland 13 Jan 2020
    I am the treasurer,secretary of an angling club on the river Ayr,where we used to run our own hatchery until we lost the ground on which it stood,I have 100 year's of catch returns to compare which marine and others have and know about the proof is undeniable, while our hatchery was running our catches went from average of 44 per year to well over 200 in a season,the whole system enjoyed this and would love to see it return,we now have a third of the membership and were still catching slightly above average,if it is done properly it will work I have information if they want it if they choose to listen,our club has purchased a third of the river Ayr through the years it would be a shame not being able to do what ever we can to help this amazing iconic fish .
  19. Alan James Parr 13 Jan 2020
    Sadly in this day and age certain species need urgent help. I consider Salmon to be one. Why wait till they are on the brink before help is given. It would only take an outbreak of disease to finish them off completely.
  20. Sam valentine 13 Jan 2020
    It's really important that we stop the decline in salmon numbers NOW whilst there's a chance to save our salmon
  21. James robertson 13 Jan 2020
    Long overdue
  22. murray stewart 13 Jan 2020
    It is criminal if salmon are allowed to die out we need to reduce the number of non native birds eating the salmon off spring
  23. William McSpadyen 13 Jan 2020
    Sometimes nature needs a helping hand. Moreso in the current environmental climate.
  24. John mcmurray Wark 13 Jan 2020
    We need more hatcheries
  25. Richard Saunders 13 Jan 2020
    Salmon stocks need replenishing NOW, not in 20 or 30 years. Both SEPA & Marine Scotland have proven to be enemies of Salmon Stocks, with their ill-thought out policies & plans, and in the case of Marine Scotland, their highly questionable "Science"!
  26. Stephen Mitchell 13 Jan 2020
    I am one of thousands of anglers who enjoy an angling trip to Scotland every year. I entirely agree with the idea that all interested parties should be consulted in this matter. Look what has happened in England! Do not allow Scotland to fall into the same trap.
  27. Andy Clive 13 Jan 2020
    About time
  28. Tom Speir 13 Jan 2020
    Hatcheries are an essential and only way to restock or increase stocks of salmon. The river Tyne has proved this although the EA don't believe this, which ignores the evidence.
  29. Simon Clark 13 Jan 2020
    I am unable to see how the critical mass of breeding fish will repair itself when none of the predators are being managed. Hatcheries must be a serious help as has been proven in Iceland on Rivers like the East Ranga. To ignore this option just hastens the demise of the scottish salmon and the economy that goes with it!
  30. Sir Peter Cresswell 14 Jan 2020
    Please read "Swimming Against the Tide-Restoring Salmon to the Tyne" by Peter Gray and Michael Charleston published by The Medlar Press in 2011.
  31. john castle 14 Jan 2020
    It is most often the Anglers who have technical knowledge and true respect for the salmon species as their quarry. Their views, balanced with realistic scientific information, should be valued and taken in to consideration.
  32. Gordon Henderson 14 Jan 2020
    Times are dire and something has to be done. This is a good start to protect rural jobs long term.
  33. David Farmer 15 Jan 2020
    Do the science first, avoid a one size fits all policy and don't throw the small community led associations out with the bath water which is what is happening now.
  34. Gordon Barron 15 Jan 2020
    Go with happened on dee in the past keep our salmon
  35. Neil Dewhurst 16 Jan 2020
    All parties probably agree that salmon decline is multifactorial.The current situation is critical and all options, including hatcheries, must be carefully appraised in an open and unbiased fashion. The final decisions must be on scientific grounds and evidence based.
  36. David Emmerson 16 Jan 2020
    I find it very sad that salmon fishing is being allowed to disappear.
  37. Ian Kitson 16 Jan 2020
    The disaster that is salmon stocks cannot wait. More hatcheries is a quick start.
  38. john stewart 18 Jan 2020
    marine Scotland appear to have their own agenda
  39. Timothy Gray 20 Jan 2020
    I am opposed to hatcheries since as an expedient palliative they tend to defer or divert attention away from the fundamental issues. But I do think that there should be an informed debate.
  40. William galbraith 21 Jan 2020
    Our river was full of salmon when we had hatchery now without one fish have vanished in river Lugar and Ayr
  41. William galbraith 21 Jan 2020
    All Scottish rivers should have a hatchery
  42. Stephen M.Fielding 21 Jan 2020
    A good idea but more measures should be taken as well to protect smolts BEFORE they return to the sea.
    Estimated mortality rate circa 50%.
  43. David Mcclymont 23 Jan 2020
    I fully support the idea of debating this subject matter to determine whether or not it would have a good effect on the situation in the future and how it would be funded, as the exit from the European union may now cause great difficulty in future sponsored activities.
  44. gary meldrum 27 Jan 2020
    Need hatchery on every river in scotland
  45. David Taylor 27 Jan 2020
    The TDSFB have many years of "on ground" experience and should be respected for this knowledge of the Tay system.
  46. John fraser 27 Jan 2020
    I have always been against hatcheries but we are now at crisis point and without help I believe salmon fishing will not be viable within my lifetime
  47. Sheila Mannion 27 Jan 2020
    We cannot allow this to to go through without stringent representations to the Scottish Government
  48. John galloway 27 Jan 2020
    Hatcherys are only way to keep rivers alive before all brood stock extinct
  49. Kevan Judge 27 Jan 2020
    Interesting how a hatcheries policy can been blundered in virtually immediately yet the Scottish Parliament can ignore rafts of information about the damage to the environment caused by the salmon farming industry. Double standards rule or is it more a case of palms being crossed with more silver by some than others?
  50. Jim Johnstone 27 Jan 2020
    Used to maintain the cctv cameras at tay hatcheries and they do an incredible job.