Petition · PE01782 · Session 1
Full consultation on stocking of salmon rivers
Signatures
0
Comments
158
Considered
3 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that a full stakeholder consultation is carried out before Marine Scotland formalises policy on the stocking of Scotland’s salmon rivers.
What the petitioner did first
Meetings with Marine Scotland officials, discussions with MSPs.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
5 Mar 20201 mention
-
29 Oct 20201 mention
-
13 Jan 20211 mention
Signatures by country
938 online signaturesComments
158 comments, oldest first158 comments · showing 51–100
-
Jeremy Hopkins 8 Jan 2020More hatcheries and more in river predator control and smolt shepherding
-
James d leacH 9 Jan 2020I don't hear much about the impact of the fish farms. Perhaps they might also be considered
-
Peter Astbury 9 Jan 2020To combat predation from cormorants and seals etc, it just makes sense to have more hatcheries.
-
James kellet 9 Jan 2020We need to replenish depleted stocks of wild salmon.
-
Guy Toller 9 Jan 2020Ensure the science is correct. Wild salmon are unique and a fragile part of the ecosystem
-
Steve Balding 9 Jan 2020the government are not doing enough to stop the netting of fish on the estuaries therefore we need to do what ever we can to rebuild the fish stocks.
-
John Clapham 9 Jan 2020I believe that the current system where the costs of fish science work and fish stocking comes from the same pot will never provide effective salmkn ftobk management as scientusts will tend to dicert resources to support the work that they do to the detrement of the sammon population inour rivers.
-
David Scott-Malden 9 Jan 2020Action needed now !
-
Gerard Pagoaga 9 Jan 2020I have been a regular visitor for 30 years and I am now very worried about the future of the scottish salmon. I am convinced that full operating hatcheries can help as they do in many others countries.
-
Clarence michael wood 9 Jan 2020For years I have seen dwindling stocks of salmon on the whiteadder and would love to see the past 14 years come back but alas I doubt this very much may just have to hang the rod up ps lovely part of the world many thanks (Mike)
-
John Warren 9 Jan 2020No hatcheries, no fish eventually. The businesses that harvest stocks at sea should pay to maintain the stocks in the breeding rivers. Common sense.
-
john stewart 9 Jan 2020Marine Scotland seem hell bent on killing off salmon with no science to back them up. Pererhaps they are an expense would should be dispensed with
-
Barry Gibson 9 Jan 2020When the Banks were in crisis government intervened, nature needs intervention action now.
-
Ian King 9 Jan 2020I have met many keepers over the years and all have a deep knowledge of what improves stocks, and they have a strong determination to do so.
-
French Wight 9 Jan 2020Stocking may not be necessary on all rivers but could be vital to keep up stocks on others, and should not be to restrictive.
-
Garry Watson 9 Jan 2020The time for a change is now salmon are in massive decline due to many factors like fish farms ,sea birds ,And mass of seals in estuary
-
Thomas Carruthers 9 Jan 2020Stocking works look at the tyne
-
Jonathan Webster 9 Jan 2020Two of the most productive salmon rivers in the UK are the Tyne and the Helmsdale. Both have longstanding hatcheries, the Wye salmon is facing extinction within 10 years and the Welsh EA are insisting on a no hatcheries policy in Wales. Iceland is a likely destination for disenchanted Scottish salmon anglers and there hatcheries are the norm. When will the scientists" start learning from real world examples and give the Atlantic salmon the leg up it so desperately needs.
-
William Duncan 9 Jan 2020As far as I am aware, stocking has worked everywhere it has been carried out.
-
Jason Evans 9 Jan 2020We need hatcheries to secure the future of wild salmon in the UK.
-
David Woodhouse 9 Jan 2020I fully support a strictly monitored stocking policy for a period of time, for all our game rivers. They are in dire need of any help we can give them to help recover back to some of their former glory
-
Dr Peadar Davis 9 Jan 2020This activity is the only way those directly affected can mitigate wholesale threats from pollution, overfishing, fish farming etc. which have massively reduced the numbers of salmon naturally returning to spawn. The salmon is an important aspect of Scotland's natural heritage
- rod caught salmon is a sadly underappreciated economic lever with great potential to aid Scotland's tourism and manufacturing industry
- it is important now
- imagine the potential if the fish and therefore catches were more plentiful and reliable. Policy needs to be evidence driven and the knowledge and expertise of those managing the rivers needs to be high on the list of key evidence utilised. -
Colin McGregor 9 Jan 2020Every river authority should be adopting a stocking policy as a matter of course, not on a voluntary basis.
-
Nicholas Mason 9 Jan 2020It seems crazy to me not to fully research and debate stocking whilst there is a backdrop of falling wild numbers.
-
Peter Moore 9 Jan 2020Any help would do nothing but good and that goes for Trout as well.
-
John Sawyer 9 Jan 2020Salmon stocking must go on to preserve the salmon future.
-
Allan Lumsden 9 Jan 2020Time is wasting away
-
Paula Spurrier 9 Jan 2020Listen to all viewpoints but pay particular interest to those who work within the industry.
-
John Anderson 9 Jan 2020There has been too much interference from people who have no real knowledge of what is needed to solve the problem ..
-
Andrew Hurst 9 Jan 2020This debate is long overdue. Science shouldn't just focus on possible genetic negatives, it should equally focus on how to optimise hatcheries to ensure diversity and fitness can be achieved. So far the hatchery debate has only ever focussed on the negatives with opposition being led by a few diehard antis.
-
David Hobkirk 9 Jan 2020Need good robust science which should incorporate the knowledge and experience of generations keepers and fisherman.
Need to assess the reliability and accuracy of the data on which decisions are being made, differentiating between weak and strong evidence.
Identify sources of bias be it political or from individual stake holders.
Above all we need to take the angling community on-board with shared objectives and goals moving away from the current them and us situation, the salmons existence as we know it is at stake . -
Dave Sellers 9 Jan 2020we need more hatcheries
-
John Twiname 9 Jan 2020Who makes the disition on who goes to these meetings was their anyone from south scotland ie castle douglas as we have not told this was happening rather upset about not being asked or even knowing some one who was invited it may be was just a jolly outing who think they k ow it all. John twiname
-
Iain neil 9 Jan 2020I am a simple man that does not ask much from life but I think saving an iconic emblem of Scotland is worth it.....when I think of Scotland it's one of the first things I think of.......we have a great eco system in Scotland I want to save or support it as much as I can and would love a policy formed on supporting wild salmon and helping them so they may continue to grace the waters of Scotland for generations to come.
-
Alan Robinso 9 Jan 2020When any animal or bird needs saving from extinction
You start a breeding program to help. But not for salmon? -
Jacqui Gibson 10 Jan 2020Move polluting Salmon Farms onto the land and give wild fish a chance to recover stocks.
-
Mark McLair 10 Jan 2020We need to send more smolts to sea. It's not rocket science
-
George Potts 10 Jan 2020You need local knowledge of the rivers not that of scientists
-
Sandy Harrison 11 Jan 2020Goverment, listen to the the people who work on the rivers for once in your life.
-
William Thomson 11 Jan 2020Let's continue to support all measures which will ensure the survival of salmon stocks here and around the world.
-
Jim wilson 11 Jan 2020Something must be done NOW
-
John Innes 11 Jan 2020The River Tweed Commission are totally against river stocking. Over thirty years ago I was told trout stocking was bad for salmon life however since the ice age both have been in the rivers, so that destroys that theory. Sensible stocking is a must and would help take pressure away from the salmon. Not every angler wishes to fish for salmon on a river and trout fishers tend to go to rainbow trout fisheries as the river trout fishing is so poor. Sensible stocking in the past never harmed the salmon so why should it do now? High time the authorities listened to anglers for a change instead of trying to manage rivers behind a laptop.
-
Paul McGuire 11 Jan 2020Time to stop the political ping pong and get on with saving the entire eco-systems of our rivers.
-
Colin maclean 11 Jan 2020Let's get the hatcheries up and running before it's too late
-
Neil Stephen 11 Jan 2020Listen to the Gillies and managers who work and live on the river twenty four seven.
-
Paul Chambers 11 Jan 2020I support this petition to support the future of our salmon
-
gary meldrum 11 Jan 2020Hatchery is a must on all rivers
-
william allcock 11 Jan 2020the people at grass roots level should have a say in these important decisions.
-
George Boyne 12 Jan 2020Our wild atlantic salmon need all the help possible including greater protection from fish eating birds and other predators.
-
george kindness 12 Jan 2020Hatcheries really do work if managed properly along with greater culling of all the predators which are totally out of control. The success of the Wester Ross River Carron just proves how a single person can increase returns almost 100 fold.