Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01757 · Session 5

Reduce actuarial reductions to the Scottish Local Government Pension Scheme

Closed Submitted 11 Sep 2019 People & Communities
Signatures
0
1,500 online signatures with a country
Comments
138
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to significantly reduce the levels of reduction to the Scottish Local Government Pension Scheme to ensure that today's low paid workers do not become even poorer pensioners.

What the petitioner did first

I have raised this issue with my employer and was advised that as the level of reductions are set out by Scottish Ministers they cannot reduce them.

I have contacted my constituency MSP and my 7 Regional MSPs (for Glasgow). I am in receipt of holding responses from Anas Sarwar, Johann Lamont and Nicola Sturgeon. To date I have received no response or acknowledgement from the remaining 5.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 21 Nov 2019
    1 mention
  2. 3 Sep 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 12 Nov 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,500 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,202 80.1%
  2. United Kingdom284 18.9%
  3. Wales6 0.4%
  4. Northern Ireland4 0.3%
  5. San Marino1 0.1%
  6. England1 0.1%
  7. Spain1 0.1%
  8. United States1 0.1%

Comments

138 comments, oldest first
138 comments · showing 101–138
  1. Marion Cunningham 23 Sep 2019
    Shocking way to treat hard working people.Worked since I was 15 after school full time had children still went back to work still working at 60 . Please do something to help me enjoy my later life with some dignity .
  2. Jennifer ramsay 23 Sep 2019
    I am signing
  3. Mary Stansfield 23 Sep 2019
    Raising the age has affected me as I cannot now afford to retire until the age of 66
  4. Angela Philip 23 Sep 2019
    Reductions should not be made that cause people to be poore at pension age!!
  5. Derek McLay 23 Sep 2019
    The pension scheme has been tampered with for decades. Time for those in parliament to temper their payouts.
  6. Henry Hughes 23 Sep 2019
    I am nearly 62 years of age so will not be affected by pension scheme changes as much as my younger fellow workers. I want them to be as protected as possible so they can afford to provide for themselves in retirement and feel valued for the contribution they have made to public service.
  7. Heather McNeil 23 Sep 2019
    I am female and intend to retire early to care for family members. The level of reduction to my pension may not make this possible and cause me hardship in retirement
  8. Henry Hughes 23 Sep 2019
    I am nearly 62 years of age so will not be affected by pension scheme changes as much as some of my younger fellow workers. I want them to be protected as much as possible so they can provide for themselves in retirement and feel valued for their contribution to public service.
  9. Catherine Carruthers 23 Sep 2019
    I agree the reduction should be reduced as I never expected the pension age to rise and I would have to work another 6 years in an already physical job .
  10. Michael Mcginley 23 Sep 2019
    Yes a reduction
  11. Diane Cowan 23 Sep 2019
    Definitely
  12. Dermot Lynch 24 Sep 2019
    The LGPS is a funded scheme which officers and authorities have been significantly funding through payments throughout their working careers(authorities usually paying in significantly more)- these changes are unfair and different to what was agreed when joining the pension scheme. This forces people to remain in posts they may not be fit for and are therefore blocking jobs for younger persons seeking employment. The reductions are too severe.
  13. Chris JAmes 24 Sep 2019
    Don't Punish Grafters
  14. Brian Armstrong 24 Sep 2019
    Why do they always keep changing the rules? Stop fiddling with hard working peoples retirement futures.
    You've survived 40 years of working in Local Government! What next?
  15. Keven Williamson 24 Sep 2019
    British works are struggling enough with poor pay and conditions, even more so with the issues with Brexit.
  16. Marion Cunningham 24 Sep 2019
    Shocking worked all my life
  17. William Tollin 24 Sep 2019
    I am directly affected by this. A family member has autism and another requires help looking after them. I want to retire asap. Not just women who are carers.
  18. Marion Cunningham 24 Sep 2019
    Worked all my life don't deserve to be a poorer pensioner
  19. elizabeth maitland 3 Oct 2019
    I think it is unfair what the government is doing and that the level of reduction should be reduced or cancelled altogether
  20. Hugh mcgovern 3 Oct 2019
    I do not agree with is proposal
  21. Hugh mcgoverne 7 Oct 2019
    I do not agree with this proposal totally unaccetptabe
  22. Ann Townsley 7 Oct 2019
    I agree
  23. Mary Murray 7 Oct 2019
    I do not agreed with the levels of reduction
  24. marion fraser 7 Oct 2019
    I think that the % reduction is excessive
  25. Catherine Pappas 7 Oct 2019
    I would like Scottish Ministers to review and issue renewed guidance which significantly reduces the level of pension reductions to avoid low paid workers becoming even poorer pensioners.
  26. Eileen Walls 8 Oct 2019
    I am absolutely disgusted that I have to work until I am 66 as I have worked since I left school at fifteen years of age. its just so wrong on every level, as it prevents the younger generation from finding employment.
  27. Isabel McLaughlin 8 Oct 2019
    support for low paid workers
  28. Loren McInally 8 Oct 2019
    I feel the Scottish Parliament should urge the Scottish Government to reduce the levels of reduction to the Scottish Local Government Pension
  29. Lorraine Mcgarrachan 8 Oct 2019
    Totally agree
  30. Helen McDougall 8 Oct 2019
    Nothing further to comment on
  31. Jacqueline Fleming 8 Oct 2019
    I think it is outrageous that once again the hard working class are being penalised and made to work for longer before accessing their pensions which they have worked hard for over decades.
  32. morag reilly 8 Oct 2019
    I am totally offended that these decisions are being implemented and how they affect female and lower paid workers I am sure that these changes to pensions will not at all affect the fat cats who are creaming off funds before making these changes public disgusted council worker
  33. Barbara Thomson 8 Oct 2019
    Yes, of course I've been affected! All my working life I expected to retire at 60yrs of age. Now I can't retire till I'm 66yrs old, with not enough notice to adjust long term financial plans. As I am a low paid worker I can't afford to lose any of my occupational pension so can't take the early retirement option due to huge deductions and without the state pension in place. I thought I had a contract with the government & my employer. As long as I kept paying my contributions, I would receive my pensions as originally agreed. Adjustment to both state & occupational pensions are akin to buying a car on a monthly payment agreement but on completion of payments, the dealer has decided the car is still not mine and they demand further payments for years ahead. This wouldn't be lawful, why are the Scottish Government & Westminster getting away with this.
    Angry and completed disgusted
    - Barbara Thomson
  34. Isabella McNeill 8 Oct 2019
    I feel the working class of this country are getting no support from their government at all.
  35. Isabella Dinnen-Smith 10 Oct 2019
    I have just recently turned 60.
    This was supposed to be my milestone and now it is just a let down. As the government always advised I started to think about my retirement plan and put it into action. I began working full time again when the kids were older and started paying into the council pension 24 years ago to enable me to have a reasonable income receiving both my state pension and council pension at 60.
    Now I have to wait a further 6 years for my state pension. I thought, well I'll just have to try and manage on my council pension, but now I find I am penalised again by my council on the instruction of the Scottish Government my council will clawing back at least 25% if I choose to leave before the state retirement age. This cannot be morally right or fair. I am being penalised by the British Government and the Scottish Government for being a woman and a mother who tried to plan ahead with no other recourse to change my retirement plan I had planned. And who benefits from my 25% stolen council pension, if the pension age remained at 60 there would be no reduction, so were is it going.
  36. Maureen Donaldson 11 Oct 2019
    This is a horrific thought. There is no way my health would allow this. Please let us enjoy the good years after 60.
  37. Alison Akremi 15 Oct 2019
    I am disgusted that when I started worked in 1982 and will have full 40 years service in May 20121 and was looking forward to retiring at 60, to find out I will be penalised for accessing my works pension at 60. My works pension is nothing to do with the Government old age pension which is now 67. This has been done without any consultation to those who will be affected by this. I have also missed out on the Rule of 85 which is also being taken away. I cannot afford to lose this amount of money from my works pension as I am only a local government assistant earning £28,000
  38. david kerr 22 Oct 2019
    i am totally opposed to not haveng the right to access pension fund until retirement age I have underlying health issue and I would like the option of addressing my own future plans with option available to access pension before retirement age