Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01757 · Session 5

Reduce actuarial reductions to the Scottish Local Government Pension Scheme

Closed Submitted 11 Sep 2019 People & Communities
Signatures
0
1,500 online signatures with a country
Comments
138
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to significantly reduce the levels of reduction to the Scottish Local Government Pension Scheme to ensure that today's low paid workers do not become even poorer pensioners.

What the petitioner did first

I have raised this issue with my employer and was advised that as the level of reductions are set out by Scottish Ministers they cannot reduce them.

I have contacted my constituency MSP and my 7 Regional MSPs (for Glasgow). I am in receipt of holding responses from Anas Sarwar, Johann Lamont and Nicola Sturgeon. To date I have received no response or acknowledgement from the remaining 5.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 21 Nov 2019
    1 mention
  2. 3 Sep 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 12 Nov 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,500 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,202 80.1%
  2. United Kingdom284 18.9%
  3. Wales6 0.4%
  4. Northern Ireland4 0.3%
  5. San Marino1 0.1%
  6. England1 0.1%
  7. Spain1 0.1%
  8. United States1 0.1%

Comments

138 comments, oldest first
138 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Jean kilpatrick 12 Sep 2019
    Change to terms are unfair
  2. Noreen Thomson 12 Sep 2019
    Yes
  3. Maryrose Aitken 12 Sep 2019
    Think is ridiculous as ppl work for as long as they can and most ppl retire due to whatever reason and due their pensions
  4. Susan Crawford 12 Sep 2019
    I agree with the petition
  5. Deborah McMillan 12 Sep 2019
    I'm signing this as I'm sick and tired of the hard working people being so poor
  6. Helen Stevenson 12 Sep 2019
    I'm a 60 year old lady who works with special needs kids who are very challenging and don't think I can do this job which I love til I'm 67 been doing it for 25years some jobs u just can't do.
  7. Rona mclachlan 12 Sep 2019
    I do not agree that the level of reductions are fare.
  8. Barbara Niren 12 Sep 2019
    Totally agree
  9. Deborah Montgomery 13 Sep 2019
    I care for family members. However due to these changes I have had to return to work full time after being part time for 17 years.
  10. Amanda Richmond 13 Sep 2019
    Totally agree
  11. catherinelilley 13 Sep 2019
    let us get the pension before we die.
  12. Bridget Linton 13 Sep 2019
    Being a 1950s female I've been denied enough through delay in receiving my state pension
  13. Catherine Logan 13 Sep 2019
    This scheme is totally unfair especially on women who have had their retirement age increased significantly for many years and who also still do most of the caring issues in family life.
  14. alice gillespie 13 Sep 2019
    I am against any changes to reduce actuarial reductions to the Scottish local government pension scheme
  15. Diane Kane 13 Sep 2019
    I believe the Govt are robbing us of our private pension, that I have paid into for over 30 years. I am a carer to family members and it is likely I will be retiring earlier before I can access my state pension at 67, to care for them. After 30 years of public service why should I be penalised if I wish to retire on or after my 60th birthday. It is discussing that the Scottish Govt can do this to hard working, and low paid workers. Shame on them. !!!
  16. PAULINE SHERIDAN 13 Sep 2019
    HOPE THE PETITION IS SUCCESSFUL
  17. Julia Brown 13 Sep 2019
    I have stayed at home to bring my children up, I should not be penalised for this because of future legislation that gave me no opportunity to put aside any savings while having only one income coming into the household.
  18. Jim Watson 13 Sep 2019
    Scheme changes should have been introduced with more thought and on a fairer basis , with more emphasis on new entrants being affected by them .
  19. Isabella Dinnen-Smith 13 Sep 2019
    I think it is shocking and a disgrace that part of my pension will clawed back because I choose to retire at the age I expected to retire when I began to pay into my pension. I expected to retire at 60. Now I have to work longer as I will be penalised further. Effectively I don't receive my state pension at 60 and I will be penalised if I try to access my private pension at 60.
  20. Suzanne Gilmartin 13 Sep 2019
    I totally agree that the levels of reductions to the local government pension scheme should be reduced. I have been directly effected by the changes to the local government scheme and by the changes to being able to receive my pension earlier.
  21. Linda Anderson 13 Sep 2019
    Everyone deserves a descent pension
  22. Ian Briggs 13 Sep 2019
    To ensure fairness, I support the principle of a holistic review of the pension reduction calculations by Scottish Ministers.
  23. Patricia Doherty 13 Sep 2019
    Yes they should be reduced.
  24. June Martin 13 Sep 2019
    I have been denied my state pension, despite spending my working life assuming I would retire at 60. I now find that retiring early from my local government scheme will carry an actuarial reduction. This seems very unfair on women who are already being penalised.
  25. Ingrid Bain 14 Sep 2019
    Pensions shouldn't be tampered with.
  26. Ellen Carmichael 14 Sep 2019
    Acturial reduction too high. Penalising those who can least afford it.
  27. Alan Carmichael 14 Sep 2019
    The actuarial reductions are far to high
  28. Elaine Kerr 14 Sep 2019
    an urge to the Scottish Government to act now on behalf of all the low-paid workers
  29. Margaret REID 15 Sep 2019
    Worked hard all my days. Pension age keeps rising and I have health issues. Do I work till I die?
  30. nancy fay 15 Sep 2019
    this scottish government are constantly penalising people who actually go out and earn money
  31. Kathleen Mcletchie 15 Sep 2019
    I have taken flexible retirement on August 2018 and am now working jobshare rather than full time due deterioration of my health after working 31years continuously un early years
  32. Ingrid Bain 16 Sep 2019
    Protect our pensions
  33. michael bekier 16 Sep 2019
    This inquest is long overdue as i agreed to a pension in 1986 when I started and it has now been altered for the worse.
  34. Michael Mccormick 16 Sep 2019
    No to lower pensions to low pay and female
  35. Elizabeth Clark 16 Sep 2019
    As a women born in the 1950's & affected by pension age increase ( from 60 to 66years old) this is yet another slap in the face for having worked from age 16 years & not able to retire with a reasonable income. After 50 years working & contributing, I thought we would have been treated with a bit more respect.
  36. Alison Melrose 16 Sep 2019
    Am I reading this right I need to work to 67 to receive my full work pension which I have been paying into now for 33 years can I not retire at 60 !!!
  37. catherine sharkey 17 Sep 2019
    I may not be in this category but I feel that anyone who is low paid should not have to suffer any losses due to schemes
  38. Wilma Burton 17 Sep 2019
    I have had bypass surgery in March 2013. On my return to work I found it very tiring and detrimental to my health to work full time and I was concerned that I had to work till I am 67yrs. Due to this I decided to access flexible retirement and accessed my works pension. This allowed me to the reduced hours to promote my health and well being. I feel discriminated against as if I was retiring at 65 this would have been my preferred option.
  39. Rita O'Neill 17 Sep 2019
    DISGRACE
  40. gerry tracey 17 Sep 2019
    yes, I agree that I have been disadvantaged financially as a result of this change
  41. John Hunter 17 Sep 2019
    People in Scotland are dying younger, in reverse to the pattern in the rest of the UK, and as such pensions shouldn't be getting reduced so dramatically.
  42. Karen Robertson 17 Sep 2019
    I think what I signed up to in 1980 should be legally binding and if not challenged in a court of law.
  43. Anita Gajree 18 Sep 2019
    agree
  44. Lorraine Campbell 18 Sep 2019
    It is time to move forward and eliminate this unjust "CARE" package arrangement for better futures for all.
  45. Lorraine Campbell 18 Sep 2019
    It is time to move forward and eliminate this unjust "CARE" package arrangement for better futures for all.
  46. Kathleen Leitch 19 Sep 2019
    I completely agree with the statement from Unison and think manual workers will suffer more than most.
  47. Elisabeth Baxter 19 Sep 2019
    Yes, I've been affected with changes to the Scottish Local Government Pension Scheme. I'm 57 passed in March and would happily retire now, however, the penalty is over 40% which I cannot afford to lose. I work for Glasgow City Council and have done for nearly 22 years. My children have started their own families but I'm not in a position to help them with child care, which is also very expensive. I believe that allowing voluntary early retirement would also allow young people to secure a job.
  48. Carole Makeham 22 Sep 2019
    I am 53, not at retiral age just yet but I would like to hope I had options in the coming years of how i would like to live those years either through illness or having quality family life with no financial worries. So you are right it's concerning that we are not in control of how much or how we get our own money returned to us.
  49. Stephen Hughes 23 Sep 2019
    I do not think there should be any reductions in our pensions having moved into my 42nd year and to find I am now being penalized for having so much service.
  50. Michele Smith 23 Sep 2019
    We have the worse pension conditions in Europe