Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01733 · Session 5

Human right to adequate food

Closed Submitted 11 Jul 2019 Equalities
Signatures
0
1,372 online signatures with a country
Comments
91
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to make the Right to Food part of Scots Law.

What the petitioner did first

I served as a member of an independent working group on food poverty convened by the then Cabinet Secretary Alex Neil MSP in 2015 which recommended that ‘The Scottish Government should explore how the right to food can be enshrined within Scots Law’.
Since 2016, I have worked with others to convene the Scottish Food Coalition, a network of more than 30 local and national organisations. The Coalition has repeatedly pressed the Scottish Government to progress their commitment to a ‘Good Food Nation’ Bill, which would read across a wide range of food issues, including food insecurity. The Coalition believes that this Bill should have the right to food as its cornerstone and highlighted this in their response to Scottish Government’s Good Food Nation consultation in December 2018.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 19 Sep 2019
    1 mention
  2. 5 Mar 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 2 Sep 2020
    1 mention
  4. 17 Feb 2021
    2 mentions

Signatures by country

1,372 online signatures
  1. Scotland962 70.1%
  2. United Kingdom368 26.8%
  3. England22 1.6%
  4. Northern Ireland2 0.1%
  5. United States2 0.1%
  6. Germany2 0.1%
  7. Wales2 0.1%
  8. Colombia1 0.1%
  9. Portugal1 0.1%
  10. Nigeria1 0.1%
  11. 9 other countries9 0.7%

Comments

91 comments, oldest first
91 comments · showing 51–91
  1. Sue Hawthorne 6 Aug 2019
    Food banks are a national disgrace
  2. Raymond Porter 6 Aug 2019
    The inequality and resulting waste is reaching appalling levels. Let us make everyone feel that a basic requirement is not beyond them.
  3. Barry Gale 7 Aug 2019
    It is not clear to me what obligations will be placed upon whom if the Right to Food will become part of Scots Law. Neither is it clear why this is a problem for anybody. As with energy, telephone and banking, it is quite easy to get good deals by shopping around, buying fresh and avoiding ready meals.
  4. Noel Darlow 7 Aug 2019
    There is no good reason for anyone to go hungry in a wealthy country like Scotland.

    The callous disregard for human life which can allow this will hurt us all in the long run.
  5. Patricia Collins 8 Aug 2019
    In the year 2019 it is totally unacceptable that there is food poverty especially in a rich country all options need to be considered and acted upon including dare I say
    - taxing the rich !!!!
  6. David Robinson 9 Aug 2019
    As someone who struggles to afford healthy and sustaining food, this petition is incredibly important.
  7. Claire kenny 9 Aug 2019
    The fact that affordable access to nutritious food has to be petitioned is a sad sad state of affairs.
  8. anne Currie 9 Aug 2019
    I have supported the work of Nourish Scotland for a prolonged period and hope that I can see results soon.
  9. Richie Calder 9 Aug 2019
    Having access to food is a basic and fundamental right in any civilised society
  10. John Sinclair 10 Aug 2019
    I wholeheartedly agree.
  11. Stuart Graham 10 Aug 2019
    No one should be punished for being poor and unfortunately this manifests as hunger when people can't afford food among the rising cost of everything and continued austerity
  12. Nikki Brannan 10 Aug 2019
    Animals should be treated with respect and are entitled to a good quality of life
  13. babs macgregor 11 Aug 2019
    We have the resources to nourish all our people well
    - let's resolve at a political and community level to do this.
  14. Ariane Burgess 11 Aug 2019
    Food is essential for life, food sovereignty should be a human right. Everyone should have access to unprocessed, nutrient-rich, regeneratively grown food.
  15. Jenny Kiernan 12 Aug 2019
    Why is healthy food always so expensive but unhealthy food is so much cheaper?
  16. Stuart Paterson 13 Aug 2019
    The right to food and therefore to live is a right that ought to be had by all. For those unfortunate enough not to have food, our country is wealthy enough to support and protect them.
  17. Kathleen Hart 13 Aug 2019
    It is a basic human right that people should have enough food to eat.
  18. Rev. Donald R Lawrie 13 Aug 2019
    Food means life good food and healthy eating means a quality of life that ultimately benefits everyone. Healthy body, mind and spirit amongst individuals ultimately means a healthier and less burdened society.
  19. Derek McLachlan 15 Aug 2019
    This is a fundamental essential to all and should be available to all no matter your circumstances and should include housing also.
  20. Joanne Rotheray 15 Aug 2019
    I want to be able to eat good Scottish food
  21. Melvin Lack 15 Aug 2019
    Good is everybody's right and should be available for all by sustained means.
  22. Morag Mackenzie 15 Aug 2019
    Good quality, healthy and affordable food should be available for all and is certainly a basic human right. The production of the food we consume also needs to be good for the environment
    - that has to be a given. Governments need to ensure that food production is ethical, sustainable and affordable. Perhaps if food producers were held to account on what is proving to be profit over health then we might see a difference. We don't need the health service picking up the cost of poor diet.
  23. Edward Jentas 15 Aug 2019
    We all deserve to have available healthy and nutritious food, sufficient to feed the population of the world. We could always take away the obscene sums of money from the mega rich and spread it around. They can't take it with them
  24. ALEX Stewart 15 Aug 2019
    I have started to grow my own veg as it is getting expensive to buy and so is the other foods
  25. wendy barrie 15 Aug 2019
    good clean fair food for all
  26. Ann Warren 16 Aug 2019
    The right to decent food is such a basic right & I fully support this campaign.
  27. Zabdi Keen 18 Aug 2019
    Food without unnessesary packaging
    - Local food businesses like the Isle of Arrans creamery that has just had to close should be supported to allow local produce to be available.
  28. Evie Murray 19 Aug 2019
    How did we ever get to a situation whereby the most basic right of all, the right to food, is withheld from those most in need of it, in such cruel and humiliating ways.
  29. Karen Birch 19 Aug 2019
    We see many challenges here in The Borders which I have no doubt are replicated across parts of Scotland
    - having to check for signs of malnutrition in our old folk when they attend community meals, fresh, local produce being unavailable or unaffordable in rural communities, obesity due to the ready access to high calorie but low nutritional value junk food and young people not knowing where their food comes from and how to prepare even the simplest meals. We need a bill that will ensure that everyone, regardless of personal circumstances, has access to healthy, nutritious food which has been fairly produced.
  30. Jo Hunt 19 Aug 2019
    I work 70 hours a week growing healthy food on our family croft, and distributing it to 500 local people. Last year I earned £0.93 an hour for this work and relied on volunteers to help. We urgently need a more just food system.
  31. Susan Crosthwaite 19 Aug 2019
    Food is medicine. Everyone should have the right to good quality healthy food and refined sugar and trans fats should be highlighted as a danger to health.
  32. Helen Scammell 19 Aug 2019
    Many people in our community do not have access to decent healthy and cheap food or can't afford to buy food.
    It is appalling in this day and age that people are forced to go to food banks because of sanctions or too little benefits to live a dignified fulfilling life.. Having to make choices between things like being warm, clothing your children or eating is not acceptable in this day and age and in this country.
  33. Gordon Ruddiman 19 Aug 2019
    Amongst any other practical way we can get nutritious food to people in need how about the new Scottish Government Best Start Food cards just launched on the 12th of August. Can this scheme not be used to help those who can easily be identified by the benefits they are on whether working or not to receive extra funds for a possibly wider range of 'best start foods' instead of a blanket approach to 'holiday hunger'?
  34. Caroline Robertson 19 Aug 2019
    Back to basics! Food is a necessity, not a luxury.
    The entire population must be more engaged in where their food comes from and in growing, buying , preparing , enjoying food. Does not need to be fancy, so called simple meals such as lentil soup, omelette, bean casserole, with or without meat are cheap and easy to prepare. But here's one of the catches, they do require a wee bit of forward planning and preparation, something which has been lost to too many folks. At the very least the Scottish government will have to reinstate home economics classes in schools as well as tackling the issue of unable or unwilling parents in this respect. Supermarkets have a role to play by reducing the range of rubbishy products on sale, but of course that means loss of revenue.
  35. Caroline Robertson 19 Aug 2019
    The entire population must be more engaged in where their food comes from and be involved wherever possible in growing, shopping, preparing, eating, enjoying and valuing food as an intrinsic part of life.
  36. Adewale Ayorinde 19 Aug 2019
    Food is inevitable to every living soul and not to be formated. Everybody should easily have access to fair and green foods.
  37. David Atkinson 19 Aug 2019
    Food should be at the heart of Scottish Culture
    We have a distinctive food production system which produces food and sustains producer and linked communities. We need to maintain this and to continue to work with our distinctive land resource which is just so fifferent from other parts of the UK
  38. Martin Charlton 19 Aug 2019
    Even better give everyone a universal basic income, that would enable people to buy food tampons etc without being humiliated by poverty.
  39. Janet Richardson 20 Aug 2019
    Invest in our farmers, enable sustainable food production bearing in mind we are an island and unfortunately rely mainly on foreign imported food which in the future may not be affordable. Time to rethink food production in the U.K.
  40. Stuart Miller 20 Aug 2019
    Everyone should have access to food, it's a fundamental right
  41. Robertha Govan 20 Aug 2019
    I want all this petition asks for also good support for the farmers involved who have done everything governments have asked for through every crisis, now they are facing CLIMATE CHANGE !