Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01704 · Session 5

Improve targets and outcomes for autistic people in Scotland

Closed Submitted 1 Aug 2018 Health
Signatures
0
1,013 online signatures with a country
Comments
85
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that an agenda of real and meaningful change for autistic people is pursued by introducing the following targets and outcomes by 2021:
That every person in Scotland going through an autism diagnostic procedure will be assessed within a calendar year and receive a statutory services assessment from a qualified social worker as an integral part of this process, within twelve months from the date of their initial referral.
That children with autism in mainstream schools will have their assessed needs for classroom support met by an ASL assistant with a recognised autism qualification as part of a mandatory registration process for ASL professionals.
That young adults with autism will have a statutory right to specialist support from their local authority up to the age of 25.
That an Autism Act will be in place within the next 5 years to enshrine specific rights and services for autistic people in our legal system.

What the petitioner did first

I have raised these issues with my MSPs, including Michael Russell, Donald Cameron and John Finnie and with MSP’s with previous ministerial responsibilities, Jamie Hepburn and Shona Robison.
I have raised my concerns with civil servants/advisors to government.
I also had a petition last year hosted by change.org calling for similar actions. This petition amassed 2,014 signatures and approximately 200 comments of support.
I originally intended for this petition to be considered by the Committee much earlier in 2018, but unfortunately it was not processed in time by the Petitions Department.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 27 Sep 2018
    1 mention
  2. 20 Dec 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 5 Sep 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,013 online signatures
  1. Scotland854 84.3%
  2. United Kingdom122 12%
  3. England24 2.4%
  4. United States4 0.4%
  5. Australia2 0.2%
  6. Northern Ireland2 0.2%
  7. Belgium1 0.1%
  8. Wales1 0.1%
  9. Netherlands1 0.1%
  10. Ireland1 0.1%
  11. 1 other countries1 0.1%

Comments

85 comments, oldest first
85 comments · showing 51–85
  1. Emma Fraser 19 Aug 2018
    Unacceptable. No excuse. Fix this now.
  2. Peter Logie 19 Aug 2018
    This needs to be brought in urgently. There should not be a two tier system.
  3. Annalise Wainwright 19 Aug 2018
    With Council budget cuts threatening school staff budgets there is a real threat schools will lose valuable classroom support staff to assist teachers and support autistic pupils. This must not be allowed to happen. Education and health are areas that should never be disadvantaged by budget cuts. Ever.
  4. Victoria Beavis 19 Aug 2018
    a family member already misses out on school because of the lack of support. If it decreases anymore it would be pointless them going to school.
  5. Eunice Duff 20 Aug 2018
    Every child and young person needs an education these children are being let down by the system constantly needs are not being met urgently needs rectifying
  6. Clare Chalmers 20 Aug 2018
    It is becoming very clear, Austin children are being failed, GIRFEC should be totally scrapped and services targeted for those children in real need of help. ASN in Schools is a postcode lottery, mostly a disgrace, not to mention the failing CAMHS.
    Austin children need more resources, better understanding of their indidual needs, some parents are turning to Home Education as an alternative, we really need to do better for these special children.
  7. Stephanie western 20 Aug 2018
    Not allowing people the support they need in their education, puts limits on their future. Invest in our education and in all children even if it does cost a bit more and they will have a more productive future. I have experienced my child not being supported and it leads to mental health problems and low self worth. Different not less!
  8. Sonia cooper 20 Aug 2018
    Signed+shared x
  9. Sabrina duncan 21 Aug 2018
    No1 should be left out. Ridiculous along with what some1 else has commented. Girfec should include children with disabilities
  10. Leanne Dunn 21 Aug 2018
    The soon this changes the better for all those being failed.
  11. Fiona Culbert 22 Aug 2018
    Leaving the Autism Strategy to the interpretation of local authorities has failed to meet autists and their families needs. Support is a postcode lottery and therefore is neither equitable nor fair, if it takes legislation as with the integrated partnerships of health and social care. Too many autists are failed and I want a future for kids is this "fairer Scotland "
  12. lisa mackintosh 27 Aug 2018
    we mived to england as the highland council was failing a family member so much they were becoming deppressed
  13. Laura Kerbey 2 Sep 2018
    Ensuring that children and young people with autism are diagnosed as early as possible will ensure they are able to access vital support and interventions. All children with autism have the right to receive support, therapy and interventions to allow them to reach their full potential in all academic settings. The impact of NOT
    diagnosing and supporting has a significant impact on mental health, education and in turn the economy.
  14. Judith Dennis 3 Sep 2018
    I support this completely. I know of a sixteen year old with a learning disability (suspected PDA) who has an fourteen month wait ahead for Ads diagnosis and no chance of PDA recognition in their area. As an adopted and once looked after child in the system since birth they deserve better than waiting lists and lack of clarity. Please help us move forward.
  15. Gillian Tosh 3 Sep 2018
    I know of a young person who was failed for years and punished instead of supported in primary school. They are still suffering trauma due to them not using PDA strategies despite being asked and the parent being told they were.By own notes they clearly show they weren't. The parent had to remove the young person for last 6 months as her mental health was suffering.Refusing to support is abusive
  16. Patricia Hewitt 5 Sep 2018
    The Scottish Autism Stratagy is not fit for purpose . Education Laws worthless . My family like tens of thousands of others are in Crisis due to a dreadful lack of understanding of the Autism Spectrum, PDA is still a Post Code Lottery even after our Petition to Holyrood . Specific Stratagies must be used . Many are without a suitable Education or any viable support . Mental Health issues are endemic due to the lack of early intervention and recognition . We need change NOW .
  17. Alison Griffin 6 Sep 2018
    I've been fighting the system since my family member was 18 months old and will be 5 in November. My family member is still undiagnosed with austim or ASD, still waiting for ASD assesment. It's taken me over 2 years to get an appointment with incontenence team for their chroinc constipation. The system meant to help and support our children is drastically failing them. My family member has just started mainstream school and they are doing all they can do but without a proper diagnosis there is only so much they can do
  18. Donna Dick 6 Sep 2018
    I initially felt lucky that my family member, aged 3, had an early diagnosis of autism spectrum diagnosis. However finding a lack of intervention available to them at a young age was dishearting and sad. Despite research and studys showing how effective this is. I was left trying to figure out interventions and pay privately for everything to ensure they had the best possible chance to be the best he can be and hopefully be able to attend mainstream school. However again on researching school and support available I am left asking what will happen when he has to go to school, how and who will support him, will they be trained and understand his needs? Will he be safe? Why is ABA not supported in Scotland however it is everywhere else in the UK? It is cruel not allowing these unique children to be the best of themselves.
  19. Alistair MacKinnon 7 Sep 2018
    Needs action, yesterday.
  20. Nancy Webster 8 Sep 2018
    This needs to be recognised earlier than it is at the moment. These children need to be taught how to deal with there own needs and they need help to do it
  21. Tracey Tanner 9 Sep 2018
    Failure to provide support for those on the spectrum with PDA, is discrimination
  22. Ruth Auchterlounie 9 Sep 2018
    Autistic people do really well when they can begin to understand themselves. Accurate timely thorough assessments can be incredibly helpful at helping families access the best support, much of which is in the voluntary sector
  23. Pamela Griffin 10 Sep 2018
    A family member has been awaiting an assessment for ASD for some time. The family has been given no indication as to the time scale other than being told that there is a "lengthy waiting list". The family member displays all signs of PDA yet the family has been informed that Highland will not assess for PDA. The family member is living with constant anxiety and their education is suffering and home life is a real struggle. Professional support and recognition of PDA would make such a difference to the family's lives and would provid a fantastic supportive framework for the family member's school to work with.
  24. Anthony Jardine 12 Sep 2018
    All children and young adults that require additional support should be given the best chance of an educational and all the support the Scottish Government can give them.
  25. Lynne Carson 12 Sep 2018
    I am signing this petition as members of my family are on the autistic spectrum
  26. Evan Conway 12 Sep 2018
    Please share please.
  27. Rosemary Kane 12 Sep 2018
    Signed
  28. Lisa Donnelly 13 Sep 2018
    A family member of mine has had a shocking time going through our system and has now closed themselves off from all family. They have not seen or spoken to some family members in almost 3 years. They are a broken individual.
  29. R.McCarthy 13 Sep 2018
    More needs to be done to help children with autism in schools.
  30. William Henderson 13 Sep 2018
    A family member of mine has ASD. Been trying to get social work assessment since Oct last year and been told may still be more than a year before they have time!
  31. Tracy McCartney 13 Sep 2018
    Children with Autism are getting missed all too often and it has to stop
  32. Elizabeth Pollock 13 Sep 2018
    My family member is autistic, but they have all the traits of PDA and it was barely mentioned at their assessment. We are able to cope with their PDA but more training needs to be given in order to support PDA traits
  33. Linda Mcphee 13 Sep 2018
    Lack of support and understanding is having a negative impact on children and families , we need better professionals, and also public awareness and education and support
  34. Johan Pearson 13 Sep 2018
    I am convinced that my family member has pda which is not diagnosed in Scotland or properly understood up here in Shetland. Due to the school not understanding or meeting their needs , they are home schooled. More support, awareness and training is needed in schools.
  35. Sharon Grant 14 Sep 2018
    Families need action and not false promises. So many families are at breaking point and so many children and young people are being failed. We have a system which frankly isn’t fit for purpose. I had to fight for my family member for 9 years before they were diagnosed, nobody listened and was failed miserably, while I was fighting to secure a school place to get them the support they so deserved & needed I had to start the fight for another family member who is now diagnosed with ASD with PDA. I’ve had to fight not only for what we currently have in place but to have their needs recognised because it’s seems easier for certain professionals to say PDA isn’t recognised even though they were diagnosed through NHS. I had to take legal action for their needs to be recognised, to secure a school placement and to gain a Co-Ordinated Support Plan, so far I have avoided 2 tribunals. Sadly our story is all too familiar and the same stories are repeated throughout our Country. Our children/young people & adults deserve so much more. PDA needs firmly put on the agenda as it’s very much a postcode lottery.