Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01690 · Session 5

Review treatment of people with ME in Scotland

Closed Submitted 20 Apr 2018 Health
Signatures
0
5,770 online signatures with a country
Comments
453
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to review the level of support for people with Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME) in Scotland with a view to:
Investing in biomedical research and creating a centre of excellence for ME
Ensuring healthcare professionals' training and education materials reflect the latest scientific evidence
Providing specialist care for patients and discontinuing the harmful treatments graded exercise therapy (GET) and cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT).

What the petitioner did first

Contacted MSPs and the Health Minister.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 7 Jun 2018
    1 mention
  2. 8 Nov 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 22 Nov 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 24 Jan 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 30 May 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 19 Dec 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 26 Aug 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

5,770 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,904 33%
  2. England1,006 17.4%
  3. United Kingdom908 15.7%
  4. United States629 10.9%
  5. Australia259 4.5%
  6. Canada154 2.7%
  7. Netherlands135 2.3%
  8. Norway122 2.1%
  9. Germany101 1.8%
  10. Sweden99 1.7%
  11. 41 other countries453 7.9%

Comments

453 comments, oldest first
453 comments · showing 151–200
  1. Suzanne 2 May 2018
    Enough my life is gone
    From active fitness instructor to dance teacher to 8 years bedbound
    Do you really believe am lazy or just tired!!!
  2. Eveline Virginia Webb 2 May 2018
    I first became ill in Scotland 35yrs ago_what an absolute godsend a centre of expertise would have been Still today it is needed even more!!!The suffering that is endured by individuals that have this horrible illness must be recognised&addressed!!
  3. Su 2 May 2018
    ME offered an opportunity for medicine to explore new avenues, and develop care partnerships with patients, who have been let down by an out of date model
  4. Ana Semple 2 May 2018
    In 2002 the Chief Medical Officer for Britain said ME Chronic Fatigue Syndrome is a serious and disabling illness. In Scotland we still do not have any dedicated medical provision for most patients after diagnosis.
  5. Mrs Mary H Young 2 May 2018
    It is vital theft research is done into this dreadful debilitating illness. A member of my family has suffered fir the past six years,our GP practice have very poor perception and can offer no ongoing assessment or appropriate treatment to help with the constant pain and struggle in patients daily lives.
  6. Dorothy Radley 2 May 2018
    I wish to show solidarity with Sottish ME sufferers by signing this petition. I would like to see improved care & treatment fir people with ME in Scotland. Scottish government should provide full support for people with ME as they do for people with cancer. The burden of this disease on Scotland is immense. I would like to see Scottish government funding on a par with the burden the disease has on Scotland. I have lived a living death with this disease for 30 years and I am still living the nightmare.
  7. Claire Armstrong-Brealey 2 May 2018
    I have had ME for over thirty years undiagnosed and diagnosed, we are still no further on. This illness is a killer.
  8. josie minto 2 May 2018
    We have all suffered being ignored for long enough, time for action. I've been moderately affected from childhood & am now 71!
  9. Leigh 2 May 2018
    Scotland has lead the way in so many health issues before
    - please lead the way in this too by providing proper research, education and care. So much suffering could have been prevented if medical professionals had been taught about this condition and how to treat it
    - and importantly, how not to treat it. The same happened with MS years ago!
  10. LeeAnn Boyd 2 May 2018
    I suffer from this illness, and it is devastating. I had to leave my successful business career, and can now barely socialize. It takes all of my energy just to take care of myself, and I must lie down alone with complete quiet for hours every day. This is not living, this is staying alive. I never complain about my illness but the lack of healthcare and research we receive for a common and devastatingingly disabling illness is a human rights crime. I have been sick for 18 years.
  11. Janet 2 May 2018
    Someone, somewhere within the recognized healthcare hierarchy needs to stop the institutional attitude of ignoring of this illness in the hope that it will go away. It won't. I have been hanging on to hope for 25 years and cannot get those wasted years back. Please try to prevent this happening to others.
  12. Elyse Silverman Jack 2 May 2018
    I'm barely able to type this because of what the illness has done to me. No one should be without the option of real medical help no matter where they live. Everyone has the right as a living human being to be treated with respect. We are all God's creatures, even if you don't believe in God, ALL of our lives matter so need to be cherished no matter the circumstance. We have a duty to each other to help one another & that is exactly what the government is supposed to be doing, period.
  13. Anthony Fryer 2 May 2018
    ME is a physical illness which is determined by symptoms including Post exertional malaise. Graded Exercise Therapy is not acceptable
  14. Margaret Turley 2 May 2018
    It is a hidden illness that needs help
  15. Ewart Shaw 2 May 2018
    I'm signing this because someone dear to me has had ME for ten years. It's a devastating condition, poorly understood, and many people with ME have been treated very badly by politicians, psychiatrists, and the NHS in general.
  16. Rebecca Martin 2 May 2018
    I want to see research being done and new treatment established for those suffering from ME. I want there to be specialists to be brought to scotland to train doctors on effective treatment options. Training for primary care doctors and specialist to refer out to. this need is immediate. let's step up to thee cause.
  17. Kirsten 2 May 2018
    I've had such a tough time with this illness and could really do with a break. Please help us.
  18. Abigail Martin 2 May 2018
    Given the number of sufferers of this disease it is unacceptable that research is not funded and patients continue to be dismissed as it being a psychological problem.
  19. Andy Venneman 2 May 2018
    As a care giver for someone with ME-CFS I urge you to help get these people their lives back by supporting in anyway possible the research needed to solve ME-CFS.
  20. Ginette Neault 2 May 2018
    I have the disease since 1990 and I understand you.
    I pray for all who have this disease. Courage!
  21. Ginette Neault 2 May 2018
    Hi, I have the disease since 1990. I understand you. I pray for you. Courage!
  22. Mary Wakefield 2 May 2018
    I have had ME for 23 years, therefore fully support this Petition
  23. Bjarke Lauritzen 2 May 2018
    Justice and equality in treatment for ME patients around the globe!
  24. John Amodio 2 May 2018
    A member of my family is of Scottish descent and has had her life significantly constrained by this devastating disease, as has millions more. One of her deepest desires is to visit Scotland. Your research could be the difference in making this happen for her and millions others.
  25. Carolyn Moser 2 May 2018
    Until I saw the documentary Unrest on Myalgic Encephalomyelitis I had no idea how serious this condition is. It literally steals their life away and the lives of their families who must care for them. The only way to discover the best treatment is research, research and more research. What does not work is graded exercise therapy GET and cognitive behavioral therapy CBT. This is a disease not a mental illness. Stop prescribing what doesn't work. Be part of the success in finding genuine medical treatment. It is so critical for the people who live in these daily prisons.
  26. Sarah Masters 2 May 2018
    It is critical the the medical and scientific communities around the world take this illness seriously and fund research for hard science to determine the underlying causes of this illness. For those afflicted the condition is a prison or worse. Please take time to learn more about the illness and find funds for research and care. Two useful places to start are the award winning documentary UNREST and the website of the Open Medicine Foundation in California, a group initiating and funding progressive scientific research. Please, please look carefully at the issue. Sarah Masters, family member of a 30 year old whose life is being stolen by this illness.
  27. trace newton 2 May 2018
    The chaos surrounding diagnosis and treatment affects people who don't have M.E. too! I was diagnosed with it and as a result no further investigations were made. Turns out I probably had premature ovarian failure and a variety of inherited conditions. Had I not been diagnosed with M.E., I may have been able to access necessary treatment a lot earlier. Misdiagnosis of M.E. has adversely affected my physical health.
  28. Jackie 2 May 2018
    My dad has ME took it over a year to be diagnosed. I want him to be able to live life freely and enjoy my wedding this summer.
  29. kayleigh kavanagh 2 May 2018
    this disease is horrific. before ME I was an active overachiever with big plans and all the energy in the world. If i put my mind to something, nothing could stop me. Unfortunately it was this same determination that led me to push and push my body, combined inaccurate information about exercise helping this illness
    - it doesn't the biomedical evidence proves it makes it worse, see dr Sarah Myhill's book "Diagnosis and Treatment of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and Myalgic Encephalitis Second Edition: it's mitochondria, not hypochondria". that led me from mild to moderate ME to being Severe. I have now been severe for over 5 years, 6 this September. unfortunately, my story isn't unusual, a lot of patients followed incorrect and dangerous medical advise that led them to become much worse, then we are repeatedly told that we are the problem. we did this to ourselves, we wished this on ourselves, it is our faulty thinking that is keeping us unwell. the only insane part about this situation is that with ample biomedical proof showing there are lots of physical things going on, these studies still aren't being funded and what little money there is keeps going to psychology. It is embarassing. I currently live in stirling. it is a beautiful city and I see why the scottish are so proud of their country. but they are failing a large community of their people. and unless more biomedical research is funded, even more people will disappear and become a part of the "millions missing" whilst they, like me, lie sick in bed, wondering why are we having to fight this battle alone and what can i do when i struggle to lift a cup to my lips, to move my limbs, to think a cohesive sentence. we need more funding for research, we need more help with housing, we need to be a priority on housing lists to get us into suitable accomodation, to get doctors who understand this disease, not who believe the incorrect spiel spouted by pace trial authors&the media with an agenda true science doesnt lie
  30. Carrie McCulloch 2 May 2018
    A family member was unable to sit his GCSEs because of ME and has been bed or housebound for the last 3 years. His friends have gone on to higher education, make friends, work and form relationships while he is stuck. This is a horrific disease that robs people and their families of their lives.
  31. Karen Dodsworth 2 May 2018
    Healthcare professionals need to be educated on how to treat ME patients without actually (albeit unintentionally) making them worse. Also any harmful treatment e.g. GET should be discontinued immediately. The research to prove that it is harmful and the effects of PEM (post exertions malaise) have been in the public domain for long enough for it to have filtered down to the medical profession to act upon it. Guidelines urgently need to be created for all those involved in any aspect of care of ME patients. I've lost count of the number of times I've been told ME? I don't know anything about that! by medical professionals.
  32. Rachel Ewuloye 2 May 2018
    This is a real illness that is very debilitating. Let's help raise awareness and sign this petition.
  33. Melissa Adkinson 2 May 2018
    ME is real. It can strike anyone at anytime. It can happen to you or someone you love. Please help those affected by doing more research and providing community supports. Their lives depend on it.
  34. Kirsty White 2 May 2018
    ME is a hugely debilitating illness, with no treatment and little support. Investment in ME research and care would assist people who are suffering, to get their lives back. It would also boost the economy as hundreds of people, could begin their working lives again.
  35. Jennifer Caldwell 2 May 2018
    I am in the US and have ME. It has devastated my life. Healthcare professionals need to be properly educated about the seriousness of this chronic neurological-immune disease that effects multiple systems. Our governments need to invest millions of dollars into research. The economic burden to society is billions of dollars and something needs to be done to develop treatments and give these struggling patients and their families relief.
  36. Kirsty 2 May 2018
    ME is a hugely debilitating illness. Investment in research and care would allow people suffering to get their lives back. It would further be an investment in the economy as this would allow many people to return to or begin their working lives.
  37. Marcia 2 May 2018
    Complex symptoms need joined-up medical approach, so a ME Center for Excellence makes sense. Need immunologist, geneticist, cardiologist & endrinologist, allergy-aware dietician, & those with understanding of non-synergetic medicines too. Neurobiologist with Lyme Disease expertise. Dental aspect also needs addressing. Rheumatology for Fibromyalgia etc.
  38. Marie Meike 2 May 2018
    Have Myalgisk encefalemyelit and hope for treatment every day
  39. Jennifer Mars 2 May 2018
    Please help us!
  40. Linda Hobbs 2 May 2018
    I have had ME and then Fibromyalgia for the last 30 years and it has completely changed the way I have to live my life. My heart goes out to all those sufferers around the world in a similar situation. People look at you and think you look OK, but they have no idea of the suffering pain and fatigue that we live with every day. It is like having severe flu every day. Extra funding into research, more training for doctors and health care professionals and specialist care for patients, as well as discontinuing GET and CBT exercise treatments would be extremely beneficial. I strongly urge the Scottish government to vote in favour of these changes, to help people with this dreadful condition, who are so often overlooked.
  41. Victoria Langley 2 May 2018
    I am signing because I went to physio 5 times and only one physio knew knew what ME was. I am seeing them for arthritis but need care to fit. My last ones opening sentence was ok well first thing we need to do with you is cardio. I sat there and went, is that meant to be a joke? Can I just check that you have read my notes and what I am diagnosed with? she said no. I proceeded to say ME and that cardio would 100% put me in bed ill, her reply was why? whats ME? I said ok end of appt!
  42. Carol 2 May 2018
    ME is a life-altering, severely debilitating illness that can often be invisible as sufferers cope behind closed doors. While healthy individuals get on with their lives e.g. work, socialize, go to school, have children, etc. those with ME are often in a darkened room, day after day, year after year barely functioning. Please support this devastating condition so we can figure out what causes it and find the cure.
  43. Mike Sawatsky 2 May 2018
    It is time to step uo and help the people that have been ignored for so long while ignoring all the neurological damages of prescriptions. It is a little embarrassing to have them ignore patients when pharamceuticals have been linked to brain injury and it is only ignored. The numbers are staggering and the incompetence is a little too much to stomach
  44. Alan Christopher Creaser, 2 May 2018
    The Best of health & luck to sufferer's worldwide!!... :)
  45. Sonia Cantellow 2 May 2018
    Important to get our voice heard and make positive changes in Scotland.
  46. Kathe V. Brown 2 May 2018
    Leave the CBT and GET behind with the leeches, the 21st century medicine demands real treatments, not quackery.
  47. Alison Knocker 2 May 2018
    This is a devastating disease made all the worse by ignorance and lack of appropriate treatment. My family member has already wasted several years of a budding career
    - let's try to understand the causes and find effective treatment.
  48. Maria 2 May 2018
    ME is a terrible illness that strikes so many. People like myself end up extremely ill & bedridden. Please assist the many people suffering by providing research funds and medical care,
  49. Elizabeth Ross 2 May 2018
    I have Fibromyalgia and the GET practice needs stopping for this too, as it does not work. I wish we had the same in the UK. I hope this petition is successful.
  50. Sandra Ferguson 2 May 2018
    I am one of the millions that this disease has robbed of everything good in life