Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01690 · Session 5

Review treatment of people with ME in Scotland

Closed Submitted 20 Apr 2018 Health
Signatures
0
5,770 online signatures with a country
Comments
453
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to review the level of support for people with Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME) in Scotland with a view to:
Investing in biomedical research and creating a centre of excellence for ME
Ensuring healthcare professionals' training and education materials reflect the latest scientific evidence
Providing specialist care for patients and discontinuing the harmful treatments graded exercise therapy (GET) and cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT).

What the petitioner did first

Contacted MSPs and the Health Minister.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 7 Jun 2018
    1 mention
  2. 8 Nov 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 22 Nov 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 24 Jan 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 30 May 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 19 Dec 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 26 Aug 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

5,770 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,904 33%
  2. England1,006 17.4%
  3. United Kingdom908 15.7%
  4. United States629 10.9%
  5. Australia259 4.5%
  6. Canada154 2.7%
  7. Netherlands135 2.3%
  8. Norway122 2.1%
  9. Germany101 1.8%
  10. Sweden99 1.7%
  11. 41 other countries453 7.9%

Comments

453 comments, oldest first
453 comments · showing 101–150
  1. Morag Thornton 29 Apr 2018
    People suffering ME need to be acknowledged
    They need an official diagnosis so they can be taken seriously
    People with ME need support to live with their condition
  2. Irene. 29 Apr 2018
    I'll now over 30 years we appear to be going backwards in treatment and acceptance
  3. Diane Smail 29 Apr 2018
    Scotland needs more help with M.E, more medical staff, more recognition and support for sufferere's.
  4. Elena Gimson 29 Apr 2018
    Due to the lack of professional care and told to just push through by doctors a member of my family went from mild to housebound.
  5. Sarah Griffiths 29 Apr 2018
    M.E. sufferers are treated criminally and if it was any other serious disease there would be an out-dry. M.E. is a multi-systemic, neurological, mitochondrial disease that destroys lives and yet people are left to cope alone, with Doctors and government showing no care, understanding, compassion or empathy, which is shameful and disgusting. You wouldn't dare treat any other desperately ill people so monstrously..
  6. Ann Forbes 30 Apr 2018
    Please speak to Carol Monaghan MP who has an excellent grasp of this subject.
    Please recommend that GET and CBT therapy be discontinued .
    Please ensure that all NHS Health Board Areas will
    (not can) appoint the services of ME Specialists
    for the approx. 15,000 people who suffer from this condition .
  7. Sarah McIntyre 30 Apr 2018
    ME just appaling. Are there any alternative treatments that work?
  8. Kristin Stempf de Vargas 1 May 2018
    Studies have found that ME places a greater burden on those afflicted with it than do many of the most serious diseases of of our time including schizophrenia, cancer, stroke, multiple sclerosis and Type I diabetes. This alone should motivate improved care, treatment and income support for people with ME in Scotland.
  9. Sheila Wilson 1 May 2018
    Stop GET it's left me 90% bedridden
  10. Rebecca French 1 May 2018
    I was first diagnosed with ME in 1998. Since that time I have had no specialist care for the condition. I am housebound and unable to access basic healthcare services such as the dentist or Women's Health checkups. I live under the shadow of benefit reform, currently there is no way for me to purchase a much needed bath lift, and no provision of funds for it. I fall through every crack in the system, alongside the thousands suffering with this life sentence in Scotland.
  11. Muriel Mackenzie 1 May 2018
    I will always sign petitions for neurological conditions
  12. Pat Moncur 1 May 2018
    Scotland has a very good record for good health care and research, but we do need to do more for me sufferers
  13. Christine Berry 2 May 2018
    I have suffered with M.E. for 23 years. I've been through a really bad time for the past two years. I only have two good days a month. I am only too glad to help others suffering with M.E. in any way I can
  14. Christine Berry 2 May 2018
    I have suffered with M.E. for 23 years. I've been through a really bad time for the past two years. I only have two good days a month. I am only too glad to help others suffering with M.E. in any way I can
  15. Marco Cattaneo 2 May 2018
    A member of my family is affected by this terrible illness, which needs to be recognised as such by governments, health services and the medical profession
  16. David Mcguinness 2 May 2018
    We need to be as one
  17. R L Bradley 2 May 2018
    Id like to see an improvement in care and treatment of all ME patients worldwide. Start in scotland and show the world how cool you scotland is!!
  18. Emily Burns 2 May 2018
    As a doctor and a scientist who has worked in biomedical ME research it is clear to me that a review is urgently needed. Not only have many legitimate concerns been raised regarding he evidence base for GET CBT but furthermore there is mounting high quality data published from reputable institutions such as Stanford University, that show immunological abnormalities in ME patients. These findings are in keeping with phase II data suggesting targeted immune modulation (Rituximab) maybe be an effective treatment for some patients with ME. When the social, economical and personal costs of ME are so high to continue to ignore this changing understanding is wasteful and harmful.
  19. Pam Kent 2 May 2018
    I would like a similar petition to be presented to the English parliament.
  20. Lavinia Capogna 2 May 2018
    Solidariety with M.E patients in Scotland
  21. Gill Harrod 2 May 2018
    Please give appropriate support to ME suffers. Making them exercise can cause worse pain. More research into this condition and training is badly needed.
  22. Alex Cheung 2 May 2018
    Scotland could lead the way for the rest of the UK to find solutions to this very debilitating chonic condition. Fresh thinking is urgently needed.
  23. Raymond Henderson 2 May 2018
    Urgent reviews of this debilitating illness required to help us ME sufferers
  24. Arthur B. Ranken 2 May 2018
    I am an activist for the Australian Government to fund research, treatment awareness and publicity into this this shocking destructive and depressive health condition that is maiming so many in our community
  25. Marian Anderson 2 May 2018
    M.E. deserves a break! Not enough research, no treatment or cure. Failed management strategies have been harmful to people with such a serious illness such as CBT and GET).
    Please make serious funding a priority
    - research, compassion, treatment urgently needed for a late group of patients who have been ignored for too long.
  26. Nicky Delacey 2 May 2018
    Please let us have recognition, support and an effective treatment nationwide for people with cfs me
  27. Julia Reid 2 May 2018
    Justice for people with ME means a fair allocation of funding commensurate with the burden of disease in research, medical and disability support services, advocacy, and actual effective treatment!
  28. Sharon goodwin 2 May 2018
    This suffering as gone on too long . We need help .
  29. Lyn Bowman 2 May 2018
    Congrations on this initiative.
  30. Laura Steckler 2 May 2018
    desperately needed!
  31. Edwin Thwaites 2 May 2018
    Scotland has an opportunity to be the world leader in ME research and care. Take it
  32. Sam Pearce 2 May 2018
    I was born in UK but moved to South Africa when I fell ill with ME 25 years ago as I could not access benefits and was crippled by the cold climate
  33. Susan Grundy 2 May 2018
    A member of my family lives with this debilitating condition which is still very much misunderstood. More research into the causes of a condition that affects so many young people destroying their lives. Support and therapies that help them to tolerate the condition will alter the quality of their lives a thousand fold.Please support this petition.
  34. Christine Knott 2 May 2018
    American researchers have found something in the plasma are shutting energy cells down. The UK are way behind in their approach to this debilitating illness. Please sign the petition.
  35. Keith Bradbury 2 May 2018
    I am a sufferer of 33 years
  36. Jonathan Myall 2 May 2018
    Would be so good for Scotland to take a lead but would be good for the UK as a whole too
  37. Brendan W Robinson 2 May 2018
    Why has this vile disease been left for only the patients and their families to deal with? Where's government help in medical research and care giving? There should be an inquiry into why.
    I suspect those accountable are the psychiatric community for hijacking the illness as in their realm, knowing full well it was all along a physical disease. And also the health insurance industry who were too, bank rolling the top psychiatric researchers to fudge results in order not to pay out millions in patient claims. They blamed it on the patients minds so they didn't have to pay out. I'm sure thats what happened.
    But for years there has been proof this is a biological disease that has destroyed peoples lives, while all the much needed funding went to those criminals
  38. Fred Vintner 2 May 2018
    30+ years of my life with this condition and healthy politicians have little interest or curiosity about how one in a hundred and fifty of us are missing from their constituency or the wider world. Because we are invisible
    - the condition is invisible.
  39. Penelope Evans 2 May 2018
    M.E. is a very debilitating illness affecting thousands of people.Funding for medical research must be allocated to try and find a cure. The current recommended medical advice for ME sufferers of graded exercise ais positively harmful for patients, and CBT denies that the disease is neurological as accepted by the World Health Organisation. Treating the illness as being psychological merely compounds the diffiulties faced by those suffering this terrible illness.
  40. Ruth Wiegratz 2 May 2018
    I've suffered long enough.
  41. Michael Field 2 May 2018
    A member of my family has been diagnosed with a MILD degree of ME.. When I see how even this level of the disease has so badly affected her life, my heart goes out to all sufferers of this most debilitating condition.
  42. Roseann Airens 2 May 2018
    I have had M.E. for almost 20 years. We need more research into this misunderstood illness and support to help us adjust to the limitation we now have to live with. With more research we could hopefully get some treatment and eventually find the cause or even a cure. Without this funding we are left to struggle with no adequate care or support. Please sign this petition to help many others like me. Thanks
  43. Betty 2 May 2018
    Get rid of the harmful GET and CBT program. Many people are permanently disabled because they did this program! Fund ME its a debilitating illness. More needs to be done to ensure people are not forgotten and left languishing in their beds.
  44. Deborah Causer 2 May 2018
    People with ME want justice and ethical science.
  45. Terri Ana Scott 2 May 2018
    I am a ME & Fibromyalgia patient and more of these ccentres are very much needed.
  46. Alyse Lopez-Salm 2 May 2018
    Every disease that debilitates like this one does deserves ample research!
  47. Donna smith 2 May 2018
    I v had ME for 13 years .
  48. Amy House 2 May 2018
    A member of my family has been living with ME for 10 years. Support and treatment of this condition is needed.
  49. Marilyn Wallman 2 May 2018
    I have had ME or CFS for 20 years without any helpful advice or treatment from the NHS. I survived with the help of proficient complementary therapists but I had to give up a well paid job to get well. Scotland is missing out on utilising the brain power of very knowledgeable, qualified and bright people.
  50. Cecile MacLeod 2 May 2018
    I was diagnosed with ME away back in 2003 by Monklands Hospital and then again in 2004 by Glasgow Royal Infirmary. But like most people I believe I was suffering from ME for many years before that. I had to give up work and try and concentrate on 'getting better'. Unfortunately after trying all manor of things, I am still the same. In the twenty years or so of having ME there has not been the same awareness with the public and medical profession as other 'silent' diseases. Not only do we need funding but we need awareness. We are more understanding of depression and how thank can't be seen. Why are we alone with this. We matter too! Not only do we live with this day in and day out we have to grieve for a life we may never have back again. We also have to deal with the non believers. We don't get accepted for benefit payments. We have to work out who is trying to con us out of money with promises of a cure. People with ME don't want to have ME!! We are the forgotten people. Enough is enough. Sadly we are too ill to fight for our rights. We need help to get help. How sad is that. Let Scotland lead the way. Do us proud Scotland. We are your people too.