Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01663 · Session 5

Driven grouse shooting study

Closed Submitted 3 May 2017 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
1,258 online signatures with a country
Comments
99
Considered
2 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to sponsor a comprehensive and independent study into the full economic impacts of driven grouse shooting.

What the petitioner did first

I have contacted my local MSP, Angus MacDonald.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 21 Sep 2017
    1 mention
  2. 22 Mar 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,258 online signatures
  1. Scotland461 36.6%
  2. England368 29.3%
  3. United Kingdom361 28.7%
  4. Wales22 1.7%
  5. United States15 1.2%
  6. Germany3 0.2%
  7. Ireland3 0.2%
  8. France3 0.2%
  9. Australia3 0.2%
  10. Italy3 0.2%
  11. 11 other countries16 1.3%

Comments

99 comments, oldest first
99 comments · showing 51–99
  1. Paul Lewis 21 Jun 2017
    There is a long overdue need to get some objective facts about the real value of this activity. And compare this against the value of other activities, such as income associated with wildlife tourism.
  2. Keith Ballard 21 Jun 2017
    Need consider carefully the economic losses from having moorland depleted of wildlife as a result of the land and wildlife management practices carried out (some illegal) in order to sustain the breeding of high populations of grouse for shooting.
  3. Joe Winstanley 21 Jun 2017
    A review into the economic impacts of grouse shooting is long overdue
    - any responsible Govt is surely obliged to accurately inform itself, and the public, as to the externalised costs of any major land use.
  4. David Parkin 21 Jun 2017
    I have long been alarmed at the damage being done to Scotland's uplands by the Ill-founded management practised by some of its owners. This study must address the perceived wisdom of rotational muir-burn and intensification of grouse management on the status of alternative wildlife such as eagles, falcons, harriers and Mountain Hares.
  5. Eileen Frost 21 Jun 2017
    It is hard to justify this so called sport, as it is for the priviliged who unfortunately have little interest in the environment. They just enjoy killing.
  6. Dennis Patton 21 Jun 2017
    Killing for sport is primitive. Stop the slaughter. Stop the barbarians.
  7. karl freeman 21 Jun 2017
    the news about this problem is very well known.there is no shying away from it.it is a disgrace that it still continues in this modern world.even the americans think it's stupid.it need to stop completely for the sake of the world.
  8. Jim Hall 21 Jun 2017
    At a time when we should be more conscious of our carbon dioxide emissions (eg turn gadgets off standby, etc), why must we witness the hills go up in flame every spring when a heather moorland and peat bog can trap more CO2 than a tropical rain forest?
  9. Paul Fisher 21 Jun 2017
    This is 2017. Blood sports are not a tradition, they are a relic.
  10. Stephen Charles Webster 22 Jun 2017
    One of the benefits of driven grouse shooting, we are often told, is the promotion of healthy populations of birds like curlew, lapwing and golden plover. Here in the outer Hebrides we have thriving populations of all these birds and many others alongside thriving populations of raptors including hen harriers, and no driven grouse shooting.
  11. Nonie Horsman 22 Jun 2017
    Proper independent research and open debate
    - we all need healthy moorlands for recreation, ecosystem services like clean water and flood reduction, nature and wildlife
    - benefits to all
  12. Nell Novak 22 Jun 2017
    What should have been a lovely hill walk last week was ruined for me by having to pass dozens of shooting butts. The thrill of seeing a family of baby grouse, and the distraction display of the mother was more than tinged with sadness and despair at the thought of what awaits that family in a few months time. Tourists must surely come away with the same impression. Such barbarity for the privileged few is a blight on our beautiful country, which is worth so much more than that.
  13. Debra Torrance 24 Jun 2017
    A modern, future thinking Scotland shouldn't be a haven for canned hunt enthusiasts. We must thoroughly investigate the real benefits to the environment and wildlife of traditional hunts and shoots in Scotland. Incorporated into the investigation should be the overall welfare of domestic and wild animals as well as the impact on our landscapes.
  14. Darren 24 Jun 2017
    Time to halt this outdated intensification and control of our uplands. Stop killing native wildlife to kill game.
  15. Julie Stebbings 24 Jun 2017
    Driven grouse shooting is hugely damaging to indigenous wildlife and the environment. These factors must be taken into account as they have knock-on economic effects. Also, I believe many driven grouse shoots are owned by people who do not pay tax in this country
    - this has to stop!
  16. AI 24 Jun 2017
    Driven grouse shooting is an utterly unnecessary.
  17. Lyndsey Emmett-Liddle 28 Jun 2017
    The natural habitat and behaviours are not being respected by this unnecessary cruel practice
  18. Gill Mitchell 28 Jun 2017
    I'm signing this petition for the four breeding pairs of hen harriers. We must do something before these beautiful birds are killed.
  19. Chris Corrigan 28 Jun 2017
    It is really important to base decisions on real evidence which a study of this kind would provide
  20. Alistair McGowan 28 Jun 2017
    If such a project were to be funded, I think it is imperative that scientists and land-managers from other countries with similar upland areas are involved as observers and to bring examples of how things are done elsewhere.

    As a part-time outdoor leader, I would like to see far more attention paid to the outdoor industry in Scotland. Such roles can be combined with others in the rural economy of Scotland and would offer potential alternative employment to gamekeepers.
  21. Tom Fitton 28 Jun 2017
    I am signing this because driven grouse shooting is destroying native wildlife. The hen harrier is almost extinct across the UK because of this practice.
  22. Andy Oliver 28 Jun 2017
    Long overdue. We need to find out the facts about the impact of this highly specialised and exclusive form of land management thatactively prevents natural regeneration and persecutes protected species of raptors and other birds, and mammals.
  23. Sally Westwood 28 Jun 2017
    Hen harriers need our help. They have no voice.
  24. Janine Hulley 28 Jun 2017
    I am signing this petition as i believe that the negative impact of DGS on wildlife and the environment far outweigh the economic benefits. The destruction of vitally important habitat and the ongoing persecution of protected BOP on grouse moors, are clear indication that conservation and protection are failing.
  25. Mark Hill 29 Jun 2017
    We need to do something now before it's too late!
  26. Gena Blaxter 29 Jun 2017
    Driven grouse shooting has nothing to do with'conservation', it is simply exploitation at the expense of our many other natural assets. It should be banned.
  27. C. Wilson-Green 29 Jun 2017
    This has to be done before it is too late
  28. Eilidh McNab 30 Jun 2017
    Some very pressing questions desperately need answered regarding the economics of grouse shooting. It is definitely time for this study.
  29. Jackie Gray 30 Jun 2017
    I believe a fair study is needed to justify the loss of other wildlife.
  30. J Preston 1 Jul 2017
    Some very important questions on tourism and flooding prevention downstream.
  31. P J 2 Jul 2017
    In Pennines we have suffered floods and loss of wildlife, particularly Birds of Prey, in huge part, due to the way land and wildlife is managed (or mismanaged) for Driven Grouse Shoots. I love Scotland and particularly visit to see wildlife such as birds of prey in the wild. It's just wrong to allow this destruction of Scotland's fragile ego-system and beautiful wildlife like the mountain hare.
  32. Juli Harris 6 Jul 2017
    Huge swathes of land set aside for this Victorian pastime of the wealthy and connected. Surely there are better ways to protect land our animals and environment?
  33. Jane Kidd 6 Jul 2017
    Let's re-green the Highlands
  34. Margaret K 7 Jul 2017
    Justification for loss of natural habitat and other wildlife
  35. margaret walker 7 Jul 2017
    Goshawk viewing platforms could add, to the list of birds of prey.
  36. Linda Moore 7 Jul 2017
    It's time that the many who love the countryside are listened to above the few who want to destroy it.
  37. Sarah Bradford 8 Jul 2017
    67% of wildlife on Earth has disappeared since the 1970's
    - a study into this unnecessary activity is more than essential.
  38. Iain Buik 8 Jul 2017
    Too many Government subsidies are being leeched out to these minority buisnesses, who have their own means of financing, greater scrutiny of public money must be done so that a better way of funding agricultural interests and for the benefit of wildlife and protection of habitats from destruction, or for "sporting" reasons.
    The driven grouse moor owners have shown themselves as barbaric, and unwilling to admit their shortcomings, Persecution of Raptor Species is no longer tolerable, the outdated methods have been exposed as a sham and no justification for it.
    I call for a reveiw and overhaul of this alleged Industry
  39. Louise Raine Hantman 8 Jul 2017
    Please help these endangered birds!
  40. Ann Ellis 9 Jul 2017
    I strongly believe that all wildlife should be allowed to thrive not be killed at the expense of a single pursuit
  41. Simon Neachell 9 Jul 2017
    Let's end this cruel industry and turn the spaces into national parks.
  42. Duncan Young 10 Jul 2017
    Yeah i agree
  43. Tom MacDonald 10 Jul 2017
    Driven grouse shooting is not an economic or cultural asset, but an unhealthy obsession that suppresses our natural heritage, wildlife and also rural economies.
  44. Karen Walker 11 Jul 2017
    I live in a beautiful part of Perthshire and my neighbours are the beautiful grouse that come in to the garden every day. All types of shooting are wrong in every way. This should be stopped immediately. The elite seem to think they have the monopoly within our country and can do what they want. There are always consequences to their actions. These so called traditions should stay in the past as they play no part of a modern society.
  45. Alexandra Campbell 12 Jul 2017
    The value of driven grouse shooting appears to be grossly overstated. No breakdown of the figures has been given, to my knowledge. The number of people directly employed in this sector cannot be significant since it is made up of gamekeepers as permanent full time staff, and then a number of seasonal part-time staff working as beaters.
    The estates might also employ staff as housekeepers, cooks, cleaners etc for any shooters staying on the property in the estate but again this is seasonal work.
    Additional maintenance work on the estate is likely to be contract work.
    It is difficult to see how these relatively small FTE jobs and payment from guests or of shooting rights amounts to the millions of pounds quoted by landowners as income from grouse shooting.
  46. Michael Bible 18 Jul 2017
    Save the raptors, and the grouse.
  47. Paddy Hanrahan 18 Jul 2017
    Once again our wildlife are being exterminated for the money, and that's the Grouse also let's live in the 21st century not the 19th and abolish all these foul evil blood sports
  48. Jonathan Theobald 18 Jul 2017
    My regular visits to the Highlands are made much less enjoyable by the systematic destruction
    - much of it illegal
    - of mountain hares, hen harriers, eagles, and anything else that might threaten the size of a grouse bag.

    I accept that the countryside needs to be economically viable. But with wildlife killed on such a scale, a financial study would help all concerned to understand what is at stake.
  49. Bob Morris 18 Jul 2017
    It is essential that claims made by the grouse shooting industry are fully assessed since claims often appear to be exaggerated with little or no empirical evidence.