Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01655 · Session 5

Scotland's National Scenic Areas

Closed Submitted 26 Apr 2017 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
405 online signatures with a country
Comments
114
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to review the process for designation of National Scenic Areas (NSAs) and consider increasing the number of NSAs in Scotland to protect the natural landscape and support the tourism sector.

What the petitioner did first

I contacted the Scottish Government in December 2016.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 14 Sep 2017
    1 mention
  2. 22 Mar 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    9 mentions
  3. 16 May 2018
    1 mention

Signatures by country

405 online signatures
  1. Scotland176 43.5%
  2. United Kingdom97 24%
  3. England60 14.8%
  4. United States13 3.2%
  5. Ireland11 2.7%
  6. Northern Ireland10 2.5%
  7. Germany8 2%
  8. Canada7 1.7%
  9. Wales6 1.5%
  10. France3 0.7%
  11. 9 other countries14 3.5%

Comments

114 comments, oldest first
114 comments · showing 51–100
  1. JOHN HILL 18 May 2017
    I am very much pro green energy and carbon reduction and genrally am supportive of turbines. However, on this occasion a balance between need and preserving the natural is required. This is an ill conceived location and will spoil an area of natural beauty and importance. There are other options I am sure, has offshore for example been considered ?
  2. Jane Meek 18 May 2017
    So much has already been lost. Please help to save what is left before it is too late.
  3. Carla Stachura 18 May 2017
    I would like to visit a beautiful, quiet, natural place without turbines! They are horrendous and a blight on the countryside!
  4. RICHARD Roach 19 May 2017
    IWT in this area would be terrible
  5. Jutta (Northern Germany) 19 May 2017
    For visitors to the Scottish countryside, with their beauty and silence around Loch Awe and other places, it is terrifying to imagine that this is soon to be a thing of the past. As tourists, we are not looking for ugly, noisy wind turbines that kill Avifauna and make people sick.
    This wind power hell we have everywhere in Germany and we hope that the Scottish fellow citizens and nature will be spared so that we continue to have a place to escape this hell in Germany at least temporarily
  6. Butre Jean Louis 19 May 2017
    and cultural heritage by their harmful effect on landscapes and historic buildings.
    wind farms imperil wildlife and destroy natural habitats which have hitherto escaped the destructive powers of earth-moving equipment, concreting operations and other highly invasive human activities.
  7. Clive Stacey 19 May 2017
    I have been travelling from Southern England to Loch Avich for over 30 years, at least once, sometimes three times a year. It is without out a doubt unique and beautiful even by Scottish standards and needs to be protected urgently.
  8. Marshall Rosenthal 19 May 2017
    "Renewable" energy schemes must never be allowed to blight National Scenic Areas. Wind power is a particularly pernicious form of this and must never be allowed to expand onto NSA's.
  9. Irene 19 May 2017
    Don't be fooled by the Wind Weasels who sell and profit from this intermittent,unreliable, devastatingly-expensive form of energy. Do your homework and learn what a devestation these are to humans, animals, birds and the natural environment. Shame to ruin the beauty of Scotland for the benefit of the few 1% who will benefit and are probably off-shore companies.
  10. Greta Gallandy-Jakobsen 21 May 2017
    Please don't destroy your wonderful country with these useless and dangerous machines. Everybody knows, this technology is a big mistake. It will cost a fortune to remove all the turbines after a rather short time. Think about your great history. 20 og 30 years are nothing compared with that. To plan the country's future must be done in a quite different way. Think of 200 years instead. Who will live in your country and how? And then look back. What have these destructive and dangerous turbines done for the Scottish people? Nothing. It was only a obsessice idea to "save the planet" , but only the investors' and industry's pockets were saved from being empty. Please look at your wonderful old landscapes and see, how they would be spoiled with this industrial rotating structures and how your own rural people are suffering from this.
  11. Jean Bowman 21 May 2017
    We need to keep beautiful areas, just that! We'll get more from tourism, keeping our area beautiful. Industrialising the area will lose us business and very likely cause ill health to residents, a fail fail !
  12. Michael CAIN 21 May 2017
    The land does not require any more structures
  13. Vincent Quint 21 May 2017
    We have been several times in that area. I can't immagine that someboddy thinks about building these windmills. Thats crazy! Don't do it !!!!!
  14. Diane Millar 21 May 2017
    Don't want another eyesore
  15. James M Crook 22 May 2017
    It seems hard to believe that someone would look to ruin the unique landscape of Loch Awe by erecting huge wind turbines. People travel from far and wide to enjoy the Loch and it's amazing views, and the introduction of new wind farms would severely threaten this.
  16. Bert van Rein 22 May 2017
    It is unbelievable that a beautiful and historic nature reserve can be sacrificed to monetary gain. Shameless and disrespectful!
  17. D McInally 22 May 2017
    Beautiful place best left as is please
  18. Mark Duchamp 23 May 2017
    Loch Awe is an unspoiled, beautiful area where golden eagles may be seen flying. It needs protection from unsightlly and bird-killing wind turbines. In California, over 3,000 golden eagles were killed by wind turbines over 25 years.
  19. Cameron Rougvie 23 May 2017
    The preservation of natural areas is both the duty of the common man and the government, Scottish heritage is for everyone, both ourselves and for nature itself.
  20. Eunhi evans 24 May 2017
    We have destroy many places by greed of human activities which should at all cost to prevent and reserve if possible.
  21. Stewart Langlands 25 May 2017
    Many places were considered too remote or difficult to come under pressure from development so did not need protection. This is no longer true and a process of protecting beautiful and scenic areas needs to be updated.
  22. Peter Scott 25 May 2017
    This would be an opportune time to review the effectiveness of protection and management arrangements for NSAs and the areas covered by these.
  23. Rosemary Howe 25 May 2017
    Do not ruin the beautiful countryside for a huge innefficient useless wind factory covering hundreds of acres.
  24. Ross Anderson 25 May 2017
    We not only need more NSAs to protect our landscape we need more National Parks
  25. Trevor Kyffin 25 May 2017
    Loch Awe and its surrounding area is blessed with the kind of natural rugged beauty that is fast disappearing from other regions of the UK. As a frequent visitor to this wonderful, peaceful area of Argyll, I beg the Scottish Parliament to urgently review and update the process for designation of National Scenic Areas, in particular to include Loch Awe.
  26. Charles Paxton 25 May 2017
    All developments within these beautiful areas should be appropriate in terms of scale and outline and should not mar the attractive skyline nor threaten the wildlife and peace of the resident and visiting population. Ideally developments should harmonise with the existing landscape features, natural and cultural, and be in keeping with the traditional land use and useful in terms of job creation.
  27. Pamela Brown 25 May 2017
    It would be a total tragedy to spoil in any way the natural beauty of the countryside around Loch Awe. This whole area needs protection from any further infrastructure projects.
  28. KATHLEEN WEETMAN 25 May 2017
    We are also in danger of our last remaining scenic space in Airdrie, North Lanarks. A developer wants to build all over the last snippet of Greenbelt. NO MORE GREENBELT GRAB .Our government needs to have Land Protection Orders similar to Tree preservation orders and listen to the people, the community councils and save it for the future .
  29. Anne Graf 25 May 2017
    The camchatka test is too long and complicated. I'm 75 years old, and had to try twice to complete it -I almost lost patience and didn't bother completing, though I had wanted to add my name to the petition! Surely you can devise and easier but still foolproof way of seeing if I'm human?
  30. Sandra wolfe 25 May 2017
    I am concerned that the world is choosing to create garbage to litter the landscapes in the form of industrial wind turbines, undermining the health and well-being of the residents (people and ecology). I am concerned about the poison these industrial wind turbines produce that permeates the land and also poisons the social infrastructure. I am concerned that practicality has been abandoned for a frivolity of such a destructive sort as industrial wind turbines.
  31. George Herraghty 25 May 2017
    The Scottish Government have allowed wind industry multinationals to trash the finest landscapes in Western Europe, to the extent that wind farms are now visible from more than 60% of Scotland!!! (Wildland Research Institute Sept 2014)
  32. Mike Sullivan . 26 May 2017
    Tourism needs a Wild Land Areas ,that's why as a family we have Holidayed in Scotland for over 40 years .
  33. A.Wilson 26 May 2017
    The Scenic,and unspoilt areas of scotland should be left untouched for visitors and future generations to enjoy
  34. Will Glenn 26 May 2017
    We need to protect our natural places even more now, what with climate change gaining strength.
  35. Blandine Vue 26 May 2017
    I suffer under windfarm infrasounds, one other and important reason not to build them in you beautifull country, the whole european country sides are getting distroyed!
  36. Sally Patricia Makinson 28 May 2017
    Protecting quiet and beautiful natural areas is essential for mankind's sanity. Most people need somewhere like Loch Awe to recharge their batteries for the hustle and bustle of everyday urban life. Once lost it will never be restored.
  37. archie brock 28 May 2017
    There are areas of Scotland where it is just not appropriate to build large scale renewable projects. There is a danger that we are now in danger of harming the positive image of Scotland as a country of great scenic value and a fantastic natural environment. It is surely time for the Scottish Government to put protective legislation in place.
  38. Scott Gibson 28 May 2017
    Please please please stop giving consents for the development of wind farms in our beautiful highlands and focus attention on other forms of renewable energy sources which do not harm the natural landscape such as hydro and wave power. We are ruining our natural landscape for the living and for those yet to be born.
  39. Susanna wilcox 29 May 2017
    There are fewer and fewer unspoilt areas in the British Isles. Please consider this area as one of them and protect our heritage.
  40. June Raven 29 May 2017
    We have to oppose the aggressive planning this area based mostly on a quest for money by business people who do not live here.
  41. Tess Doig 29 May 2017
    It is too bad that the lowlands of Scotland are being invaded by wind farms, but to keep pursing this one in the most beautiful , unspoilt region is unthinkable.
  42. James William ALSTAIR HILL 29 May 2017
    THE CURRENT PLANS AND INSTALLATIONS OF WINDPARKS WILL LEAD TO A DISASTROUS LOSS OF AREAS OF NATURAL BEAUTY. This will end tourism or at least hit tis industry seriously in the long run. In the mean time many of Scotland's iconic birds will be decimated.
  43. Peter and Pauline Carruthers 29 May 2017
    We were residents in Taynuilt from 1989 to 1999 and then Kilchrenan overlooking Loch Awe and its environs from 1999 to 2007. We consider the outstanding quality of the landscape fully justifies classification as a National Scenic Area.In our opinion it matches the beauty of some of Scotland's existing National Parks.Many people, both locals and visitors, will consider protection for this landscape is long overdue.
  44. DT Wall&Mrs MMWall 29 May 2017
    We have visited this area on a number of occasions for its utterly impressive beauty and wildness. Although the local economy must be sustained we hope that due regard will be given to maintaining this breath-taking environment.
  45. John Anthony Phillips 30 May 2017
    Anything which protects wild, unspoilt landscape from industrial depredation and leaves it to be enjoyed and savoured by residents and visitors must be supported.
  46. Stephanie Findlay 30 May 2017
    Increasing the number of NSA sites should be increased across Scotland. Fundamemtly we still have the power to protect for good our environment of thriving habitats and forrests some of which are considered to be ancient forrests. This means the land has changed very little over time in these areas and there's much knowledge to be gained in respect of that from various aspects of study from medicine to history and all else inbetween. To actually allow for these unspoilt areas to come under threat of destruction would literally be robbing people the knowledge to be gained from these parts and a great loss of natural environment which Scotland is renowend destroy our reputation of our beautifully land untouched by modernisation which people pay a lot of money to see from around the world definetly further destructive acts on the environment will effect our tourism so why do that when lots of money is to be gain for not doing anything to our land just sit back let folk climb the hills and how glens. We should be forefront on environmental movement and considered further protection and better enforcement to those caught doing wrong as well as funding for studying areas of importance and better management of forestry, environmental sites and heritage sites too.
  47. Lan Garrod 31 May 2017
    I regularly visit Scotland to get away to wild places not to see large scale human development blight the landscape. I am not alone in this feeling that Scotland is a special place, please protect as much of its wild space as possible for all of those that love to visit or will visit in the future.
  48. Sam Phillips 31 May 2017
    I visit Scotland several times a year, in particular the west coast which I think is the most beautiful part of the UK. I believe the designation of this part of the country as an NSA would protect the landscape and its value as a tourist destination.
  49. Bev Gray 2 Jun 2017
    I have NOT visited Scotland recently after many years of visiting due to the increasing destruction of the unique views and lonliness of the Highlands with wind turbines. I have just visited Iceland, beautiful....and no turbines in sight. Beautiful
  50. Anon 2 Jun 2017
    Too many places of natural scenic beauty in Scotland are being overrun with wind farms. Increase the number of NSAs to protect these areas from having wind farms constructed to preserve what is left of our beautiful countryside.