Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01516 · Session 4

Referenda for Orkney, Shetland and the Western Isles

Closed Submitted 11 Mar 2014 Parliament & Constitution
Signatures
0
1,177 online signatures with a country
Comments
149
Considered
2 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to hold three separate referenda in Shetland, Orkney, and the Western Isles on Thursday 25 September 2014, one week after the Scottish independence referendum, asking the people of each island group whether they would prefer their island group to:
· to become an independent country, or
· to stay in Scotland
and, in the event of a yes vote in the referendum on Scottish independence, to have the following additional option:
· to leave Scotland and stay in the remainder of the UK

What the petitioner did first

Soundings of the Scottish Government and of the respective local authorities have met with no support, despite there being many people in each of the three island groups who would welcome the chance to take part in such a referendum.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 20 May 2014
    1 mention
  2. 5 Aug 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

1,177 online signatures
  1. Scotland702 59.6%
  2. United Kingdom286 24.3%
  3. England134 11.4%
  4. Wales9 0.8%
  5. Ireland6 0.5%
  6. United States5 0.4%
  7. Germany4 0.3%
  8. Canada4 0.3%
  9. Australia3 0.3%
  10. New Zealand3 0.3%
  11. 16 other countries21 1.8%

Comments

149 comments, oldest first
149 comments · showing 101–149
  1. Catharine Beck 28 Mar 2014
    The islanders have the right to decide the status of the islands. If you agree with that statement, sign this petition. If you don't, don't.

    The Scottish Government will hold these referenda on 25 September 2014 if enough people sign this petition. We expect to be successful.

    The idea that it is pointless to petition the Scottish Parliament because constitutional questions are reserved to the UK Parliament is nonsense. Both Parliaments and both Governments would obviously have to respect the result of these referenda.

    If the UK Parliament tried to stand in the way of the Scottish Government holding these referenda in the first place, that would be appalling and we would expect maximal support from the Scottish Government. The principle here is self-determination. That's the same principle which is behind the Scottish referendum. Let's not pack up and go home because of often facetious arguments. If you want these referenda to be held, sign this petition.

    If enough people sign, the Scottish Parliament will have to support us, and so will the Scottish Government. We will then get the referenda. We have a right to them. We have had enough of representatives or others who tell us we should know our place and that such matters are for our betters. This is democracy in action. We should be proud of ourselves.
  2. David Machon 28 Mar 2014
    I would like to hear the SNP respond to the call for referenda on the islands. Right now! Will they say OK if enough people say they want them? The answer can only be "yes". Let's hear it. Now.
  3. Patricia Knowles 29 Mar 2014
    This petition is well-conceived and will have real force. But after they have signed it, people should write to Alex Salmond and ask him whether he will allow these referenda if enough people sign this petition. Yes or no. Put him on the spot!
  4. Mr harmer 29 Mar 2014
    All who post on here please say where you stay as it is no good people out with the isles trying to put an opinion across, when frankly they have no right too...
  5. margaret mcneil 29 Mar 2014
    Having looked through the list of names and where the people come from I am really surprised that a large majority of the signatories of this petition do not live on Orkney, Shetland or the Western Isles. people from England, Canada, United States etc, they would have no say in any referendum on this matter so why sign the petition?
  6. Joanna Smith 30 Mar 2014
    Let's circulate news about this petition by email as well as by other means. Even joke petitions can get thousands of signatures nowadays, just because they go "viral" by email. The petition for referenda in the islands is serious, worthwhile, and significant. It should get as many signatures as possible. I know a circular email has started. If you receive it, please forward it. Otherwise, please write your own and send them to friends, family members and contacts. And remember to include a link to this site, to make it easy for people! Thanks! Joanna in Stromness
  7. David Smith 30 Mar 2014
    Yes. If you want to help this petition more than just by signing it, please circulate the news by email, telling people what it's about and giving them a link to this site. This includes members of local Better Together groups. Don't be shy!
  8. Bertha Marpey 30 Mar 2014
    67 percent of "Scotland's" oil is Shetland's. If Shetland stays in the UK while Scotland goes independent, all of that oil stays with the UK. If Shetland goes independent on its own, that oil goes with Shetland. 67 percent!! Source: Jonathan Brown's article in the Independent, 26 March.
  9. Dave Ballard 31 Mar 2014
    Why shouldn't the highlands & Islands get their own powers
  10. James Harris 31 Mar 2014
    Everybody has a right to sign this petition who supports the islanders being able to decide the status of their islands. Signatures are very welcome from everyone who supports that aim, regardless of where they live. If an islander does not wish to have a say in the future of their island group, all they have to do is abstain in the island referendum. I live in Shetland and 90% of my friends and neighbours and family have signed this petition.
  11. Sheena Reid 31 Mar 2014
    I feel that the North East of Scotland -Moray, Banff and Aberdeen Shires should also be given the choice to stay in the UK as we have a different culture also Pictish
    - Norse. Some of us do not want to be governed by the Central Belt.
  12. david irvine flett 31 Mar 2014
    Nearly at the 1000 already !
  13. L Weatherley 31 Mar 2014
    Someone with some sense!
  14. David Innes 31 Mar 2014
    Local authorities everywhere need more empowerment. These are the political structures cl i sest to people, many of whom feel that Edinburgh is as remote and out of touch with their locality as London currently is. Freedom for pre-1974 Banffshire.
  15. Ali Inkster 1 Apr 2014
    Those folks complaining about people signing the petition when they don't live in the isles please note many islanders live all over the world forced to by lack of opportunity at home. And many might want to return to independent islands with the opportunity that will bring for them and their families. So why should they be barred from signing the petition.
  16. Andrew Craig-Bennett 1 Apr 2014
    I first heard about repaying the dowry in the bar of the Queens Hotel in September 1977. It struck me as a good idea, then, and I think it's a good idea, now.
  17. James Watt 1 Apr 2014
    My family came from the Western Isles (Harris), but left three generations ago for economic reasons. We have flourished elswhere in the UK and abroad but still retain a close interest in the affairs of the Isles. I do not welcome the 'Balkanisation' of the UK
    - but feel that the Isles deserve better than to be governed by the Lothian belt politocracy.
  18. john c laurenson 3 Apr 2014
    I was born in Shetland, went to school in England, and have worked all over the UK. I consider myself British, and as a Shetlander certainly not Scottish. We have no traditions involving tartan, kilts or tam-o'-shanters, gaelic, or hurling cabers around at the highland games.

    A few years ago, pre-oil, the average scotsman had very little idea where the Shetland islands were.

    And as for Alec Salmond, he seems determined, through systematic centralisation, to take all he can from the islands. Fire service and NHS lately.

    History can tell us what the Scottish lairds and lords did to the islands, and its inhabitants. They were cruel taskmasters. They cant blame the English for that.

    I have no wish to be classified as Scottish.
  19. Alastair Macintyre 3 Apr 2014
    I would encourage Orkney, Shetland and WI to hold a separate referendum and perhaps split away from Scotland if a yes vote happens. Indeed Fife where I stay could become a separate country. We have water to the North, East and South and would only need a land border at the west. We could make our money by charging Edinburgh people extortionate rates to enter the kingdom
  20. Kevin 5 Apr 2014
    Whats next, viliages and towns wanting independence, worst idea ever.
  21. Bill Stones 6 Apr 2014
    If we have to be ruled by someone else, better the enemy you know than the one you don't
  22. James Smith 7 Apr 2014
    It's Shetland's oil
    - and the SNP has got no answers to that, except ones that depend on tricksy wordplay.

    Of course there should be referenda in the islands. If Scotland goes independent, most people I know in Shetland will want to stay in the UK. We should get a chance to choose that option.

    By the way, can I say a big thankyou to people outside the islands who have signed this petition to support our right to decide the status of our islands. Your support is much appreciated. Please keep it coming!

    In response to Bill's comment about better to be ruled by the enemy you know. I'm not sure what you mean, but it's interesting that in Scotland the turnout in UK general elections is significantly higher than the turnout in Scottish general elections.
  23. Hamish 7 Apr 2014
    What complete nonesense. I suggest Scotland calls on Russia to invade our native soils which for a time were invade by external forces.
    Please tell me if the custom posts would be in Wick or Stromness or Aberdeen?
  24. Kevin Tullock 8 Apr 2014
    No way! Scottish Independence or bust, plain and simple!
  25. Ariadne Robinson 8 Apr 2014
    The argument in favour of the referenda is clear: the islanders have a right to decide.

    The argument against? There isn't one. People say things like "get back to Russia" or "why can't villages go independent?", but they aren't arguments
    - sorry.
  26. Frank Jones 8 Apr 2014
    Hamish
    - you don't get it, which is probably why you open by saying "What complete nonesense." Sarcastically saying you want a Russian invasion isn't an argument. As for customs posts? Please read what this petition is for. It isn't for independence. It isn't for a change. It isn't for the status quo. It is for *referenda* so that the islanders can democratically decide which option they prefer. Not sure that you understand about customs post either. Have you travelled between France and Germany recently? Or the Republic of Ireland and the UK?
  27. Dave 8 Apr 2014
    Surely the SNP would support an Isles referendum. Their reason for existing is that they do not believe that smaller, more distant communities should not be ruled by their larger southern neighbour who does not understand their needs. So obviously they would not want Orkney to be ruled by Edinburgh and the central belt.
  28. Another Islander who wishes people would stop using us as propaganda material 8 Apr 2014
    This is not democracy, our Councillors don't know the meaning of the word democracy. They have no mandate from us to be asking for this. We are already getting a vote on UK or Scotland, lets focus on that. Stop playing games with our future.
  29. Hamish 8 Apr 2014
    Frank Jones

    What this is all about is a couple of anti YES campaigners trying to cause some upset. But we have been here before. If islanders from Barra in the West, up the west coast and North to Orkney and Shetland wish to be heard more they will need to vote YES. Then all of the peoples making up this country will be able to be heard and demand local democracy that works. Voting No will mean such concerns are buried for a generation.
  30. John McAndrew 8 Apr 2014
    In response to the comment made at 13.33: of course a referendum is democracy, so long as all serious options are included, which they will be.

    As for a mandate, the whole point of a referendum is to give the politicians a mandate. Let the people decide.

    You tell us to focus only on the Scottish referendum, but why? Did you say that before the Scottish referendum was announced? Personally I want us to stay in Scotland if it stays in the UK and to leave Scotland if it doesn't. Nobody is playing games with anybody's future. Why don't you trust your fellow islanders to make the right decision?
  31. Frank Jones 8 Apr 2014
    Hamish: if you think that whether or not islanders' concerns are addressed depends so starkly on the result on 18 Sep, then you should support the holding of islands referenda on 25 Sep. Why? Because if the islands referenda are held, then our concerns will certainly be addressed. It won't matter what the result was on 18 Sep. We won't be dependent on whether people in Perth or Galashiels vote or against Scottish independence. At the end of the day, it is up to us to make our voices heard, and the best way for that happen is in clear, no-nonsense referenda on the islands. The announcement of the date should be made within a month of when this petition gets lodged, in my opinion. 25 Sep sounds fine to me.
  32. david irvine flett 8 Apr 2014
    A significant number of people in the islands would like the opportunity of such a referendum
    - always have. Not everybody on the islands by any means. The point of the request for signatories to a petition explores that. If the number interested is only two or three then that's that. However the islands historical links with Scandinavia and subsequently the often unusual relationship with Scotland make them somewhat
    Unique. Orkney folk are smart enough not to be hi-jacked by badly motivated folk looking for more personal power in a smaller pool -if that's the case nobody will sign the petition nor vote in a referendum if there is one. We either put in place representatives we trust who we empower to make decisions on our behalf or we have reps who simply refer our views and desires people's reps and then have who shouts loudest democracy. Anyhow we have a vote , if we feel strongly we can stand up and state our party and policy. If this petition and referendum is daft idea or worse stilt a badly motivated coup by ambitious councillors it will be easily seen through and disappear. I don't believe that and do think it is great chance for islanders to really say what they want
    - if islanders don't want to they won't.
  33. john moffat 10 Apr 2014
    Is there really demand for this? By September we will all be done with the referendum
    - and to think we can have another straight after when we'll not have had time to properly digest the results of the first is ridiculous.
  34. Mr C Carus 11 Apr 2014
    I believe in self determination.
  35. Morag Maciver 11 Apr 2014
    The three island groups would have twice as much sea area as Scotland! This will belong to the UK if the islands stay in the UK, and it will belong to the islands themselves if they go independent. Click here for details: i58.tinypic.com(slash)ao7udz.jpg

    Denmark has a 200-mile economic zone around the Faroe Islands. A similar zone (up to the midpoints with other countries where necessary) would exist around the islands.
  36. David Brown 11 Apr 2014
    The islands issue finishes the call for Scottish independence. Only a lunatic would now back Scottish independence. Without the islands, Scotland loses 67% of its oil and 70% of its sea area. The country could go bankrupt within the first week.
  37. Ian Leask 11 Apr 2014
    What really annoyes me is the fact that most people signing this Petition, don't even live on the islands, I live in the shetlands isles, I want Scotland to be independent and the isles to be part of that, and not part of some Westminster agenda, which is what this is, and I will be voting YES SCOTLAND no matter what, yes it is shetlands oil, but we are part of Scotland and not england
  38. Adam 12 Apr 2014
    Good on the islanders for standing up to Mr Salmond. Every drop of revenue from oil will be needed to prevent an ailing Edinburgh from economic collapse and you can be sure that Orkney and Shetland will be left with nothing. If Mr Salmond is so sure about self determination then he should have no problem with this? I truly hope the UK does not rip itself apart, but hopefully this independence debate will bring about a more federal system. This isn't just about Scotland v England
    - Wales and Northern Ireland contribute so much to what makes up this unique union of nations.
  39. Paul Davies 13 Apr 2014
    If Alex Salmond demands self-determination for the Scottish people on the grounds of their unique heritage, then it is only right that he should allow the same for the people of the Isles who also have their own unique hertitage.
  40. cecil robertson 14 Apr 2014
    I now live in Inverness, but was born and brought up in Shetland, and can trace my ancestors who all all lived there, back until the time of the Scottish Bruce and Steward incomers in the 16th century. I should have a vote in any referendum which would determine the status of my homeland Shetland.
  41. Ali Inkster 14 Apr 2014
    Ian Leask, you say most folk signing the petition dont even live in the isles While i would say that most folk either live in the isles or are expat islanders. My proof is in the surnames of those signing where's your proof? Or is your comment just another Scotnat shout it enough and it must be true tagline. As a Shetlander ask yourself this will Edinburgh give us enough of our own income (they like to call it a grant) to maintain our way of life when the oil runs out? And for the answer you just need to see that they are not letting us keep enough of our money just now to maintain our way of life. Our budget is set by Edinburgh not Westminster. Now if you are daft enough to believe the "free beer tomorrow" promises of the Scotnats fair enough but some of us require a little bit of proof when dealing with politicians.
  42. Dennis Alfred Bryant. 17 Apr 2014
    I fully support the petition for independance for Shetland and Orkney
  43. Betty Bryant. 17 Apr 2014
    I would like to see a referendum for independance of Orkney and Shetland.
  44. Steven Jarmson 20 Apr 2014
    Shetland and Orkney shouldn't be lumped in with the Western Isles.
    We're very different in all sorts of ways.
    The Western Isles is truly Scottish whilst Shetland and Orkney are neither Scottish nor Scandanavian but we are also both of those!!
    Orkney and Shetland are run as one area whilst the Western Isles is split among several council areas.
    The western Isles waste millions on promoting its dying language, Shetland and Orkney have never had that language and have no interest in it.
    Far too many things to list, but don't think for one minute that I, a Shetlander, have anything in common with a Western Islander!!!
  45. Ali Inkster 22 Apr 2014
    Yes Steven a lot o whit du says is true, but yuns no reason ta deny da Western Isles da right ta a say in dir ain future.
  46. Mary Robinson 27 Apr 2014
    Steven
    - I don't know why you think Orkney and Shetland are run as one area while the Western Isles are split among several council areas. Exactly the opposite is true. The referenda in the three island groups will be completely independent of each other. Personally I think the islands could work fantastically well if all three island groups became a new country in the form of a union. Its maritime zone alone would be twice as big as an independent Scotland's! (Even Shetland on its own would be the second biggest oil power in the North Sea after Norway.)
  47. robert sandison 27 Apr 2014
    We hold all the aces use them or lose them.
  48. John Coutts 28 Apr 2014
    I currently live in Spain, but spent close to 50 years of my life living in Shetland where I was born and brought up. I can trace one side of my ancestry back to around 1510 in Fetlar, and by inference back another five generations to around 1350, also in Fetlar.

    That surely makes me a Shetlander, and while I don't live there today, I keep a very close eye on what's happening.

    I fully agree that Shetland and the other island groups now have the best opportunity they are ever likely to have to decide a future for themselves and for generations yet to come.

    I truly hope that Shetlanders everywhere, and anyone else who has the islands' interests at heart, signs this petition to give the residents of Shetland, Orkney and the Western Isles the chance to have their say in this very important matter.
  49. john bain 28 Apr 2014
    I heard Gary Robinson say on radio that " It would be greedy of Shetland to claim the oil revenue"
    - well now, who was greedy and self centred when the Tories sacrificed our fishing industry for entry into the "Common Market" The only "Common Market" WE see is Spaniards, Frenchmen and the rest taking OUR fish
    - we don't go South and take there grapes! why should they come north and take our fish !

    Whether or not you agree withStuart Hill's efforts regarding the relationship between Shetland and Scandinavia or not my research clearly shows that indeed Shetland still belongs to Scandinavia, therefor we could, if the will were there, invite Norway to "buy" us back ( they have tried at least 11 times in the past ) and tell the EU and the UK to go their own way, we, and our forebears owe them NOTHING.