Petition · PE01516 · Session 4
Referenda for Orkney, Shetland and the Western Isles
Signatures
0
Comments
149
Considered
2 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to hold three separate referenda in Shetland, Orkney, and the Western Isles on Thursday 25 September 2014, one week after the Scottish independence referendum, asking the people of each island group whether they would prefer their island group to:
· to become an independent country, or
· to stay in Scotland
and, in the event of a yes vote in the referendum on Scottish independence, to have the following additional option:
· to leave Scotland and stay in the remainder of the UK
· to become an independent country, or
· to stay in Scotland
and, in the event of a yes vote in the referendum on Scottish independence, to have the following additional option:
· to leave Scotland and stay in the remainder of the UK
What the petitioner did first
Soundings of the Scottish Government and of the respective local authorities have met with no support, despite there being many people in each of the three island groups who would welcome the chance to take part in such a referendum.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
20 May 20141 mention
-
5 Aug 20141 mention
Signatures by country
1,177 online signaturesComments
149 comments, oldest first149 comments · showing 51–100
-
Keith Waugh 21 Mar 2014I very much agree that the island communities should be permitted to decide their destiny. However, I would ask if the Norwegian government has been approached regarding the possible annexing of the northern and western isles?
-
John 21 Mar 2014Independent Scotland yes.
Orkney independence is just a cynical egotistical power grab by the cabal of bovine brained parasites with a long history of incompetence in school place......the question is where is the money coming from.......YOU ......NO GOVERNMENT HANDOUTS .forget about this totally impractitcal nonsense and the idiot promoters.
Forget about the other bunch of parasites in londonshire.
Independent Scotland you know it makes sense. -
Jim Fraser 21 Mar 2014I was unaware of the Western Isles was part of Norway.
-
Island man 22 Mar 2014This petition will never be taken seriously until an official one is done BY ISLANDERS. It's okay for joe blogs from Kilmarnock to say the islander should get a say but he is no islander so what right has he to even have a say he understands nothing of the history and culture of the isles.people say 30% of the oil is in Shetland water? I think you will find it will be a lot less than that as they made the boundaries with the amount of coastline each country had on the north sea.what about fishing? I am sure the pelagic men will get there quota slashes by more than three quarters ,what about the whisky distils on Orkney and the western isles do they no longer become scotch? If there are any islanders on here? You need to see through this nonsense I believe we should get greater devolved powers but this talk of independence is really getting my back up especially when it is not islanders or people who have thought so little of their"home" to stay in other parts of the country
-
James Magnus eunson 22 Mar 2014Has the snp not been bleeating on about the English opreshon against scots now they are going to do the same to the outer Islands. If that's there attitude we would be beter staying with the rest of the uk
-
AGW 22 Mar 2014The Orkneys, the Shetlands and the Western Isles all have a unique identity, each of which is distinct from the rest of Scotland. Given the legal positions as to the Orkneys and Shetlands, certainly, there is a genuine case for a referendum. More democracy is a good thing, I say.
-
J. Irvine 22 Mar 2014Better together.
-
Russell Hogben 23 Mar 2014I think the islands have to right to self determination. Scotland says it owns the oil in the North Sea but actually a great deal of it belongs to Shetland.
-
Magnus Gear 23 Mar 2014Take the island groups away from the corrupt leadership of England and Scotland. Let the island groups be an example to the world with a fair and just system of rule for the common good, not plutocratic gain.
-
Ali Inkster 23 Mar 2014Folk have been signing the petition but their names are not listed. why is this? Also the captcha has become near impossible to decipher
-
Ian Leask 24 Mar 2014I Live in the Shetland Isles, this Petition should be stopped at once, this is just an attempt by unionist to cause trouble, this person Malcolm Lamont probably does not even live in any of the Island groups so has no say, and the fact that any one from any where in the uk can sign this Petition makes in invalid, not that many people would want to stay with the rest of the uk after independence anyway
-
Island man 24 Mar 2014And BTW shetland was under the Danish crown when it was pawned off back to scotland. It was part of the Pictish Kingdom as were the western isles and Orkney before they were taken by the Norse men.
-
William Pirie 24 Mar 2014I want to remain in the UK
-
Bruce Johnston 24 Mar 2014I think we should stay in the UK the SNP need their heads looked at.
-
Victor Muir 24 Mar 2014If Scotland were to say 'Yes' , I would very much welcome for us in Orkney and Shetland a vote to see if the majority wish to stay in the UK and continue to be governed from Westminster .
-
DBR 24 Mar 2014If it is the settled will of the islanders to remain with the UK then so be it. Who are we (mainlanders) to deny you this vote
- don't let Holyrood bully you out of your democratic right. -
Allan J Campbell 24 Mar 2014I have to go back at least three generations to find a connection to any of the islands to which this applies
- maybe that means I haven't got the necessary background information to make an informed decision here, but I prefer to think I'm looking at it with my head instead of my heart. I signed the petition because I believe that if there is sufficient desire that any people should be allowed to determine their own future. For what it's worth I think the best deal for the islands would be increased autonomy within a Scotland independent from the UK, something akin to the Aland Islands relationship with Finland, and if they wanted it would give the islands the opportunity to form closer ties to Scandinavian governments (as many commentators here seem to desire) as the Aland islands have (they hold their own seat on the Nordic Council). -
Ewan Magnus 25 Mar 2014Whilst I agree with the idea
- I do think a referendum should be for islanders only. Better together I say. -
Richard Rendall 25 Mar 2014I will never in my lifetime get another chance to see an independent Scotland, so it's now or never. So vote yes and make an old man very very happy!
-
Geoffrey Rayner 25 Mar 2014The people of the islands should have the same right to self determination as any other cultural or geographical grouping in the UK, or indeed anywhere. Other parts of Scotland should have the right to break off from the hegemony of the southern (ie Edinburgh)elite.
-
Neill Hall 25 Mar 2014Become an independent country? After the shambolic administration over recent years by Shetland Islands Council do you really want to give these people more powers? Let's stay as part of Scotland and build a small successfull nation like Norway
-
Colin Houston 25 Mar 2014It os only fair that the Islands get there say too. It is not just for Salmond and the SNP to push for in dependence and then deny others the chance to determine their own destiny.....FREEDOM!
-
Jane Fitzroy Smith 25 Mar 2014The Channel Isles and Isle of Man are already in this situation and do very well so there is no reason why this cannot be successful. If they wish to be independent of Holyrood I wish them every success.
-
David Burgess 25 Mar 2014It's the Northern Isles' Oil. Not Holyrood's!
-
Graham Leiper 25 Mar 2014Don't know how real this petition is, or if it's obfuscation by bettertogether. Re staying in UK, Isle of Man gets a 12 mile zone, not median line. Would ask somebody from there what they think of Westminster. Independence would give Shetland a lot of oil, staying in UK if Scotland became independent wouldn't. Different rules apply regards Islands in another countries waters. Have lived in Lerwick as a child, great place, but as a Soothmoother, am wondering who (and why) is behind this petition.
-
Irene Hart 25 Mar 2014Do one for the Highlands as well as
-
Nick beal 25 Mar 2014The northern isles, in my case Orkney, are largely ignored by the Scottish government. If you don't live in the central belt they really couldn't give a fig about you. We would be better of staying with RUK if Scotland gets independence. We were given away as a wedding present by the king of Norway so it would be nice if Scotland gave us back!
-
Tom 25 Mar 2014Living between Inishowen and Northern Ireland we can see the beautiful Outer Hebrides. These island are quite disconnected from Scotland and if they had more autonomy they could do greater things. I think they need some kind of economic investment to sustain themselves as an independent nation. Hopefully tourism, agriculture, fishing and maybe even oil will sustain them. It is understandable that they feel they are overlooked by the scottish parliament, the rural and even wild nature of these parts are badly connected to the mainland and maybe simply signing this petition will demonstrate that these islands need more attention, or more devolvement or even independence. Open the doors to discussion and investigate what the options are.
-
Jackie Irvine 25 Mar 2014We'll it is it's own island
-
Aaron McDaid 25 Mar 2014I agree that there should be a discussion on this topic but i dont think they should go ahead with the independence votes for the islands, even to stay within the UK. Those island were part of Scotland under the UK, and should follow scotland should it vote for indepenedence, you cant pick and choose specific parts of a country because they may have some people wishing to stay within the UK. Its like Scotland voting for independence and Liverpool or Manchester calling for a vote to stay aligned with Scotland. The islands should put their fate in the hands of the referendum.
On another note, should this go ahead and the islands vote in favour to stay within the UK, doesnt that look remarkably like what happnened in Crimea? Except without the military involvement of course. Annexing scottish territory which also just so happens to hold rights to oil reserves. Some seriously dirty tricks being played here. I expect no less from the British empire. -
William Tulloch 25 Mar 2014The Islands deserve to choose their own future the same as the SNP has forced on the public of Scotland
-
david irvine flett 25 Mar 2014Am I correct Angus McNeil thinks it is a fair idea ? please correct if I got that wrong
-
john chisholm 26 Mar 2014Every voice should be heard, fair deal all round. Go for it.
-
Paul Bright 26 Mar 2014If Scotland feels it should be independent of Westminster because they don't want to be ruled by a distant voice then it makes sense for the Islands (and even the Highlands) to become Independent of The Edinburgh Government for the same reasons. If Ministers in London are out of touch with their fellow cities of Edinburgh and Glasgow then Holyrood certainly does not understand the needs and Culture of the rural communities to the North.
-
Rachel Thornley 26 Mar 2014So far, the SNP in power has made it clear that they have little or no interest in Orkney and what happens here. The latest example is their review of the impact on the Isles when the lifeline ferry service was disrupted last year. If the 'Yes' vote wins, we will be completely forgotten about.
-
G M Grant 26 Mar 2014Let your views be known!
-
Andrew Pearson 26 Mar 2014What next
- independence for Mull or Arran?
What about Iona, Islay or some of the other 700 plus? -
Donald Mackenzie 26 Mar 2014Monaco manages it. So do San Marino and Liechtenstein. Personally I prefer the status quo, but I think islanders should be able to decide in a referendum. Lets actually do democract rather than talk about it. Let's go for it. Spread the word about this petition, because if enough of us sign it the Scottish Government will HAVE to call these referenda.
-
Kirsty Peterson 26 Mar 2014The Scottish Government should maybe wait until the petition is lodged before they respond, but the SNP should respond to it, publicly, right now. They're not the government. They're a political party. Come on! Show some leadership! What does the SNP think of this? Or do they only think that if they ignore the islanders we won't have any influence except what the Edinburgh govt allows us to have? Come on, SNP, what do you think of the idea to hold referenda in the islands on 25 Sep? For or against, and why?
-
wee w 26 Mar 2014The secretary of this group says,
We have no official contacts, but several of our members are either councillors or married to councillors.
We also have contacts on a completely unofficial individual level with executives and with other councillors in all three island groups.
Nuff said. Inspired by Bernard Ingham, who said he invented this meme to "muddy the waters of independence". -
Barry Clark 27 Mar 2014If we vote in Scotland to leave the UK
- The Northern Islands MUST be given the vote to leave Scotland and stay in the UK. -
Carol Clark 27 Mar 2014Yes lets leave Scotland the SNP have no interest in Orkney, remember last year with the lifeline ferry
- and giving the ferry contract to SERCO who normally run
- but badly prisons, what was wrong with Northlink,
- nothing, Serco have put up all the prices on the Ferry and are actively reducing staff and the safety of Passengers. -
William Hunter 27 Mar 2014Shetlanders should be able to chose, to stay part of the UK, rather than be forced to leave.
-
David Broom 27 Mar 2014I agree with other commenters: islanders must get the right to stay in the UK if Scotland goes independent. Anybody who agrees, please help publicise this petition, because if it gets enough signatures, the Scottish Government will have no option but to allow us that right, and we can then actually exercise it
- in September, with no nonsense. 800 signatures sounds like a lot but it isn't that many. Please can someone set up a Facebook group and publicise it. I've met one of the organisers of this petition, who is in his 60s and does not use Facebook. Young people, please help! Creat some Facebook groups and help islanders get what we want! -
Barry Porteus 27 Mar 2014We want to remain British
- its that simple. Our history is not that of the SNP fuelled hatred of anything south of Berwick, so let us have our own say. -
richard 27 Mar 2014As a Shetlander I can't imagine how disappointed I would be if we voted Scotland independent then Shetland voted to remain in the UK. A chance for change instead of the guaranteed austerity, narrow mindedness and [theft] of our countries wealth.
The chance to be the 14th richest oil producing nation as opposed to 28th as part of the UK. Don't buy into the fear of change. If we don't get out now, we condone the disgusting behaviour of westminister. Illegal wars, corruption, fraud, billions [wasted], funneled into friends businesses.
Please do some research into the viability of an independent Scotland. -
jean 27 Mar 2014I want to remain British and part of Britain
- and I don't want to see any break away parts. -
Pete 27 Mar 2014We should stay part of Britain it has served us well so far
-
Geoff McLeish 27 Mar 2014How can the SNP goose deny equivalent choice to these three Nordic ganders? Fair's fair, surely.
-
Craig Murdoch 27 Mar 2014Constitutional matters are reserved to Westminster, there is little point in petitioning the Scottish Parliament for something which is entirely out with their control.