Petition · PE01451 · Session 4
Review of smoking ban
Signatures
0
Comments
137
Considered
2 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to review the smoking prohibition and control provisions of the Smoking, Health and Social Care (Scotland) Act 2005 in the light of new developments in clean air technology and the European indoor air quality standard Ventilation for non-residential buildings, EN 13779.
What the petitioner did first
Previous petition PE1042 in 2007 called for the establishment of an air quality standard. The committee deferred consideration of this petition until the smoking ban came up for review, but it was not known in 2007 when post-legislative scrutiny would take place. It is mentioned in the Legacy Report for the Health and Sport Committee, published at the end of the last session.
We wish to update our position in light of the time elapsed, and further developments since PE1042.
Two of our members have recently presented relevant evidence in a meeting with the Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy, Jackie Baillie MSP. Ms Baillie has been fully briefed but no subsequent meeting has been arranged.
Our campaign to date has included the following activities:
• Demonstrations, including one at the conference announcing the results of Pell’s study (‘junk science stat of the year’), entitled ‘Towards a smoke-free Scotland’; and outside the venue of the UKNSCC (smoking cessation conference) in Glasgow, 2010. http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa0706740
• Signing the Aldebaran Treaty in 2008 to launch The International Coalition Against Prohibition, recognising that the smoking ban has been replicated in other countries all over the world
• Campaigning vigorously against further extensions of the smoking ban– including the move in 2009 to abolish the exemption that existed in respect of mental health facilities, including a call to withdraw the 2009 mental health consultation on the smoking ban, which made specific claims about the health effects of secondary smoke, cited no references, and was manifestly biased in favour of a change in legislation. We also presented a petition PE1246 to the Parliament on this in 2009
• Campaigning against the plan by NHS Grampian to ban smoking on its premises and to ban staff from carrying tobacco while on duty (this involved letters, a press release and several media appearances)
• Complaint to Press Complaints Commission about press report claiming that flouting the smoking policy of NHS Borders (regarding smoking outdoors on NHS premises) was a breach of the law. The editor accepted the complaint and has issued a correction
• Blogging and supporting other blogs to educate the public about our views.
We wish to update our position in light of the time elapsed, and further developments since PE1042.
Two of our members have recently presented relevant evidence in a meeting with the Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy, Jackie Baillie MSP. Ms Baillie has been fully briefed but no subsequent meeting has been arranged.
Our campaign to date has included the following activities:
• Demonstrations, including one at the conference announcing the results of Pell’s study (‘junk science stat of the year’), entitled ‘Towards a smoke-free Scotland’; and outside the venue of the UKNSCC (smoking cessation conference) in Glasgow, 2010. http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa0706740
• Signing the Aldebaran Treaty in 2008 to launch The International Coalition Against Prohibition, recognising that the smoking ban has been replicated in other countries all over the world
• Campaigning vigorously against further extensions of the smoking ban– including the move in 2009 to abolish the exemption that existed in respect of mental health facilities, including a call to withdraw the 2009 mental health consultation on the smoking ban, which made specific claims about the health effects of secondary smoke, cited no references, and was manifestly biased in favour of a change in legislation. We also presented a petition PE1246 to the Parliament on this in 2009
• Campaigning against the plan by NHS Grampian to ban smoking on its premises and to ban staff from carrying tobacco while on duty (this involved letters, a press release and several media appearances)
• Complaint to Press Complaints Commission about press report claiming that flouting the smoking policy of NHS Borders (regarding smoking outdoors on NHS premises) was a breach of the law. The editor accepted the complaint and has issued a correction
• Blogging and supporting other blogs to educate the public about our views.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
27 Nov 20121 mention
-
22 Jan 20132 mentions
Signatures by country
373 online signaturesComments
137 comments, oldest first137 comments · showing 101–137
-
Alec Johnston 11 Oct 2012Eddie "The number of signatories to a petition is irrelevant" Surely it is highly relevant how many people from Scotland (merely 51 after a month) want something to happen, how many don't want to sign (over 5 million), and how many activists from lobby groups around the world want our parliament to change things to suit their agendas.
I think the lack of support, coupled with the misleading wording of the petition, and the inability of those behind the petition to show how their proposed ventilation systems will comply with EH40 (which they can't because they won't) should consign this petition very effectively to the waste bin. -
Eddie Douthwaite 11 Oct 2012Alec the Anonymous: Talking of "lobby groups" the Scottish Government funds ASH Scotland to the extent of nearly £1 MILLION a year. Until you have the courtesy to reveal your true name then I will treat your comments as I would an anonymous signature to a petition.
-
Alec Johnston 11 Oct 2012Eddie, so you are resigned to getting a paltry 51 Scottish supporters in a month, being unable to show that your ventilation systems can comply with EH40 (they can't, smart move!), don't want to address the fact that over 5 million Scots have chosen not to sign, and don't wish to tackle my suggestion that the petition is misleading. Instead, you try to derail the discussion with a ASH Scotland's funding. I for one am not put off by your attempt at a smokescreen.
-
Eddie Douthwaite 11 Oct 2012Alec the Anonymous: If the Petitioner had a fraction of the £49.2MILLION that the Scottish Government has planned to spend on Tobacco Control between 2011 and 2015 it could be given greater publicity. I think I have hit a nerve mentioning ASH Scotland, you might wish to Google "Government lobbying Government" to find out how "Smokefree" was exposed in England.
-
german1964 12 Oct 2012Hello.
In Germany, no traces of elevated lung cancer or COPD risk for waiters and waitresses in restaurants and bars where people used to smoke have been found (look at www.grieshabers-passivrauchen.de ). On the contrary: waiters and waitresses in such restaurants have been associated with LOWER risks of the kind mentioned, compared to the average working cohort and to the average local population. Consequently, either there cannot be an elevated risk for smoke-related deseases or waiters and waitresses have another (maybe hidden) preventing factor (such as: they move a lot during working hours
- or the like)
Thus, making restaurants and bars smoke-free is fighting a non-effect, whilst smoke- free bars are prone to premature closure, as statistics on gastronomy show, especially in Britain.
Re-evalution of legislation is thus overdue! -
Alec Johnston 12 Oct 201251 Scots have signed, and so have 270 people from other parts of the world. Over 5 million Scots haven't signed. Let's hope democracy prevails over organised lobbying by international networks of pro-smoking groups.
-
Margot Stoeger 13 Oct 2012Secondary smoke is a big hoax to control the people. More restrictions will follow
-
Belinda Cunnison 14 Oct 2012This is the petition against allowing smoking on film sets in Wales, Alec. The full list isn't visible but there is still quite a lot of interest from outside Wales on the front page, I think you will agree? Search The Welsh Government: keep smoking ban strong in Wales
-
Alec Johnston 15 Oct 2012"Secondary smoke is a big hoax to control the people. More restrictions will follow
Margot Stoeger"
- of Austria? And Belinda (the petitioner) is encouraging people via this Scottish parlaiment site to interfere in parliamentary matters in Wales. This is just a shameless example of how the international pro-smoking lobby works to create the impression of large scale support by the mobilisation of a few individuals across the world. -
Alec Johnston 15 Oct 2012Meanwhile, with 7 days to go, this petition has drawn 53 people from Scotland to sign it, plus 278 from other parts of the world. Still over 5 million Scots haven't signed, and the shameless international lobbying continues. It's noticeable that the pro-smoking lobbyists have given up trying to claim that the ventilation solution will comply with EH40. I'm glad to have helped them realise that it won't. I presume from Belinda's shift to lobbying the Welsh Assembly here that her organisation have given up this particular petition as dead in the water.
-
Belinda Cunnison 15 Oct 2012Alec, you haven't even read what I wrote, far less understood it. There is no facility for people who oppose the aims of the Welsh petition to comment. I pointed out simply that all petitions on either side of the smoking debate attract attention and support from outside their locality. The latest three signatures on the Welsh petition are in Scotland.
They also seem to think 500 signatures are enough! -
Eddie Douthwaite 15 Oct 2012This petition will be a very difficult one for MSPs to handle. If they allow the petitioners the opportunity to present the full evidence held they could be in the position of having to admit they were wrong in supporting the introduction of the smoking ban as it currently exists. The integrity of the Scottish Parliament and it's members is at stake and justice must be seen to be done in the handling of the petition. The so called "experts" in Tobacco Control, their supporting "Charities" and NGOs may regret some of the claims they have made when called to do so under oath in the Law Courts
-
john watson 16 Oct 2012I don't smoke however smoking should be a life style choice. Government should not be interfering in the life style choices of others. You are born free, and we should all be allowed to die free. Government can advise and warn, other than that government should stay clear. If some one wants to smoke, run a smoking bar or enter a smoking bar that choice should be left to every one of us. It is not the duty of government to protect us from our selves.
-
Jason Stanworth 16 Oct 2012Please note everyone i have signed this petition before and my name was not registered, please check your name is on the petition if you have voted.
Jase -
Alec Johnston 16 Oct 2012Eddie, I think you're a bit deluded when you say "This petition will be a very difficult one for MSPs to handle.". The MSPs will conclude that Scots don't want this, the international tobacco and smoking lobby community do, they will be given technical advice that the petition is misleading in its claims, and that the ventilation systems you propose won't comply with the requirements of EH40.
-
Alec Johnston 16 Oct 2012John Watson, why are you promoting people's right to be addicted to a harmful substance under the guise of freedom? If you don't smoke, why are you meddling in other people's habits?
-
Bill Gibson 16 Oct 2012Alec, likewise why are you interfering in the rights of others to express thir opinion on what is a legal pastime.
I refer you to the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948
Article 1.
All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood. -
Bill Gibson 16 Oct 2012Alec, I suggest that you read the WHO Guidelines on Indoor Air Quality .... all 484 pages
-
Moderator 16 Oct 2012FAO Jason Stanworth: Mr Stanworth, your signature to the petition was registered on 27 September at 8.53am and is showing in the list of signatories. Moderator.
-
Alec Johnston 16 Oct 2012Bill, you should read EH40 and give this up as a bad job. Also, "All human beings are born free" but quite a lot of them get addicted to tobacco and are no longer free. Sinister that so many non-smokers go out of their way to promote tobacco addiction in the name of freedom.
-
Bill Gibson 16 Oct 2012Tobacco use is a habit and not an addiction. You are certainly out to make a foll of yourself Alec and doing so in grand style.
-
Bill Gibson 16 Oct 2012Alec, to enlighten you further read Science Daily Surprising New Study Shows Cigarette Cravings Result from Habit, Not Addiction.
-
Alec Johnston 16 Oct 2012Here we go, tobacco use is not an addiction eh Bill? That just adds to your credibility. I know some people smoke because of habit, but a fair few are addicted and not free. You seem to suggest that nobody is addicted to smoking. Pull the other one.
-
Eddie Douthwaite 17 Oct 2012Alec the Anonymous: Just Google " TC Tactics" and you will get all the details about the dirty tactics of Tobacco Control.
-
Alec Johnston 17 Oct 2012Eddie, have a read of EH40. You'll see that the claim in the petition that "All toxins have safe levels listed in Health and Safety Executive Workplace Exposure Limits, EH40" isn't true. You'll also see that your proposals for ventilation won't meet EH40's requirements for carcinogens in the air of a workplace.
-
Alec Johnston 17 Oct 2012Bill, I googled Science Daily and Nicotine Addiction and found their article "Why Some Smokers Become Addicted With Their First Cigarette". This doesn't help your claim that nicotine isn't addictive.
-
Eddie Douthwaite 18 Oct 2012Alec the Anonymous: I don't debate with a cardboard cutout.
-
Alec Johnston 19 Oct 2012"I don't debate with a cardboard cutout". You have nothing to debate anyway. Your petition is wrong and misleading. The ventilation systems you're proposing don't comply with the requirements of EH40. The vast majority of the petition's signatures are from tobacco advocates outside Scotland.
-
Eddie Douthwaite 19 Oct 2012Alec the Anonymous: As I said before, it is NOT my petition.
-
Alec Johnston 19 Oct 2012Eddie, back on the 4th you said "The comprehensive evidence which will be given to the Petitions Committee by the petitioner will prove the effectiveness of Air Filtration systems". It might not be 'your petition' but you clearly feel you are involved with it, otherwise how would you know what they are going to present?
-
Eddie Douthwaite 19 Oct 2012Alec the Anonymous: If you know where to look on the Internet the evidence is available. Enjoy searching for it. Remember there are lies, damned lies and Tobacco Control.
-
Alec Johnston 19 Oct 2012Eddie, if you're looking for lies, then you need go no further than this part of the petition "All toxins have safe levels listed in Health and Safety Executive Workplace Exposure Limits, EH40"
-
Chris Rendall 21 Oct 2012SHS is really deadly!!?? Wow this is great, it means I can get myself a soft top sports car now. Great, and it is also wonderfull because it means I can be behind a bus, lorry, or even another car I can then breath in the beautiful aroma of there fumes because its safer than breathing in deadly second hand smoke! When is the next trip to Afganistan????
-
Alec Johnston 21 Oct 2012Eddie, if you read the forum you can see that I went to the site of the systems that the petitioner referred to, and they say it doesn't work for airborne carcinogenic chemicals like those in cigarette smoke. The petition is misleading, and your constant references to the evidence being on the internet is clearly wishful thinking, because you have failed to provide it. When the petitioner suggested a manufacturers site it said it wouldn't work. And not a single one of you has managed to show that your ventilation proposal will comply with EH40's requirements for carcinogens (because it won't). Lies, damned lies and tobacco industry propaganda.
-
Alec Johnston 21 Oct 2012369 signatures at 23.33 on 21st October. 68 from Scotland, 301 from the rest of the world. It has been discussed in The Scotsman, and still the rest of the world seems to want us to change our smoking ban far more than Scots do. Considering the efforts made by the pro-smoking and tobacco lobby groups to promote this, 68 Scots is a particularly feeble showing.
-
Eddie Douthwaite 22 Oct 2012Alec the Anonymous: Stop hiding behind your anonimity. At least the Petitions Committee do not make their decisions based on the number of signatories of a petition. Talking of numbers ASH Scotland have 27 staff yet get funded £1MILLION a year by the Scottish Government. They must be one of the few "charities ?" that exist mainly on public funds, you never see them on the street collecting for their " Charity ?"
-
Eddie Douthwaite 22 Oct 2012Alec the Anonymous: The petitioner does not have the resources or money that GLOBAL TOBACCO CONTROL, THE GOVERNMENT, ANTI-SMOKING ALLIANCES and their SUPPORTING CHARITIES have to publicise their PROPAGANDA.