Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01451 · Session 4

Review of smoking ban

Closed Submitted 10 Sep 2012 Health
Signatures
0
373 online signatures with a country
Comments
137
Considered
2 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to review the smoking prohibition and control provisions of the Smoking, Health and Social Care (Scotland) Act 2005 in the light of new developments in clean air technology and the European indoor air quality standard Ventilation for non-residential buildings, EN 13779.

What the petitioner did first

Previous petition PE1042 in 2007 called for the establishment of an air quality standard. The committee deferred consideration of this petition until the smoking ban came up for review, but it was not known in 2007 when post-legislative scrutiny would take place. It is mentioned in the Legacy Report for the Health and Sport Committee, published at the end of the last session.
We wish to update our position in light of the time elapsed, and further developments since PE1042.
Two of our members have recently presented relevant evidence in a meeting with the Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy, Jackie Baillie MSP. Ms Baillie has been fully briefed but no subsequent meeting has been arranged.
Our campaign to date has included the following activities:
• Demonstrations, including one at the conference announcing the results of Pell’s study (‘junk science stat of the year’), entitled ‘Towards a smoke-free Scotland’; and outside the venue of the UKNSCC (smoking cessation conference) in Glasgow, 2010. http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa0706740
• Signing the Aldebaran Treaty in 2008 to launch The International Coalition Against Prohibition, recognising that the smoking ban has been replicated in other countries all over the world
• Campaigning vigorously against further extensions of the smoking ban– including the move in 2009 to abolish the exemption that existed in respect of mental health facilities, including a call to withdraw the 2009 mental health consultation on the smoking ban, which made specific claims about the health effects of secondary smoke, cited no references, and was manifestly biased in favour of a change in legislation. We also presented a petition PE1246 to the Parliament on this in 2009
• Campaigning against the plan by NHS Grampian to ban smoking on its premises and to ban staff from carrying tobacco while on duty (this involved letters, a press release and several media appearances)
• Complaint to Press Complaints Commission about press report claiming that flouting the smoking policy of NHS Borders (regarding smoking outdoors on NHS premises) was a breach of the law. The editor accepted the complaint and has issued a correction
• Blogging and supporting other blogs to educate the public about our views.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 27 Nov 2012
    1 mention
  2. 22 Jan 2013
    2 mentions

Signatures by country

373 online signatures
  1. England131 35.1%
  2. United Kingdom69 18.5%
  3. Scotland68 18.2%
  4. United States30 8%
  5. Denmark12 3.2%
  6. Canada9 2.4%
  7. Wales8 2.1%
  8. Ireland5 1.3%
  9. Spain4 1.1%
  10. Austria4 1.1%
  11. 18 other countries33 8.8%

Comments

137 comments, oldest first
137 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Bill Gibson 1 Oct 2012
    Alec, you should be addressing your concerns to the Health and Safety Executive not me as they have clearly stated that they cannot offer evidence that second hand smoke is an increased risk to health.

    It is also noted that as yet you have not offered a shred of evidence that I acted in a sales capacity within the Ventilation Industry and would therefore expect a withdrawal of your claim and an apology.
  2. Alec Johnston 1 Oct 2012
    Bill, I apologised for assuming you were a salesman in a post that has not been published. I'll apologise again, and note that you merely worked for Tornex as a self employed consultant.
    You're being evasive about the carcinogen requirements of EH40. Is that because you don't understand, or because it destroys your argument that ventilation (other than fume cupboard or local exhaust) would be acceptable to reduce carcinogen levels to the degree required by EH40?
  3. Bill Gibson 1 Oct 2012
    For anyone who is interested in the truth this is an excellent read Toxic Toxicology by Littlewood & Fennel
  4. Bill Gibson 1 Oct 2012
    Finally

    Google JTI, Dubai Airports and JCDecaux unveil striking smoking lounge initiative

    Proof if any is needed that this is the way forward to save what remains of our hospitality sector and to boost the economy creating jobs instead of losing them.
  5. Bill Gibson 1 Oct 2012
    Finally, finally

    Alec, as the HSE, OSHA (USA) and MAK (Germany) operate in parallel, the data presented in Toxic Toxicology (see previous post) may be applied to all three.

    As is shown in the chart, the chemicals are of extreme trace elements, presenting no real health hazzards when exposed over a typical 8 hour work pattern.
  6. Alec Johnston 1 Oct 2012
    Bill's suggested read is not the truth, and is popular with the pro-smoking groups he associates with. For proper, unbiased advice about ventilation and hazardous substances like carcinogens, go to the HSE website and read their advice. "Local exhaust ventilation (LEV), or extraction, is an engineering control solution to reduce exposures to dust, mist, fume, vapour or gas in a workplace.
    Use a properly designed LEV system that will draw dust, fume, gases or vapour through a hood or booth away from the worker.
    An extraction system should be easy for workers to use and enclose the process as much as possible.
    It should effectively capture and contain the harmful substance before it is released into the working environment." Bill and this petition are advocating a far less effective system than HSE describe.
  7. Bill Gibson 2 Oct 2012
    There are many well ventilated Smokers Lounges in existance, working within the respective country's Occupational Health Limits. ETS is no more dangerous than other Occupational Hazards such as Paint Spray Boothes etc.

    www.osha.europa.eu.en.topics.ds.oel.members.stm

    substitute . for forward slash
  8. Belinda Cunnison 2 Oct 2012
    Alec, what you say about isolating the toxins assumes that the ambient air is clean. But we know that there is ambient pollution everywhere because of the UK breaking records in its emissions. Declaring air clean and safe because it doesn't hold cigarette smoke does not wash.
  9. Alec Johnson 2 Oct 2012
    Bill, why don't you answer my questions? Is it because you don't understand, or is it because a truthful answer would destroy your case.
  10. Belinda Cunnison 2 Oct 2012
    In answer to Alec Johnson, or Johnston, your suggestion to Bill Gibson at 21.26 refers to only one kind of air cleaning technology, but not one suitable for tackling ambient air: see links on plasmacluster technology. You will have to look them up.
  11. Alec Johnston 3 Oct 2012
    Belinda, you are missing the whole point, and it just shows how poor your understanding of the requirements of EH40 is. It doesn't matter how effectively you can clean the air, the whole hierarchy of controls for COSHH and for ventilations of airborne carcinogens doesn't allow for the carcinogenic pollutant to be emitted into the air of the workplace, regardless of levels, if a more effective means exists for eliminating exposure. And it does. But you and Bill won't talk about elimination or local exhaust ventilation.
  12. Alec Johnston 3 Oct 2012
    From the manufacturers
    - and not a very reassuring assessment of the capability in the real world of pubs and clubs, "Again, we can not guarantee that in real conditions we will eliminate the virus and chance of spread but Plasmacluster is a real tool in helping to prevent infection in the air."
  13. Alec Johnston 3 Oct 2012
    More from the manufacturer about the product you are suggesting will protect people from carcinogenic chemicals if your petition is successful, "Plasmacluster Ions have no immediate effect on chemicals". In your quest to smoke in pubs, you are being remarkably cavalier with other people's health. I didn't get these quotes from a detractor or competitor. They are from the manufacturer's website.
  14. Alec Johnston 3 Oct 2012
    Final few quotes from the manufacturer. "PCI products are not medical equipment and therefore we do not claim that they will prevent infection. " But then they say "Plasmacluster is a real tool in helping to prevent infection in the air." And "The test results were obtained under controlled laboratory conditions. In an actual room, the efficacy will be affected by factors such as room shape, appliance location, and windows. Results will not be exactly the same as those obtained in tests" So even the manufacturer doesn't claim that they will work in the real world for tobacco smoke.
  15. Belinda 3 Oct 2012
    Actually Alec I don't believe that the manufacturer specifically excludes tobacco smoke. But give me a link if that is what it does.

    If we exclude everything from the marketplace that did not achieve in the real world what it achieves in the lab, not much would be invented at all. Where equipment is critical to safety of course checks, maintenance and improvements have to be made. But if the equipment did not make a noticeable difference to air quality there would be no demand for it. Saying it is not as good in the workplace as in the lab does not necessarily mean that it is not fit for purpose.
  16. Bill Gibson 3 Oct 2012
    The response to a Freedom of Information Request by Tobacco Control Department, Edinburgh

    We hold no information about actual deaths due to passive smoking. It is not possible to give precise figures on deaths resulting from tobacco use
  17. Belinda Cunnison 3 Oct 2012
    Actually I don't believe that the manufacturer specifically excludes tobacco smoke.

    If we exclude everything from the marketplace that did not achieve in the real world what it achieves in the lab, not much would be invented at all. Where equipment is critical to safety of course checks, maintenance and improvements have to be made. But if the equipment did not make a noticeable difference to air quality there would be no demand for it. Saying it is not as good in the workplace as in the lab does not necessarily mean that it is not fit for purpose.
  18. Belinda Cunnison 3 Oct 2012
    Nobody said that the machine was medical equipment and who said anything about viruses?

    As for rules prohibiting a carcinogen being released unnecessarily, that is moot. First of all the ambient air already contains carcinogens. The current system does not require the removal of anything except tobacco smoke.
  19. Belinda Cunnison 3 Oct 2012
    Secondly smoking is a societal phenomenon in which up to one quarter of the population partakes. More in some districts, less in others. Prohibiting public smoking makes it harder for them to get together, which diminishes their quality of life.
  20. Dermot Hanway 3 Oct 2012
    Why are the majority of signatories not from Scotland?
  21. Bill Gibson 3 Oct 2012
    Alec

    Point of Law ..... Kay Labate v Commission of the European Communities
  22. Otto Kjaergaard 4 Oct 2012
    I am have been frequent traveller to Scotland for many years, I have seen how much damage this ban has done to your pubs. I dont smoke myself but being in a pub with smokers is always a very good experience. Your Scottish pubs are World Heritage and must be protecred as such.
  23. Bill Gibson 4 Oct 2012
    Dermot ... until at least October 2014 Scotland is part of the United Kingdom, therefore many of the signatures that have the United Kingdom shown may well be from residents within Scotland.
  24. Alec Johnston 4 Oct 2012
    Dermot, a similarly pertinent question would be why there are so many signatories to the petition from the international pro-smoking movements. Bill seemed to suggest he knew most of them in an earlier post and he is, after all, a mover and shaker in a few international pro-smoking (although he'd probably try the tired argument that they're pro-freedom) movement. I don't go with the 'freedom' angle that they trot out because addicts aren't 'free'.
  25. Alec Johnston 4 Oct 2012
    Bill, your point of law is irrelevant to this. Why are you bringing in irrelevant points when the key issue is that your proposed ventilation solution won't be good enough to meet the requirements of EH40?
  26. Alec Johnston 4 Oct 2012
    Belinda, the equipment manufacturer says " "Plasmacluster Ions have no immediate effect on chemicals". You are claiming that they somehow make tobacco smoke safe. The manufacturer says they have no immediate effect on the carcinogenic chemicals in the smoke.
  27. Eddie Douthwaite 4 Oct 2012
    The comprehensive evidence which will be given to the Petitions Committee by the petitioner will prove the effectiveness of Air Filtration systems and destroy the myth that "Tornado Strength Winds" would be required as stated in one study used in support of the smoking ban.

    Food for thought:-

    It's too early for post legislative scrutiny.

    Google. Health & Sports Committee Meeting 12 Sept 2007.

    But the Health Committee meeting on 6 Feb 2007
    details the post legislative scrutiny carried out.
  28. Alec Johnston 4 Oct 2012
    Belinda says "As for rules prohibiting a carcinogen being released unnecessarily, that is moot." It is only moot in a parallel universe that doesn't understand the requirements of EH40. Back here in the real world it is a big issue, and one that you and your associates clearly don't understand. Are you really suggesting that the presence of carcinogens in ambient air means that employers are free to add carcinogens as they like?
  29. Alec Johnston 4 Oct 2012
    Eddie, surely it doesn't help your case that Belinda and Bill can't string together any decent evidence that your super new ventilation system will adequately protect workers if the smoking ban is relaxed. Even the manufacturer agrees, although Belinda doesn't seem to grasp this. Why not post your evidence here if it is so compelling? I suspect you won't because it isn't at all compelling, and we've probably already heard about it from Bill and Belinda.
  30. Belinda Cunnison 4 Oct 2012
    It makes absolutely no sense to remove smoke on the grounds of improving air quality as if it is the only pollutant in ambient air that will make any difference. The point of the petition is to establish acceptable limits of ambient pollution in the air, and treat air that exceeds these limits. There is no reason to suppose that it should be impossible to remove the content of tobacco smoke before it becomes an annoyance or irritation to others. As to international coverage, campaigns to promote smoking bans are also global, and it is only to be expected that petitions attract certain interest groups.
  31. Eddie Douthwaite 4 Oct 2012
    Alec, As I said, the FULL evidence will be presented to the Petitions Committee for consideration and not in this comment forum.
  32. Bill Gibson 4 Oct 2012
    For every hospitality venue that is forced to close, politians must accept that there is also loss of sales tax, business tax revenue, etc to the treasury. This will result in further increases in indirect taxation to attempt to keep the nation afloat while paying out more unemployment benifits ... all in the name of health when as a nation we cannot afford the costs of growing old as it is.
  33. Alec Johnston 4 Oct 2012
    Belinda, you continue to flaunt your ignorance about the requirements of EH40. Firstly your petition states that "All toxins have safe levels listed in Health and Safety Executive Workplace Exposure Limits, EH40", which is simply not true.
    Then you suggest a solution involving a product that doesn't have any impact on carcinogenic chemicals, and want to ignore the requirements of EH40 about carcinogens.
  34. Alec Johnson 4 Oct 2012
    "all in the name of health when as a nation we cannot afford the costs of growing old as it is.
    Bill Gibson" Smoking has been proposed by the tobacco industry as a means of keeping down the numbers of expensive older people before Bill.
  35. brian moore 4 Oct 2012
    lets make this land FREE again and fight the tobacco TALIBAN and all the anti people who wish to make our lives as missrable as THEIRS.
  36. Eddie Douthwaite 4 Oct 2012
    Alec, it will be up to the Petitions Committee to make an informed decision on this petition. For someone who has commented so much on this site it is surprising that you do not appear in Internet searches. The possibility exists that you may be an " agent provocoteur" in an attempt to find out the extent of the evidence that will be given to the committee.
  37. Alec Johnston 5 Oct 2012
    Eddie, I hope the Petitions Committee are told the truth. Your petition says that "All toxins have safe levels listed in Health and Safety Executive Workplace Exposure Limits, EH40" which is untrue. Your colleagues from the pro-smoking movement promote plasmacluster technology as a solution to the problem, even though the manufacturer says it isn't effective against chemicals (including carcinogens). I think it is important that the Petitions Committee get good advice from properly qualified Health and Safety experts. If you had bothered to get that advice, you wouldn't have created such a misleading petition.
  38. Eddie Douthwaite 5 Oct 2012
    Alec, for a start it's not my petition and I understand the organisation raising it is "PRO-CHOICE" not pro-smoking. The Law Courts will eventually decide what the truth is.
  39. Michael J. McFadden 6 Oct 2012
    Alec, is there a safe level of exposure to the Class A carcinogens of UV radiation and ethyl alcohol?
    - MJM
  40. Alec Johnston 7 Oct 2012
    At 10.30 on Sunday 7th October there were 298 signatures. 50 were from Scotland.
    * from Canada, 10 from Denmark, 3 from Netherlands, 2 from Germany, 24 from USA, 4 from Italy, 3 from Australia, 5 from Wales, and 110 from England. So much for Scottish independence, we aren't that bothered, the rest of the world wants to tell us what to do. (Edited by Moderator)
  41. Alec Johnston 8 Oct 2012
    Eddie says "I understand the organisation raising it is "PRO-CHOICE" not pro-smoking." They all say this Eddie but the only choice they seem to be really interested in is the freedom for people to be addicted to smoking, which seems to be one of the least worthwhile 'freedoms' to be fighting for.
  42. Alec Johnston 8 Oct 2012
    Michael JM, your signature on the petition says you are in the USA. What do you have against letting Scots make up their own minds about issues like this? We have enough people trying to mislead our government over this issue without importing extra ones from across the Atlantic.
  43. Stephen Helfer 8 Oct 2012
    The problem with the data on passive smoking...is that the estimated risks are so close to zero.
    Canadian Medical Association Journal (editorial), August 5, 2003
  44. Alec Johnston 9 Oct 2012
    Stephen, are you from Scotland or are you another person trying to manipulate what our Government does on our behalf? Checking your name on the web reveals someone with your name as the founder of Cambridge Citizens for Smokers' Rights in Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA "Cambridge Citizens for Smokers' Rights is a non-profit group based in Cambridge, Massachusetts. We actively oppose excessive tobacco regulation and efforts to stigmatize smokers." Is this you Stephen?
  45. Alec Johnston 9 Oct 2012
    PS Stephen. The web also says this about the Stephen Helfer from CCSR. "Stephen is an avid tobacco user. He is fond of tobacco either as it is found in cigarettes, or smoked in a pipe. His favorite cigarette is the unfiltered Camel. He has the notable habit of field stripping each cigarette after he smokes it. His tobacco activism centers on a philosophy of protecting and maintaining personal freedoms in the face of 'big government' policies that would seek to legislate the private habits of individuals with their so-called welfare in mind. Stephen strongly believes the individual is in a far superior position to determine their own self-interest regarding life style and health choices."
  46. Bill Gibson 9 Oct 2012
    Alec
    Maybe you can explain why ASH New Zealand and the Cancer Society of New Zealand offered written evidence to the Scottish Parliament Health and Sports Committee with regard to the Tobacco Display Ban. Purely a Scottish issue or are you cherry picking as is normal practice for a Tobacco Control Addict.
  47. Bill Gibson 10 Oct 2012
    Alec, you must complain to the very highest level within the Scottish Parliament as on the 10th January 2012, the Health and Sports Committee took oral evidence from Professor Timothy Stockwell (University of Victoria, British Columbia on the subject of Minimum Pricing of Alcohol ... again in your mindset, a Scottish issue and not subject to influence from an overseas perspective.
  48. Bill Gibson 10 Oct 2012
    Phase two , to obtain justice for all the businesses that have endured financial and moral hardship as a result of the Smoking Ban " Private Investment Fund Horecaclaim" All those who have misinformed the public over the years must be brought to account for their actions.
  49. Alec Johnston 10 Oct 2012
    Only 51 people from Scotland have signed this petition in the month it has been here. It was in The Scotsman about 3 weeks ago, and still Scots don't support it. There are over 5 million of us nowadays, and yet only 51 signed the petition. (Edited by Moderator)
  50. Eddie Douthwaite 11 Oct 2012
    Alec the Anonymous: The number of signatories to a petition is irrelevant, I suggest that you have a look at other petitions on this site.