Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01443 · Session 4

Investigating the cause of miscarriage

Closed Submitted 20 Jul 2012 Health
Signatures
25
864 online signatures with a country
Comments
79
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to offer all women, who have suffered miscarriage, investigations following one loss through miscarriage and to review NHS Scotland’s policy on the investigation and treatment of couples who experience miscarriage to help relieve the anxiety and distress to women caused by the current guidelines.

What the petitioner did first

SCIM have campaigned steadily on this issue since 1994 but it is very difficult to engage with the health service. Most recently, we have approached Robert Calderwood, Chief Executive of NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde. This has resulted in a response that does not grasp the seriousness of this issue. The SCIM Management Committee asked Greater Glasgow and Clyde, NHS Board, to offer women who have suffered miscarriage, investigations following one loss though miscarriage. However we were referred to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists guidelines (2011): http://www.rcog.org.uk/files/rcog-corp/GTG17recurrentmiscarriage.pdf
We approached every health authority in 1995 and were referred to guidelines which call for three consecutive miscarriages before the relevant tests would be offered. This is the position of the GGHB at the most recent approach. Our charities resources do not allow us to test the other boards, however we have no reason to believe that any other health board, in Scotland, would behave differently.
We have also approached Neil Bibby MSP, Mary Fee MSP and other Glasgow City Councillors such as Cllr Elaine Smith and Cllr Gordon Matheson who have all expressed their support in this matter and some of whom suggested that we submit a petition to the Scottish Parliament.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 27 Nov 2012
    1 mention
  2. 5 Feb 2013
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 16 Apr 2013
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 25 Jun 2013
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 17 Sep 2013
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 26 Nov 2013
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petition
    1 mention
  7. 28 Jan 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

864 online signatures
  1. Scotland598 69.2%
  2. England81 9.4%
  3. United Kingdom80 9.3%
  4. United States36 4.2%
  5. Sweden21 2.4%
  6. Australia7 0.8%
  7. Wales4 0.5%
  8. Canada4 0.5%
  9. Norway4 0.5%
  10. Germany4 0.5%
  11. 15 other countries25 2.9%

Comments

79 comments, oldest first
79 comments · showing 51–79
  1. amie jackson 24 Aug 2012
    As someone who has had 4 miscarriages it was hard to find out no-one was willing to help or try find out why its happening all because I haven't had 3 in a row surely ones enough!!!
  2. c anderson 24 Aug 2012
    It is hard enough to go through this once and have no answers let alone 3 times the unanswered questions about why this happened is one of the most difficult things to deal with will never forget the feeling of devastation and helplessness i felt in 2005 its about time someone took notice of the pain and anguish this issue causes.
  3. jane tyler 26 Aug 2012
    I support this petition wholeheartedly
  4. Anne 2 Sep 2012
    I support this and hope something is done.
  5. sharon morrison 2 Sep 2012
    Have a friend that has had quite a few miscarriages and if this helps in anyway not just for her but all the other women out there going through this awful thing x
  6. claire forbes 2 Sep 2012
    I will support this 100%, bout time women were treated with respect and investigations sought after their loss instead of being another percentage for a miscarriage statistics. having 1 miscarriage was heartbreaking enough, women need more support and help instead in being shown the exit of the hospital doors.
  7. Lynne macmillan 3 Sep 2012
    Not enough done about it
  8. Isabelle Buchanan 16 Sep 2012
    Something should be done,save a lot of heartache !
  9. Marie Brown 17 Sep 2012
    Fully support this petition. After having two miscarriages and being told that they would not check out as to why until I had three, was too frightened to mentally go through another pregnancy but I knew why I had the first two, I would have tried for the baby we so wanted in our family. Thankfully I have a son Matthew whom i love so much but he would have also have liked to be a big brother. My 2nd miscarriage was a missed miscarriage and the treatment you recieve should change
  10. Susan Sherry 18 Sep 2012
    STOP GOING ON ABOUT KATE AND HIGHLIGHT VERY VERY IMPORTANT THINGS LIKE THIS TO HELP PRIMARILY WOMEN BUT WHOLE FAMILIES IN AN EXTREMELY DIFFICULT TIME.

    (Edited by Moderator)
  11. Karen 19 Sep 2012
    It happened a long time ago but you never really get over it 18th October 1987 RiP x
  12. Sarah Donaghy 20 Sep 2012
    Every year for 33 years now at my babys due date I cry.Its something I can never ever forget. My poor baby lost forever. I was told at the time that it 'was just one of things', go away and try again in three months. Not good enough.
  13. Claire Lonie 20 Sep 2012
    In support of all the lost angels
  14. ann mcmahon 20 Sep 2012
    never happened to me but right behind u all 100% xx
  15. Amanda Doherty 20 Sep 2012
    I hope this helps to get things changed.
  16. Pam Macdonald 21 Sep 2012
    Thinking of all the wee sleeping angels when signing this, sleep tight xx
  17. Ian Brown 23 Sep 2012
    We went through this as a family and they should change the way the nhs do things, my wife had two miscarriages and we where called into the same room and we called it the BAD NEWS ROOM, this should change as it so hard hearing the news that you have lost a baby
  18. Shelly Herd 25 Sep 2012
    Doing this for a special friend at this very sad time x
  19. Karen kelly 25 Sep 2012
    Went threw it 3 times its the worst feeling ever,thoughts go out to those who its happened too
  20. Gillian Mckie 28 Sep 2012
    I've had 5 miscarriages And it's horrific, totally in support of this petition. My love and prayers to everyone suffering from the pain of recurrent miscarriages. Xx
  21. pamela jarvis 28 Sep 2012
    absolutely.
  22. Julie Michie 30 Sep 2012
    My husband and I suffered a silent miscarriage in 2010. We went for our 12 week scan to be told that there was no heart beat. We were ushered to a room where other people were waiting for their scans, which was awful other obviously pregnant women. We were offered three choices how to get rid of our much wanted baby. Our baby left us three days later on valentines day. Only when this happens to you you realize how common miscarriage is. I work for the Nhs and now money is tight, however I think it is unspeakable to be expected to have multiple miscarriages before you are investigated! We were lucky we then went onto have a beautiful baby girl. My mum says everything happens for a reason- she also has had a miscarriage, maybe so! If our first baby had have survived we wouldn't have our daughter !
  23. Wendy 1 Oct 2012
    Living in the USA. Please realize that the world it watching.
  24. Ellen Stewart 7 Oct 2012
    Having had 7 miscarriages I would love to see some changes! So other women don't have to suffer.
  25. lynsay graham 15 Oct 2012
    After having 2 and being told that I'd have 2 wait till a had another before the would do anything. Am now 2 scared to even try again. :(
  26. lillias mclachlan 15 Oct 2012
    would like to see more changes to help mothers.
  27. Morag Devlin 16 Oct 2012
    My husband and I suffered two miscarriages. we were told it was just mother nature doing her thing!! Thankfully we have three beautiful kids now, but it never leaves you, even after twenty years! Things need to change....
  28. ann mcculloch 16 Oct 2012
    the devastating number of miscarriages which women experience should be investigated. It is not good enough to think that any miscarriage is tolerable. Only with improved investigation and research will we see progress for families, leading to fewer miscarriages
  29. Marion 16 Oct 2012
    My daughter very distressed after two miscarrages and desperately hoping not to have to endure another before any help is available.