Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. I welcome you all to this meeting of the Public Petitions Committee. As always, I ask everyone who has a mobile phone or electronic device to switch it off now, please, as such devices interfere with our sound system.I place on record our thanks to one of our assistant clerks, Alison Wilson, who is moving to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee. The committee thanks her for her work over the past three years, and we wish her all the best in her new committee.I welcome Andrew Howlett, who is replacing Alison. I thank him very much for joining the committee and hope that he enjoys his experience with us.Agenda item 1 is consideration of new petitions. PE1443, by Maureen Sharkey, on behalf of Scottish Care and Information on Miscarriage, is on investigating the cause of miscarriages. Members have a note by the clerk, the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing and a copy of the petition.I welcome Maureen Sharkey and Elizabeth Corrigan. Thank you for giving up your time to come along and speak to the committee.I ask Maureen Sharkey to address the committee for around five minutes, after which I will kick off with a couple of questions. I will then ask all my colleagues whether they would like to ask additional questions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Miscarriage (Causes) (PE1443)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Maureen Sharkey Scottish Care and Information on Miscarriage 40
- David Stewart Lab 18
- Jackson Carlaw Con 13
- John Wilson SNP 6
- Chic Brodie SNP 6
- Anne McTaggart Lab 5
- Adam Ingram SNP 3
- Angus MacDonald SNP 2
- Elizabeth Corrigan Scottish Care and Information on Miscarriage 1
The record
94 contributionsThank you very much for inviting us to the meeting.The petition is about women who can be helped by testing, not women who cannot. The current guidelines have no medical justification—it is an accountancy matter. Currently, women are required to suffer three consecutive losses before any relevant testing will be offered to them. We would like all women who have had a miscarriage to have access to investigation. We have argued for a change since 1994 but have found it very difficult to engage with the health service.The latest statistics show that, from April 2009 to March 2010, there were 5,708 miscarriages in Scotland. The official definition of a miscarriage is“a spontaneous pregnancy loss up to 24 weeks”.There are three trimesters in pregnancy, and miscarriage can happen in the first two. A spontaneous loss after 24 weeks is a stillbirth.I would like to share with the committee the point of view of a woman who currently does not qualify for testing under the existing miscarriage policy. Last week, she said:“There were those feelings of complete failure as a woman that somehow they knew something that I wasn’t getting to know, that caused me to search within myself for a reason, that was very painful for me.”Scottish Care and Information on Miscarriage is the only counselling organisation of its kind in Scotland. Over the past 18 years, I have heard and seen on a daily basis the physical and emotional effects of the policy on women. Those women generally feel like failures. They are unable to return to their work or they fail to function in the workplace. They suffer from depression, they isolate themselves, their relationships fail, and in some cases, they feel so helpless that they contemplate suicide.The policy has a direct effect on friends and family members, too. Husbands often report how helpless they feel, as they are unable to help or make things better, and best friends are embarrassed by their on-going pregnancy. Miscarriage is hard to explain in the workplace when the medical response was a shrug of the shoulders and the words, “Come back if it happens again.”Testing will help those who have a recognisable condition. The testing policy is not uniformly imposed across the country. Some are tested sooner, but I suspect that that is more to do with where the resources are and people having the confidence to stand up to the medical profession. Testing after miscarriage should not depend on an individual’s ability to argue for it; it should be part of the support that every woman and family gets from our health service.
Thank you very much for your contribution.I will kick off with a couple of questions. Do you think that the public understand the heartbreak, trauma and loss that families experience after a miscarriage? I suppose that that is the wider issue for me.
I think that that is an extremely difficult thing for people to understand, unless it has happened to them. From my personal experience—I have worked with women in a therapeutic counselling capacity for many years—I would say that one of the difficulties that the women raise time and again is the inability of other people to understand what has happened to them and the knock-on effect that that has on their lives.
In a sense, it is a form of bereavement.
Absolutely.
Do you feel that emotional or psychological support should be offered when families want it, not just to the woman involved but to the partner and any surviving children?
Yes. That is something that the organisation that both of us are with offers to all families in Scotland. We have done that for 18 years. We are open to calls from friends or relatives—a mother might phone us and ask us what she can do in support of her daughter. A husband or even an employer might make a similar request. The worst-case scenario is when women phone when they are in the midst of a miscarriage and do not know what to do. We might refer them to emergency services and talk them through that. That is an incredibly sad call to take.
Good morning. For me, the question is straightforward: why has it taken so long for such a petition to be lodged?
That is an extremely good point. There was always a hope that somewhere along the line we would be heard and the issue would be considered without our having to come here—although we are delighted to be here—but that has never happened.
Is that because you feel that the response that you have received from Government officials or health boards has not been satisfactory? It is clear that it has not been satisfactory—that is why we are discussing the petition. You said that, although there are guidelines that say that if someone suffers three miscarriages, they should get some support from the health board, some people get help sooner. Could you give some examples of good practice by health boards, as well as of health boards that do not carry out investigations and provide support in the way that you would like them to?
The first thing that we notice is that, following the bad news, women are just sent home or they might have an overnight stay in hospital, but they are not given any debriefing. It is all just a matter of course and then they are shown the door. In some cases there is a follow-up, but not always. That is what I meant when I said that there is no uniformity. Women are left to deal with things, to get their heads round what happened and to get themselves back to work. Unlike when other losses are experienced, there is no entitlement to time off. Women have to go straight back to the workplace. They are not given any debriefing before they leave the hospital.
That is all for the moment.
Good morning, Maureen and Elizabeth. You mentioned in your preamble the variation in support across health board areas. We have a table that shows that there seems to be a significant variation by health board area in the total rate of miscarriages. For example, the rate in Grampian is about 10.2 per thousand women aged between 15 and 44, whereas the rate in Forth valley in my area is 4.6 per thousand women. Why do you think that the rate varies so much?10:15
That is partly why testing needs to be done. If it is not done, we will never know why that is the case. At the moment, the rule is that a woman must have three consecutive losses. Some women could have two losses and then have a child but then have another loss, and they would not qualify for testing. Other women may have a stillbirth, a miscarriage, a couple of children and then another loss, and they would not qualify for testing either.
Good morning. In reading the petition and the supporting documentation that we have received, I have become concerned about the lack of data. You say that 1 per cent of all miscarriages are recurrent miscarriages. How should NHS inform collect data to give pre-warning of that particular issue and how could data be gathered post-treatment? What discussions have you had with NHS inform or those who can collect data?
I am not entirely sure what you are asking.
You say that there is no data, and I am trying to scope it out. You say that the figure is 1 per cent but, according to the information that we have, data is not really being gathered.
No. The most recent statistics are for 2010. That is how far behind they are. I gathered those statistics last week, and they are two years behind.
I know of the actions that you have taken, but it seems to me that, once it is properly scoped and we have the data, that will provide a basis for pursuing any recourse to action.
Yes, but women have to shout quite loudly before that happens.
I invite Elizabeth Corrigan to come in at any time. Are there any points that you wish to raise at this stage, Elizabeth?
Only on the timespan, which I think is relevant, and my own personal experience. For the past 20 years, the policy has not changed that a woman must have three consecutive miscarriages before anything is done. I think that that is really awful.
I would like to pick up on that point. The Scottish Government published “A Refreshed Framework for Maternity Care in Scotland” in January last year, the key aim of which was to improve health outcomes for both mother and child within maternity services by having services individualised according to women’s needs.In the case of miscarriage, every woman is different and the circumstances are different. My own wife had a miscarriage during her second pregnancy. I understand that a woman suffering a miscarriage during her first pregnancy would be significantly more alarmed or concerned about what that might imply for her future. In that case, there may be a strong case for having some sort of test. My wife had had a successful pregnancy before, and family support saw her through the miscarriage. Fortunately, we had three more healthy children afterwards.Rather than taking a blanket approach to testing, is the idea of having an individualised service that would be sensitive to a woman’s needs, as is set out in the Scottish Government’s policy, not the way to go? Have you seen any difference in the approaches that are being taken across the country in response to that new Scottish Government policy in the area?
We are here today to ask that women who suffer one miscarriage are offered testing. I think that that is essential if it is to be understood from a scientific point of view what has happened, which is rarely answered in such cases. I think that that is the most difficult aspect for the women involved, who go away not knowing what happened or why. For every other kind of bereavement, people get an indication as to what happened and it is common for people to ask what happened and to get a response. However, in the case of miscarriages, women do not get that kind of response, which means that they start to search within themselves, which is a particularly painful process to watch. On most days, Elizabeth Corrigan and I hear women asking, “What did I do? What was it I didn’t do?” Women get a bit anxious about those questions.
Have you seen any evidence of the new framework being put into practice up and down the country and maternity services taking an approach that focuses on the individual needs of particular women?
As I said earlier, some women are treated and responded to in a much better way than others. From one hospital to another and from one doctor to another, the situation is incredibly different. We know that from the work that we do, which can vary from speaking to someone in one phone call to working with someone for up to a year, which is how long some women take to recover from a miscarriage. In addition, there is always the fear of trying to become pregnant again for fear of a miscarriage happening again.
Good morning, Maureen and Elizabeth. I want to drill down a wee bit further into some of your points. What do you feel would assist these women in their communities and what needs to be put in place?
Testing. I think that it is absolutely necessary now that testing is done. If we could help 10 per cent, that would be 500 women, which is 10 women every week. That is why it is very important.
Adam Ingram referred to the policy document “A Refreshed Framework for Maternity Care in Scotland”. What are your views on that?
We have seen no change whatsoever—none.
You said, though, that the situation was better in some areas than in others. Are those specific geographical areas or national health service areas?
It is a bit of both, but even then it is not uniform. It can depend on the consultant a woman sees or on the woman herself standing up in the middle of her grief and saying, “Look. I just need something done here.” That is not really the ideal time for someone to be trying to argue their case.
I am sorry to come back in, Maureen and Elizabeth, but I want to go back to the figures that we have in front of us. In the written submission to support the petition, you referred to the same figures that we have before us. My difficulty is that the only figures that we have in front of us are about the number of miscarriages. Do you have any information about the number of recurring miscarriages within those figures? You referred to 1 per cent. It would be useful if the figures for recurring miscarriages were available and we could sit them alongside
the 5,708 miscarriages in Scotland to see what proportion are recurring. We could measure that against the health boards to find out whether issues arise in that respect. As my colleague Angus MacDonald indicated, Grampian NHS Board has a miscarriage rate of 10.2 per 1,000 women aged between 15 and 44, while the figure for the islands health boards is 2.2. Clearly there is some variance there, but it would be useful if you were aware of how those figures relate to the number of subsequent miscarriages suffered by women in those areas.
I do not have those figures with me today. It is really important that all those figures are covered in a way that identifies all the issues. At the moment, we are two years behind with the figures. Nothing is up to date.
I agree. It would be useful for everyone concerned to be aware of the figures. It goes back to the point that you have raised on a couple of occasions, which is that we do not know whether what happens is that a good consultant, doctor or midwife decides to take on the issues at a local level and examine them further. It might also be down to pressures on services that are being delivered at the local level. We need to ensure that, when we take the issue forward, we do so in a way that results in a consistent service delivery throughout Scotland, and not just service delivery in one area while other areas are omitted.
We know from the care that we offer women following loss that, in planning a future pregnancy and during pregnancy, they are incredibly anxious. Our programme gives regular support to women and offers them referrals to various units and so on. We sit down and talk to them most weeks. We have a 74 per cent reduction in the incidence of miscarriage. However, we are extremely dependent on whether the hospital gives women information about our organisation. Despite the fact that we send information to the hospital, women often do not get it. It is distressing when women come through the door and say, “I specifically asked my doctor and the hospital for some counselling support and I wasn’t told about your organisation.” Those women have had to search for the information and are incredibly angry about it.
Good morning. I am slightly unpersuaded by what I have heard so far. It is good that there is an organisation from which people can obtain information, of which people can be made aware and to which people should have access and referral. It appears that only 1 per cent of women suffer recurrent miscarriage. I assume that, for most women, getting pregnant a second time and having a successful pregnancy is the best possible therapy for having lost the first child. I am slightly concerned that if we start suggesting that there should be an automatic testing process, we create the very anxiety that you are trying to alleviate. If a woman suffers a miscarriage, she needs understanding and support. If she is told, “We’re sending you for tests”—and it seems that there would have to be a series of relevant tests—that creates an anxiety that there is something wrong when in fact women have suffered miscarriage throughout history. My concern is that by initiating a statutory series of tests on an automatic basis, we create for women an anxiety that there is something wrong when in fact there may be nothing wrong at all and a second pregnancy will be completely successful. In my wife’s case, that was what happened. I am concerned that some people might delay the process of considering having a second pregnancy because they are awaiting the outcome of tests. For as long as it took to get the information back—it might take even longer if we initiated thousands of these tests—we could create in women a completely unnecessary anxiety, which would compound the loss that they have suffered. 10:30
I totally disagree with you, I am afraid. I would say to you that women want to know what happened.
You say “women” in a general sense. How many of the 5,708 women have you spoken to?
We speak to thousands of women.
To how many of the 5,708 women who miscarried between April 2009 and March 2010 did you speak?
Last year, we offered 446 face-to-face appointments; 292 telephone sessions; and 303 fertility management sessions. On top of that, we offered email support, online support and other pieces of support. Obviously, if someone did not want to know or did not want testing to take place, that would be their choice. I am suggesting that women should be offered that choice. At the moment, they are not.
If recurrent miscarriage affects only 1 per cent of women, the creation of a culture of the mandatory offering of testing might lead women who decline testing to think that it was wrong of them to decline it. Further, if the issue affects only 1 per cent of women, I wonder whether you might be unnecessarily creating an anxiety in women that something might be found by testing when, in fact, in 99 per cent of cases, the answer is that nothing will be found, and the most beneficial thing that they can do is get support and counselling to deal with the miscarriage and go on to have a successful second pregnancy, which is clearly what 99 per cent of them do.
Women do not always have a successful pregnancy following a loss. Some women suffer from recurrent loss. Recently, we saw a woman who had had two successive miscarriages but did not qualify for testing. She went into the private health system to figure out what might have happened and figured out that she needed to take low-dose aspirin. She asked what would have happened if she had taken the advice that she was given in the hospital just to try again and was told that, if she had become pregnant, she would have lost that baby, because she would not have been taking low-dose aspirin.That is the kind of woman I am talking about. It does not take much to sort that out, and it does not cost much, either. The cost of the procedures for miscarriage is £501, and the cost of the emergency call-out—because the women have to be taken to hospital by the emergency services, as they are in an emergency situation—is £217. That adds up to a sum of £718. Blood tests cost between £53 and £72.
Yes, but that cost in relation to miscarriage would not be obviated, because the processes that you are advocating would come into play only after a miscarriage had been suffered.
Yes, but if someone is not tested, they could have further miscarriages. Very often, that is what happens.
Well, not very often—only 1 per cent of the time.
Again, I bring you back to the statistics, which state that, in 2010, 5,708 women suffered a miscarriage.
But not a second miscarriage. Nothing that you are suggesting would stop the first miscarriage. You are talking about a test in the event of a woman having suffered a miscarriage. Nothing that you are proposing by way of testing would have any impact on the number of primary miscarriages that women suffer.
But it would have an effect on subsequent pregnancies.
Yes, but that is not 5,708.
We can go back and forward with the figures—
It is 1 per cent.
What I am saying is—
It is five.
—if we do not test we will never know what the reasons for the miscarriage are. The whole point is the knock-on effect on women. I know from my own experience and my 18 years’ experience of sitting down with women and offering them counselling the devastating effect on women.
On some women.
Yes. It has a devastating effect on some women.
We are running a little bit short of time, so I will bring in Chic Brodie and then take a final point from Anne McTaggart.
I have a very quick question, convener. We know that there is no real data for recurrent miscarriages, but has Maureen Sharkey seen best practice from any of the health boards that she can share with us?
Well, there are the emergency services.
But is there any particular area?
It is very difficult to say.
So we cannot point to a particular health board that is doing well and translate that to other health boards.
As I have said, it is very difficult. Women might come in and say that a particular hospital was good, whereas others might report that the same hospital was not so good.
With regard to Jackson Carlaw’s point that a woman would need to have had a miscarriage before any testing could be carried out, do you think that the evidence from that testing could be used to ensure that other women did not reach even the first stage of miscarriage?
Absolutely.
But how?
The evidence could be gathered and collated to prevent others from having a miscarriage.
You are absolutely right.
We have run out of time, but I have a very quick question on a factual point. Does Scottish Care and Information on Miscarriage receive Scottish Government or any other funding?
Yes. We receive section 10 funding.
Roughly how much do you get?
Not very much. It was cut by about 10 per cent or so. We get £7,000 a year.
Is that your only source of funding?
No. We are also funded by Glasgow City Council. We received funding from North Lanarkshire Council, but its funding was cut this year. That was a pity because in the years that we worked there we saw an absolute drop in the number of miscarriages. Of course, we cannot say that that was entirely a result of what we were doing but it certainly had a lot to do with it.
I presume that all your staff are volunteers.
Yes.
After all, that is a very small amount of funding.
I know.
You probably do not have this figure to hand, but have you estimated the costs to the Scottish Government if it decided to pursue the testing proposal in your petition?
As I have said, the testing costs between £53 and £72 per person.
Do you have an estimate of the annual figure?
No.
I appreciate that the question is very difficult to answer, but I expect that we, too, will be asked it if we refer the petition on.Moving on to our next steps, I think that we should certainly continue this very interesting petition and ask the Scottish Government some of the questions that you have asked us. Our clerks have laid out some draft questions on, for example, the data collection issue that Chic Brodie raised, and seeking views on the petition from the Government, which will be the main player with regard to longer-term action. Do members wish to pursue any other points? I believe that it was suggested that we also ask the royal colleges, the professional associations, the Miscarriage Association and other such groups to take a more detailed look at the petition.
I suggest that as well writing to the royal colleges we also ask the British Medical Association Scotland about the guidance given to general practitioners on dealing with patients who have suffered a miscarriage.
Okay. Do members have any other views?
I would like a detailed response from the Scottish Government on how the framework for maternity services is being rolled out and the feedback that has been received on it. Clearly practice differs across the country and we must establish the extent to which that has been addressed.
We should also ask whether the effectiveness of the new framework has been studied. Is it also worth raising Angus MacDonald’s point and asking about the different miscarriage rates in various health board areas?
It would certainly be helpful to hear its response on the question why the figures vary so much.
Do members have any other comments?
When we write to the royal colleges and others, can we ask why the current guidelines have been established?
That is a good point.As the petitioners will have heard, we will continue the petition and pursue a number of organisations for answers to certain questions that it raises. Obviously we will keep you up to date on progress. Finally, I thank both of you for your evidence. I realise that giving evidence is not an easy job.At this point, I suspend the meeting for two minutes to allow our witnesses to leave and new witnesses to be seated.10:41 Meeting suspended.
10:42 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Nov 2012 →- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 94
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 98
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 4
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 7
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.