Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Former MSP

John Scott

Con Was MSP for Ayr (constituency) 2000–21

Distinctive phrases: lab · con · west snp · south snp · central snp · lothian lab · snp mcleod · mid fife · east snp · east lab

12,928 contributions · showing 1–50
  1. 24 Mar 2021
    Continued Petitions
    Public Petitions Committee

    Yes, please, convener, and thank you for letting me speak. I pay tribute to Finlay Carson and Brian Whittle for the work that they have done on the issue. They have done the heavy lifting in driving forward some of this work in the Parliament. I also pay trib…

  2. 24 Mar 2021
    Continued Petitions
    Public Petitions Committee

    I am sorry; I do not appear to be able to make the chat function work. I agree with members that the petition should be passed to the next health committee. I appreciate that we are too late in the session to do anything about it, but I wonder whether a codic…

  3. 24 Mar 2021
    Continued Petitions
    Public Petitions Committee

    I am grateful to the committee for allowing me to speak at the final meeting of the session of the Public Petitions Committee. Further to what Jackson Carlaw has just said, I, too, think that the petition should be kept open. The matter is still a work in pro…

  4. 24 Mar 2021
    Dogs (Protection of Livestock) (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill
    Chamber

    Thank you for your indulgence, Presiding Officer. I have very little to say except to welcome the passage of the bill and declare an interest—Interruption. I thank the cabinet secretary for her sedentary intervention. I declare an interest as a sheep farmer a…

  5. 23 Mar 2021
    Covid-19 (Reflections and Next Steps)
    Chamber

    The First Minister is aware of the continuing anxieties and tensions in our communities resulting from vaccination anxiety, the worry about appointments for other illnesses being delayed and the lack of contact with friends and loved ones. Mental health issue…

  6. 16 Mar 2021
    Covid-19
    Chamber

    The First Minister will be aware that two primary schools in my Ayr constituency have had to close, having reopened, because staff had caught Covid or had to self-isolate. Are such temporary closures to be expected in other schools across Ayrshire and the cou…

  7. 10 Mar 2021
    Portfolio Question Time
    Chamber

    The First Minister gave me an assurance a week or so ago that she would discuss with the cabinet secretary the difficulties that the bed-and-breakfast sector faces and how to overcome them. Will the cabinet secretary please say what progress has been made on …

  8. 9 Mar 2021
    Climate Change Plan
    Chamber

    I declare an interest as a farmer. Does Edward Mountain agree that there is huge willingness across Scotland to meet those challenges in the transport and agriculture sectors? Does he also agree, however, that there is a huge need for knowledge transfer from …

  9. 9 Mar 2021
    Covid-19
    Chamber

    Long Covid appears to be an emerging and growing problem. Can the First Minister tell us how many cases there are in Scotland, what measures the Scottish Government has put in place to deal with long Covid in hospitals and in the community, and whether additi…

  10. 4 Mar 2021
    Annual Report
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Yes, of course.

  11. 4 Mar 2021
    Annual Report
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    I do not know the answer.

  12. 4 Mar 2021
    Annual Report
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    I have a technical point to make, but I have nothing against the report. Under “Resilience of the Scottish Parliament’s practices and procedures”, item 5 says: “A rule change providing for the temporary amendment of Standing Orders came into effect on 8 March…

  13. 4 Mar 2021
    Scottish Parliament Practices and Procedures
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Thank you for being straightforward.

  14. 4 Mar 2021
    Scottish Parliament Practices and Procedures
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Yes. 10:15

  15. 4 Mar 2021
    Scottish Parliament Practices and Procedures
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    I just wanted to ask the minister what he considers has been achieved over the course of session 5 to improve the quality of documents accompanying bills, such as financial resolutions. Minister, can you talk us through what has been done to improve the stand…

  16. 4 Mar 2021
    Scottish Parliament Practices and Procedures
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Thank you.

  17. 4 Mar 2021
    Scottish Parliament Practices and Procedures
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    What evidence supports the argument that the powers are being used only for as long as required? Will you go back to what was normal as soon as you can, please?

  18. 4 Mar 2021
    Scottish Parliament Practices and Procedures
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    I will move on the next section of our questions. What has influenced the use of the made affirmative procedure in response to the Covid-19 pandemic? To what extent has the use of those powers been proportionate? What have been the advantages and disadvantage…

  19. 4 Mar 2021
    Scottish Parliament Practices and Procedures
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    I want to go back to Maureen Watt’s point about the need for members to be present at Parliament. The Parliament is a living entity and we have an obligation to be open and accessible. There is a need to have cross-party groups too and to make this a place th…

  20. 4 Mar 2021
    Subordinate Legislation
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Have you had any feedback from electoral administrators on the impact of moving the deadline for postal votes by 10 working day, from 20 April to 6 April?

  21. 4 Mar 2021
    Subordinate Legislation
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    No, I am just seeking general reassurance that that aspect is being dealt with.

  22. 4 Mar 2021
    Subordinate Legislation
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Can the minister provide an update on what is being done to ensure the timely delivery of postal votes for Scottish armed forces electors who are posted overseas?

  23. 4 Mar 2021
    Subordinate Legislation
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Thanks very much.

  24. 4 Mar 2021
    Subordinate Legislation
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Yes, that would be helpful.

  25. 4 Mar 2021
    Subordinate Legislation
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    What level of proof might be required?

  26. 4 Mar 2021
    Subordinate Legislation
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    I see. So there are no grounds on which an application might be rejected.

  27. 4 Mar 2021
    Subordinate Legislation
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    I want to ask a couple of questions about that. Would an elector be required to demonstrate that their request for an alternative proxy was due to coronavirus, or could that be for any reason?

  28. 4 Mar 2021
    First Minister’s Question Time
    Chamber

    I, too, have been contacted by several constituents who have applied over the past few weeks for newly self-employed hardship grants and mobile and home-based close contact services grants, only to have their applications rejected because of so-called glitche…

  29. 2 Mar 2021
    Scottish Parliamentary Elections 2021
    Chamber

    I welcome the arrangements that have been made for polling day under which only 800 people will be allowed at each polling station. Some polling stations would usually expect more people and some would expect less. Will local authorities make an effort to dir…

  30. 23 Feb 2021
    Covid-19
    Chamber

    Among all the good will towards the business sector that the First Minister speaks of, one part of that community has slipped through the cracks—namely, the bed-and-breakfast sector. It is struggling hugely and is badly in need of targeted support. Will she c…

  31. 16 Feb 2021
    Topical Question Time
    Chamber

    I spoke this morning to a constituent who, along with her five-year-old daughter, is in Finland where her partner is receiving hyperbaric oxygen treatment following a severe brain injury. With school now about to restart for their five-year-old, the family wa…

  32. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Other people have suggested that that has not been the case, so you might want to look further into that. Our information tells us that examples of good practice are not being built on. I note your optimism and ebullience, but I think that the matter needs cl…

  33. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    When the committee first discussed the matter in December, I asked for examples of good practice. We got several examples in the follow-up information that the commissioner submitted. She stated: “The case studies have been acknowledged by the panel chairs, o…

  34. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Gil Paterson said that we would be “missing a trick” if we did not include people on low incomes. I agree with that, and with much of what the cabinet secretary said about the need for greater flexibility. However, we would also be missing a trick if we did n…

  35. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    No.

  36. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    I do not have much more to say, except that it is a sweeping generalisation for Neil Findlay to say that the 22 per cent of people in the category of those who prefer not to say what they earn are necessarily high-income earners. There is a reticence among no…

  37. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Hmm—well, I will move on to my final question. The commissioner published a good-practice case study on the Poverty and Inequality Commission board recruitment round. What features of that round made it a success, and what is the Government doing to roll out …

  38. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    That takes us on to the broader picture. Since you apparently do not want people with established managerial abilities, what role does the definition of merit have to play here? How will you judge people who are meritorious and suitable for appointment? We ar…

  39. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    I note your use of the word “daunting” to describe how people from the private sector find the application process. I agree that we must focus on outcomes, but your principles-based approach seems to suggest that the process might be less rigorous than it has…

  40. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    My point is on socioeconomic diversity. The cabinet secretary will be familiar with the tables with which we have been provided in our committee papers. Table 5 shows that around 78 per cent of the Scottish population works in the private sector but that only…

  41. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    I am not sure that it does, Kate. We are talking about budgets of £17 billion, and I think that it really needs to be very clearly defined. I am sure that there is some work to be done on how you are going to change the system for the better, because I am not…

  42. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    I would have to say no—I am not clear about that. I could not hear Kate Forbes, and I regret to say that it was not clear what was meant in the response from her assistant, whose name I do not have in front of me—I am sorry.

  43. 11 Feb 2021
    Public Appointments
    Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee

    Good morning. Can the cabinet secretary explain to me, and possibly to others, what she means by a “principles-based code”? She has said it twice, and, if that is going to be the new theme, perhaps she could explain what the principles might be.

  44. 10 Feb 2021
    Continued Petitions
    Public Petitions Committee

    Thank you very much, convener, for letting me come back in. I, too, pay tribute to the work of the clerks over many years, not just on this petition but generally. They are assiduous beyond measure—I agree with you about that. I think that the petition should…

  45. 10 Feb 2021
    Continued Petitions
    Public Petitions Committee

    Thank you, convener, and I apologise for my late arrival. I want to complement what has been said by Jackson Carlaw and Neil Findlay and will begin by saying that I, too, think that the petition should be kept live. I very much welcome the work of the committ…

  46. 2 Feb 2021
    Scottish Parliament (Assistance for Political Parties) Bill: Stage 3
    Chamber

    I welcome the Scottish Parliament (Assistance for Political Parties) Bill and the work of the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee in bringing this committee bill to Parliament. The bill was introduced and the stage 1 process was completed …

  47. 28 Jan 2021
    Budget 2021-22
    Chamber

    I declare an interest as a farmer. Given that much transitional funding is required to move Scotland’s rural areas towards net zero, is the cabinet secretary confident that sufficient funds are being made available in the budget to achieve early carbon-reduct…

  48. 28 Jan 2021
    First Minister’s Question Time
    Chamber

    I declare an interest as a shielded person. Further to Ruth Davidson’s questions, can the First Minister explain to the Parliament why general practitioners in my constituency, who vaccinated their over-80s and nursing home patients some weeks ago, cannot now…

  49. 21 Jan 2021
    Portfolio Question Time
    Chamber

    The cabinet secretary will know that tourism businesses such as coach operators and visitor attractions have been waiting months for support. Last week, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities suggested that the support that was announced in December may…

  50. 21 Jan 2021
    Portfolio Question Time
    Chamber

    To ask the Scottish Government what recent meetings it has had with representatives of the tourism industry, and what was discussed. (S5O-04928)

Search matches debate headings only. For the words spoken, use the Official Report search filtered to this MSP.