MSP
Keith Brown
Previously: Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Veterans (2021–23) · Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work (2016–18) · +7 more
Distinctive phrases: veterans · high-speed rail · brexit · armed forces · clackmannanshire · high-speed · awpr · apd · franchise · ret
-
19 Nov 2026Prevention and Preventative Budgeting
There is no reason why they cannot do that. I appeal for a bit more of a joined-up debate in future.
-
19 Nov 2026Prevention and Preventative Budgeting
As Katie Hagmannn said, if people are genuinely serious about this debate, then, before they say that money must be put into making savings in one place, they must identify what they would cut to get that money. Some might say that that is the Government’s re…
-
19 Nov 2026Prevention and Preventative Budgeting
I acknowledge that point. It raises a point about what the Conservatives, and sometimes some of the Labour Party members, think that their role in the chamber is. Surely it should be to speak up for proper resourcing from Westminster, not just parroting whate…
-
19 Nov 2026Prevention and Preventative Budgeting
I will do, if the Presiding Officer is feeling generous.
-
19 Nov 2026Prevention and Preventative Budgeting
The member has mentioned that, and I have said that the Scottish Government has to take responsibility for its actions, but I wish that he would take some responsibility for the overall situation, and he just will not do it. That is the denial and the delusio…
-
19 Nov 2026
-
19 Nov 2026Prevention and Preventative Budgeting
I am sorry, Mr Hoy—I do not have much time. I am in my last minute.
-
19 Nov 2026Prevention and Preventative Budgeting
Harry Burns used to always say that that is where we should start, and he highlighted a couple of initiatives down in the north of England that started with the premise of asking people what they actually wanted rather than all the things that we give to them…
-
19 Nov 2026Prevention and Preventative Budgeting
I do not disagree with the point that Carol Mochan makes—I have tried to say that. The Scottish Government has to accept responsibility. I think that the Scottish Government—here is a heresy—should acknowledge the fact that we have not been able to fund local…
-
19 Nov 2026Prevention and Preventative Budgeting
I welcome the debate and the Government’s commitment to accelerating the shift towards prevention, particularly through the new prevention unit and the development of a prevention investment framework.A couple of aspects of the debate have been quite disappoi…
-
19 Nov 2026Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body Question Time
I welcome the steps that have been taken to increase capacity, which Stephen Kerr has outlined. However, given the difficulties experienced by members in the previous session, can the corporate body provide assurances that those measures will be sufficient to…
-
19 Nov 2026Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body Question Time
To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, in light of the delays reportedly experienced by MSPs during the previous parliamentary session, what action it has taken to increase the capacity of services, including legal services, which support MSPs to p…
-
12 Nov 2026Armed Forces Community (Remembrance)
I did not intend to speak this year—this is the first time in about 15 years that I have not made a speech in these debates, so I thank Lloyd Melville for taking this intervention.Lloyd Melville will be aware of the incredibly beautiful memorial at Barry Budd…
-
11 Nov 2026Portfolio Question Time
The talk of strangers reminds me that there is nothing stranger than the Reform party.Unlike Reform, I believe that it is positive that the Labour Party has scaled back somewhat on its crackdown on health and social care workers, but the UK Government’s immig…
-
10 Nov 2026BBC and Public Service Broadcasting
And then, at every point when Ofcom was asked to serve that audience, it said, “That’s not for us—it’s for somebody else.” Ofcom is a creature of the UK Government and it is failing—as will the BBC unless it changes.
-
10 Nov 2026BBC and Public Service Broadcasting
I thank all my SNP colleagues, because it has been heartening to see so many SNP colleagues wanting to speak in the debate.George Adam mentioned the words “broadcasting”, “Scotland” and “Scottish broadcasting”, so I will quickly mention a company called Broad…
-
10 Nov 2026Broadcasting and News
That level of underfunding, if you can call it that, is probably equivalent to the cuts that BBC Scotland is currently making, so it is not a matter of no importance.That was my final question, and I will put it to the BBC. In fact, we will have a debate on t…
-
10 Nov 2026Broadcasting and News
My final question is similar—you can see that there is a theme here. To return to a point that Victor Currie made, the level of licence fee income from Scotland that the BBC spends in Scotland is around 88 per cent. The equivalent figure is 99 per cent in Wal…
-
10 Nov 2026Broadcasting and News
That is what I am relying on, and it is why the question is being put to you. If Sky has no obligations, whether in relation to news or sport, to serve different audiences in the UK, and if you are saying that your key role is to make sure that audiences are …
-
10 Nov 2026Broadcasting and News
Let me turn to another area with which you might be familiar: football and sport. On Sky Sports, there is very little coverage of Scottish sport. I can only imagine that it is worse for Wales and Northern Ireland. There is little coverage, with some important…
-
10 Nov 2026Broadcasting and News
I have raised the matter with the BBC, which did not take it very seriously. It goes back to the point about whether the audience is being well served. I would say that it is not. Try it tonight. I am sure you will find that it is routine.
-
10 Nov 2026Broadcasting and News
I have articulated that question twice. I have also written to Sky, but your response was that I might not get a response, which I did not in that case. I give you advance warning that that will continue through the next election period—just so that you are a…
-
10 Nov 2026Broadcasting and News
As Victor Currie said, you mentioned that the role of Ofcom can be quite circumscribed, but it is there to ensure that audiences are well served. I have a couple of specific, quick questions.I asked this question the last time you were here, but you treated i…
-
10 Nov 2026Broadcasting and News
The point about where things come in the channel list is interesting. I do not know whether you have ever tried to find out Scottish football results on the BBC, but a lot of patience is needed to do that.My last question is for Paul McManus. In the previous …
-
10 Nov 2026Broadcasting and News
There is also an issue with relevance. BBC Scotland has decided that it will not touch those issues because somebody else will discuss them, but they are of vital importance to people in Scotland.I have only one question for each witness, and the next one is …
-
10 Nov 2026Broadcasting and News
Jenny Young and I were recently on the BBC “Debate Night” programme, and perhaps the best question of the night was from somebody who asked in whose interest it is that the BBC fails or declines. Some of the answers were similar to what Paul McManus has descr…
-
7 Oct 2026Fishing Industry
I will try to help the member to get to her nine-minute target.Does Ariane Burgess agree that the shafting of Scottish fishermen last year by the Labour Government was entirely predictable, one, because that is usually the case and, two, because whether we ar…
-
6 Oct 2026Scotland’s Future in Europe
I was talking about what we would gain from acceding to the EU. We would gain access, on proper terms, to a market of 500 million people. That would be quite a big win.
-
6 Oct 2026Scotland’s Future in Europe
I know that the member is new here, but I point her to the number of debates that this Parliament has held on Europe, Brexit and various other issues. She also heard the Presiding Officer’s ruling that it is perfectly legitimate for the Parliament to discuss …
-
6 Oct 2026Scotland’s Future in Europe
It is worth stating the fact that Scotland is a European nation—geographically, culturally and economically. It is also a country that has the right to self-determination; it has the right to decide. That is agreed by everybody in the Parliament, apart from t…
-
6 Oct 2026Scotland’s Future in Europe
In Neil Bibby’s amendment, which he has just mentioned, he says that“the interests of Scotland are best served by … being negotiated”by the UK. However, there was an absolute farce when the UK was in charge of the Brexit negotiations. It reversed its previous…
-
6 Oct 2026First Minister’s Question Time
Andy Burnham has said that the United Kingdom can revisit Brexit 10 years on and that, in fact, we could “go all the way” and rejoin. Does the First Minister agree that the logic of Andy Burnham’s entirely reasonable decision to revisit Brexit must be extende…
-
6 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
I appreciate that. The libraries legislation is better than nothing. As you say, it is ambiguous, but it means that local authorities can be held to account to some extent if they have inadequate provision.If we have 100 small councils, that is where the cult…
-
6 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
That would be useful. I am sure that we will ask the cabinet secretary about it next week.My last question is on a point that Jenny Young made. I agree that there is little point in changing legislation if the money is not there to follow it through. However,…
-
6 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
Back in the day, when they were there.
-
6 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
But you are unable to say whether the funding for the cultural co-ordinator posts was ring fenced or hypothecated by the Scottish Government.
-
6 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
The UK is £3 trillion in debt, and is very much at the ceiling on what it can borrow, because of what is happening in the middle east, so I cannot imagine any prospect of dramatic change in the budget that Scotland gets and that flows through to local authori…
-
6 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
We have been talking a lot about public sector reform, so I will ask a general question, although it bears a little bit on culture. Councils down south have gone bust, and there has been a squeeze on local government. We cannot pretend that that has happened …
-
6 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
That seems right. You can see the opportunity in Edinburgh, I think.
-
6 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
I want to pick up on that last point. As I understand it, under the visitor levy legislation, it is entirely up to individual local authorities whether they want to apply a levy. On the question of where the money goes, Edinburgh is spending it on, among othe…
-
6 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
Kate Wimpress might want to come back in, in defence of Edinburgh.
-
6 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
I am interested in your proposal for what you call equal funding rather than equitable funding, so that all local authorities—we have to go with the local authorities that we have now, although who knows what we will have shortly?—are treated the same. The co…
-
6 Oct 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
I agree with Pauline Smith’s last point. It seems as though the proposed model would devolve power, and perhaps funding, to community level, but the report still seems to be hedged by all sorts of requirements on organisations to do strategies, report back an…
-
29 Sep 2026Breast Cancer Now’s Wear It Pink Day 2026
Stephen Kerr is talking about the Beatson centre, where I spent many hours, and about the staff there, and it occurs to me that on one occasion, when I was there with Christina, the tea trolley came round, and the person who was pushing the tea trolley was Je…
-
29 Sep 2026Breast Cancer Now’s Wear It Pink Day 2026
I am very grateful to Clare Adamson for lodging the motion to bring the debate to the chamber, and in particular for the very generous words that it contains about Christina. I suspect that members will understand that the debate is a very personal one for me…
-
29 Sep 2026Empowering Communities and Strengthening Local Democracy
Will the member correct the record? The process never took five years—it started in 1992, and the councillors were all elected by 1996. We had councillors who served on three different bodies at the same time, despite what Alexander Burnett said. Last time, t…
-
29 Sep 2026Empowering Communities and Strengthening Local Democracy
Will the member take an intervention?
-
29 Sep 2026First Minister’s Question Time
What discussions has the Scottish Government had with the Mining Remediation Authority, and other relevant agencies, following reports that its investigation into the ground movement at Coalsnaughton in my constituency has now widened to other sites in Clackm…
-
29 Sep 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
Because we are short of time, I will not ask my second question, which was going to be on that idea of travelling around the world and the impact of Brexit on the sector. I am very pleased that Fiona Campbell mentioned Covid in that regard, because that is a …
-
29 Sep 2026Pre-budget Scrutiny 2027-28
In previous years, many people from the sector have advocated that the committee should put pressure on the Scottish Government to allow cultural and arts organisations to take part in meetings relating to other portfolios. I have not heard that today, but I …
Search matches debate headings only. For the words spoken, use the Official Report search filtered to this MSP.