Former MSP
David Davidson
Distinctive phrases: minister's · executive's · health councils · committee's · arbuthnott · end-product testing · arbuthnott formula · atbs · health community · wealth creation
-
28 Mar 2007Airdrie-Bathgate Railway and Linked Improvements Bill
The debate has been wide ranging and consensual and has covered all the relevant issues. The committee has done a wonderful job and the procedures that will be followed as a result of its work—the promoter's acceptance of which we hope will be backed up by th…
-
28 Mar 2007Airdrie-Bathgate Railway and Linked Improvements Bill
Consensus is breaking out. I begin with the retiring members who have spoken today. Phil Gallie has been a quiet, mild-mannered man all the way through his parliamentary life and has argued and won his case by subtle persuasion. On occasion, Opposition member…
-
28 Mar 2007Airdrie-Bathgate Railway and Linked Improvements Bill: Final Stage
I congratulate the Airdrie-Bathgate Railway and Linked Improvements Bill Committee on its thorough work. Many people who live adjacent to the proposed line have been concerned about the process, as is the case with any major rail or road construction exercise…
-
22 Mar 2007Education
It would be more useful for us to concentrate on children. If Mr Neil wants to come outside to be talked to about what is wrong with his policy, I will be happy to oblige him. Robin Harper and I agree on one important point—dedicated PPP planning advice needs…
-
22 Mar 2007Education
I was not aware that David Cameron was offering lodgings to Frank McAveety.The debate has been interesting, especially as there is a lot of common ground, despite the rants that we have heard. The minister's rant against the SNP was very enjoyable. Amazingly,…
-
22 Mar 2007Education
Does Mr Neil intend to set up a House of Lords in Scotland?
-
22 Mar 2007Education
Will Ms Hyslop enlighten us on the science baccalaureate? What plans does the SNP have to fill the current shortages in science teachers at the top end of school, given that such teachers seem to be few and far between?
-
22 Mar 2007Education
The minister is not the only one who visits schools in Scotland; as he would expect, we all do. Secondary schools have been telling us that a quarter of primary 7 pupils are failing numeracy and literacy standards, which means that the senior schools have to …
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
That is kind of you and I thank you for your assistance as deputy convener. I forgot to mention the Scottish Parliament information centre, whose staff have given the committee and the clerks much support in the past year. With that, I conclude the meeting.
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
It was not as long as that.
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
This is the committee's final meeting of the parliamentary session. On the committee's behalf, I thank all members of the clerking team, including those who were involved for only part of the past year. I have found them all to be a tremendous support. In the…
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
The legacy paper also lists in chronological order the petitions that we considered. The documentation that has been presented to the committee today will be part of the meeting papers and will be in the public domain.Do members agree to the legacy paper, as …
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
Thank you—I am always grateful.
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
Members appear to have no comments on paragraphs 23 and 24. Paragraphs 25 to 28 concern the prisoner escort contract. Paragraphs 29 to 32 deal with legislative consent memorandums. Paragraphs 33 to 36 are on the budget. Paragraphs 37 to 42 are on the scrutiny…
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
Is the committee content?Members indicated agreement.
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
We are indebted to Jackie Baillie for her sterling work in convening the sub-committee. Would she like to think of wording for a comment to add to the legacy paper?
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
No.
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
Indeed. We will act on two fronts. We will include a note in the legacy paper and the clerks will talk to Executive officials.Members appear to have no comments on paragraphs 10 to 14. Paragraphs 15 to 17 are on youth justice. The next section is on the manag…
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
I will tidy the sentence with the clerks.
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
Is the rest of the committee content?Members indicated agreement.
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
Are you content with the suggestion?
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
Will we include a sentence that refers to the minister's pledge and says that, as of the date on which the legacy paper was agreed to, the committee had not received an order to commence the provisions but expected it to be made by the end of the month? Is th…
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
Yes, it is the most appropriate place. Do other members have comments?
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
Thank you. There appear to be no comments on paragraphs 1 and 2. Paragraphs 3 and 4 are on the Conveners Group legacy paper. I inform members that representatives of that group will meet the Parliamentary Bureau this afternoon to follow through some of the co…
-
20 Mar 2007Legacy Paper
Item 2 is consideration of the legacy paper. I invite comments on the paper and the other documents that have been circulated to members. Many of the documents relate to the legacy paper.Since the committee's initial consideration of the legacy paper, it has …
-
20 Mar 2007Subordinate Legislation
Are members therefore content with the instruments?
-
20 Mar 2007Subordinate Legislation
Do members have any comments?
-
20 Mar 2007Subordinate Legislation
Are members content with the order?
-
20 Mar 2007Subordinate Legislation
The order was drawn to the committee's attention because an Executive note was not provided initially. The Subordinate Legislation Committee has since received that note and provided it to us. Do members have any comments?
-
20 Mar 2007Subordinate Legislation
In that case, are members content with the instruments?
-
20 Mar 2007Subordinate Legislation
Do members have any comments?
-
20 Mar 2007Subordinate Legislation
Welcome to the eighth meeting of the Justice 2 Committee in 2007—our last meeting in this session of Parliament. We have received apologies from Michael Matheson. I ask members to turn off mobile phones, pagers and anything else that goes "raspberry" in the n…
-
15 Mar 2007Custodial Sentences and Weapons (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
The minister is talking about implementing the legislation. When will implementing the measures in the community be practicable, given the shortage of people with the right training and experience to implement them? Does the minister have a date in mind for w…
-
14 Mar 2007Edinburgh Airport Rail Link Bill: Final Stage
Businesses in the north-east of Scotland have regularly approached me to ask whether there will be more flights out of Scotland and have told me that, if the extra flights are to be from Glasgow or Edinburgh, they would like to have direct rail links to those…
-
14 Mar 2007Edinburgh Airport Rail Link Bill: Final Stage
The difference is that David Cameron is carrying secret documents. Would Mr Ballance carry such documents on a bicycle? As Mr Ballance will appreciate, it is dangerous to put things in an e-mail these days.Margo MacDonald was absolutely right to say that we a…
-
14 Mar 2007Edinburgh Airport Rail Link Bill: Final Stage
It has been an interesting debate, humorous in part. We have managed to cover newts, U-turns and a new railway line all thrown in together.Our position was outlined by David McLetchie. We want the airport to be connected to Scotland, and we argued about the m…
-
7 Mar 2007Alcohol Misuse
This has been a consensual debate, and I am glad that the SNP raised the subject this afternoon. As has been said by many members, we must take a multifaceted approach to the problem. It is not a single issue and, as Nanette Milne said, there is no quick fix.…
-
7 Mar 2007Christmas Day and New Year's Day Trading (Scotland) Bill
Sorry. The deputy minister would not move them on the minister's behalf. The Scottish Executive fudged the issue and left it to the last minute—today—to produce something.As Jim Mather and Murdo Fraser said, the issue is about a compromise. Good legislation o…
-
7 Mar 2007Christmas Day and New Year's Day Trading (Scotland) Bill
Not at this time.Jeremy Purvis asked why I moved the minister's amendments at stage 2 and then voted against them. As I said earlier, the answer is simple: I voted against them because the minister did not have the courage to support her own amendments.
-
7 Mar 2007Christmas Day and New Year's Day Trading (Scotland) Bill
Members seemed to have forgotten that nobody is forced to go shopping and that it is a matter of choice for individuals. It should also be a matter of choice for business owners to decide whether there is a market or public demand. They would then have to neg…
-
7 Mar 2007Christmas Day and New Year's Day Trading (Scotland) Bill:<br />Stage 3
I did not introduce the bill; Karen Whitefield did. The point is that, if there is no market, people will not open their premises. People should be left to run their businesses in co-operation and consultation with their staff. That is how the retail trade ha…
-
7 Mar 2007Christmas Day and New Year's Day Trading (Scotland) Bill:<br />Stage 3
Restraint on trade is the principle of the bill.
-
7 Mar 2007Christmas Day and New Year's Day Trading (Scotland) Bill:<br />Stage 3
I hear members shouting from a sedentary position, but what is the difference between somebody who works to meet a public need, whether related to health or otherwise, and someone who works to meet public demand for something sold by the retail trade? Mark Ba…
-
7 Mar 2007Christmas Day and New Year's Day Trading (Scotland) Bill:<br />Stage 3
I am sorry, but given that I ran retail businesses that had to operate on Christmas day to provide a public service, I think that that comment is a wee bit misplaced.
-
7 Mar 2007Christmas Day and New Year's Day Trading (Scotland) Bill:<br />Stage 3
Very simply, we do not think that there should be a bill at all. There was no evidence that anybody, at this stage, wants to trade on Christmas day. The retailers more or less said that there is no demand for that. I find it staggering that the Deputy Ministe…
-
7 Mar 2007Christmas Day and New Year's Day Trading (Scotland) Bill:<br />Stage 3
It would have been nice if Mary Mulligan had attended the Justice 2 Committee and laid before it the evidence that she claims she has, identifying all the intimidation that she mentions on a factual basis. If people had such evidence, they could have gone to …
-
1 Mar 2007SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
I regret that the minister made no attempt to answer the question other than to describe what the bill is about, and we are all well aware of that.The bill will put tremendous strains on local authorities to find, provide, train and pay for extra criminal jus…
-
1 Mar 2007SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
To ask the Scottish Executive when it anticipates that local authorities will be in a position to implement the provisions of the Custodial Sentences and Weapons (Scotland) Bill. (S2O-12193)
-
28 Feb 2007Prostitution (Public Places) (Scotland) Bill
Such areas exist in Aberdeen city and in Dundee. I will not go into the details of the individuals who complained.The Hood group—the expert group—did a good job and the Parliament must re-examine some issues that arise from its work.It is fair to say that not…
-
28 Feb 2007Prostitution (Public Places) (Scotland) Bill
I hear yesses across the chamber. Some time must be spent on the issue eventually.It was interesting that the minister made an announcement about routes out but, as was said later, he gave no details or statistics, of which it is important for the Parliament …
Search matches debate headings only. For the words spoken, use the Official Report search filtered to this MSP.