Former MSP
Brian Monteith
Distinctive phrases: auditor · auditor general · item enable · general entitled · national theatre · committee's · auditor general's · general team · executive's · invite auditor
-
29 Mar 2007The Future of Scotland
I understand what the member is saying, but the real growth has been in the public sector. Whether it then engages the private sector in some cases is neither here nor there. It is my belief that, if public sector spending was not growing so much, the private…
-
29 Mar 2007The Future of Scotland
The Parliament is not going away—that is an important statement for me to make, given my background before coming here—but it requires reform. Politicians who do not raise the money that they spend suffer from complacency and arrogance in the selection of the…
-
29 Mar 2007The Future of Scotland
If the SNP is so committed to reducing business rates, why, on the two occasions on which I sought an annulment of the increase in business rates, did the SNP vote against those attempts?
-
21 Mar 2007Point of Order
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. Further to the point of order that Mike Rumbles raised last Wednesday about the Standards and Public Appointments Committee's conduct in respect of the right of members to have a hearing before it, I beg your brief indu…
-
8 Mar 2007Complaint
I have worked in the media for 16 years. I understand what an embargo means. To give a member a statement that has an embargo on it means that the statement is in the public domain—the press have the information, but it should not be used.My third reason for …
-
8 Mar 2007Complaint
No, I will not.
-
8 Mar 2007Complaint
Three minutes? Thank you, Presiding Officer.I oppose the Standards and Public Appointments Committee motion for three reasons. First, I was denied natural justice in this process. Secondly, I did not disregard the Glasgow Airport Rail Link Bill Committee, as …
-
27 Feb 2007Committee Reports (Responses)
Thank you very much. That is greatly appreciated. I look forward to sharing a drink and swapping a few ideas and stories with the next convener of the committee whenever he or she is appointed.
-
27 Feb 2007Committee Reports (Responses)
That ends item 7 and brings the meeting almost to a close.This is the final meeting of the Audit Committee in this session of Parliament. Before I close the meeting formally, I will say a few words of thanks. We have today agreed a legacy paper, which will be…
-
27 Feb 2007Committee Reports (Responses)
Are we agreed to note the response?Members indicated agreement.
-
27 Feb 2007Committee Reports (Responses)
Next, we have a response from the Education Department to our report on the teachers agreement. We had a question about the chartered teacher project, which has been answered by Colin MacLean. The committee has no points to raise on the response. Does the Aud…
-
27 Feb 2007Committee Reports (Responses)
Can we agree to note Dr Woods's response, noting also that we are particularly pleased to read, in the paragraph on the lack of clarity in the response, how committed the department is to responding appropriately?Members indicated agreement.
-
27 Feb 2007Committee Reports (Responses)
I think that Margaret Jamieson commented on that very example and I am sure that she would support your view. Your comments are well made. You talked about change across sectors; it could be argued that there are similarities with the way in which the Executi…
-
27 Feb 2007Committee Reports (Responses)
Item 7 is responses to committee reports. We have received a response from Dr Kevin Woods, head of the Health Department, with regard to our report on the implementation of the consultant contract. I invite members' comments.
-
27 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
All those responses are noted.
-
27 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
We have received a letter from Dr Kevin Woods regarding "Planning ward nursing—legacy or design? a follow-up report". There are no comments on the letter. Do we agree to note the response?Members indicated agreement.
-
27 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
The next response relates to transport in Scotland. We have received a reply from Philip Rycroft. The committee has no points or comments on the subject, and we have no questions for Audit Scotland. Do we agree to note the response?Members indicated agreement.
-
27 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
There are no further points in relation to the SQA. Do we agree to note the SQA's response?Members indicated agreement.
-
27 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
Item 6 is responses to reports by the Auditor General for Scotland. There are a number of papers for the committee to consider. Members will recall that, for one or two reports by the Auditor General, we decided not to hold an inquiry or take evidence ourselv…
-
27 Feb 2007Accounts Commission
Thank you. We have found it most useful to invite the Accounts Commission to come before the committee not only to answer questions on its overview report on local authority audits but to clarify working relationships and lines of accountability. After all, s…
-
27 Feb 2007Accounts Commission
I have one final question in this our final meeting of the Audit Committee in session 2. Given that we started the process of taking evidence from the Accounts Commission a number of years ago, and given that one or two of us will not return to the Parliament…
-
27 Feb 2007Accounts Commission
Personally, I think that communicating to people what the reserves are for is the key to allaying people's fears. The problem with the way in which the reserves figures were reported by the media in recent years was essentially due to the fact that it was unc…
-
27 Feb 2007Accounts Commission
You have moved on to address my next point. You said that there are now stated reserve policies. Can we learn any lessons from them? Are councils sticking with them, or is it too early to say?
-
27 Feb 2007Accounts Commission
You took my council tax question, Margaret. Not to worry—I still have a few more.The most interesting bit of information that you gave us was that the £100 million extra that was collected was a 0.6 per cent improvement. The improvement is marginal, but it re…
-
27 Feb 2007Accounts Commission
I have a couple of questions, but I am happy to let Margaret Smith in now.
-
27 Feb 2007Accounts Commission
You have raised a useful issue; I hope that the rest of Parliament is also aware of it.
-
27 Feb 2007Accounts Commission
Do we know whether that is happening because of the drive for more efficient government or because of packages that make it more attractive for people to leave, or is it just that people think that it is an appropriate time to leave because the make-up of cou…
-
27 Feb 2007Accounts Commission
I would like to clarify that it is generally known that there will be a change in the councillors who will take post after 3 May, because of the new form of local government elections, and that because of the changeover there will be a significant loss of exp…
-
27 Feb 2007Accounts Commission
I welcome the public and members of the media to the fourth meeting in 2007 of the Audit Committee. I also welcome the witnesses who are with us for item 5, which concerns the Accounts Commission's local authority audits for 2006. This is the fourth annual ev…
-
15 Feb 2007Education
I have another example of a situation in which teachers and head teachers welcome inspection reports. When a report identifies that a school building is letting the pupils down, the head teacher can use it to argue for greater investment in the school infrast…
-
15 Feb 2007Education
Will the member give way?
-
15 Feb 2007Education
I know that the member takes a great interest in the affairs of Linlithgow. Can she tell me whether she is satisfied that seven primary schools were not inspected between 1983 and 1995?
-
15 Feb 2007Education
I am just about to wind up, Presiding Officer.I propose that the inspectorate should come before the Education Committee annually to explain its annual report and all the good work that it does so that its policies can be examined. That is the sort of account…
-
15 Feb 2007Education
I am rather hopeful that this debate on schools will be better tempered than the previous debate, but one never knows. I was surprised to see that an amendment to my motion was lodged, as I had thought that the motion would allow members to contribute to the …
-
15 Feb 2007Education
Presiding Officer, will you clarify how long I have for my opening speech?
-
13 Feb 2007Subordinate Legislation
I thank David McLetchie for his broad support for what I have been arguing for. I have covered parity, but he mentioned the affordability of making changes, as did Sylvia Jackson. One must take proposed changes in the context of all the other taxes and spendi…
-
13 Feb 2007Subordinate Legislation
I thought you would like that.
-
13 Feb 2007Subordinate Legislation
I have listened intently to the debate, which has served the purpose that I intended—to elicit from committee members their personal and party views on the issue and, in particular, the view of the minister, George Lyon, on the Executive's policy. I remain un…
-
13 Feb 2007Subordinate Legislation
I welcome the opportunity to have the minister appear before the committee to debate non-domestic rates not just with committee members, but with other MSPs. My intention is to welcome the cut in non-domestic rates, which is important. Naturally, I say that i…
-
13 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
Having tidied up that matter, I suspend the meeting, which will reconvene in private session. I ask members to be back by 11.15.
-
13 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
Before we move into private session, I return to item 1 on the agenda. The clerk has reminded me that consideration of our draft annual report will be on the agenda of the committee's next meeting. It would be useful for us to agree now, rather than at that m…
-
13 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
That covers all five of the responses. Does the committee agree to note the responses?Members indicated agreement.
-
13 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
Do you wish to add anything, Auditor General?
-
13 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
Again, we note the response.Finally, we come to the response from Dr Andrew Goudie, head of department, on "The 2005/06 Audit of the Scottish Fisheries Protection Agency". Members will recall that we were concerned about some health and safety issues, but we …
-
13 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
We note the response.The fourth response is to "The Efficient Government Initiative: A Progress Report". We received quite a detailed response from John Elvidge. There are no comments from members. Auditor General, do you wish to comment?
-
13 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
The next response to consider is that on "Catering for patients: A follow-up report". There are no comments from members or from the Auditor General, so we will simply note the response.The third response is to "Overview of the financial performance of the NH…
-
13 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
Would we invite the principal accountable officer to do that?
-
13 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
They are not committee conclusions. The report is by the Auditor General.
-
13 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
Do members want to make any other points on the IT report before I invite Audit Scotland to comment?
-
13 Feb 2007Auditor General for Scotland Reports (Responses)
Less steep.
Search matches debate headings only. For the words spoken, use the Official Report search filtered to this MSP.